Contessa Brewer: GOP Obstructionism Slowing Response to Swine Flu?

Photo of Scott Whitlock.
  • Bookmark and Share

"MSNBC News Live" anchor Contessa Brewer on Tuesday speculated as to whether supposed obstructionism by congressional Republicans may end up hampering the response to the swine flu outbreak. Talking to Republican strategist Tucker Bounds and Democratic strategist Peter Mirijanian, she asserted, "Let me ask you, Health and Human Services secretary has not been confirmed. You have a missing director of the CDC. The surgeon general is not there."

Specifically addressing Bounds, Brewer quizzed, "Do you, Tucker, think that Republicans are in any way to blame for standing in the way of those important positions- when you're facing swine flu- from being filled?" Bounds, of course pointed out that Democrats control both the Senate and the House. As for the CDC, Obama has not even nominated a candidate. Regarding the position of surgeon general, Dr. Sanjay Gupta was considered, but took his name out of contention. No one has picked to fill the spot. So, how, exactly, would Republicans be to blame? Brewer didn't say.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

In an odd non sequitur, Brewer began the question on Republican culpability by musing, "A viewer just e-mailed me here and he said he just saw this bumper sticker called- that says 'Republicans No Everything.' And no was N-O."

The MSNBC host also announced that "Rush Limbaugh is blaming President Obama for swine flu." She then proceeded to play the following clip, which obviously seems like a joke and not an actual accusation by the popular talk show host:

RUSH LIMBAUGH: Everywhere Obama is spreading Obamaism, there is a deadly disease taking place either in the T.A.R.P. community or in the newspaper business. Obama goes to Mexico, they have an earthquake. Obama goes to Mexico, pig flu.

Brewer then taunted, "Wow! Tucker, would you like to respond on behalf of conservatives everywhere?"

To be fair, Brewer did discuss Democratic criticism of GOP Senator Susan Collins for removing $800 billion from the stimulus bill that would have gone to fight a flu pandemic. Brewer noted, "Peter, do you think it's fair to point the finger at Susan Collins? After all, Senator Schumer also called the flu pandemic money porky?"

A transcript of the April 28 segment, which aired at 10:14, follows:

CONTESSA BREWER: Yeah, some of that finger pointing, Tamron, is directed at Republican Senator Susan Collins, the moderate Republican from Maine led the effort to remove more than $800 billion to fight a flu pandemic- fought to remove it from the stimulus bill. John Nichols at The Nation today calls Collins a "no nothing" and accuses her of irresponsibly playing politics. Republican strategist Tucker Bounds and Democratic strategist Peter Mirijanian are here with me now. Peter, do you think it's fair to point the finger at Susan Collins? After all, Senator Schumer also called the flu pandemic money porky?

PETER MIRIJANIAN (Democratic strategist): Yeah. I mean, to give Senator Collins the benefit of the doubt, I'm sure she regrets that now. You know, there was no way to foretell this was out there. But, I just think that there has to be an abundance of caution when it comes to this. I mean, you know, we live in a world where everybody, you know, flies all over the place and these diseases are transmitted. So, this is serious stuff. So, to look at it just as a budget item that could be cut and it's unnecessary I think she probably regrets that decision today.

CONTESSA BREWER: You know, it's interesting the people who are finger pointing today- Rush Limbaugh is blaming President Obama for swine flu. Let me play it.

MIRIJANIAN: I'm surprised.

RUSH LIMBAUGH: Everywhere Obama is spreading Obamaism, there is a deadly disease taking place either in the T.A.R.P. community or in the newspaper business. Obama goes to Mexico, they have an earthquake. Obama goes to Mexico, pig flu.

BREWER: Wow! Tucker, would you like to respond on behalf of conservatives everywhere?

TUCKER BOUNDS (Republican strategist): Uh, no, you know, I really wouldn't. I think that's a radio host weighing in. What I think here is that we have serious issues that surround the response to this. And I think that the politics of it, they're really not mature yet. I think that the politics and the political debate that surround the response to this swine flu really will stem from the management of how we're able to respond nationwide once we get a better handle on what the actual response is going to be from the Obama administration. Right now, they've been trying to perpetuate a calmness. I think that's smart. But I think we're going to have to wait and see how the politics play on this, save Rush Limbaugh. I mean, his radio show is every day. He's forced to wade into these waters regardless. I don't think that represents Republican politics.

BREWER: You know, a viewer- A viewer just- A viewer just e-mailed me here and he said he just saw this bumper sticker called- that says "Republicans No Everything." And no was N-O. Let me ask you, Health and Human Services secretary has not been confirmed. You have a missing director of the CDC. The surgeon general is not there. Do you, Tucker, think that Republicans are in any way to blame for standing in the way of those important positions- when you're facing swine flu- from being filled?

