Obama's Health Care Plan Stalled, But Not Because Media Haven't Been Pulling For It

Photo of Rich Noyes.
  • Bookmark and Share

Liberal hopes for a quick health care bill are in collapse, as Senate Democrats push any floor action off until the fall, a move House Democrats may match this week. But if the Obama White House is upset that their plans for a huge expansion of government health care have been delayed, they surely cannot complain about the media coverage.

Last week, a new study by the Media Research Center’s Business & Media Institute (BMI) found broadcast coverage during the first six months of 2009 tilted heavily in favor of Barack Obama’s big government plan. BMI’s Julia Seymour and Sarah Knoploh looked at 224 health care stories on the ABC, CBS and NBC morning and evening news shows from Obama’s January 20 inauguration through his June 24 prime time special on ABC.

Among the key findings:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

■ Fully 70% of soundbites (243 out of 347 total) supported Obama’s liberal health care ideas. Only nine percent of stories (21) suggested the total price tag for Obama’s “reform” would top $1 trillion.

■ Reporters exaggerated the number of uninsured Americans. Omitting non-citizens, those capable of paying, or those eligible for assistance programs already in place, a reasonable figure would be between 8 million and 14 million uninsured, not the “50 million Americans” statistic BMI’s analysts found touted by the networks.

■ The networks also spent virtually no time investigating states that had experimented with big government health schemes — just one story on how Massachusetts’ plan for mandatory health insurance is working out (costs are rising faster than expected), and no stories on Hawaii’s already-cancelled program to insure all children.

BMI’s study period ended in late June, but the networks’ favors for Obama have continued in July, even as public sentiment shifted against both the President and his plan. Opening the July 15 CBS Evening News, anchor Katie Couric sounded a lot like Robert Gibbs reciting talking points: “President Obama says he wants it done now, as in this summer — universal health care. As he put it today, it's time for us to buck up. And there are a lot of bucks at stake. Since 1999, health insurance premiums have increased 120 percent — four times as much as wages. And about one and a half million American families lose their homes to foreclosure every year because of sky high medical bills.”

The next night, July 16, both the NBC Nightly News and CBS Evening News skipped over how, in the words of ABC White House correspondent Jake Tapper on World News, “the President's case was dealt a blow today” when the Congressional Budget Office chief told Congress the health care plans will require massive additional spending.

And the following morning, after the House Ways and Means Committee had formally passed an estimated $554 billion tax increase to help pay for the ambitious health plans, CBS skipped that development, too, as ABC and NBC’s morning news shows offered only a single sentence. NBC’s Natalie Morales, on her network’s four-hour Today program, gave it just 12 seconds: “During the night, the House Ways and Means committee voted to increase taxes on higher income earners as part of a health care reform bill.”

If these had been setbacks for a big Bush administration initiative, do you think the network coverage would have been so paltry?

Reporter commentary has also betrayed a lack of objectivity. In a July 22 interview with California’s Arnold Schwarzenegger on Good Morning America, ABC's Chris Cuomo painted Republicans as endangering Americans’ health: “Do you believe that Republicans are playing politics here, at the risk of people's health care....Is this getting to be a little bit of a reckless situation?”

That night on MSNBC, after the President’s press conference, NBC medical reporter Nancy Snyderman confessed she was “rooting” for him: “As a physician, you know, I felt like I understood the complexity of the problem. As an American citizen, I was rooting for the President to hit a home run.”

The public’s anxiety seems to have delayed the day of reckoning on health care until at least this fall. The big questions: Will network reporters continue their favors for ObamaCare? And will the tilted media landscape be enough to make liberals’ policy dreams come true?

—Rich Noyes is Research Director at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The majority of the msm,

The majority of the msm, hard as they have tried to cram this down our throats every single day, are actually working for us in my opinion, this tactic of theirs is backfiring...their overkill has helped the sane side of the aisle.

Good work SRM!

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

SOME 0-CARE PROBS

JUST SOME
PROBLEMS WITH OBAMA-CARE

Obama is a known serial liar.
The country is broke.
The democrat leaders have purposefully kept details from voters.

The premises are false and nutty.
Congress is not included in the Plan.
Federal workers are included in the Plan.

There is no tort reform.
Medicare and Medicaide are broke under the gov-meant.
The more we know the more resistance grows.

It grows the gov-meant.
It will fund abortion and mercy-killing…eventually.
It will bankrupt insurance companies because the gov-meant needs no
profit.

Its not online and kept there a week before any votes.
There is no portability…as far as we know.
There is no provision for much larger networks, like a state or two…to
lower costs.

