Arnold Grabs ABC's Shipman, Demands: Stop Spinning Fire Coverage

Photo of Scott Whitlock.
  • Bookmark and Share

Reporter Claire Shipman did her level best to get California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger to say the efforts to combat the state's wild fires were going poorly. Shipman interviewed the governor on Wednesday's "Good Morning America" and wondered about "the comparison to Katrina that everybody's making in the back of their mind..." At one point, Governor Schwarzenegger cut off Shipman's pleas for negative assessments of the effort by grabbing her arm. He bluntly scolded, "Trust me when I tell you, you're looking for a mistake and you won't find it because it's all good news, as much as you maybe hate it, but it's good news."

Video (1:21): Real (2.21 MB) and Windows (2.51 MB), plus MP3 audio (632 kB).

Earlier, the ABC correspondent attempted to deflate Schwarzenegger's sunny optimism by mentioning unnamed officials in Orange County who asserted the state doesn't have enough resources, including firefighting aircraft. The former actor simply wouldn't go along with this premise of victimization. He firmly retorted, "Anyone that is complaining about the planes, just wants to complain because it's a bunch of nonsense." Schwarzenegger then proceeded to point out that the state has 90 planes and only wind has hampered their use.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Shipman also spun President Bush's planned visit on Thursday as a bad thing. She noted how the governor "remained upbeat" about the trip. Later, somewhat incredulously, the ABC reporter stated that Schwarzenegger "actively encouraged" the visit and that "...despite the disruption this presidential visit will cause tomorrow, it will keep the federal government and all of its resources focused on California, ideally hoping to stave off any Katrina-like situations." However, as a September 1, 2005 CyberAlert noted, "Good Morning America" anchor Diane Sawyer grilled President Bush for not being proactive in terms of dealing with Hurricane Katrina.. In addition to several other left-leaning questions, he asked him, "When are you going to go?"

A transcript of the October 24 segment, which aired at 7:07am, follows:

DIANE SAWYER: Of course, the man in charge of the battle against nature is Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger. And ABC's senior national correspondent Claire Shipman talked one-on-one with the governor and has that exclusive interview. Claire?

CLAIRE SHIPMAN: Diane, this is a governor who is always up, who never betrays a hint of worry. And so, characteristically, even after visiting the front lines of these devastating fires, after coming here to see the evacuees, he was relentlessly insistent that the effort is going well. The spotlight squarely on the governor as he navigates California’s biggest crisis on his watch.

CALIFORNIA GOVERNOR ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER: We have to do everything we can to protect the people and protect the property.

SHIPMAN: Relentlessly delivering the same message around devastating parts of the state.

SCHWARZENEGGER: You should know you're not out there by yourself fighting these fires, that the state is there to help you.

SHIPMAN: We caught up with him for an exclusive one-on-one at the makeshift evacuee camp at the Qualcomm Stadium. His optimistic demeanor going full tilt.

SCHWARZENEGGER: And then when you think about it, I have declared a state of emergency in the seven counties and then we requested it from the federal government and within a day they came through and within a day they came through. So, I mean, that's quick action! Really, I've never seen that before.

SHIPMAN: So, you think the comparison to Katrina that everybody's making in the back of their mind these days is a good one in terms of state and federal.

SCHWARZENEGGER: All you have to do is just look around here and see how happy people are. No one is screaming. No one is complaining about anything.

SHIPMAN: Well, you're saying everybody's working together, but you have heard there have been some complaints from officials. For example, in Orange County who say, 'If we'd only had more resources earlier, more planes, more firefighting resources, we might have been able to head off the fires ravaging Orange County right now.'

SCHWARZENEGGER: Anyone that is complaining about the planes just wants to complain because it's a bunch of nonsense. The fact is that we have all the planes in the world here. We have 90 aircraft here and they can't fly because of the wind situation.

SHIPMAN: At one point, he even employed a heavy weight grip to make his case. The point he was making, you have to be ready to fly --

[Schwarzenegger grips Shipman's arm and starts vigorously shaking it.]

