ABC Grills McCains on Abortion; Skipped Issue with Obamas

Photo of Scott Whitlock.

"Good Morning America" host Diane Sawyer on Wednesday grilled Cindy and John McCain about differences in the couple's position on abortion and the subject of overturning Roe V. Wade. And yet, when co-anchor Robin Roberts talked to Barack and Michelle Obama in May, she didn't raise the issue, instead wondering if the Illinois senator would be prepared for all the negativity he would surely face as Democratic nominee.

In fact, on at least seven appearances in 2008, no GMA host asked Barack or Michelle Obama about abortion and that includes skipping issues such as the senator's controversial opposition to a bill that would have offered protection to babies who survive botched abortions.

On Wednesday, Sawyer cited a CBS interview in which Mrs. McCain stated her opposition to overturning Roe V. Wade. The journalist then interrogated, "And yet, Senator McCain you have indicated in previous interviews that you would like the repeal of Roe versus Wade so that the states can make their decisions. What's the difference in the two of your view of the issue?" Sawyer followed up, But, Mrs. McCain, do you oppose the repeal of Roe versus Wade? Was that report correct?"

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Sawyer could argue that she was simply trying to get a clarification from the potential first lady. But in a similar joint appearance by the Obamas, GMA reporters displayed no interest into delving into either the candidate or the spouse's position on abortion. During the May 19 interview, Roberts tossed softballs such as "What have you learned about yourself since that night in Iowa?" She also sympathized with Michelle Obama's attitude towards political attacks: "I like how you said people make things up and things that you go, like, huh?" (Barack Obama appeared by himself on Monday's show. The issue wasn't discussed then either.)

In February, GMA reporter Deborah Roberts also skipped the issue of abortion and celebrated Michelle Obama as "the spouse of politics' newest star." During the February 4 piece, she enthused that the couple "genuinely believe that people want to move beyond that [negative attacks], talk about something else."

Going all the way back to January of this year, when the presidential primaries were in full swing and voters could have been educated as to the nuances of differences between Obama and his opponent Hillary Clinton, GMA continued to ignore the issue of abortion while interviewing the Illinois senator.

On January 3, Sawyer focused instead on the issue of racism and wondered if, in Iowa, "people have shown they are willing to look beyond race in this country. Has that victory been won, whatever happens tonight?" Later in the month, on January 23, Sawyer continued didn't mention this important social issue and plead for calm between Obama and his primary opponent: "We have heard a lot of people say they are exhausted by this charge, counter charge."

Perhaps, since the militant abortion group NARAL (National Abortion Rights Action League) has given Barack Obama a 100 percent lifetime voting record for his time in the Senate, "Good Morning America" could ask him if his stance on the issue is in sync with the rest of the country.

A transcript of the September 17 segment, which aired at 7:42am, follows:

ROBIN ROBERTS: We are back in Gustavus, Ohio. It is our whistle-stop tour, day three. And good enough to join us, Republican presidential candidate John McCain and his wife Cindy McCain. And it was cute when Diane asked you how many days left until -- you were quick, 48 days.

CINDY MCCAIN: 48 days. Who is counting?

ROBERTS: Everyone seems to be counting. You're never far from your husband's side. Does he confide with you? Does he talk with you about the major issues and get your advice on some things?

CINDY MCCAIN: Certainly at the end of the day the issues are not what we're talking about. We usually are checking in with our children and things like that but certainly we talk, absolutely.

JOHN MCCAIN: I think we should have full disclosure. There is a critique.

CINDY MCCAIN: There is a critique. That's true. I was trying to be nice.

JOHN MCCAIN: Performance and those kinds of things.

DIANE SAWYER: How does she think you're doing?

JOHN MCCAIN: Sometimes I get mixed reviews and sometimes I deserve them.

