ABC Gleefully Plays Watergate Tapes Attacking 'Dumb' Thompson

Photo of Scott Whitlock.

On Tuesday's "Good Morning America," ABC contributor Brian Ross chose the day of Fred Thompson's first debate to slam the 2008 candidate for his work as a lawyer on the Watergate hearings 34 years ago and also play clips questioning the then-attorney's intelligence. The investigative correspondent intoned that although Thompson has touted his role in the hearings, "a much different, less valiant picture of Thompson emerges from listening to the White House audiotapes made at the time as President Nixon plotted strategy with his aides in the Oval Office." Ross proceeded to play several clips of Richard Nixon calling Thompson "dumb as hell" and of administration associates alleging that the lawyer will help the White House.

As all of this information is old news, the Ross report is clearly timed to injure Thompson on the day of his big debate. The New York Times reported the same allegations way back on August 27, 2007. The article, by Jo Becker, used many of the same Nixon quotes. (And, in fact, a report by ABC's own Jake Tapper preceded the NYT article and also mentioned Nixon's "dumb as hell" line.) Ross closed his October 9 segment by snidely noting, "We tried to get a response from Thompson but his staff did not return our phone calls and he walked right by us when we tried to put the question to him in person." However, the ABC reporter also referenced other Thompson associates, such as former Senator Howard Baker, who appointed Thompson to the Watergate investigation. And although Baker is very much still alive, did Ross seemed unable to find anyone of that era who would go on record and say something positive about Thompson.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

GMA co-host Robin Roberts introduced the segment with a tone that suggested new information was about to be revealed. She breathlessly asserted, "And ABC News spent several months digging some revealing tapes out of the national archives, shedding light on Thompson's role as a young lawyer, investigating the Watergate scandal."

However, as noted earlier, both The New York Times and ABC have previously reported many of the key quotes. Ross played this clip during his October 9 segment:

Alexander Haig: "He's talking to Fred Thompson. I said you're not-"

Richard Nixon: "Oh, [Bleep]. He's dumb as hell. Fred Thompson. Who's-- Who's he? He won't say anything."

The August 27 New York Times reported it this way:

Moreover, new transcripts from the Nixon White House tapes reveal that the Nixon administration regarded Thompson as a useful idiot -- "dumb as hell," in President Nixon's words, but "friendly."

And Jake Tapper reported on this even earlier, on August 7. The GMA "investigative team," however, has yet to look into the Hillary Clinton campaign hiring convicted document thief Sandy Berger.

Also, it should be noted that this is the second time in less than a week that GMA has used Richard Nixon as a club to attack conservatives. On October 5, David Wright defended Barack Obama's decision not to wear a U.S. flag lapel pin by pointing out that Nixon wore one while "he told the American people he had nothing to do with Watergate."

A transcript of the segment, which aired October 9 at 7:10am, follows:

ABC Graphic: "The Fred Thompson Files: Watergate Tapes Reveal Nixon’s Thoughts"

Roberts: "All eyes will be on former Senator Fred Thompson when he walks on the stage for the Republican debate tonight, his first debate since he joined the presidential race. And ABC News spent several months digging some revealing tapes out of the national archives, shedding light on Thompson's role as a young lawyer, investigating the Watergate scandal. ABC News chief investigative correspondent Brian Ross is here with more. Very enlightening, Brian. Good morning."

Brian Ross: "Good morning, Robin. Fred Thompson's made much of his role 30 years ago as a young Senate lawyer, helping to lead the investigation of Watergate and President Richard Nixon. But a much different, less valiant picture of Thompson emerges from listening to the White House audiotapes made at the time as President Nixon plotted strategy with his aides in the Oval Office. Thompson's job on the Watergate committee was to lead the Republican side of the investigation. Appointed by his mentor, Senator Howard Baker, of Tennessee. When Nixon's aide, H.R. Haldeman told him of the Thompson's appointment, Nixon was less than impressed."

H.R. Haldeman: "Baker has appointed Fred Thompson as minority counsel."

President Richard Nixon. "Oh, [Bleep]. That kid."

Haldeman: "I guess so."