SCHWARZENEGGER: Trust me when I tell you, you're looking for a mistake and you won't find it because it's all good news, as much as you maybe hate it, but it's good news. Trust me, okay?

SHIPMAN: I don't hate it. I'm just listening to Orange County.

SCHWARZENEGGER: No, no. I'm just telling you-- No, but you're--

SHIPMAN: When we agreed to move on to another subject, the President's plans to visit California Thursday, the governor remained upbeat.

SCHWARZENEGGER: Whenever the president shows interest in our fires--

SHIPMAN: You take it --

SCHWARZENEGGER: --and wants to help, you know, the federal government has a lot of help ready for us. We want to utilize that help.

SHIPMAN: So the governor is positive, but practical. He actively encouraged President Bush to come out here as soon as possible. He knows that despite the disruption this presidential visit will cause tomorrow, it will keep the federal government and all of its resources focused on California, ideally hoping to stave off any Katrina-like situations.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Too bad...........

Too bad he didn't have a "terminator" moment.

 

I can't stand that mousy little wench Shipman.

Good For Arnold

Good for Arnold for bursting Shipman's bubble. His Democrat Lieutenant Governor is already on Television undercutting him.

Arnold may have to be a constant fixture on TV to conteract this new smear.

Lets see Bush will disrupt

Lets see Bush will disrupt the fire fighting...but the fire fighting won't disrupt Hillary Clinton

http://blogs.abcnews...

Celebrities came to see to see Clinton, D-N.Y., and to celebrate in
advance of the former first lady's 60th birthday. Although they didn't
bring gifts, celebrities from Jamie Lee Curtis, Magic Johnson, Ted
Danson, Bridget Moynihan and Chelsea Handler raised a half a million
dollars for the Clinton campaign and enjoyed cocktails and hors
deouvres in return.

Despite the massive fires miles away in
Malibu, guests were greeted by men dressed in head to toe white, with
lavender bow ties saying with "Welcome to the Reiner's," as they
shuffled up and down the street parking Bentleys, Porsches, and BMWs.

Yes. Nero fiddled while

Yes.

Nero fiddled while Rome burned too.

I think we all know what would be said if a Republican party occured in place of the Reiner party. 

Killing them with kindness isn't working.  Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.

I can see the headlines

I can see the headlines "Conservative mugs News Reporter" oh that was already done?

SHIPMAN: So, you think the

SHIPMAN: So, you think the comparison to Katrina that everybody's making in the back of their mind these days is a good one in terms of state and federal.

Schwarzenegger: "The difference is... I'm just going to kill you." –in "Collateral Damage"

THAT would have been awesome.

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

"Remember Shipman, when I

"Remember Shipman, when I promised to kill you last?

I lied".

Not sure which of his movies that was from, but that would have been good too.

Leon says "By the way, I'm not afraid of fat people, I'm repulsed"

Truth Monger Says - "Both are religions [Christianity & Islam], yes - with the same percentage of terrorists."

True Lies?

Possibly?  Total Recall?

I cant place it because its one big blur of awesome. 

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

Commando

It was one of his best.

Duhhh

How could I miss that?  Time for another Arnold marathon at the ol' sunandsteel house, wife and kid beware. HAHAHAHAHAA

 

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

Commando

That line is from Commando!

Arnold gets a SHACK on that

Arnold gets a SHACK on that one.

It was Sully

In Commando. Classic.

Remember, Scully, when I

Remember, Scully, when I promised to kill you last?

I lied.

That was from Commando. A good movie, even if Rae Dawn Chong's car managed to repair itself significantly between scenes.

"A communist is someone who reads Marx. An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx." Ronald Reagan

Shipman says "that despite

Shipman says "that despite the disruption this presidential visit will cause tomorrow...".  

Now the President will disrupt the ongoing efforts.   Great, wonderful, now they criticize him because he is going to California, to a state that more like Russia than the USA!

