ABC Reporters Laud Gore; Applaud Use of Propaganda

Photo of Scott Whitlock.
By Scott Whitlock | October 16, 2007 - 17:34 ET

ABC contributor Cokie Roberts apparently approves of propaganda, as long as she agrees with it. The veteran journalist appeared with George Will and Sam Donaldson on Sunday's "This Week." In response to a claim by token conservative Will that Al Gore grossly exaggerates the threat of global warming, Roberts positively assessed, "The truth is, there have always been propagandists who make something popular."

Using a strained comparison, Roberts continued to justify Gore's misinformation by arguing that the former Vice President popularizes the work of climate change scientists: "Go back to the revolution....You had Tom Paine and you had the Continental Congress. So you do have the two and they both work for a debate."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

If there was any confusion about what Roberts thought of the useful nature of propaganda, she cleared it up by gushing, "But good for Al Gore. He worked hard on this. He got this prize." A few minutes earlier, host George Stephanopoulos allowed Will a few minutes to offer some token denunciations of Gore. Veteran ABC journalist Sam Donaldson apparently could only take so much. Like Roberts, he also lauded Gore for doing "very important" work and derided skeptics as being in denial. Addressing Will, he hyperbolically lectured, "Now, if you and Senator [James] Inhofe want to continue to stick your heads in the sand - I'm going to make it out. I'm old enough that I probably will get out of here before the Earth collapses, but I have grandchildren, George." A bewildered Will could only wonder, "How does the Earth collapse?"

On an unrelated note, host Stephanopoulos interviewed House Speaker Nancy Pelosi earlier in the program. He closed the segment with some comments that seemed to be aimed at portraying the liberal Pelosi as a moderate. (Her lifetime score from the American Conservative Union, by the way, is three.) Stephanopoulos commented that the House Speaker has been facing "disaffection in the Democratic base, anti-war activists." After playing a clip of protester Cindy Sheehan attacking Pelosi, he marveled, "But how strange that is that for you, though? You know, your entire career you get attacked as a San Francisco liberal and now your most vociferous opponents are on your own side." The Congresswoman quickly retorted, "Well, I'm one of the most vociferous opponents of the war."

For a comprehensive look at Stephanopoulos's history of bias, check out the anchor's section in the MRC's Profiles in Bias.

Partial transcripts of the two segments, which aired at 10:15am and 10:33am on October 14, follow.

10:15AM

GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS: We're just about out of time. You know, the Congressional approval ratings have taken a hit this year. A lot of that, as you know, is because of disaffection in the Democratic base, anti-war activists -

SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE NANCY PELOSI: Right.

STEPHANOPOULOS: Cindy Sheehan's running against you.

CINDY SHEEHAN [Speech clip]: And not only am I going to run against her, but I will beat her in California.

PELOSI: I respect the dissatisfaction with the war and myself would not give Congress high marks on ending the war. We don't have the veto - the pen to sign or not to veto. But we are doing all we can to change the debate. But I do think that many of the things we have done again that I mentioned and I won't go over again, about the safety and security of our country and the strengthening our families and protecting our environment are very important to our base and to the country. And for that reason, we are double-digit in every issue - practically every issue you can name would you vote for Democrat or Republican in relationship to health, education, and the economy, the environment, et cetera. So I'm not sad about our Democratic numbers. They're excellent. Turning Congress - the opinion of Congress around is a big task and we're working on it. And you're right, most of the - much of the dissatisfaction is from the Democratic base.

STEPHANOPOULOS: But how strange that is that for you, though? You know, your entire career you get attacked as a San Francisco liberal and now your most vociferous opponents are on your own side.

PELOSI: Well, I'm one of the most vociferous opponents of the war. And so that is more ironic. But again, I was an advocate myself. By their nature, they are dissatisfied, persistent, and just keep fighting. And I respect that. It's an important part of our democracy. And I, you know, wish this war would end as well. And we will continue to pass legislation to make that point. We happen to be blocked by 60-vote hurdle in the Senate, but the public doesn't care about that. They just want us to end the war.

STEPHANOPOULOS: Barney Frank says this is a moment of truth for liberals. Is he right?

PELOSI: It is. It's a dynamic. I don't know if it's a moment but it is a dynamic. And it is - and any issue you can name, we want it more for SCHIP, that's for sure. We want more - we want to end the war faster. Almost every category you can name, we would have rather had a higher minimum wage and done it even - well, almost every category you want to do more. And the legislative process is you do what you can pass, but you don't settle for anything that isn't bold enough, that isn't bold enough. And so I'm very proud of our caucus, the consensus we have on a bold agenda to take us in a new direction. And again, sometimes our base is not happy with that. But I think in the long run, we will prevail in next year's election with even a stronger majority and a Democrat in the White House. And I look forward to that.

