Newspaper Edges Back from Anti-Limbaugh 'Slavery' Smear; Sports Writer Says He’s Right Even if Quote Is Wrong

Photo of Rich Noyes.
  • Bookmark and Share

Today’s St. Louis Post-Dispatch has an “Editor’s Note” on their sports pages about the false quote attributed to radio host Rush Limbaugh, that Limbaugh had supposedly said that slavery “had its merits.” The paper says the quote came from a left-wing book that offered “no specific details” about its origins and that “the Post-Dispatch continues to research the origin of the quote.”

Back on October 7, Post-Dispatch sports writer Bryan Burwell was the first to inject the quote into the debate about whether an investment group including Limbaugh should be able to buy the St. Louis Rams; in his column today, Burwell suggested it didn’t really matter if the quote was a “fabrication.”

So what are we left with? Well, essentially, I think we just threw a deck chair off the Titanic. There is still a huge pile of polarizing, bigoted debris stacked up on the deck of the good ship Limbaugh that he can't deny or even remotely distance himself from.

That doesn’t sound very contrite for a writer who jump-started a nasty round of character assassination with a quote that his own newspaper says needs further “research” to confirm.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

How would the paper react if any other public figure — Barack Obama? Bill Clinton? Keith Olbermann? —  was smeared with such an inflammatory quote that could not be verified?

Aren’t editors supposed to keep unverified slander out of the newspapers in the first place?

Here’s the full editor’s note as it appeared in the October 14 Post-Dispatch, followed by an excerpt from Burwell’s October 14 column:

A quote in Bryan Burwell's column Oct. 7 attributed to Rush Limbaugh about the merits of slavery in the United States came from the 2006 book "101 People Who Are Really Screwing America" by John Huberman. The book does not provide specific details about the quote.

Limbaugh, who is part of a group bidding to buy the St. Louis Rams, said Monday that he did not make that statement, which has been widely reported in recent days.

The Post-Dispatch continues to research the origin of the quote.

Now some of Burwell today suggesting that he's right even if the quote he used in making his case was "a horrible fabrication":

So now the man who for the last 20 years has used the words of others like a mallet, is finding that the world is a little less comfortable when he ends up on the business end of that same swinging cudgel. Limbaugh is being damned by his own words. His many critics — and I happen to be one of them — have collected some of his greatest hits and thrown them back in his face for scrutiny. And what do you know? Limbaugh apparently wasn't so keen on becoming the poundee after excelling for so long at being the pounder.

One particular quote seemed to bother him the most:

"Let's face it, we didn't have slavery in this country for over 100 years because it was a bad thing. Quite the opposite: Slavery built the South. I'm not saying we should bring it back. I'm just saying it had its merits. For one thing, the streets were safer after dark."

That particular quote was reported in the 2006 book by Jack Huberman, "101 People Who Are Really Screwing America." I repeated it in a column last week. The quote was so in character with the many things that Limbaugh has said before that we didn't verify it beyond the book. The quote was repeated in the ensuing days as NFL players began to express their uneasiness with Limbaugh as a potential owner.

Limbaugh at first said he couldn't remember saying it, then after his researchers were unable to find any evidence beyond the book — which listed no sources — he stepped up his game and on his Tuesday radio broadcast said the quotes were lies. In an e-mail to the AP on Tuesday, Limbaugh said, "The totally made-up and fabricated quotes attributed to me in recent media reports are outrageous and slanderous.''

Fine, let's play along for the time being and take him at his word that he was inaccurately quoted in the Huberman book. Heck, let's go along for the full ride and believe that it was all a horrible "fabrication."

So what are we left with?

Well, essentially, I think we just threw a deck chair off the Titanic.

There is still a huge pile of polarizing, bigoted debris stacked up on the deck of the good ship Limbaugh that he can't deny or even remotely distance himself from.

—Rich Noyes is Research Director at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Shades of Dan Rather

Isn't that what Rather said. It didn't matter if the documents were not genunine because the story was true.

when you know it's time to

when you know it's time to dump your newsmedia wholesale.