BOUNDS: Well, look, Governor Sebelius is going to be confirmed today. I think that the Obama administration could be doing more to get their nominees confirmed. They control both houses of

Congress, the House and the Senate. So, I don't think it's a good time to lay blame on anyone's hands. But, I think what we're going to see, and I'll say it again, is that the politics and the political debate that surround this issue are going to get more divisive as the issues of management become more mature. At this point, we're in such an infant stage of where this issue really is, it's hard to weigh in on a political perspective.

BREWER: Peter, given this could- has the potential, we're not there yet and certainly we could avoid a pandemic. This has the potential of being a very serious for the Obama administration, how much is riding on how effectively he and his team address it?

MIRIJANIAN: Well, certainly the American public wants to see the administration taking action and taking all the kind of precautions, not signaling there should be any reason to panic, but that we should take precautions and safeguard against it. Look, let me go back to what Tucker said. I mean, the fact of the matter is, as Tucker knows, in the Senate any one senator, if they really choose to do so can hold up a nomination. The fact that Sebelius' nomination is now troubled because of her views on abortion, you know, shocks me because you know, I think the average American, again, looks at this and says why should the head of the largest health agency, the most important health agency in the country, should their nomination be held up over one's personal views on abortion rights? So, I mean, yeah, Republicans run the risk they become obstructionist on areas of widespread public health concern. That's the problem. And that's why, although we can give Senator Collins the benefit of the doubt, you know, if you're a partisan Democrat, you can make hay over this.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

MSNBC

The propoganda arm of the DNC.

Liberals hoping for disaster?

The other day liberals were saying that former VP Cheney wanted America to get hit again so it would make Obama look weak.

How many liberals do you think are, right now, secretly hoping for many deaths from this flu so that they can lay it at the feet of Republicans?

Or, at the very least, hoping for a massive outbreak so that Obama can be a hero? 

They might say "Wow, that sucks!"  But at least they'll say "Wow!"  -Duff Goldman, the Ace of Cakes

smell the hope and change

I am so glad that we are living in the post partisan age, where polical labels no longer matter and everyone works together in love and unity. Obama has been gracious enough not to randomly blame Ronald Reagan, and his supporters are mature, intelligent, nay, nuanced enough not to just start blaming Republicans.

Thank Shahinshah he hasn't found the time to even nominate a surgeon general yet. His wisdom is far too great for us to comprehend. And his most magnificent HHS secretary, who was held up in confirmation because she was caught lying about lobby donations, will surely do a great job when her time has fully come. And the money for vaccine research really did belong in an emergency economic stimulus plan - but Democrats have been gracious enough not to point fingers over this.

We are so lucky to have such a nice guy in the White House.

 

Re Contessa

Is that just her name or is she real royalty?

Rush on pig flu - Tucker should have..

Well, the first thing that Tucker Bounds should have said, is that Rush did not blame the swine flue on Obama - that he merely said odd and dangerous things seem to be following the boy president around.

The second thing that Tucker should have said, and so should each and every Repbulican guest on TV, when they are confronted with whatever one of the "Gang of Six, (Rush, Coulter, Hannity, O'Reilly, etc.)" has said in the course of their job is,

"can not you folks talk about an issue facing this country without using the words a handful of radio or TV commentators in which to phrase your understanding of the view from the other side? President Bush was in office for 8 years. Just how many times did you bring up whatever the nutsy things (often vile spewing hatred) that was barked out daily by the radical voices on the left on AM and FM radio, and all over the network and cable news outlets?"

Ever notice the tone of

Ever notice the tone of questions directed to republicans vs democrats on MSDNC? Every single news host on this network of nitwits uses the same hateful tone in every single question to a conservative, seldom gives them time to answer the question and/or disputes every point they make.

Brewer in particular doesn't have the intelligence level (her IQ is somewhere between 2 and plant life) to discuss or debate any issue with even their token conservative guests.

Unfortunately, the election of our first half-white president has made this network even worse than it was before.

At least their consistent

I mean if an act of God in a hurricane is blamed solely on Bush then why should logic and intelligence stop MSLSD from doing the same here?

I have only ever made one prayer to God, a very short one: O Lord, make my enemies ridiculous. And God granted it - Voltaire

Who's in charge here?

Aren't the Democrats in charge now?  Don't they have majorities in both the House and Senate?  And don't they have their guy in the White House?

Blame it on the GOP all you want, but it was the Dems who reminded us last year that because a Republican was in the White House, Republicans were to blame for this nation's failings (never mind that Democrats controlled Congress after 2006).  So the buck and blame stops with Obama.

His administration won't even consider closing the borders.  His administration is responding slowly to this problem (probaby figuring out how best to use it to ram through some liberal agenda).  His administration isn't doing what needs to be done.

Aut viam inveniam aut faciam

Ironically......

all this fuss over a diseases that has affected approximately 45 Americans...45 of over 200 hundred million citizens....people leave your homes, run wild in the streets, scream, and panic.

In about a week Comrade Obama will come on the news and tell  you it is ok. But the house you go back to is now his, that car you drive is now his, that job you have is now a government job.

