NewsBusters is holding a 5th anniversary happy hour in Washington, and you're invited! Click here for details.

New Yorker Writer Compares Glenn Beck to Lonesome Rhodes

  • Bookmark and Share

Um...Let me guess. Nancy Franklin is somewhat less than enamored with Glenn Beck. In fact, she downright hates and despises him as you can see in her New Yorker article. Ironically Franklin accuses Beck of spreading venom in her incredibly venomous story which concludes by comparing him to the character of Lonesome Rhodes in the excellent 1957 film, A Face in the Crowd.

A few of the "love notes" tossed in Beck's direction:

Glenn Beck, the energetically hateful, truth-twisting radio and Fox News Channel talk-show host, was absent from the airwaves for a week...

The persona that Beck has cobbled together over the past few years combines a determination to draw attention to himself, because what he has to say is so important, with an outsized, in-your-face show of modesty...

Beck looks cherubic, with his boyish crewcut, his rubbery, expressive face, his wide eyes, and his seemingly innocent smile, but he has a wizened heart and a sulfurous outlook on American life and politics.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Beck’s negative, regressive take on politics is expressed with raw-throated outrage, smiley sarcasm, and, occasionally, a display of hurt, even tears.

Wow! So what is it about Glenn Beck that you DON'T like, Nancy? ...Just kidding!

The strangest thing about Franklin's attack on Glenn Beck is her accusation that he uses "irresponsibly edited video clips" to criticize administration officials...but then admits that the unedited video validates Beck's criticisms:

Throughout the year, Beck has gone after Administration officials, repeatedly showing irresponsibly edited video clips, in which they say things that make them easy marks.

And then this Franklin admission in the very next sentence:

Sometimes, though, the clips really do raise questions about someone’s judgment or self-awareness, even when you hear a longer version of the comments.

Which means Beck was correct in his critiques but Franklin can't bring herself to admit that. She even grumbles that the Obama administration should have done a better vetting job on its appointments because that oversight provided fodder for Beck such as in the Van Jones case:

The Administration should have known that some of Jones’s speeches, and other questionable parts of his record, would be made public; the Internet-savvyness of the Obama Presidential campaign seemed to vanish not long after the election.

So what was Beck's crime here? Accurately quoting Van Jones?

And here is the conclusion of Franklin's poison pen hit piece with a comparison of  Glenn Beck to the character of Lonesome Rhodes:

A headline at the top of Beck’s Web site announces what he thinks he’s selling: “the fusion of entertainment and enlightenment.” If by this Beck means that his product is radioactive, he’s got that right. We can only hope that its toxic charge will fade over time. But that seems unlikely. At the end of the Elia Kazan–Budd Schulberg movie “A Face in the Crowd,” the Arkansas opportunist and petty criminal who has been repackaged, by a radio broadcaster, as a guitar-playing professional hayseed called Lonesome Rhodes (played brilliantly by Andy Griffith), and who has been consumed and ruined by fame, shows his true colors when he bad-mouths his audience over an open mike. The nation abandons him, and, as the movie ends, he’s shouting, unheard, into the night. These days, because of the Internet, it’s not so easy to get rid of a demagogue. Long after Beck leaves radio and TV, his sound bites will still be with us.

Why do I get the feeling that one of Franklin's big fantasies is to somehow become a latter day version of the Patricia Neal character in that film who opens up a mike to expose Glenn Beck while he (in her fervid imagination) secretly bad mouths his audience.

Oh, and Nancy, would it make you feel better about Glenn if he were to serenade you with his version of Mama Guitar? ...Better brush up on your baton twirling skills.

—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.

NewsBusters is turning 5. Enter our free t-shirt contest to help us celebrate!


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

i guess she's only paid attention to glenn for one year

i wonder why she never mentions glenn rightfully condemning progressive republicans as far back to the days when he was on cnn, she only saw the times he talked about regular progressives. oh but that would completely destroy the whole pretense of her article that glenn only goes after democrat progressives.

thankfully now, nancy has now defined that whenever you disagree with a progressive you are hateful, sulfurous(come on lady you are going way too for out of the way with your geological terminology to try and look smarter than us regular rubes in america, oh but who are you really published to, your echo chamber sychophants), negative, regressive, and toxic.

wow i can't believe racist didn't work it's way into nancys column. 

nancy, just so you know, from my own perspective, i don't like the decisions obamas white half is making either. thanks ahead of time for not labeling me a racist. 

lunaticcringeradio

On the contrary!!

Beck is merely illuminating the poison being spread by the liberal, socialists.....like this one!!    They just don't like looking in the mirror.....can't say I blame them!

I think that Nancy.....

 

...needs more fiber in her diet.......OR

she's secretly in heat for Beck...methinks she complains too much.

 

Remember in November 2010

The only reason I started watching...

...Glenn Beck was because I knew it would anger lefties. I now enjoy the show and watch when I can. It is a decent show.

Plus "Special Report" is right after it on FOX.

New Yorker

Don't these people know we can tell who actually watches the show and who just repeats talking points given to them? If she watched at all, she'd see all Beck is doing is reporting what certain people did or said, with recordings of them saying it.

Ms Nancy-

Just one question, prove him wrong. Its that simple. Accusing him of whatever has no validity.

