Pulitzer-Prize winning author and professor of history at Stanford University David M. Kennedy told Bloomberg radio Nov. 18 that the current financial crisis bears no comparison to the Great Depression.
"Well, we're not yet in anything remotely resembling the crisis, the scale of crisis of the Great Depression." When Franklin Roosevelt took office in 1933, 13 million Americans were unemployed. "That was 25 percent of the work force," Kennedy told Bloomberg host Tom Keene.
The professor laid out exactly what has changed since the troubled 1930s:
Every bank in the country was closed shut. There was no such thing as old age pensions, there was no such thing as unemployment insurance. There was no such thing as the Securities and Exchange Commission to regulate the stock markets. There was nothing like the National Labor Relations Board to keep peaceful relations between management and labor. We have a whole array of things in place now that will make this crisis much less severe than the one of the 1930s.
He also looked to the past to warn against protectionism in the U.S.:
We have a thick historical record of the consequences of yielding to the temptations of protectionism and isolationism.
Kennedy said that in the 1930s, almost every nation in the world enacted protectionist measures, "that essentially strangled international trade and deepened and worsened the crisis of the Depression."
"I hope we've learned the lesson that that's the wrong road to take, although it's always very, very tempting because you can sell [those] kind of policies, protecting jobs at home and taking care of our own first and so on," the professor said.
In 2004, economists at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), studied the policies of President Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal and determined it actually prolonged the Depression by seven years.
Harold L. Cole and Lee E. Ohanian blamed anti-free market measures for the slow recovery in an article published in the August 2004 issue of the Journal of Political Economy.
Kennedy is the author of "Freedom From Fear: The American People in Depression and War, 1929-1945."
—Paul Detrick is a research analyst at the Business & Media Institute.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
DOW down over 400
November 20, 2008 - 16:12 ET by bigtimerThis is pretty interesting read...I certainly have never thought this is anything, now will it ever be anything like The Great Depression.
I hope you don't mind me mentioning the DOW closing today though...down around 445 getting very close to 7500...I think it was 7552 last I saw...this has been quite the bail-out plan eh?
Oil down below the 50 buck a barrel mark now today...that is about 100 pts below the high from June or July if memory serves me...we are thankful for gas prices going down as we have to travel quite a way daily for work in our area...on the other hand, the pressure to drill adn be self-dependent here is going to be quietly forgotten, as always with people, plus we have the leftists in now, so it is a done deal to do nothing now.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
dow and oil
November 20, 2008 - 20:18 ET by nathanbforrestwell, big, first off the dow was down about 445 points .. the price of oil is down about $100.00 .. diferent terms of measurement .. the total of the dow industrials is divided by a certain # to get the dow average .. now that we're past that, you are correct that the dems will say to drilling "NO WE CAN'T" .. but they will be doing SOMETHING .. and you can be sure we won't like it ..
never look a gift skunk in the tail
Saying it isn't like the last big recession
November 20, 2008 - 16:54 ET by DuymonDoesn't mean it's not worse than the last one. I mean, heck from what I see this time around we have large populations of weaklings raised under the welfare state that feel entitled to have everything given to them throughout their adult lives.
It only takes a walk around the corner to see those Section 8 parasites (most able bodied enough to be playing f-ing basketball or carry those boxes of electronics into their free apartments) just idling around b*tching about how bad their lives are living on low government payments... all while we regular folk are dogging away 8-10 hours a day and barely getting by.
I don't mean to sound harsh, but this country won't make a smooth exit from this recession with all that "baggage" and the promises the left gave that "Baggage" for their votes & guaranteed easy lives.
I'd like to show...
November 20, 2008 - 17:29 ET by littlemissmuffinI'd like to show him our 401k's and IRA's. Maybe the country isn't in a great depression, but we sure are every time we look at our statements. We WERE close to retirement, but that's out of the question.
"If we conservatives moved to those seven non-existent States, the government couldn’t find us and tax us to death!"
you need to read
November 20, 2008 - 20:28 ET by nathanbforrestyou need to read WALDEN POND .. figure out what you really need to retire .. possibly work part time, a couple of days a week or something .. walmart door greeter .. if you have 401k's and ira's you obviously can't be going barefoot and wearing worn out overhauls with a torn and dirty tank t-shirt ..
never look a gift skunk in the tail
Not a Great Depression but an Inflationary Holocaust
November 20, 2008 - 21:01 ET by PopularTechThey are right, government before has never printed this much money and thrown it into an already overheated economy, no we will not have the Great Depression but an Inflationary Holocaust.
Jim Rogers: Government Creating an Inflationary Holocaust (Video) (7min)
America's Great Depression (PDF) (368 pgs) (Murray Rothbard, Ph.D. Economics, 5th Edition, 2000)
Censored Global Warming Videos
Very good PT
November 20, 2008 - 21:37 ET by general companyWith so many suggesting the very same as Rogers, it just boggles the mind why the Fed just doesnt "get it". Who are they trying to please? Certainly not the folks.
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
After January 20th, this is
November 20, 2008 - 22:16 ET by TN MomAfter January 20th, this is obama's problem to fix; the Dems and obama can blame Pres. Bush for about 6 mos, after that, it's ALL on them to fix. Obama should step up tommorrow and say he isn't going to raise Cap Gains, won't raise taxes on Small Business, will freeze spending, etc. to turn the economy around...
Who am I kidding? We don't know anything about Obama; no one knows how far into socialism he will take this country. Mr. Hope & Change had better get moving on fixing the economy. Re-election will begin in approx. 2 years.