ABC Leaps to Defend the Laughter of Fun-Loving Hillary Clinton

Photo of Scott Whitlock.

On Monday’s "Good Morning America," ABC reporter Kate Snow rose to the defense of Hillary Clinton and the fact that she’s been seen manically giggling in many interviews. Referencing the mocking that the Democratic presidential candidate has taken on "The Daily Show" and other places, Snow asserted that either Hillary Clinton is either "having a really good time out on the campaign trail, or she's the master of a shrewd political skill, disarming her critics with a gleam in her eye and a roar straight from the belly." So, the former First Lady is vibrant and fun-loving or brilliant in a good natured way? Those are the only two options?

During the segment, only Democratic operatives or Clinton campaign officials were asked to explain the candidate’s recent outburst of giggles (except for a brief "Daily Show" clip). According to Snow, "Her inner circle insists her laugh is not calculated. It's natural." Clinton operative Capricia Marshall found Hillary’s laughter to be "contagious." Democratic strategist Chris Lehane glowingly described the cackling as "smart and pretty adroit." What else would ABC and Kate Snow expect them to say?

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Co-host Robin Roberts introduced the piece by sympathetically observing of Clinton, "...It is not easy being the front-runner." An ABC graphic defensively read, "Laughing in Face of Critics: The Debate Over Clinton Chuckle" And despite the friendly nature of the piece, the GMA host and reporter seemed embarrassed to even be talking about it. Almost apologizing, Snow asserted, "Okay, maybe we are over analyzing a little bit here" and deemed the giggling to be a political weapon. After playing a clip of Clinton defending her laughter by saying that she had been slammed previously for not laughing enough, Roberts agreed. She added, "But she has a bit of a point there. When a lot of people were critical of her because she wasn't showing a sense of humor and then she does do that–" Snow quickly interrupted to concur that "when you're a front-runner, you get it from everybody."

In contrast, even the New York Times managed to show some more skepticism then Ms. Snow. In a September 30 piece by Patrick Healy, the Times made the point that GMA dared not mention. The laughter can just come across as odd:

The weirdest moment was with Bob Schieffer on the CBS News program "Face the Nation" when Mr. Schieffer said to Mrs. Clinton, "You rolled out your new health care plan, something Republicans immediately said is going to lead to socialized medicine." She giggled, giggled some more, and then could not seem to stop giggling — "Sorry, Bob," she said — and finally unleashed the full Cackle.

The Schieffer moment seemed particularly calculated because Mrs. Clinton has most certainly not laughed in other settings when she has been accused of pursuing socialized medicine. She faced that accusation at a forum in Las Vegas this summer, for instance; she turned frosty and traded barbs with the audience member who made the assertion. It was clearly no laughing matter there.

ABC viewers probably should expect more of this type of reporting. After all, "Good Morning America" is the program that, in January, identified the battle between Clinton and Obama as "hot factor" versus "fluid poetry."

A transcript of the October 1 segment, which aired at 7:43am follows:

7:43am

Robin Roberts: "As we showed you earlier this morning, it is not easy being the front-runner. ‘Saturday Night Live’ took some, well, liberty with Hillary Clinton and they're not the only ones. Now, Senator Clinton’s getting some scrutiny because of her laugh. GMA Weekend anchor Kate Snow has more on that. A lot of people are writing about this and talking about this."

ABC Graphic: "Laughing in Face of Critics: The Debate Over Clinton Chuckle"

Kate Snow: "A lot of people. We’ve been talking about it for weeks here, Robin. Depending on who you ask, Hillary Clinton is either having a really good time out on the campaign trail, or she's the master of a shrewd political skill, disarming her critics with a gleam in her eye and a roar straight from the belly. She's taking hits from all sides. At debates."

Former Senator Mike Gravel: "And I'm ashamed of you, Hillary."

New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson: "I also disagree with Senator Clinton."

Snow: "On the internet."

Political ad: "Hillary Clinton is turning her back on them."

Snow: "On the trail."

Senator Obama (D-ILL): "Even the senator of New York wasn't clear about the Yankees."

Former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney: HillaryCare continues to be bad medicine."

Snow: "So, no surprise Hillary Clinton has an arsenal ready to take on her attackers. There's the slow giggle. [Hillary giggles.] The ‘I-can't-believe-he-just-said-that’ chuckle of disbelief. [Hillary laughing] And then there's the full Hillary."

Chris Wallace: "A partisan view of politics."

[Clinton laughs hysterically]

Snow: "Jon Stewart had a field day on the Daily Show."

Jon Stewart: "To the untrained eye, that looks like a satellite delay, but that was not a satellite interview. This is what is really is."

Wallace: "Send my best to the President."

