ABC Bizarrely Hypes Non-scandal Over Bush Dinnerware

Photo of Scott Whitlock.

"Good Morning America" hosts and reporters on Wednesday bewilderingly touted a total non-scandal, the "brewing brouhaha" over the new set of presidential dinnerware that President Bush and the first lady have ordered. Despite the fact that a private organization is paying the $485,000 bill, a salient point not revealed until late in the story, co-host Robin Roberts fretted, "So, why wait to give such an expensive gift right before they leave?" (If the plates are not taxpayer funded, what's the basis for the story?)

Veteran ABC reporter Ann Compton worried, "So, why is Laura Bush introducing new Bush china two weeks before they move out?" Compton even featured the Washington Post's Sally Quinn, not identified as a liberal in the report, to bash former President Ronald Reagan's china incident. Compton explained, "Washington veteran Sally Quinn recalls the furor when President Reagan was slashing the federal budget and his wife, Nancy, ordered $200,000 of scarlet china with the presidential seal in gold."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Quinn, who proclaimed herself "baffled" by the current dinnerware crisis, said of Nancy Reagan: "When she ordered all of that new china, she took a lot of heat for it, because it was very expensive." Compton did note that the plates will be used at events such as state dinners and that the set being used now had become fragile.

However, not until near the end of the segment did she reveal, "When the White House celebrated its 200th birthday, Hillary Clinton got to design a new $250,000 set, paid for by the private White House Historical Association, which is also footing the $485,000 Bush costs." Apparently, it didn't occur to Compton that her admission essentially negated any justification for the story.

A transcript of the January 7 segment, which aired at 7:17am, follows:

ROBIN ROBERTS: Now, to the brewing brouhaha over the presidential plates. President and First Lady Laura Bush are leaving behind a new set of dinnerware when they leave the White House in two weeks, a set of china costing nearly half a million dollars. So, why wait to give such an expensive gift right before they leave? Well, here's ABC's Ann Compton.

ANN COMPTON: There's nothing more elegant than a state dinner at the White House. The finest food, on the finest china. Even Hollywood gushed over the elegance in the movie "The American President."

["American President" clip]

COMPTON: There's a whole room set aside at the White House for the surviving antique china from Madison, Monroe, Abraham Lincoln, the Roosevelts. So, why is Laura Bush introducing new Bush china two weeks before they move out?

DANA PERINO (White House press secretary): No time like the present.

COMPTON: The White House worried that wear and tear had taken a toll on its fragile china selection collections. And the Bushes took some time to decide on a new design.

SALLY QUINN (author and journalist): I'm baffled by this, the timing of it.

COMPTON: Washington veteran Sally Quinn recalls the furor when President Reagan was slashing the federal budget and his wife, Nancy, ordered $200,000 of scarlet china with the presidential seal in gold.

QUINN: When she ordered all of that new china, she took a lot of heat for it, because it was very expensive.

COMPTON: After the outcry, a private foundation was put together to pay for the Reagan china. When the White House celebrated its 200th birthday, Hillary Clinton got to design a new $250,000 set, paid for by the private White House Historical Association, which is also footing the $485,000 Bush costs. Normally, only two-term presidents have time to order custom china. Presidents Nixon, Carter, and Bush 41 never did. Adding to the collection is one task the new first family shouldn't have to face when they entertain. For "Good Morning America," Ann Compton, ABC News, the White House.

ROBERTS: And, again, at least it's not taxpayer money going for that.

SAWYER: $485,000? A lot of plates.

ROBERTS: I know.

SAWYER: Carry them carefully, if you ever-

ROBERTS: Don't let Malia and Sasha near them. Keep 'em away.

SAWYER: I assume they don't go in the dishwasher.

ROBERTS: No, no, no. I think that's a safe assumption.

SAWYER: Okay, a mystery almost solved here.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Class is in Session

Reporting 101

What not to do when writing a story, negate your intial claim half way through the segment.

 

"If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquillity of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you."

Ha!

Ulterpend,

Your "Reporting 101" line is priceless. A great way of putting it!

White House China

IIRC, Jacqueline Kennedy undertook a massive renovation of the White House, using private funds.  Of course, at the time she was lauded for it.

I see no difference.

 

 

?

