CBS's 'Dangerous' Cough Medicine Segment Hard to Swallow

Photo of Paul Detrick.

So what "dangerous" product should you not give your children now? Cough syrup, if you were watching the October 3 "Early Show."

"They're safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them to be dangerous," said Dr. Alanna Levine, a pediatrician based in Englewood Hospital in New York.

The CBS segment focused on new regulations of over-the-counter cough and cold medicines for children by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), but left out any representation by pharmaceutical companies or trade organizations.

Levine stressed problems with use of the product telling viewers that emergency rooms see up to 7,000 children a year, but she focused on the medicines, not on the caregivers improperly administering them to children.

"Studies show that they don't work [when used properly]," Levine said when asked if they work by Smith. "Making them drowsy is not helping cough and cold symptoms."

A "multiyear plan" is in the works to increase regulation, according to Linda Suydam, president of Consumer Healthcare Products Association (CHPA).

Suydam said in an October 2 statement that the plan is "specifically designed to help improve the safe use of [over the counter cough and cold medicines] and reaffirm the efficacy of these medicines. The leading makers of these medicines remain committed to working with FDA and pediatric experts to ensure that parents and caregivers continue to have appropriate treatment choices for their children."

In late 2007 a number of drug makers, under threat of regulation, pulled products marketed to children under two years old.

—Paul Detrick is a research analyst at the Business & Media Institute.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

From the linked

From the linked article:

New
regulations will include updating how cough medicines are marketed to
children
as well as their safety – a process the Journal said would
take years.

Cough syrups are marketed to children?  They have ads that encourage kids to pester their parents to buy cough syrup????

Give me a break!

Maybe they should look into those ads for adult medicines that encourage everyone to "ask your doctor if XXX is right for you."

At least a third of all prescriptions are written at the request of the patient. Do they think if it's prescribed by a doctor, there won't be side effects? 

And is anything more annoying than those people talking conversationally about side effects that may occur and who shouldn't take them????

Sorry I got off track...I think I'm done now. LOL

Great catch here Mr.

Great catch here Mr. Detrick...

I really tire of these networks and their constant know-it-all sissified scares, let alone an agenda to hurt some of these companies...

My biggest bitch about this all the time is like you say...they never ever, the talking heads or the so-called expert doctors they have on the show hold the parents or care-givers whoever they be responsible...or accountable. 

Heck in this country anymore, we aren't even responsible for our own selves from the time we wake up in the morning til bed-time.

We need a govt. 911 number to call to get our complete instructions for the day....we are going into an abyss of socialism fast.

I am sickened by what I see happening daily, and today is a mighty big one.

<edit> btw..I forgot to add in a boon for the leftist trial lawyers too with these reports against the companies..it is getting tiring. 

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Heck in this country

Heck in this country anymore, we aren't even responsible for our own
selves form the time we wake up in the morning til bed-time.

True, bt, but we are all held accountable for others!

mb... You got that

mb...

You got that right...and we end up paying for it too...one way or the other...big time!

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

More from the Nanny

More from the Nanny Congress.

It's bad enough that I can't get Sudafed over the counter anymore thanks to the nannies in Congress.  Now they're worried that if people don't use their cough medicine correctly, it might be bad.  Congress to the Rescue!

I think it's time to get out the Ban Dihydrogren Monoxide (DHMO) petitions again--the nannies need to be reined in.

»→ DHMO

It's unbelievable the number of deaths worldwide that can be directly attributable to DHMO abuse.  

Welcome to the USSA

DHMO facts

Get the facts on DHMO before considering a ban. 

If conservatives are RIGHT, then liberals must be WRONG.

»→ DHMO

True enough, but I saw enough of the danger of DHMO inhalation on Baywatch  

We kicked Hezbollah out of Lebanon - Joe Biden

Ah ... Baywatch

Excellent, excellent!

A terrific show with rivoting dialogue. Skilled acting by David Hasselhoff (sic)  and the very talented, Pamela Anderson.