SAWYER: If I could ask about one issue because we are here in the heartland and we keep hearing about a lot of social issues as we travel around here. And I wanted to clear up something, if I could. Because Mrs. McCain, CBS reported on Roe versus Wade that they had contacted your staff and that you had said that you do not, as Mrs. Bush has said, in fact, does not want the repeal of Roe versus Wade so that some states with outlaw abortion. And yet, Senator McCain you have indicated in previous interviews that you would like the repeal of Roe versus Wade so that the states can make their decisions. What's the difference in the two of your view of the issue?

JOHN MCCAIN: Well, let me just say this is all about courage and compassion. It's about changing the culture of America. I am pro-life and I support that position, and I know that Cindy does too and we need to ask young American women who are faced with this terrible decision that we will help them have the courage to bring a baby into this world and we'll have the compassion and help them in every way that they can address it. And it will be if Roe V. Wade is overturned, go back to the states and the states will make the decisions about it. So that's the issue here as to how we treat the issue of human life in America and it's got to be done with courage and compassion. And that's both of our positions.

SAWYER: But- But, Mrs. McCain, do you oppose the repeal of Roe versus Wade? Was that report correct?

CINDY MCCAIN: You know, there are people that are without jobs, that are hurting whose businesses have collapsed, who don't know where they're going to find money to feed their families. This is not the major issue on people's minds right now. What concerns me is when I talk to people like people today on this farm, people we had dinner with last night, they're having trouble making ends meet. A difference in how we stand on abortion or things like that are not what's foremost in the voters' mines right now, at all.

JOHN MCCAIN: So, look, this is an issue that we have to change the culture of America, those of us who respect the rights of the unborn. That's the thrust of our effort, and I'm happy to know -- to note that we are adoptive parents and it's enriched our lives and we hope that will also encourage others to do the same.

ROBERTS: You talked about that people don't want to get into personal issues. That doesn't help them. That they want to talk about the issues, but it has gotten very personal this particular time around, the campaign, on both sides. And a lot of people thought it was refreshing on 9/11 that no negative ads, you both, you and Senator Obama appeared at the presidential forum on community service, and can we make that kind of commitment? Why does it have to -- how does it serve anybody when it becomes so bitter?

JOHN MCCAIN: It doesn't. But I can tell you one way it makes it a lot better because I've been in previous campaigns. Have Senator Obama come to a town hall meeting with me. Let's go to town haul meetings all over America. Both of us stand before the American people. That's what Barry Goldwater and Jack Kennedy had decided to do. And I've asked time after time.

SAWYER: Does it feel like-

JOHN MCCAIN: Senator Obama, come to the town hall meetings with me. Have the people ask, we respond. I guarantee you that changes the tone of the campaign, because then people pay attention to the candidates. Not the back and forth. Not the surrogates, not the 527s and so I asked Senator Obama again. We've got 49 days left.

CINDY MCCAIN: 48.

ROBERTS: She's critiquing you, 48.

JOHN MCCAIN: 48. Let's go to the town hall meetings and then the American people will be focused on that. I don't know why he's refused to do that. Because when first asked he said he would go anywhere, any time so I hope that he will take up that request and I look forward to it. I'll fly with him. I promise not to fly the airplane.

SAWYER: Senator, the computer is going to cut us off in just a minute. We want to thank you so much for this morning and we have frozen you to death, Mrs. McCain we owe you one on that. We really do.

JOHN MCCAIN: Appreciate it.

SAWYER: It's great to see you.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Not a shock

Everyone knows what Obama is like off prompter and on hard hitting issues.  To actually ask Obama a tough question is against the MSM code of ethics.  You can't have the chosen one looking like a buffoon.

However, when conservatives get the tough questions and handle the pressure well, that makes us look all that much stronger.  Obama stands for whatever will get him elected.  The American people aren't fooled by this fool.

MSM...

why do you keep bringing up abortion? Who gives a rats butt, really? Theere are way more important issues to discuss.