10:33am

STEPHANOPOULOS: But I do want to begin, though, and I have to do this for George with the Al Gore Nobel Peace Prize because, George, when I heard this on Friday morning I said, this is designed to drive you, George Will, crazy. You don't like the Nobel Peace committee. You don't like Al Gore. You don't think global warming is a crisis.

GEORGE WILL: Right on all three counts. The New York Times, in one of those headlines that I'm sure it really believes is without editorial content said "Gore Vindicated." I suppose in that sense Yasser Arafat, world's foremost terrorist was vindicated by getting the Nobel Peace Prize. It actually was two prizes. They say he's sharing the price with the Intergovernmental Panel on -

STEPHANOPOULOS: Climate Change.

WILL: --on climate change, but they're doing two different things. The panel does the science. He does the hyperbole that gets people to pay attention to the science. And there are all kinds of scientists who are quite candid about this. The panel says over the next century we might anticipate a one-foot increase in the sea levels, approximately what we've had since 1860 without a planetary crisis. Mr. Gore says 20 feet, hence the scene in his movie where Ground Zero is inundated.

STEPHANOPOULOS: Yeah.

WILL: Because he assumes all of the ice in Greenland melts, which scientists say could happen in a thousand years or more.

SAM DONALDSON: Whoa, whoa. There are now studies which suggest that within 30 years the polar ice cap may melt.

Will: It's not polar. We're talking about Greenland. Go ahead.

DONALDSON: Well it's near enough for government work. Did Al Gore deserve the prize? I think he's pointed out something and he's been the leading exponent publicly of something that's very important. Now, if you and Senator Inhofe want to continue to stick your heads in the sand - I'm going to make it out. I'm old enough that I probably will get out of here before the Earth collapses, but I have grandchildren, George.

WILL: How does the Earth collapse?

DONALDSON: Well, the Earth collapses -

COKIE ROBERTS: Well there have always - The truth is, there have always been propagandists who make something popular. Go back to the revolution. You know, oh, you had Tom Paine and you had the Continental Congress. So you do have the two and they both work for a debate. But good for Al Gore. He worked hard on this. He got this prize. The question now is what does it mean politically?

STEPHANOPOULOS: The immediate question.

ROBERTS: That's right.

DONALDSON: Nothing.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Cokie, I knew Tom Paine

I knew Thomas Paine and Al Gore is no Tom Paine.

Typcial liberal

Typcial liberal philosophers. "It doesn't matter if the story is correct, it's the message that counts."

Liberalism is based upon the premise that it's entirely possible to pick up a turd by the 'clean' end.

You know, oh, you had Tom

You know, oh, you had Tom Paine and you had the Continental Congress. So you do have the two and they both work for a debate.

Ah! But therein lies the problem, Cokie (if that's your real name) ... Gore declared the debate over ... before even having one ...

Gore GOT his prize

Probably the only true words spoken by Coke and Sam as Gore did not earn this prize, was not awarded this prize........but GOT this prize for selling his soul to the globalists for power.

Gore is the same jerk who changed his pro life stance for power and changed his vote for air time trades.

Coke and Sam can drool over Gore and look like fools.......the only problem they have is not global warming but GLOBAL WAR which is coming up.

 

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

If man-made "global warming"

If man-made "global warming" was an actual phenomenon, wouldn't Sam Donaldson's toupee be a major contributing factor?

If Man-made global warming,

If Man-made global warming, we did it for a reason. Man dosent like it cold. I like lots of water around. Man likes to listen to the rain at night. Man likes to frolic in the surf. Man likes to look at the women in bikinis. Lots of reasons for man made global warming. The only ones I see harping about it is the ones that dont look good in swim suits.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Collapse Earth

Nope.  Can't think of how the earth would collapse.  Have read if you could eliminate all the distances between atoms and electrons and such, you could fit the earth on a pinhead.  Maybe something along those lines.  Anybody know if its true?  Factoid?

Sometimes when I get into debates with libs, I just have to shake my head.  How the heck does one go about debating with them when they person doesn't have a clue.  George Will must wonder which planet they are from.  Who has they're head in the sand?  Will, who I'm sure has read both sides or Donaldson who I'm sure has read only the Globull warming crap. 

