MSNBC Host's False Attack Leads to Threats Against Conservative

Photo of Rich Noyes.
  • Bookmark and Share

On her MSNBC show last night, the left-wing Air America host Rachel Maddow took a swipe at the conservative Shirley & Banister Public Affairs firm, specifically President and CEO Craig Shirley. Maddow accused Shirley of being behind a grassroots Web site funded by the group Grassfire.org, based on a research provided by the “independent watchdog group Public Citizen,” and she showed still images from an incendiary “Obama=Hitler” video that’s posted on the Grassfire’s ResistNet.com Web site.

But Maddow was wrong. The Public Citizen web page she cited is several years old. Shirley & Banister hasn’t represented Grassfire.org since 2004. And Diana Banister, a partner and Vice President at Shirley & Banister, told NewsBusters that Maddow’s false report has led to hate mail and even death threats to the public relations firm. (Let’s see if the left-wing thuggery gets any attention from the MSM.)

[UPDATE, 8/15: Ridiculous Maddow Paints NewsBusters as Vehicle of 'Right-Wing' 'Intimidation']

Craig Shirley and Diana Banister are demanding a retraction and apology from Maddow. They have sent a letter to Maddow that reads, in part:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Shirley & Banister Public Affairs has had no affiliation with grassfire.org or any of its affiliates since 2004.   We DO NOT represent them in any way.

Your apparent source for this information is Public Citizen, a left-wing website, not a "watchdog" group.  One phone call from a producer or researcher to our office would have set the record straight.  However, your lack of research and your statements prove you are not interested in facts.

If a retraction is not forthcoming today we will pursue legal action against you, MSNBC, NBC Universal and General Electric.

The false report originated in a story by Adele M. Stan on the far-left Alternet Web site. Stan cited the Nader-ite Public Citizen page as his evidence of a link between Grassfire.org and Shirley & Banister. The left-wing Salon.com picked up the story on Wednesday, and Maddow repeated it as her own (citing only Public Citizen as evidence).

Maddow reminded her audience that Shirley helped create the 1988 “Willie Horton” ad, which liberals have been waving around like a bloody shirt for more than 20 years:

According to independent watchdog group Public Citizen, Grassfire.org is represented by the Washington, D.C.-based P.R. firm Shirley & Banister Public Affairs. The “Shirley” in Shirley & Banister Public Affairs is a man named Craig Shirley. Craig Shirley is a very long-time Republican PR operative whose resume includes the famous race-baiting Willie Horton ad from the 1988 presidential campaign....The Willie Horton ad-making Republican PR activist guy is the same guy that reps the anti-health care reform “Obama = Hitler” Web site.

As for the video Maddow found on Grassfire’s “ResistNet.com” Web site, it had a grand total of 114 views as of Friday afternoon, even after the promotion by Maddow on TV Thursday night. It’s obviously content posted by a user, not some corporate message from ResistNet’s masters. If you go to their home page and click on “All Videos,” you get 20 per page on 184 pages, which suggests more than 3,600 videos, so the Left has done some serious cherry-picking here. There’s also a disclaimer in big red letters: The Views of the Bloggers do not necessarily represent ResistNet.com’s views.

They certainly don’t represent the views of a publicist who hasn’t worked with Grassfire.org for five years.

And, before the Left gets it wrong, Shirley & Banister Public Affairs does not represent the Media Research Center, but did represent Crown Publishing in promotional efforts for MRC President Brent Bozell's last two books. And they did a good job.

Here’s the relevant excerpt of Maddow’s fact-challenged and incredibly convoluted rant, from her August 13 MSNBC show:

RACHEL MADDOW: One of the places where scary information is coming from, one of the places where town hall protests are being promoted and town hall protesters are getting their marching orders before they go, is a place called ResistNet.com. If you surf over to ResistNet.com, you will see that they bill themselves as, quote, "The online community for patriotic citizens who are opposing the Obama-led socialist agenda." Right there on the front page, right at the top is the message, "WE NEED YOUR HELP," all caps, "August Recess Health Care Blitz."

So, what sort of information is available at ResistNet.com for people who might want to “blitz” something in the August recess? Well, there's this video which is titled “Obama equals Hitler,” the contents of which you can probably figure out based on the not-at-all ambiguous name and these nice shots.

You want to know specifically about what they say about health care? Well, there's this helpful post, quote, “Waiting lines will be long. Others will die. Why is this being done? Back door reparations. I pray that God will strike Obama dead and all who stand with him, they are evil.”

So who runs ResistNet.com? Well, if you scroll way down to the bottom of this Web site, you will see that it is run by something called Grassfire.org. In fact, on their "about us" page, you will find that Grassfire is funding ResistNet as part of, quote, "our overall patriotic resistance efforts"-which is an awfully nice thing for Grassfire.org to do, I mean, to completely fund this Web site that's calling President Obama "Hitler" and organizing against health care reform and posting death threats against the president. I mean, you know, kind of makes me want to know more about Grassfire.org.