Unfortunately this person has no knowledge of what a journalist is, she is nothing but a democratic con artist acting like a journalist, who makes her main priority to say anything negative about the President.

All these people liberal activists on TV; ARE NOT JOURNALISTS but demoratic activists. 

We can not be fooled anymore......!

Really...when you hear that someone is a journalist, you really have to investigate to see if that is true.

 Don't you think it's time we boycott these media groups; stand in front of their buildings; boycott their advertisers?

Boycott

Believer 

Only one alphabet channel here! Rabbit ears and the ibook. You can do it. If all of us would simply call up and cancel for a month, think of the possibilities, I can only imagine. 

Great song too. 

Boycott

Believer 

Only one alphabet channel here! Rabbit ears and the ibook. You can do it. If all of us would simply call up and cancel for a month, think of the possibilities, I can only imagine. 

Great song too. 

Song

I sure hope you are thinking MercyMe and not John Lennon. >:-O

 

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

What a refreshing change

What a refreshing change from the whining Louisiana governor. It reminds me of when Margaret Thatcher lectured Leslie Stahl on her negativity. Ahnold will be punished severely for this...

One of these things just doesn't belong here

  1. Florida hurricanes. Capable Republican governor. Devastation but best possible response.
  2. California wildfires. Capable Republican governor. Devastation but best possible response.
  3. Lousiana hurricane. Incompetent Democrat governor. Devastation, slow response.

Hmmm .... right ... must be the federal government's fault.

Of course you need citizens

Of course you need citizens who actually cooperate and take responsibility for themselves and their families, too.

Good observation

and a great job by Arnie, defending his response services in (Use an Austrian accent)Cow-a-for-nea.

 

Shipman

He should have grabbed her by the throat and choked off some of that ridiculous drivel!

It's about time! We need

It's about time! We need much, much more of our side telling these idots what time it is. I mean, what are they afraid of? Pissing off the press? Screw em'!

I also liked the moment when Chertof laughed when Ahnold went off. Michael should learn from this moment.

Nortonalec

Good for Ahnuld. It must

Good for Ahnuld. It must get annoying as a politician to have to listen to reporters all the time.

You SOB. Who are you and

You SOB. Who are you and what have you done to Bal?

Lol. I just think, you

Lol. I just think, you know, things are bad enough out there right now without some reporter trying to get her merit badge.

When he grabbed her hand you

When he grabbed her hand you know what he was thinking... I could snap this like a twig!

Get Email updates from Fred http://socialnet.imwithfred.com/email_alert_july_26.html

She was thinking the same

She was thinking the same thing. That's why she backed off!

Leon says "By the way, I'm not afraid of fat people, I'm repulsed"

Truth Monger Says - "Both are religions [Christianity & Islam], yes - with the same percentage of terrorists."

I was thinnking the same

I was thinnking the same thing. She is like a little Gnat. One of those pesky little bugs that just won't go away. You can tell while watching him that deep down he really, really wanted to just tweek her wrist just a little bit to bring her to her knees. 

Watch her body language as

Watch her body language as he tells her she hates the good news. She looks to the side and laughs. That's a classic psychological response by someone who knows they've been exposed and they don't like it. How many times have you done that or seen somebody do that? It's a CLASSIC response! She knew he had her, and she didn't want to look bad on TV, but her response was knee jerk and she couldn't help it. Forget 911, I dial 9MM.

I'm waiting for the

I'm waiting for the headline, "Republican Governor attacks respected journalist in attempt to stifle dissenting opinion - clear and blatant violation of the 1st Amendment..." 

The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers

Good for Arnold!!

When the Cedar Fire raged through San Diego 4 years ago today, Gray Davis had just been voted out of office and was just biding his time before Arnold took over. He didn't do ANYTHING to help! Some folks feel it was because San Diego had a big hand in voting him out. Lots and lots of political BS kept planes on the ground then. Arnold has been a big help by getting Michael Chertoff to authorize relief almost immediately. Chertoff has been here and seen first hand the devastation and is eager to help after the bad impression of Katrina. This is not nearly the same thing as Katrina. It is unfolding over days and is ongoing. The danger is constant. It is taking many days to play out. There was no advance warning as with a hurricane. And when people have been told to leave, they got the hell out! The only similarity to Katrina (IMHO) is that some people have lost everything and things will never be the same...