Ross: "Nixon worried that Thompson's Democratic counterpart, Sam Dash, would outsmart Thompson."

Nixon: "Dash is too smart for that kid."

John Dean: "Sure. Runs circles around him."

Ross: "As the investigation picked up speed, Nixon grew increasingly concerned about Thompson standing up to the Democrats, speaking here with his then chief of staff Alexander Haig."

Alexander Haig: "He's talking to Fred Thompson. I said you're not-"

Nixon: "Oh, [Bleep]. He's dumb as hell. Fred Thompson. Who's-- Who's he? He won't say anything."

Ross: "Weeks later, Thompson was still being described in the Oval Office as not very smart but, at least, beginning to play ball."

Fred Buzhardt: "Our approach is now, we've got pretty good rapport with Fred Thompson. He came through fine through for us this morning."

Nixon: "He isn't very smart, is he?"

Buzhardt: "Not extremely so--

Nixon: "But he's friendly."

Buzhardt: "But he's, he's friendly."

Nixon: "Good."

Ross: "A few days later, White House aides are heard saying that Thompson will be even more helpful than his boss, Senator Baker. And that Thompson agreed to secretly help undercut the credibility of white house whistle blower John Dean."

Buzhardt: "They've finally got him under oath. Thompson will work with us so that--"

Ross: "Does he realize that Dean has some problems?"

Buzhardt: "Oh, yes, sir, quite a few. He is willing to work with us. He is also now willing to work with us on shifting some focus to the Democrats. He's finally made up his mind he's got to start look at some of their stuff."

Scott Armstrong (Fmr. Investigator, Senate Watergate Cmte): "It was the equivalent of two prosecutors, because supposedly this was bipartisan, knowing about something and one of them going behind the scenes to tell the person being accused what the witnesses were saying about him."

Buzhardt: "He's willing to go, you know, pretty much the distance now. And he said he realized his responsibility was going to have to be as a Republican increasingly."

Ross: "Two months later, Nixon resigned and Thompson would later take credit for helping to reveal the secret White House taping system that led to Nixon's downfall. We tried to get a response from Thompson but his staff did not return our phone calls and he walked right by us when we tried to put the question to him in person."

Roberts: "All right, Brian. And again, many anxious to see how he'll do tonight in his first presidential debate."

Ross: "Big moment for him."

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Ahhhhhh, our unbiased media

Ahhhhhh, our unbiased media at work.

Famous last words

"Fred Thomsen? Who's he? He's dumb as hell..." 

- Highly-Disgraced, Former, Resigned-or-Would-Have-Been-Impeached, Ex-President Nixon

A service of the new NB respect police

My thought, exactly, TM.

My thought, exactly, TM. Since when do the media value anything that came out of the mouth of Richard Nixon?????

when it helps them

when it helps them lie:) 

A service of the new NB respect police

Well, where are the other tapes, Brian Ross?

ABC doesn't seem to be very consistent with what tapes it deems worthy of playing for the voters, does it?

From Progressive Review On-Line Report #70 , 28 Jan 1998.

While the press has no problem reporting such stories about Barry (or Dan Quayle for that matter), it has not told the public about the existence of a police tape of Roger Clinton describing his own cocaine trafficking and saying of his brother, "Got to get some for my brother; he's got a nose like a vacuum cleaner."

--  A former informant for a drug task force in Arkansas tells Ambrose Evans-Pritchard of the London Telegraph that she supplied Bill with c ocaine during his first terms as governor. On one occasion, according to the woman, "He was so messed up that night, he slid down the wall into a garbage can."

Certainly, that was well sourced enough for Dan Rather, or/ no one has proven it wrong, yet.

It amuses me that the

It amuses me that the extremist leftists in the news media would suddenly use Richard Nixon as their arbiter of the truth!

If ANYONE listed to those Nixon tapes they would hear a vulgar, hateful, nearly psychotic man (Nixon) blathering about every enemy and hating everyone! Nixon had a severe mental problem for sure.

Yet, here we have the news media using this unbalanced man's words to condemn Thompson!

And let's see where else the MSM views Nixon's words are approaching "truth" on any subject.... wait they DON'T!