A truly visonary show that entertained and informed.

If conservatives are RIGHT, then liberals must be WRONG.

"They're safe if they're

"They're safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them to be dangerous,"

This is kind of obvious, but you can practically misuse everything. Cars are safe if you use them properly, but they can be dangerous, pens, cleaning supplies, food, alcohol...

Last I checked, kids still pretty much hate cough syrup. Robbitussin isn't the most tasty thing out there... 

News Flash!!!

LIFE....is dangerous!!

Danger! Danger! Will Robinson!

Automobiles are safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them dangerous.

Fishing poles are safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them dangerous.

Toasters are safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them dangerous.

Houses are safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them dangerous.

Bicycles are safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them dangerous.

Chairs are safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them dangerous.

Shoes are safe if they're used properly, but so often they're not and so I consider them dangerous.

I work with someone

I work with someone who is always fearful of things. Our favorite qoute is "But is it safe?". We have great fun at times at their expense but as we talk about the safety they come to realize how foolish the concern had been and they laugh too.

 

P. S. I can visualize a scene where the robot arms are flailing and the red light is flashing!

A few years ago, a company

A few years ago, a company came out with patches that stuck on the chest, and were like the sticky Vicks stuff that works so great, but makes a mess. These patches were fantastic, all the effects with none of the grossness.

A couple of years ago they took them off the market, because, children MIGHT pull the patch off and chew on it.

Ummm hello? What kind of a kid would chew on anything that smelled like Vicks? But even assuming that some mentally-deficient kid might, wouldn't it have sufficed to put a warning on the package that they should not be used on children under 5, or something?

That one really ticked me off, because that stuff was fantastic! But, more important of course, is the smugness of the self-righteous-police: "your kid can't have this because someone else's kid might be stupid enough to abuse it."

 

"I've now been in 57 states -- I think one left to go." ~ Barrack Hussein Obama ~

"You cannot go to a 7-11 or a Dunkin' Donuts unless you have a slight Indian accent.... I'm not joking." ~ Sen. Joe Biden

The parents or caregivers

The parents or caregivers are the responsible parties here. Give a child too much water and they will get sick. It's the same thing with medication. If you follow the instructions and keep medications out of reach, they are safe.

 Get with it, people,

 Get with it, people, cough medicine is the old school, Bush way of doing things, and look where it has gotten us: children dying from cough syrup overdose. When Obama is president, there will be no sick, coughing children. Now THAT'S change we can believe in.

He's gonna save us.....

He's gonna help us...

Obamas gonna fix it

Obamas gonna save us all..... 

 

Obama's Economic plan: more taxes, more spending, more regulation. Prosperity here we come.

Getting back into this thread late

No one will read this, but who here remembers Jarts?

There's a heckuva fun game that the nanny government took away from us.

So! A handful of people take a metal lawn dart through the skull, and the government has to ruin it for everyone. I always figured that the jart was doing Darwin's work.

Man! I wish I knew a blackmarket for those things.

Jarts were cool.

We had a set when I was a kid back in the early '70's.  :-)

-Dave

Palin/Anybody other than McPork in '08


Its got a hallucinogen in it.

Kids chug it to get high.  The cough suppressant in it is Dextromethorphan, a dissociative hallucinogen in high enough doses.

I doubt if many of the emergency room visits are due to parents administering it improperly.  

Parker

Don't you have to go to the pharmacy counter to get it now? I know in Texas, we do.  

"This
liberal would be all about socialize -- uh, uh, would be about
basically taking over and the government running all of your companies."-Maxine Waters 2008

They'll get it

Anyone abusing these products will still get them. What's to prevent a child from raiding the medicine cabinet or asking an adult to buy it for a "cough"? This is already done with alcohol and other items like spray paint that get used illegally.

 

Dihydrogen Oxide was the subject of a spoof recently where folks took petitions to ban it around for signatures. It was funny how many people on the video of this spoof took the ban seriously without realizing that it was water.