I mean Obama practiced on NYC yesterday.

 

 

“Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter”  - Thomas Jefferson

EXACTLY!!!!!!!!!!

I love the sarcasm!  The 24 hr news cycle is all about a virus that has sent one American to the hospital and no American casualties, a flyover of NYC that caused panic and confusion, and no actual damage, and Specter admitting what we have known for years.

Watch the giant green head and pay no attention to the teleprompter behind the curtain!!!!!!!!

Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe. - Albert Einstein

Giant green hand....

Tim,

 Maybe Obambi meant that exact symbolism when he flew his plane behind the Stature of Liberty....

 

“Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter”  - Thomas Jefferson

Navy...

That's my point exactly.  It seems like the news cycle is on a diversionary course.  Serious issues are bieng dealt with this week with little coverage due to panic over a disease that is at best overblown,  An illadvised, at best, flyover and a RINO making his actual allegiances official.

WTF?

Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe. - Albert Einstein

→ Hand Sanitizer

Wasn't the left making jokes about President Bush a few months back when he offered the Obamas hand sanitizer at the White House?

Is that something I imagined, or did it happen?

It's hard to talk when you're teabagging - Anderson Cooper

Maybe it was this?

From  "The Audacity of Hope," when Obama was first elected to the Senate:

"'We both got better [wives] than we deserve, Mr. President,' I
said, shaking the First Lady's hand and hoping that I'd wiped any
crumbs off my face. The President turned to an aide nearby, who
squirted a big dollop of hand sanitizer in the President's hand.

"'Want some?' the President asked. 'Good stuff. Keeps you from getting colds.'

"Not wanting to seem unhygienic, I took a squirt."

(Quote from the E and P Pub)

 

They might say "Wow, that sucks!"  But at least they'll say "Wow!"  -Duff Goldman, the Ace of Cakes

probably not a pandemic

I have noticed that ever since last summer, our government does whatever it wants with the assistance of emergencies and crises. Paulson pushed the first bailout through Congress by screaming that all would be lost the next morning if they waited. Tim Geithner was confirmed to the treasury because we were all headed for economic apocalypse and he was the only one who could save us.

Now all the sudden, with Sebelius being stalled in confirmation and the public railing against Napalitano....why, this is a life and death emergency! Sebelius is too big to fail and there's just no time to replace Napalitano.

Not trying to make light of those who died or are suffering, but I have feeling the pandemic risk will fizzle out precisely when Obama gets what he wants out of it.

 

No reflection

The opposition party is blamed for opposing.

When the Democrats were in the minority, the media did the dirty work of attacking the majority. Now the situation is reversed, anf the media is attacking the minoroty party ... for being in the minority.

Why do we keep up the pretense of an objective media?

KC, I don't think anyone

KC, I don't think anyone does, outside of the actual media.

And that's their story, and their stickin' to it!

They might say "Wow, that sucks!"  But at least they'll say "Wow!"  -Duff Goldman, the Ace of Cakes

Strategy

You have a point, mb, but it's still frustrating.

Strategy is when you act according to what you think everyone else is going to do. A lot of political movement depends on individuals being willing to take a risk, but only if they think others will join them. Politics is a constant game of "you first." But, how do most of us get information on what everyone else thinks? The media.

And the media spends all of its time saying to conservatives, as they're saying here, "no one else will follow you." Now you know that others should follow you, but you can't measure how many actually will. That's how they promote liberals and restrict conservatives.

No one actually pays attention to liberals. But the damage comes because the liberal media obscures and distorts any realistic chance for fellow citizens to join together. Look at what they did with the Tea Parties. They actively tried to prevent conservatives from gathering, and mocked and ridiculed those who did.

They want to be referees. They're players.

OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

It is now approx. 60 cases, none serious, most in NYC.....dear god help us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Guys, I'm going AWOL. I'm going into my shelter. I don't want to die from the PIG!!!!!

Dear God <nervoulsy bites nails, moving eyes side to side> were all going to die.

 Ok, enough sarcasm. Get over it MSM..start covering the real news...like how a majority of the citizens do not want nationalization of anything.

 But keep dropping that ACORN.....eventually the even the idiots will learn.

“Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter”  - Thomas Jefferson

It should now be obvious that Contessa Brewer won her job...

...for reasons other than her qualifications.

-Dave

This coup has gone on long enough. The time to put it down is NOW.

What

What kind of mother names a child Contessa? Maybe a frilly poodle, but a child?

One with high hopes.

One with high hopes. LOL

They might say "Wow, that sucks!"  But at least they'll say "Wow!"  -Duff Goldman, the Ace of Cakes

Bush's fault...of course. 

Bush's fault...of course.  Who watches this drivel?

They actually take a joke Rush made and treat it as a serious accusation?

Their 'aghastness' over that was amusing/disturbing.

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 61% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory (yep...approval for Congress now at 39%...do you believe that!?).