Buckeye

These are rhetorical questions, right?

gee, i know that paying

gee, i know that paying bills is important

but mass extermination of 3000 kids every day does still concern me quite a bit - in fact much, much more than paying bills - for some very strange reason... 

Journalism is the opium of the liberals

Yes TM,

but this should not be the job of the federal government. This should be a job for the state and local levels. The federal govenment should step back and leave this issue alone...just the way our founding fathers wanted it to be with such issues...as well as the banks, schools, and numerous others.

sorry but nope, it's a

sorry but nope, it's a federal issue

people cross state lines to get abortions 

and no state can legalize murder

Journalism is the opium of the liberals

TM, you are constitutionaly

TM, you are constitutionaly wrong in this assertion "sorry but nope, it's a federal issue" as the constitution clearly spell out the powwers of the feds and says The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people..

So the states do have the express rights to regulate what they see fit as long as it does not conflict with federal law.  And until Row v Wade decision the states did regulate abortion.  Some states such as California actually allowed abortion, from 1960 or so, while other states banned it in all forms except in dire circumstances.

So it is not a federal issue; but marriage is because it affects those neighboring states under teh good faith clauses meant to make sure things like marriage were applicable in all states in teh union.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

Abortion for some, tiny American flags for others

I believe it is the MSM that keeps bringing up the issue! Well, if you're not on their side.

I don't see Obama, the Messiah and Lord of this Earth, getting any questions about how he's going to protect partial-birth abortions?

PALIN/McCain 2008

With a big smile...

With a big smile McCain  should have answered, " well Dianne I'm glad you are giving me a chance to clearify my position just as you did with Mr. Obama. (pause for effect)  My position is..."

 

The silence for Dianne would be deafining.

 

That would have been ...

AWESOME!  I wish McCain or Palin would do that to these liberal nutjobs!

I really have to agree that

I really have to agree that this would be excellent. More candidates should do this.

I hope one or two stops by this thread and pays attention to that comment...LOL

 

------------------------------------------------------------

"My morality is your morality."

My favorite part of the

My favorite part of the interview:

ROBERTS: But, but...

You just know she's thinking, "But that's not what I was told you'd say! Don't you know you're supposed to disagree, argue, fight like you're on a reality show, and make him look like a fool?! Why won't you play my game?!!"

They don't need to ask Obama

They don't need to ask Obama what his stance on Roe v. Wade is. They already know and agree with his stance, but they need to obscure it as best they can. If they did ask Obama about it, it would probably come out as,

"How do you feel about McCain being so out of touch on Women's Health issues? Do you think that hurts him as much as it should? Don't you think he should just step aside and let you rule as is your rightful place?"

MC...

Yeah we know where he stands. He's already made it quite clear that if his daughters were pregnant it would be "punishment". So instead of young people being blessed with a baby, they are being punished! What a turd.

Sarah Palins Email Hacked

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

Screencap: is that Obama or Robama sitting there?

Which office is Cindy running for? Oh, she's not? Then WTF does her personal stance on Roe have to do with anything?

"Obama likes Scrabble but does not like ice cream." (the big revelations from Robama Robert's Aug. 08 interview with Michelle O.) 

Hey, is that like those old

Is this like those old "Fanny Dooley" jokes-- He only likes things with double letters?

Like:
- Obama likes Michelle but he hates sex.
- Obama likes ballots but he hates votes.
- Obama likes stuttering but he hates teleprompters.

Hey, this could be fun!

SoL

Which office is Cindy running for?

This was my first thought, also.

Can't Ask Obama Hard Questions!

It would be RACIST to ask this empty black suit a HARD question since he doesn't have his trusty telepromter to read the answer from.

You'd think they'd be insulted by the kid glove treatment they've received, but then again they've ridden the Afirmative Action wave to where they are today! No reason to fall back and be treated fairly now is there?

Hey Barack, Are you gonna have a teleprompter in your bedroomn for the 3:00 AM Call?