90 planes and 9 million illegals to stop the fires

Maybe Claire Shipman should have asked the Governator if California was going to employ those 9 million illegals out there to help put out fires instead of jamming up the lines at Walmart all day.

Gee HAS ANYONE NOTICED, not one Mexican has come forward to call on their people to help fight the fires as a thank you to the United States.

Newsbuster exclusive.

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

  The msm has become an

 

The msm has become an utter embarrassment.

 

I'm a refugee from the Democratic Party.

 

SHIPMAN: So, you think the

SHIPMAN: So, you think the comparison to Katrina that every-body's making in the back of their mind these days is a good one in terms of state and federal.

This is what makes me furious with these nit-wit talking heads that have no clue but try their best to act as if they are speaking for all Americans, or any Americans for that matter except the loony leftists like themselves....

Katrina is not was not on or in the back of anyone's minds but you idiots with an obvious political agenda.

You make me ill.... all of you!

By the way...here is another bunch of inteninally inserted political BS by the sleazy Shipman..... 

SHIPMAN: So the governor is positive, but practical. He actively encouraged President Bush to come out here as soon as possible. He knows that despite the disruption this presidential visit will cause tomorrow, it will keep the federal government and all of its resources focused on California, ideally hoping to stave off any Katrina-like situations.

If this was Clintoon coming out for the same exact reason he would be hailed as the next coming...

Talk about hypocrites with an obvious agenda when people are hurting.

Filthy...just plain filthy.

 

The lefty MSM loves unnamed

The lefty MSM loves unnamed sources.

Journalism 101.... Name a source or two once in awhile.

"EVERYBODY???" Do list a few people. I'm sure they all come from the left!

 

 

I'm a refugee from the Democratic Party.

 

BRAVO!

After seeing that clip I have new found respect for the Governator. 

Let this be a lesson to Arnold

This should be a lesson to Arnold that just because he acts like a liberal most of the time, as long as he has an R next to his name he will be a target of unrelenting attacks from the MSM.

Don't be fooled - Arnold's

Don't be fooled - Arnold's no Republican.  He also said last night that we also have a responsibility to help restore what was destroyed (translation: the government will pay for everything).  He really is a Democrat with an "R" next to his name.

Dutch

Darth... Bingo! He has

Darth...

Bingo!

He has been a big disappointment for me in Calif.

I am glad for him handling Shipman and some of the press the way he does ...other than that he has hurt the people on the right that voted for him in Calif. in so many ways...illegals are one main sticking point.

He is nothing but a big socialist can't we all have a group hug kinda guy....Kennedy family and ambition has always helped.

Guess he figures if ya can't beat em' join em'....to others detriment.

BT, to Arnolds credit, he

BT, to Arnolds credit, he has always said he is a physical conservative and social liberal. I cant agree with social liberals, goes aginst my grain, but he has always been honest about it. He is losing his physical grip tho. The best thing to say about Arnold, is he is one of a kind.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

But there is the rub.  How

But there is the rub.  How do you fund all of the socially liberal programs if you also want to be fiscally conservative.  One has to give way to the other.  And in Arnold's case, it's clear that, after the special election when he really tried to pass a number of conservative proposals that would have limit government and unions and the voters turned those down, he has swung so hard to the left it's surprising that he didn't break a bone.  He can talk about being fiscally conservative all he wants, but we in California are now in a worse state financially than we were when Gray Davis was governor and that's saying a lot.  Arnold's liberal politics will always trump his so-called desire for fiscal conservatism.

Darth Dutch

Good for him

Good for the Guv. The only way to clean up the journalist-agitprops who infested the MSM is to, on camera, call their bluff, and challenge their assumptions. With trust in journalists at an all-time low, it's time to clean up the mess they have created.

yeaaaaaaaaaaaaah!!!!

yeaaaaaaaaaaaaah!!!!