LOL, Warner

I was thinking the same thing.   The drive-by media is sooo transparent.   ;^>

Me too. I also found it

Me too.

I also found it interesting that the MSM has interest Fred's background from over 30 years ago, but they didn't display the same interest when it came to Kerry's military record 30 years ago since he "reported for duty" during his campaign.

Nixon is an MSM man of

Nixon is an MSM man of stature now:)!

And Fred used to pee his pants too - in kindygarten 

A service of the new NB respect police

Yeah, it's amazing how smart

Yeah, it's amazing how smart Nixon has become, isn't it? It took them 30 years to appreciate him....LOL

he can be dumb again,

he can be dumb again, too - or both simultaneously, or neither - you can easily mix and match...!

dizzy now:((((

A service of the new NB respect police

Gee, why not Warner?

Gee, why not Warner? Everytime they have Jimmy Carter on, they bring his statements up on screen:

The Rich pardons: "In my opinion, that [Clinton's actions] was disgraceful."

And,

Kosovo: "[Our attack [Clinton's]] has been counterproductive, and our destruction of civilian life has now become senseless and excessively brutal... The American-led force has expanded targets to inhabited areas and resorted to the use of anti-personnel cluster bombs. The result has been damage to hospitals, offices and residences of a half-dozen ambassadors, and the killing of innocent civilians... [Our] insistence on the use of cluster bombs, designed to kill or maim humans, is condemned almost universally and brings discredit to our nation."

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thompson is lazy. Thompson is dumb.

They said the same thing about Reagan.  

30+ years ago..?

This is Dumb, not Fred.   Going back 34 years ...... Fred the kid was probably dummer than Nixon.... Go back 50 years ago, and he probably couldn't even Spell...but lets not talk about 10 years ago when he won a Senate Seat...that's current events...and they don't wanna go there..but their "ah fixin to go there" ...and so is Hillary. 

There' not enough Dirt on Fred to cover up any Clinton, male or female, but the MSM won't put the shovel in the ground on Hillary Inc..

I wouldn't talk to you MSM guys either, and instead of walking right by you, I'd probably break into a Jog.

What happend to Hsu ?  etc..etc... 

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

Why is it that something

Why is it that something Clinton said or did a few months ago or last year is "old news" and "ancient history" and has no bearing on her now, but Nixon's opinion of Thompson back in the 70's is relevant? Jeez, Clinton doesn't even think what she did in the 90's matters now.

I'll bet if they go look up her classmates at Wellesley, they could find some that didn't think very much of her....nah, they wouldn't do that.

34 years

So they have to go back 34 years and use hearsay from the Nixson era in order to find "dirt" on Thopmson. Well I bet you could go back 34 years in many a persons life and find hearsay form others that does not reflect well on the person in question as well. How much can a person mature in 34 years? I’d say this attack on Thompson was stupid, out of touch and irrelevant after 34 years.

Now they Quote Nixon???

If Nixon is right about Thompson being "dumb as hell" then maybe he was right about the Left being out to get him.... How intelligent are you when you use someone to whom you give no credibility as a source? Who are the dumb ones, anyway?

This is part of the substance-avoidance technique of the Left: Rather than debate substantive issues, describe your opponent as "dumb," "angry," "zealous," "out-of-touch," etc.... Anything but talk about the issues...even giving creedence to something Nixon said....

"Ignorance has a well known Liberal bias." - Publius

Dittos mattm

My first thought as well Matt - You've got to be kidding me. The same demedia that persecuted Nixon (and then some) is now quoting him to their perceived advantage?

I just have to laugh at audacity of the demedia while crying for the poor souls that buy into this madness.

File another one under the demedia leaving no stone unturned in their quest to coronate Her Thighness.  Or as the dems prefer to call it - getting their message out.

Will somebody please tell my

Will somebody please tell me how in the hell left-wing, liberal idealogs can claim that the MSM is biased to the right (and not just Fox News) with this type of sh*t that is spewed everyday?!!!  I am so sick of the concerted effort of the MSM to make republicans look bad;  it is suprising they win any office with the deck so stacked against them!  DAMN!