This is a most bewildering story:

ROBIN ROBERTS: Now, to the brewing brouhaha over the presidential
plates.  (Who is doing the brewing?)   President and First Lady Laura Bush are leaving behind a new
set of dinnerware when they leave the White House in two weeks,   ( At least the Bushes aren't going to take the loot to Texas, like guess who!)   a set
of china costing nearly half a million dollars. So, why wait to give
such an expensive gift right before they leave?  (Who, exactly, is waiting to give the gift? It sounds like the Bushes are delaying their gift for some nefarious reason)   Well, here's ABC's Ann Compton.  (No one better to stick her pug nose into a pile of bullshit)

All in all, a very lame attempt to create controversy with absolutely nothing to go on. Don't they know how they look?

Did it ever get reported

Did it ever get reported how much a last-minute action of the Clinton White House cost the US taxpayers?  Remember when the Clinton Kids trashed the offices and wrecked the computers?  I think that money had to be paid by us.  How much was it?

"An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last."  - Sir Winston Churchill

That's besides the Clinton

That's besides the Clinton White Staff always stealing "souveniers" from the President's VC-25 (Air Force One)

 

"Gov. Palin has been subjected to one of the most massive and dishonest pile-on smear attacks in the history of liberal media."  -- Lowell Ponte

Talk about Biased!

"So, why is Laura Bush introducing new Bush china two weeks before they move out?"

Talk about Biased!  It's not the "Bush" china, ya twit, it's the WHITE HOUSE china!  Get a clue, will ya?

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

And if the Bush's hadn't ordered new china...

....the MSM would be reporting on how the Obama's were left with junk.

. . . and how that proves

. . . and how that proves that Bush, Cheney, Palin, and the rest of the GOP are all racists !

Well....

...that goes without saying.

Soon to be followed...

.. with a glowing report on First Lady Obama's elegant, delightful, and appropriate 1 million dollar china purchase.  With an addendum on how the Taxpayers should be footing the bill and not private donors, to avoid the appearance of impropriety, don't ya know!

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

apparently the Bush's were required

to leave the selection of new china to Obama's baby momma.  No doubt there is some Chicago dinnerware manufacturer who needed paying off.

Upon leaving office

Upon leaving office President and Laura bush bought new china for the White House. The Clintons stole the old china when they left. Yep, it adds up alright.

Things to come.

The greens and enviros will donate recycled paper plates for Obama.  Obama's "O" symbol will replace the Presidential Seal. 

Outside of a dog, a book is man's best friend.  Inside of a dog, it's too dark to read. ----- Groucho Marx

fake people

with more fake news.  And yet we still have 2 years until the next election.  What the heck are these people going to do with themselves with the Dem majority lineup and no one to pick on.

"part of what I'm hoping to introduce as the next president is a new ethic of [government enforced] responsibility" - B. Obama

They should have just...

...ordered a full set of Obama plates from the Franklin Mint. They would have saved $484,950 dollars and all the White House guests would have gotten tingling sensations up their legs while eating off of such beautiful plates, especially the ones showing Obama's manly pecs!

Well...if that's not enough

to make one lose one's lunch, I don't know what is.

Too funny!

 

not just plates

plates.. glasses... mugs, wine glasses and something for the children

"part of what I'm hoping to introduce as the next president is a new ethic of [government enforced] responsibility" - B. Obama

I guess....

I guess the media is trying to find new ways to get their licks in on this family, in any way they can, over the next two weeks

Barry Punny

This site can be so nuts sometimes!

 

Hey kata

Where's the Obama cigarette lighter....or the Obama cocaine mirror, hmmm?

 

Obama's teleprompter pose

It's really quite funny looking at all this Obama crap when you realize that the "stoic" pose they chose for the Obama "merchandise" is just a screen grab of him robotically reading from his teleprompter, like one of those Disney animatronic amusment attractions.

That junk is rednecky and

That junk is rednecky and tasteless.

When the "Kennedyesque" Obamas get in there, they'll bring in some really sweet rhodium silverware and fine Kenyan china.

One of the 24% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 89% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.

Adding to the collection is

Adding to the collection is one task the new first family shouldn't have to face when they entertain.

Sounds like they are doing the Obamas a favor, so how is this a bad thing?? And exactly where has this been brewing? I haven't heard anything about it anywhere but here. I do believe it is a case of bad Reporting 101.