*Argue for your limitations and sure enough you will achieve them.

Gore has taken what should

Gore has taken what should be scientific discussion and USA Today-ized it, right down to the colorful charts. Talk about dumbing something down so the dumbies who buy it can run down the street screaming...

  Now, if you and Senator

  Now, if you and Senator Inhofe want to continue to stick your heads in the sand - I'm going to make it out. I'm old enough that I probably will get out of here before the Earth collapses, but I have grandchildren, George.

 

So, Sam, I take it you have The Golden Ticket on some alien space craft?  And you're leaving your grandkids behind??!!?? What kind of selfish prig are you?

 

Earth collapse ...

Umm, Sammy, that would be a Black Hole ...

I think he's trying to

I think he's trying to claim the  prize money for proving AGW is real. But I think he's wasting his time.

"There is a clear attempt to establish truth not by scientific methods but by perpetual repetition."
- Richard S. Lindzen, Ph.D. Professor of Meteorology, MIT

Cheney's Turn

Thats it. Its our turn. When Cheney retires, again, he should go on an all out,world wide, media blitz for a year about the devastation our civilization will have to endure if the Liberal idiots take over our great country.

We can call it "man made idiocy tour", and march out all the believers in conservatism to trash every liberal program under the sun.

Just sayin'

(think he is nobel material?....nahhhh!)

Joseph Goebbels

If you're going to give an award for producing propaganda, go to the grandfather: Joseph Goebbels

We should humorously give the same title to Al Gore, "New Minister of Enlightenment and Global Warming Propaganda". Michael Moore could be "Junior Minister of Enlightenment and Non-Sequitur Propaganda"

"Boats are safe in the harbor, but that's not what they're made for." -- Maritime quote

Al Gorebbels

It would appear that the MSM is admitting that they're following the Goebbels model as it pertains to 'information'.

MSM needs Balance....they are OOB

These talking Heads sitting around each Alphabet network patting each other on the back isn't good for us, or them.

It's a Cloistered Society of Talking heads, there is no outside influence, they cannot be shaken or stirred, ice or no ice.  It's a mutual admiration Society.

Unless we get hit by 3 ft of snow in New York or Chicago this winter, or maybe the Coldest Winter in 50 years, or some other Event to shake them up, they will end their carrers embracing each other like the "View" group.

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

JT is OOB short for

inbred mutants?

OOB

Out of Brains

Out of Balance

Out of Bounds

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

"Unless we get hit by 3 ft

"Unless we get hit by 3 ft of snow in New York or Chicago this winter, or maybe the Coldest Winter in 50 years, or some other Event to shake them up, they will end their carrers embracing each other like the "View" group. "

No, no ,no haven't you been listening to the propaganda? Any abnormal swing in temperature,up or down, is caused by AGW. Also, any natural disaster be it weahter or geologic will also be attributed to AGW. And, lest we forget, in case the children are not terrified enough already any time a cute fuzzy animal dies it is the fault of AGW. Come on now, get with the program.

/sarc off

 The MSM will go down in flames with AGW, preaching it to the bitter end, they are to invested in it. Then when they are proven wrong they will do what they always do, ignore it and carry on as if nothing happened.

 

"In any compromise between good and evil, only evil can profit." Ayn Rand

The brains must be really

The brains must be really pi$$ed.

Just saw, even with all this. The majority of Americans still don't want Gore as president.

What can a hysteric do to be crowned emperor. 

"There is a clear attempt to establish truth not by scientific methods but by perpetual repetition."
- Richard S. Lindzen, Ph.D. Professor of Meteorology, MIT

ALGORE

I had a coffee through the nose and all over the paper moment this past weekend when my wife casually mentioned " I think Al Gore won the Publishers Clearinghouse Sweepstakes or something...

LMAO!!!!

LMAO!!!!

ROFL, tears in eyes, WR,

ROFL, tears in eyes, WR, make this your tag line, extremely funny and deep.  This will be an excellent response everytime a lib just mentions the name, Al Gore.  Oh, you mean that guy who won the Publishers Clearinghouse Sweepstakes or something...

This is sure to enrage the libs, you might even get Ann Coulter to join in on that one.

Hanlon's Razor: Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity

Dan Rather standard

Apparently you can be wrong on the facts but still be correct because your heart is in the right place.  Because liberals are morally superior.

Dan Rather helped define the new Gold Standard in journalism: never mind that the facts are falsified - if you think you have a good story go ahead and tell it.  "We decide/We report/You listen".