Well, according to independent watchdog group Public Citizen, Grassfire.org is represented by the Washington, D.C.-based P.R. firm Shirley & Banister Public Affairs. The “Shirley” in Shirley & Banister Public Affairs is a man named Craig Shirley. Craig Shirley is a very long-time Republican PR operative whose resume includes the famous race-baiting Willie Horton ad from the 1988 presidential campaign.

So, the next time you hear Republican Party Chairman Michael Steele say something like this.

CLIP OF MICHAEL STEELE ON FOX NEWS: And anyone out there who says that the Republican Party or state parties or Republican activists are out there doing that are flat-out lying. They are wrong.

MADDOW: Flat-out lying, they are wrong. Actually, they are not wrong. The Willie Horton ad-making Republican PR activist guy is the same guy that reps the anti-health care reform Obama equals Hitler Web site. No wonder people are afraid.

Maddow’s MSNBC page promises her show is a “smart look at politics and the day’s top stories. It’s mind over chatter!” So much for “smart” -- more like “lazy and hateful.”

A programming note for masochists: the accuracy-impaired Ms. Maddow will be one of the panelists on NBC’s Meet the Press on Sunday.

—Rich Noyes is Research Director at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Sue the idiots!

I kinda hope there's no apology so MSNBC and Maddow can be sued for libel and bankrupted.  I suppose that's too much to hope for... 

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

Remember This?

Pelosi 

Hiding lying 

JDW

DAILY WAVE

Jobs, jobs, jobs ... Spending, spending, spending

And now...

...she will broadcast a smarmy, back-handed correction marginalizing the error and its whistle-blowers, and, ultimately, her 6 viewers will get a laugh.

Signed, Corny McPoo 

"To be is to do." - Plato

"To do is to be." - Aristotle

"Do be do be do." - Sinatra

Rock Maddow

This dude just keeps sticking his nose where it doesn't belong.

Maddow and MSNBC ...

Maddow and MSNBC offering to do a retraction? Like that's ever going to happen.

Remember folks, Freedom isn't Free. It was bought with the blood and sacrifice of the men and women who are serving and who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces.

For those who fought for it, Freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.

Also remember folks, that the way to SUPPORT THE TROOPS is to support their mission. Anyone who says that they support the troops but don't support their mission is lying about supporting the troops. And if you want to know, yes I do have a dog in the fight, he is a United States Marine.

 

Speaking of false

Speaking of false attacks...

According to an AP story: Senators exclude end-of-life provision from bill

Why would they be removing something they previously claimed wasn't there?

But - But - But

I heard Sen. Spector say today that Sen Grassley was wrong about what the provision that isn't there says.

Chai

“When all government...in little as in great things, shall be drawn to Washington as the center of all power, it will render powerless the checks provided...” Thomas Jefferson

LOL.. yes. They decided to

LOL.. yes. They decided to take out what wasn't there.

They are such buffoons. Time to send them all home.

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

Horton = Gore

I believe that the first person that brought up Willie Horton was Senator Gore when he was running for president in 1988.

You are absolutely

You are absolutely correct.  He used it in a failed attempt to win the nomination.  I'm pretty sure he was also the first to bring up the pollution in Boston Harbor issue, too.

Wow, Gore actually got

Wow, Gore actually got something right, of course it was done for HIS personal gain (like every other thing he has ever done). And yes, I know even a broken clock is right at least once a day.

Twice a day as long as

Twice a day as long as you're not in the military.

At least = I know there are

At least = I know there are plenty of military/vet posters here.

'Why would they be removing something they previously...'

That's a good question. I found this the other day

JDW

DAILY WAVE

Jobs, jobs, jobs ... Spending, spending, spending

Maddow apologise for

Maddow apologise for misrepresenting the facts and thus creating a situation which endangered the lives of innocent people???

Never. She's just doing her job as a trained seal for the revolution. She'll now get an award from MSNBC and GE.

The most she might say if enough pressure is applied: "They misunderstood what I said. So it's their fault."

Remember Bill Clinton's ethical guidance if caught doing something naughty: "Deny, deny, deny."

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

Maddow's Sitting Back

Rachel is kicking back in her big anchor chair busily designing her 'Mission Accomplished' background for this evening's broadcast.

More evidence that fact checks aren't

Maddow checked the "facts." And didn't find truth.