___________________________________________________________
Graphical conservative commentary - animations & pictures for posting on forums: http://ubama.org/chu...

Bingo. Must be the new

Bingo. Must be the new kind of journalism.  

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

That's what came to my mind, too, allanf

Politically-charged diatribes passing for serious journalism is pandemic.  Its practioners believe that they intuitively know The Truth, and therefore supporting evidence is nice if you can find it, unnecessary if you can't.

The Democrats race plantation

Has lots of gate keepers.

The luxury of liberalism is

The luxury of liberalism is that you can be right even when you're wrong.

And what, Mr. Burwell...

...are those supposed statements which you call "bigoted debris"?  Make your case with facts, sir.  Print those quotes exactly.  Don't just say there are more.

Of course, you cannot because the truth is, there aren't any because that would destroy your argument.

"Our liberties we prize and our rights we will maintain." Official Motto of the State of Iowa

journalistic epic fail

aka. business as usual.

____________________________________________ 
The Emperor, he has no clothes

Talk about begging the question

You cannot assume something to be true in the effort to prove it. Logic forbids. If you use [statementA] to establish a pattern, and then it turns out that [statementA] is untrue, you cannot argue that it doesn't matter because he already has a pattern. 

When these jackasses assure us that they have plenty of other material, they need to be challenged. Produce it. Imagine if this was a court of law, and the prosecutor simply said, "Oh your honor, we have plenty of other evidence." OK, let's see it.

George Will said that a journalist is someone who reasons in public. Well, lawyers and scientists are the only ones whose public arguments require proof. When a journalist tells the public that someone is unfit, they owe the public their reasons why. If they don't have an argument, they should shut up.

Repeat: If you don't have the proof, Shut the ---- up.

Even that isn't certain . . .

"Well, lawyers and scientists are the only ones whose public arguments require proof."

As we've seen in court rooms and international fora, not even those professions require proof -- they merely need to convince their audiences.

When is Rush going to

When is Rush going to retain attorneys to file slander lawsuits on every one of these McCarthyite reporters and journalists who liberally defame his character without the slightest shred of evidence and even make up quotes?

 

McCarthy was right in his

McCarthy was right in his accusations of communism in the gov't. Even FDR's 3rd Vice President, Henry Wallace, was a paid communist agent, complete with code name, paybook and Soviet controller. So was Alger Hiss and very many others. 

Corrupt Wikipedia

The blogger Ed Driscoll had a great post on how liberals can create lies and then use the lies that they created as references. It all goes back to, –what else is new, the evil Wikipedia. Let this be another point of data on how corrupt and biased Wikipedia is.

The Faith-Based Encyclopedia in Action: http://pajamasmedia.com

Now this know-nothing

Now this know-nothing scumbag Burwell has really stepped in it.  He admits to his part in journalistic fraud, then like the coward that he is, he tries to hide behind the protection of a non-existent catalogue of "bigoted debris".  Now that he has perpetrated the original fraud, he doesn't get off so easily with this phony misdirection act.  He needs to be isolated for the fraud he has committed and everything he writes from here on out is fruit from the poisoned tree.  Whatever journalistic credibility he had is completely shot now...sure he'll get his sycophantic peers to circle the wagons around him, but so did that proven fraud Dan Rather.  Ultimately, the truth will be Burwell's undoing.

"I spent a lot of money on booze, birds and fast cars. The rest I just squandered."  -George Best

Hard to believe

This guy is even stupider than he looks.

Time to resurrect Lt. Gen. Honore's saying. He was talking to journalists covering the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina when he said it

 "Don't get stuck on Stupid"

 “the Post-Dispatch

 “the Post-Dispatch continues to research the origin of the quote.”

I suggest they sift through the muck in the sewer in which they dwell.

The total break in information is just about here. Soon, there will be two completely different source groups for news and information - one for liberals - the other for everyone else. It's all part of the cold civil war in this country.

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

Cold Civil War

What are the rules of engagement? And what interrogation tactics are permissible? 

"I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason

Mr Wong Way

Yes.... the editor is more or less saying.. I'm right even though I'm wrong....lol...