There are too many mini-czars forced upon voters and doctors.
It is not patient-centered but cost-centered.
It will slash medical incomes.

The gov-meant cannot run a hot dog stand.
The gov-meant lied (to sell us) many past programs…that quickly cost
3-9x what they told us
The taxes on top of 4x the national debt we now have will crush any
recovery.

The usual control freak suspects that love socialism salivate at
this bill.
The potential for patient abuse is off the scale.

Doug Schexnayder, Ph.D. (theconservativecrawfish)

Hey Katie, is that your tongue in your mouth?

Or is that Leslie Moonves unit?

"Let him who would move the world, first move himself." -Socrates

"We sit together, the mountain and I, until only the mountain remains." -Li Po

Here's what some in the

Here's what some in the medical profession think about O-Care...

 

Medical Stimulus
Package:

Apparently
the
American Medical Association has weighed in
on the new
economic stimulus
package....



The Allergists voted to
scratch it, but the Dermatologists advised not to make any rash
moves.

The Gastroenterologists
had sort of a gut feeling about it,  but the Neurologists thought
the Administration had a lot of nerve.

The Obstetricians felt they were all
laboring under a misconception.

The Ophthalmologists
considered the idea shortsighted.

Pathologists yelled, "Over
my dead body!" while the Pediatricians said, 'Oh, Grow
up!'

The Psychiatrists thought the whole idea was madness, while the
Radiologists could see right through it.

Surgeons decided to
wash their hands of the whole thing.

The Internists thought it was a
bitter pill to swallow, and the Plastic Surgeons said, "This puts a
whole new face on the matter."

The Podiatrists thought it was a step
forward, but the Urologists were pissed off at the whole
idea.

The Anesthesiologists
thought the whole idea was a gas, and the Cardiologists didn't have
the heart to say no.

In the end, the Proctologists won out,
leaving the entire decision up to the a$$holes in
Washington.

 

 

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

My orthopedist says he has

My orthopedist says he has a bone to pick with Uhbama... 

"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me

LOL HK... Our local

LOL HK...

Our local dentist said he can't sink his teeth in this either.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

   I don't care who Y'are

   I don't care who Y'are that's funny right there....

Afternoon MA... My Aunt

Afternoon MA...

My Aunt sent this to me this morning, I thought this was a perfect place to put this, the whole thing is madness that is going on, Obama Care being crammed down our throats, a little humor is needed at times.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

non essential medical expenditures

The big new solution is to tax "unneeded" healthcare. The government can decide whether you are spending money on the purely cosmetic and create a special tax -

Looking at the photo of the senior citizen Couric (using AARP standards), I would guess that Kate spends tens of thousands keeping her locks that strange, unnatural orangy color. Since this is cosmetic, it should be heavily taxed. While we are at it, the make-up people at the TV studios should be doubly taxed for wasting precious resources on unnecessary cosmetic procedures. They are probably emitting some type of noxious gas that can be triply taxed.

Dr. Obama can expand the special taxes to all sorts of things we don't need. The deficit can be solved in no time at all.All it takes is a little more government coercion and good will on the part of right minded citizens to sacrifice for the greater good.

              

                   I don't think they (the govt.) will wait till fall. I'll bet they try to pass it on the last day, late night, while WE are sleeping. Their usual tactics.

Ok, Katie, how about

Ok, Katie, how about this.  You now make $90k a year, the rest of your salary goes to healthcare.  All those people who say that the middle class can afford it will have to become the middle class. The same goes for everyone in the House who supports the bill.

 

Government's first duty is to protect the people, not run their lives.

Ronald Reagan

More Zombie Data

Again those fake figures for 'medical bankruptcies' are being used. They are just too attractive for the liberal media to avoid, as fake as they are and no matter how many times they are debunked.

And why not, this entire effort has been put together to address another fake number, the mythical '47 million uninsured'.

The Silver Lining

Personally, I think the socialists have hit their high water mark and we will slowly start pushing them back now. As many predicted, they over reached with the healthcare power grab and crap and trade tax.

But the silver lining which I understand Rush pointed out is becoming more and more apparent. The blatant propogandizing done by the media for these Robofascists has ended their credibility with thinking people for at least a generation, and maybe, with luck, forever.

Cronkite did as much as he could to help the communists in Viet Nam, but he was much, much less conspicuous about it. Today's crop have the sublty and sophisitcation of a Jr. High Cheerleading squad (no offense to any young cheerleaders here).