Computerized voice: "Humorous remark detected. Prepare for laughter display in two, one, go."

[Clinton laughs hysterically]

Snow: "Her inner circle insists her laugh is not calculated. It's natural."

Unidentified Hillary advisor: "It comes from her soul."

Capricia Marshall (Hillary Clinton campaign Women’s Outreach): "It’s contagious."

First unidentified Hillary advisor: "Yeah. It’s really, like– It’s so heartfelt."

Snow: "But when you're the front runner with a lot of baggage, laughter can also be a savvy political move."

Chris Lehane (Democratic strategist): "She is someone who finds some humor in these things, but also, it's also smart and pretty adroit to, you know, take the questions, sluff [sic] them off and move on to what she wants to talk about and I think the laugh has served as a pretty effective tool."

Snow: "Back in January, she made a joke about dealing with evil and bad men. And when reporters kept pushing about who she was referring to–"

Clinton: "I thought I was funny. You know, you guys keep telling me, lighten up, be funny. You know, I get a little funny and now I'm being psychoanalyzed."

Roberts: "It’s true."

Snow: "Okay, maybe we are over analyzing a little bit here. One Clinton spokesperson said sarcastically yesterday, ‘Breaking news, the Senator laughs.’ But as Mark Twain once said Robin, ‘The human race has only one really effective weapon and that is laughter. That’s Mark Twain’s quote and in politics, you need all of the weapons you can get."

Roberts: "Yes, you can. But she has a bit of a point there. When a lot of people were critical of her because she wasn't showing a sense of humor and then she does do that–"

Snow: "Right. And when you're a front-runner, you get it from everybody."

Roberts: "Oh, yeah. All right. You’ve got a nice laugh, Kate. See there. We won't overanalyze that."

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

While the rest of us know

While the rest of us know that nothing Hillary Clinton does is natural or uncalculated. Probably not even the way she breathes...

Roberts again misses the irony

When Hillary is criticized for not having a sense of humor, she offers a lame, obviously calculated laugh when asked tough questions. Roberts thinks that's proof that she has a sense of humor? It proves she doesn't.

  • If we began criticizing her for having a high voice, I have no doubt Hillary would begin speaking like Barry White. If poll numbers said she was too short, she'd put on high heels.

Just goes to show ... Hillary isn't trying to persuade America of anything. She figures all she has to do is give the media a little of what they want, and the media will do whatever she wants.

nothing Hillary Clinton

nothing Hillary Clinton does is natural or uncalculated.

Natural or not, IT WILL BE CHANGED if they find out it's not "polling well." Her whole campaign is one "range-finding" shot after another. I've already predicted that she will change it to more of a chuckle, the kind you get from an indulgent parent with a precocious child. I will see if I am right.

Oh, and ABC called it both the "Clinton Chuckle" when talking about criticism of it and a "roar straight from the belly." Well which is it, a chuckle or a roar? Can't be both.

Secret Weapon

I say we make an audio loop of all of Hillary's "laughs", especially the ones from last Sunday's morning shows, and have our military blast it across the A-stan-Paki border in an effort to drive out UBL into the open. Hell, we might just save some $$$ and use it on our borders to keep out illegals.

Secret Weapon/

Good ideas ---ddrillanwr.  That laugh is so

phony its ridiculous.   They don't even make

sense where she "cackles".    Her speaking

voice is bad enough, we don't need her

cackles.

Sorry, I'm not disarmed....

 Hillary's laugh "disarming her critics" ? ?

Uh, sorry, that's a no-go explanation.   This is damage control by people sleeping in the same bed.....MSM....

Her sense of humor is non-existent, and her laugh is contrived, and it's obvious to the most casual observer...and it would take more MSM air time than we have until the election to sell this red herring.   

I know Bill Clinton, and Hillary is NO Bill Clinton.....

Oct. Nov. Dec....she will drop in the polls...the only damage control is to take her off the MSM air....too much air time is shrinking her base, and damage control is stinking up the MSM airwaves.     

 

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

What do you mean, "her

What do you mean, "her sense of humor is non-existent"?

Don't you remember her classic "Gandhi working at the 7-11" joke?

How about the "I had no idea that Bill was unfaithful" side splitter?

Who could forget her memorable rendition of "I don't recall, I don't recall, I don't recall, I don't recall.... I was baking cookies for Chelsea" schtick?

"I have always been a Yankee's fan" had them rolling in the aisles.

Everyone agrees that her "I was named after Sir Edmund Hilary" skit is priceless. 