  • That's an old philosophical problem. Socrates asked the same basic question. "How do you know when you know?" The usual answer is that you investigate. You study. You embark on a journey of scientific or moral truth. However, over the centuries we've discovered that human beings tend to quit the investigation as soon as they get an answer they like, instead of following the the trail for as long as it leads.
  • Maddow's is a classic case. When she (or her staff) were investigating the trail of the Obama-Hitler poster, they happened to brush past some alleged connection with Republicans. Stop the search! She ran to the microphone with "proof!" Facts! Republicans are involved!
  • Had they investigated any further, they would have found that the allegation of Republican involvement collapses, as Rich's piece shows.

You can't call yourself a real truthseeker if you stop seeking it at the first clump of mud that you can throw at your opponents. Because it proves that you weren't seeking truth at all ... just clumps of mud.

Maddow

Who is this Maddow dude?  Oh, that's right, he is from that failed radio broadcast Air America.  Now he is doing the same thing on television.

forget the apology

Forget the apology and any attempt at civility.

She put people's live in danger by not checking her information prior to broadcast.

Sue her personally, sue MSNBC, sue the parent company GE.

Sam: "I hurt somebody's feelings once"

Name's spelled wrong.

It's name is Mancow because MSNBC is "udderly stupid".

By the way if the jerks on the left want to boycott Beck's ads who the hell cares, most of Obama's fans are on welfare so it isn't like they're spending any money. Ah but those of us in the middle or leaning right could stick it to GE "BIG TIME". So lets do it! Stop buying anything GE sells, then watch NBC and MSNBC spin down the toilet bowl.

SOBama is not Hitler

but I sure do love his mustache

Did I remember to say?,

MADCOW IS A MORON!

There is one big advantage Liberals have over Conservatives...

which isn't really an advantage.  Liberals are free to say anything they want, whether it is true or not.  Conservatives try to stick to the truth and will apologize if they make a mistake.  Liberals almost never consider apologizing, even when they are in the wrong.  They consider apologizing a character defect, unless like Obama, they apologize for others and not for themselves, no matter what.  Jim Webster

Maddow the brown shirt dude

No one was confusing ole Rachel for a reporter, anyway.  She? is a propaganda smear artist.   Maybe this time she went after someone who has enough money to make MSNBC pay for the smear.  And maybe the shock troops to took Rachel's comand and threatened Rachel's thought enemy will be investigated by the target and prosecuted.

We can not let Obamaites get away with acting like Chavez's crew.  We have to bloody their noses everything so they walk away thinking about it. 

  

I hope...

no retraction is forthcoming, so that we can see legal action against this lameass 'news' organization. I would love to see this sorry excuse for a reporter get her head handed to her. My guess is she will not have the courage to make a retraction, and in fact, will probably find some way to blame conservatives for her mistakes. 

 

President Obama is nothing more than a lying empty suit; a Hollywood
style special effects smoke and mirrors show that has shown itself to
be a total fraud.
 

WAKE UP AMERICA! SAVE OUR CONSTITUTION! 

Wait a Minute!! Was That an Apology?

I watched just to if see man-hands was even a little bit contrite. Was that it? I don't think so. In fact, it was just a wee bit condescending. Oh well, what can you expect from someone who looks like  THIS!

"There was a Texas Ranger one time who said that there's no stopping a man who knows he's in the right and keeps a-coming."--Louis L'Amour

FALSE WITNESS OF MSNBC

The GE propaganda network strikes again. One leftist source lies and the others swear to it. GE (Government Electric?) like GM (Government Motors) deserves to be scorned by the American people. Just say NO and boycott these bastardized companies. Unfortunately, GE still does plenty of business in Iran. (I know, it has been "grandfathered" since the days of Jimmy Carter and our hostages.) Buy another brand, change the channel. To Jeffery I-the signature message of Felix Unger is how I sign off: FU!

What a frigging whore

Rachel, have you looked at your ratings?  Have you appreciated that O'Reilly is kicking not only bathtub boy's ass but practically all the major networks combined including your pathetic broadcast?

How sad it is that I would not be upset in the slightest if anything adverse were to happen to you.  You are a disingenous lying piece of trash. 

"Let him who would move the world, first move himself." -Socrates

"We sit together, the mountain and I, until only the mountain remains." -Li Po

Rachel's not a whore

She's only cheated on Keith once and that was when Hillary slipped something into her drink

Whats The Big Deal, Rachel?

Whats the big deal, anyway? We have a right to say what we want to tin this country and it doesn't matter what organization we are connected with! The left wing loons are getting a taste of their own medicine and they just can't handle it! I think comparing Obama to Hitler or Stalin is right on the money! I believe he is a Communist and his every action serves to validate my beliefs! Furthermore, his Attorney General is a bigotted Communist as well! He has proven his ineptness with his refusal to prosecute three Black Panthers for voter intimidation while proceeding to bring charges against CIA agents! The Viet Cong and the North Vietnamese Regulars of forty years ago had more class than this arrogant ass could ever dream of. At least they made known their intentions! Instead, our ignorant American electorate voted for change and change is what they're getting!