Wake up America! The Marxist/Socialist Bastards are taking over!

Scott. Polls consistently show that ...

Scott. To the best of my recollection, polls consistently show that ... a majority of Americans want restrictions on abortions.

A NBC News/Wall Street Journal Poll, conducted Sept. 6-8, 2008, shows that only 25% said that they want abortions "legal all the time." 24% said "legal most of the time," 37% said "illegal with few exceptions," 10% said "illegal without exception."

ABC News/Washington Post Poll. Aug. 19-22, 2008, shows that only 22% want abortions to be "legal in all cases," 32% "legal in most cases," 26% "illegal in most cases," and 18% "illegal in all cases."

I'd suggest that the MSM reprsents the view of about 1/5 - 1/4 of the voters on this issue (like many other issues.)

Former President Jimmy Carter, on those few occasions that it is allowed to be heard, is still strongly convinced that abortion is wrong. The Dalai Lama (for all those liberal Zen Buddhists in Hollywood) simply believes the obvious, abortion is the premeditated taking of a human life.

The MSM has a different view. No discussion which challenges the MSM's view will be allowed to take place in the confines of their media.

(;~/ gary

Yes But

You know, I love coming to NewsBusters and seeing that others are concerned at the mainstream media's overt bias. But let's be clear; those of us who keep up with this clap-trap, who can see this unfairness in real-time, are a small fraction of American voters. The vast, vast, (vast) majority of Americans hear something, or read something, and believe it. We are blisfully naive. When the Olbermans of the world knowingly repeat lies (i.e. Palin slashes funding for special needs children) for political effect, and it goes unchalleged, we lose. But when we complain, no one hears us.

And it hurts.

That said, when I was a young man growing up in Washington D.C., I believed every word that I read in The Washington Post and the New York Times. "It must be true; it's right here in the paper" I would say. I never believed that anyone, for political or financial gain, would skirt the truth, even lie, to get what they wanted.

I helped vote out of office a 20 year Republican Congressman based on a lie I read in the Post (page A-1) that turned out to be untrue (page A-20). To this day, I regret that.

Never again. NewBusters, you keep on going on.

I really need to know

I really need to know things about Obama like what colors her prefers his shirts to be, what his free throw percentage is, and where one can find the best food in Chicago. However, I need to know what McCain thinks about the financial state of the country and what he thinks might help the situation and how he might try to turn it around.

If it were not for this blog and talk radio, I would find it difficult to determine what position Obama holds on any issue.

The Newsbusters Comments Crew: Saving the Environment - One Ribeye at a Time! h/t Dr_Liberty

The LEFT is FOR ABORTION

Anyone who considers abortion should think "Where would I be if my mother had aborted me"?

 

Ecclesiastes 10:2 (New International Version)

 

2 The heart of the wise inclines to the right,
but the heart of the fool to the left.

 

Sawyer: "Senator, the

Sawyer: "Senator, the computer is going to cut us off in just a minute..."

Was this some slight against McCain seeing as how he supposedly doesn't know how to use a computer?  Agism, Agism, Agism!!! Lol.

What was the toughest question that Obama was asked by anyone in the mainstream media?  Have there been any tough questions put to Obama?

greval... No. "America

greval...

No.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

As tough as it got...

COURIC: Do you think your relationship with Rev. Wright has been permanently
damaged or severed?

OBAMA: Yes, and I already indicated as much.

COURIC: And finally Senator, have you heard from Rev. Wright., and we're
not gonna use all this but I'm just curious, since you repudiated him last week.

OBAMA: No.

COURIC: Have you heard from him at all or any of his
associates?

OBAMA: No, I have not.

OBAMA: No, I haven't Katie.

COURIC: Okay, Sen. Obama, I know you're sick of the Rev. Wright
questions, but we're going to focus mainly on the other stuff and I thank you
for your time.

MM: Thank you Katie, The most Right Rev Wright controversy dismissed...

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...