No sense of humor.. I beg to differ.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq  to derail the impeachment vote:  “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Jerry

and her collection of characters

"i ain't no wise turd"

"WE HAVE A RIGHT TO DISSENT"

Yes, you are even more annoying than Blonde.  the EYE

Botg

<Shriek> "I am sick and tired of being called un-patriotic just because everything we're doing is so un-patriotic!" </Shriek>

Hilary, Hussein, & Headwards... what a choice.. three blind mice comes to mind.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq  to derail the impeachment vote:  “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

jerry you have

correctly identified her 'shrieker' persona (non grata)

Yes, you are even more annoying than Blonde.  the EYE

Everyone knows

Everyone knows that Graboids turn into Shriekers.  And, what to Shriekers turn into?  You'll see the next time a real journalist does not genuflect in her general direction. 

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

A less slick version of Slicky Boy

Hitlery is really a sick individual.  She is a political animal - she has no humanness.  I wouldn't be surprised if Chelsea was allowed to be born for political reasons.  Her forced cackle of a laugh was just the tip of the frigid iceberg she is.

But, she's no different than Bill.  They are both political whores.  Bill is just better at it.

mattm,

LOL-When I first saw your post, I thought you had said "Sticky" Boy.

Whew! Glad to see it was just my normal afternoon dyslexia kicking in.


When I'm president, privatization is off the table because it's not the answer to anything.
-Hillary Rodham, September 3, 2007 AARP Legislative Conference.

More like cackling over her

More like cackling over her caldron of Government run health care before making the rest of us eat the apple.

Fly Hillary! Fly!

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

One Laughs for 3 Reasons

There are only 3 human reasons why people laugh:

1. The subject is funny.

2. The person is uncomfortable with the subject and being nervous laughs in reflex action.

3. The person is either drugged or intoxicated.

Since Hillary has never exhibited this trait before, even in her pretty in pink lectures on FBI files or her fangs sunk in to Republicans.........I would like to have her disclose ALL her hidden and medical files, because she just might be on happy pills as the stress is too much.

 

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

Lithiume anyone?????? The

Lithiume anyone??????

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

she's hip, she's with it, ducka-ducka-ducka

great laugh - really "disarms" me - lets get her some sharks with frickin laser beams too

she'll run this country for.........(zoom in).........one MILLION dollars (cackle, cackle, cackle) !

And she made meat helmets

And she made meat helmets in the summer. 

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

summers in rangoon - beaten

summers in rangoon - beaten in burlap sack - pretty standard really

Were a Zoroastrian Velma

Were a Zoroastrian Velma ritualistic shaved her...now that brings up and interesting question.

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

Hillary: "I'll get you my

Hillary: "I'll get you my pretty, and your little dog Toto, to.  Cackle, cackle, cackle."  Yup, I feel pretty much disarmed.  She sounds human and humane to me ... bwahahahahahaha.  Sorry, I just can't type that with a strait face. 

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

Yes, but can she laugh in a

Yes, but can she laugh in a Southern Black dialect?

HILLARY'S LAUGH

The funniest joke yet, is the proposed "Baby

Bond of $5,000 per baby born.   Boy oh boy,

those welfare people will be pushing out

babies by the dozens.    Who does the public

think is going to pay for this?     We are

sucka's  that's the biggest joke on people who

see this as another brilliant idea of Hillary

Everyone in the real world

Everyone in the real world knows that witch's calculated cackle is just that...phony and calculated... msnbc tried this BS this morning...seems all the leftist press have the same talking points regarding this fake destructive leftist enemy within....seems to be going full force today.

NOT gonna work though....they can try as hard as they want, when lying to oneself repeatedly seems to me only the person lying believes it....with practice that is.

Msm are just fools.

Sick and tired

I am sick and tired of this field of candidates for the Dems. They are all trying to out socialize each other. Can we start all over with some better ones? Sorry I forgot. This is the best they have.

I remember hens cackling like her when they would lay an egg.  

 

Southern by birth, Tarheel by the grace of God!

still waiting for the one Question from MSM to Hitlary...

MSM "As a Senator from NY, whose job is "legislation", why don't you propose the Hillary Health Care idea as legislation...NOW ?"

Good ideas have to be put on a shelf and will only bear fruit if she is elected President  ?

If she was a Govenor, I'd understand the lack of proposal for Health care legislation, but she's a Senator elected to do a job.....and she is basically saying..."If elected President, I will do my job as Senator"... 

Why doesn't anyone on MSM notice this contradiction ? ?         

 

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

Good Point!

As someone from upstate NY who did not vote for her twice, I can't think of one thing she's done for our state. Yet she believes she's a good candidate for President because of her experience as First Lady. Her terms as Senator are merely being used to pad her resume.

How about she goes back to

How about she goes back to NY and does her job as senator NOW???

She and Obama have been running for President ever since they got elected Senators. Actually all the Senators who are running. Don't they feel any obligation to do the job they have now?

What's so funny, funny girl?