The movie

The movie you are referring to is Commando

this reminds me of the

this reminds me of the occurance several years ago when they were chasing a child molester in orange county. the sherriff was addressing the media and finally had had enough of their whining and sniviling.

he held up a picture of the guy and mentioned very loudly that this guy was a child molester, had murdered, after raping repeatedly, a small girl and he wanted him in his jail immediately. no reward was offered and the feeling taken from the sound bite was that if the guy was dead it would save orange county quite a bit of money.

the media acted as if the guy had dumped a big one in the chamaigne.  

the miscreaent was in custody in about 32 hours.

(now if only arnold could work on his tendancy to spend our tax money like it was water.) 

Shipman: "With all due

Shipman: "With all due respect governor, you're not following the story line, OK you didn't bite with the Katrina comparison. How about Bush, couldn't Bush have started these fires to distract from his abysmal record in the middle east, or perhaps since the republicans stopped the amnesty bill, these fired were ignited by angry aliens? Or maybe these fires were started by conservative talk radio? Come on governor get with the program."

Ahhnold: Claire, you ignorant slut, you sound just like the  Lt.governor and all the other girly man democrats. Hasta La Vista Baby.     

great stuff.

great stuff.

Glad Arnold dident break

Glad Arnold dident break anything there. But in the end, she still just couldent let the Katrina thing go. Had to keep it out there.
 

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Arnie Rocks

Arnie has been pissing me off lately, going pretty hard left on global warming and such, but now he's redeeming himself.

He should've bench-pressed Shipman.. do some curls.. freak'n clean-jerk the broad. It wouldn't be the first time.. The man is a monster with the chicks.

Fires

Hooray for Arnold! It's about time that somebody gives these scum-sucking media what they deserve.  Always looking to blame the people who are actually trying to help, and never the person who caused the problem.

Commando

The "I will kill you last" line is from Commando!!!

She knew she was lying.

Shipman phrased her question in such a way that we all could know that she was lying.  When you want to propagate a lie that you know is a lie, without taking credit (or blame) for it yourself, you start out by saying "Some say..." as in "Some say that the sky is falling..."

When Shipman says: "So, you think the comparison to Katrina that everybody's making in the back of their mind these days..." she is making it clear that she has made this up.  She is not making this claim herself, she is quoting un-named others, who are not even saying this, but who are thinking this "in the back of their minds."  This is a great technique you use when you want to confront someone and see what their response is.  If they buy into the lie, then you have gotten the sound-bite that you wanted, and it makes the lie sound more true.  If they confront you with your lie, you just shrug it off because they're not your words.

"Some say you beat your wife..."

"Some say the planet is warming up..."

"Some say it's your fault..."

That post is priceless. I

That post is priceless. I want to save it. Classic stuff.

 

We all know what the political views are of Shipman. 

 

It is refreshing to see how Arnold dealt with her.  It is surprising more republicans are not as able as Arnold to deal with someone like Shipman who is so obviously looking to score for her liberal "friends". 

 

Arnold was polite, responsive, and 100% effective.  Thank you Arnold. What is special about Arnold is that I don't believe he has much hate in him.  He has no desire to embarass her.  He was just not going to let them push him around IN ANY WAY and get away with shading the truth.  Not at Arnold's expense. 

Ok now someone needs to

Ok now someone needs to explain to me how president bush walking around the stadium visiting with politicos and the families needing to be there will effect the firefighters 20-30 miles away?  Guess I'm a little slow but I don't think they make a presidential firefighting suit.   These people are a total waste of oxygen.

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSH LOL

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

Ideally hoping to stave off any Katrina-like situations...

AMAZING!! She said the President is coming, "Ideally hoping to stave off any Katrina-like situations...".

Clearly saying: "he wants to stave off any situation like the one we, the media, created with Katrina...but we'll make sure he doesn't!!!"