Just like what the football player said when he ran to the wrong end zone. 

The Usual MSM Excuse...

"The quote was fake, but accurate!"

Maybe the quote ...

Maybe the quote came from one of the many thousands of black who owned slaves in the 1800s.

Can't wait for the denials that blacks owned slaves.

Remember folks, Freedom isn't Free. It was bought with the blood and sacrifice of the men and women who are serving and who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces.

For those who fought for it, Freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.

Also remember folks, that the way to SUPPORT THE TROOPS is to support their mission. Anyone who says that they support the troops but don't support their mission is lying about supporting the troops. And if you want to know, yes I do have a dog in the fight, he is a United States Marine.

 

Right along with what is NOT largely taught..

That their own people sold them out.  Whites were also slaves, and so too were the slaughtered tribal left-over natives.  Let us also remember that no one seems to be on the Jews side... they endured 2000+ years of slavery the blacks?  Less than 200. 

Not one single ethnic group has escaped slavery.  Not one.

 

 "Not one single ethnic

 "Not one single ethnic group has escaped slavery.  Not one."

 Yes, but only American blacks have the likes of Sharpton, Jackson, et al to manage the shakedown on their behalf.

"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me

Mr. Burwell, there is a

Mr. Burwell, there is a huge pile of debris piled up indicating that you are an habitual child molester. Care to comment?

"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me

The liberal media would

The liberal media would NEVER stereotype anybody, especially a conservative, wink wink.

The reality is that liberals are the biggest stereotypers out there.  They *know* that Limbaugh is a racist, but darn it they just can't seem to find any reason to back up that position.

Dear Post-Dispatch.

 

Why not Dispatch the lying, racists employee that created the slanderous accusations POST haste?

The paper should not have to be the one doing the research.

The person that created the problem should have had the documentation handy when his boss asked for it.

An IMMEDIATE retraction and FRONT PAGE APOLOGY should be a given in an HONEST media.

No chance of honesty in the media anymore is there?

http://gjresult.com

 

Racism is the last undefendable slur

Who cares if it is a lie? Those who want to believe it don't need proof. Those who have an axe to grind are not going to waste their time doing research which might take away a great soundbite. This is scurrilous and below contempt. Not to mean it's not useful...

Liberals are factually

Liberals are factually challenged.

His teeth and his journalism

His teeth and his journalism are the same shade of yellow

socialist rag

gah!

I live in the St Louis Metro area.  In the grocery store where they give out free samples there will occasionally be someone selling subscriptions to the STL-PD.  "Would you like a sub--"

Before they can finish, I tell them, "No thanks, it's a socialist rag."  It's hilarious that there's a weekly in town that's even more left, because the Post isn't left *enough*.

rush nfl

Mmm....Mmmm....Mmmmm!, I'm loving it!

 vcb-tn

After reading this tripe, I

After reading this tripe, I thought I might try my hand at Bryan's edgy tactics and see if it might pick up a little steam of its own. Here goes. Bryan Burwell is a raging flaming queen and favors the company of little boys. Sure, this may not have any basis in truth, but that doesn't really matter... you just read it on the internet..... soooooo............. you know, just sayin'!

 

"STOP THE PRESSES!... No, I don't have any earth shattering news, I'm just sayin' stop the presses."

 

 

 

Burwel is the racist here,

Burwel is the racist here, as are the rest of the old stream media. They know the quote is a blatant lie and they repeat it to damage Limbaugh. This is causing him personal, professional and financial damage, he has more money than God and I hope he uses it to sue these malicious liars arses off. I mean get personal judgements against them well into the mid 6 figure range. They deserve to suffer monetarily

              

              They lie about Rush & call it the truth. The world is full of two faced people, most of which are either in the media or the govt..                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             

racism?

So basically he's just going to hate Limbaugh even if the quotes\accusations are proven to be false?  He's determined to hate him for something and even if the "something" doesn't exist, he's till a hater.

But HE's not a racist?  How does all this work? If you're black you're allowed to hate a white person and you're not a racist since you're black?

I'm so confused...