Here's a women who, to my recollection, has never laughed in public - ZAP - out of the blue is now laughing at anything ... A-N-Y-thing! Is that what her advisors told her? To humanize her? To which she seems to have interpreted to "Hillary, give us your most insane cackle. Be sure do this at times most inapt."

Can we get a YEEEEEEEAAAOOOOW!

Model 501GGH

I want to offer apologies to all who were offended by our Model 501GGH political campaign robot, which you have come to know as "Hillary Clinton". Somehow, the software code was approved without a rigorous final tested and uploaded into Model 501GGH' CPU without my personal approval. The result was the ill-timed "laugh-cackle" which was so noticeable. Internally, we were pleased with the overall performance of this virtual lifelike robot, but we now obviously wish we, as a company, had used our well established quality controls more effectively on this occasion.
Again, our apologies,

Merton Climfmare
President, Political Robots R Us.

celator.... LOL... Wonde

celator....

LOL...

Wonder if Frank Rich is gonna accept your apology?

I think it was him (along with others) I heard is not happy with Hill and her cackle...among other things he wrote about today.

I should look it up...may later.

Nevertheless, it is funny the dem's that are coming out with the unhappiness with Hill herre lately...who knew?

LMAO! 

Hillary's Natural Laugh

Hillary's laugh is uncontrived....sure...perhaps in the world of pit vipers.

I'm sorry...I am just one of those people who has an absolute visceral reaction to everything about that woman.  I hear some of these liberal women with whom I work talk about how "smart" Hillary is, or some equally other idiotic statement...I seriously would like slap some sense into them.  How anyone can not possibly not see HRC for what she clearly is just doesn't compute.   

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

Thanks, Blonde, I'm glad to

Thanks, Blonde, I'm glad to know I am not the only one. I too cannot understand how people can NOT see through her. She is the biggest phony, poll-tested, focus-grouped, trial-balloon floating woman EVER. I saw clips of her on Hannity and Colmes tonight, and I noticed, in her closeups, that she now is showing some gray in her hair, along the front edges. I'll bet anything this was poll-tested to, and she decided let some gray show, to make herself look more "serious."

 

Oh come on, MB!

Don't you take a poll every day to find out about your subordinates' take on you?  To make sure they really liiiiiiike you?

I do...it makes a diff.   What says you, mb?  Should I belly laugh tomorrow, or just cackle?

Please, please...let me know.  It's important stuff! 

I really, really want the little brats to like me.

My professional life depends on it...NOT! 

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

oh yeah Blpnde

poll the cats, and pita's too

SOD, Bruce

Do you know what you just said?  LOL, times a thousand.

"Poll the Cats".

Classic.....seriously.

I could have thrashed around for a thousand days and a thousand words.  But that just did it.

Poll the cats.  Woo hoo!

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

it may be easier than

it may be easier than herding them??

really you need a pied-piper

Yes, you are even more annoying than Blonde.  the EYE

She is taking polls?  I

She is taking polls?  I didn't know she leaned that way. 

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

Clinton operative Capricia

Clinton operative Capricia Marshall found Hillary’s laughter to be "contagious."

I never knew the sound of fingernails on a chalkboard could be contagious.

 

Fish...

Other things are "contagious" as well, if you are in proximity to a Clinton...

The early bird gets the worm, but the second mouse gets the cheese.  ~ Unknown

Snow: "So, no surprise

Snow: "So, no surprise Hillary Clinton has an arsenal ready to take on her attackers."

This MSM angle is really getting old, that poor Hillary is being ganged up on by all the "boys" running against her. The job she is applying for is President of the United States, the most powerful position on the face of this planet. 

Although this Bi**h is cut throat enough for the job in some respects, she is devoid of the overarching qualities required for such a position; integrity, courage, decisiveness and morals. She posesses none of the aforementioned.

So yes Katie Snow, she will be criticized for her "cackling laugh", as it illustrates her inability to think on the fly, respond to tough issues and basically tell the truth.  As for you Ms. Snow, MIT could use the inside of your skull for micro-chip development as it is the perfect vaccuum that is required for such research.  

The early bird gets the worm, but the second mouse gets the cheese.  ~ Unknown

You know, that's true...no

You know, that's true...no one else's opponents are referred to as their "attackers."

And regarding your comment about "the boys", they need to say out loud, hey, if she is going to run for President, if she can't take an attack from Rudy Giuliani (or any other candidate) how the hell can she be counted on not to wilt in the face of Kim Jong Il or Mahmoud Ahmedinejad? They should NOT send their wives out to criticize her.

Fun-Loving Hillary?

So, we can expect kite-flying, badminton and croquet on the south lawn. Pinata parties in the dining room? 

Hmmm... just what the Nation needs in a CIC.