Ah.. the double standard of our MSM

Fred Thompson's past can be dredged up from 34 years ago, but when that PHONEY Senator, Hillary CLINTON, has been the focus of numerous investigations, and now has hired one of her Husbands aids that STOLE DOCUMENTS FROM THE US ARCHIVES, that doesn't get so much as a second thought. The continuous perversion of journalism, and blatently LYING by omission to the public, is treason and should be dealt with accordingly. Hillary "I have no recollection of those Whitewater files being in my bedroom with my finger prints all over them" CLINTON will get a pass by our transparent MSM. Despicable.

The American Revolution Continued

Good point.

Good point.

Good point.

Good point.

Why doesn't Fox News pursue

Why doesn't Fox News pursue those issues more, then? Why don't they push those issues into the limelight?

its time to moveon dot

its time to moveon

dot org 

A service of the new NB respect police

Political Voting Guide by:

Political Voting Guide
by: Ima Dumcon Sirvative

Polyticks is hard to figger,
But one thing that fer sure.
Whoever the media's agin,
That's who I am fer.

You might not know just who should run,
Nor even who should win.
But whoever big media's fer,
That's who I'm agin.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq  to derail the impeachment vote:  “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

The so-called "mainstream"

The so-called "mainstream" media's obsessive desire to get a Democrat elected would be hilarious if it wasn't so transparent and disgusting. What passes for "journalism" these days includes tossing nothing but sycophantic softballs to Hillary, BJ, Edwards, Carter and Obama; then submarining Republican candidates by dredging up cheap gossip about Rudy, Mitt and Fred...reporting it as relevant, important news. This was a lame hit job, nothing more, nothing less. Last week, they used a convenient Nixon Watergate clip to imply that wearing a flag pin was essentially phony patriotism...thus giving cover to that buffoon Obama for his idiotic comment on the matter. This week, Nixon is all of a sudden a great American for questioning the intelligence of Fred Thompson...well over thirty years ago! If that's not trying to have it both ways! Geez, Brian Ross, don't you have enough pervs to stalk?

ROTFLOL!!!!

I remember when they were saying almost EXACTLY the same stuff about Ronald Reagan. He was stupid, unsophisticated and just an actor who read scripts.

Definition of "dumb" according to Nixon: Someone who doesn't do as he is told for political purposes. Can't be easily manipulated. Won't suborndinate investigative ethics to political expediancy.

He was so "dumb" that the Nixon crew thought they were controlling him right up until the moment he slammed the cage shut by revealing the tapes.

 



The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back!  Fred08.com

C5Explosion

Are you saying the Democrats are using an old Regan strategy that works.....worked....for the Republicans  ? 

All right, far out....

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

Eye Of The Beholder

So, Nixon thought Thompson was dumb, huh?  Well, let's see: Nixon was a petulant, petty, self-serving president who resigned in disgrace and lived out his remaining days dreaming of what could have been.  Fred Thompson has had a distinguished career as a United States Senator, managed a pretty fine acting career, and he is shaping up to be one helluva promising presidential candidate who gives a direct and honest answer to any question put to him. And he has a beautiful and intelligent wife by his side.  So, who is the dumb one again? 

Oh, and Brian Ross is an opportunistic, mudraking troll. 

Mr. Nixon on Clinton

Mr. Nixon on Clinton: "The American people don't believe anything's real until they
see it on television," he said. "When Whitewater hearings are televised, it will
be Clinton's turn in the bucket."

Here is an interesting tid-bit:

http://findarticles....

 

I've posted this before and

I've posted this before and here it is again:

GWB is an idiot, Reagan was a dunce, Nixon was stupid and Eisenhower was dumb (or whatever term was used back then to describe one's intelligence).

What else do they have in common?  Each was elected to 2 terms.

That makes 8 dem presidential candidates that lost to people that lacked intelligence.  Hmmm.  

There are even more dems that lost to these people when you include lower offices.

 

I tried to avoid reading or

I tried to avoid reading or listening to anything proclaimed by Brian Ross. He makes me want to scream!

BTW, the msm is trying very hard to turn the public against Fred Thompson...he must scare them for some reason.