PROVE HIM WRONG_HE BEGS THAT YOU DO!!! 

BHO-  THE PROGRESSIVE PIRATE

 

 

 

The Lib/Lefties CAN'T!

The Lib/Lefties CAN'T!  But wouldn't it be refreshing to see them try?

jimmy1660 got it right

republicans are racists, beck is a fear monger, blah blah blah, all the typical insults and slander are slung around whenever a conservative criticizes a progressives agenda instead of proving them wrong. because they can't debate the facts, progressives can only engage is false smear tactics.they can't prove them wrong, all they can do is cry they are being picked on.

you've seen this before with the film makers catching acorn workers doing very bad things, and now global warming pseudo scientists working on the global warming scam. don't blame the people actually doing things wrong, blame the people who are pointing out the bad behavior.

lunaticcringeradio

"Liberal" (a misnomer)

Another fine example of modern "liberalism": hate-filled, vicious, closed-minded. Never deal with the facts, rather fling personal attacks. Have you noticed?--- all they have is negative emotion-- which they display every day. Self-loathing, illogical and immature. Trust them, listen to them, try to change their minds --- at your own peril.

P.S. Glenn Beck is just pointing out the obvious. Modern "liberalism"( progressivism, relativism, collectivism, communism, etc.) has ruined a once-great nation. Allowed to continue, it will destroy America completely. 

 

 

 

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

Aw

They just hate him because he's beautiful.

old news, Nancy

Olbie's been calling Beck "Lonesome Rhodes" for weeks if not months now. get a new idea, Nancy!

as someone said above, it's easy to tell who actually watches Beck and who just crabs about him. I watch his show as often as I can, and I don't hear him preaching hate or racism. I hear him worrying about his country and exposing those who would harm America.

but then again, the New Yorker crowd thinks anyone who doesn't adore Obama is a racist.

Echo

Yeah, she's basically echoing Keith's "Lonesome Rhodes [Ding!]" meme.  It's just like all the people that refer to FNC as "[c-word that means, via Merriam-Webster, 'a number of similar things that occur together'] Fox," "Fox Noise," "Fixed News," etc., and refer to Bill O'Reilly as "Billo," etc.  The progressives' hero uses all those terms, among others ("Boss Limbaugh," "Orly Taitz Limbaugh," "news actor/actress," etc.).

Beck isn't running for anything

She's too stupid to notice a major difference right off the bat: Beck isn't a political candidate or office-holder. He's not running things. He can't be a Lonesome Rhodes or a Kingfish type -- unless by comparing him to Rhodes she means, "Beck falls in the category of people I hate because they say things uncomfortable to me."

 

 

The left should beware...

History shows that, when totalitarian regimes crop up, it's usually the ones who enabled it who get "purged" first. Or, be careful what you wish for, lefties. If you can't defend this nation, best you depart now, because you'll only be in the way.

‘When bad men combine, the good must associate; else they will fall, one by one, an unpitied sacrifice in a contemptible struggle.’ - Edmund Burke, 1770

Obviously, Nancy needs a course or two in anger management,

...to say nothing of a good dose of reason and logic. But then she wouldn't be the lefty wackadoodle she is and able to spew ignorant venom in a litter-box liner like the New Yorker... 

Nancy, like most members of

Nancy, like most members of the lamestream media, has found a new and more powerful drink to satisfy her thirst.  These people are far beyond the koolaide drinkers that voted the big Zero into office. 

 

This incredibly toxic concoction of which they imbibe?

 

Haterade (H/T to Red Eye on Fox)

RTNS... Lol...Haterade...y

RTNS...

Lol...Haterade...ya gotta love it...leave it to Red-Eye to come up with that.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

I'd laugh my butt off

...if Beck opened his show in black and white with a guitar slung around his back and "Mama cuitar" playing in the background.

This dolt needs to rewatch "A Face in the Crowd" Lonsome Rhodes

he wasn't re-packaged by the radio broadcaster.  He was re-packaged by the media, just like Obama!  The media hate Beck.

This woman's comprehension of the film is a joke 

Hey Dee... You hit the

Hey Dee...

You hit the nail smack on the head!

Beck speaks the plain truth, connects the dots etc ...and they can't have that...or handle it.

Great seeing you here...miss ya around here, but I do understand. I go to Twitter and I never get off of their either...whcih I'm going to be doing soon enough, probably after Turkey Day...you and yours have a great one gal.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

You too BT

Hopefully I will see more of you on Twitter.  

Try this out!

Simply take this opening paragraph...

"Glenn Beck, the energetically hateful, truth-twisting radio and Fox News Channel talk-show host, was absent from the airwaves for a week... The persona that Beck has cobbled together over the past few years combines a determination to draw attention to himself, because what he has to say is so important, with an outsized, in-your-face show of modesty... Beck looks cherubic, with his boyish crewcut, his rubbery, expressive face, his wide eyes, and his seemingly innocent smile, but he has a wizened heart and a sulfurous outlook on American..."

Now replace "Glenn Beck" with "Jon Stewart" or "Bill Mahr" and "Fox News Channel" with "Comedy Central" or "HBO" respectively, and this would make a whole lot more sense!

"truth-twisting" No,

"truth-twisting"

No, actually I don't take Glenn Beck or anybody at his or her word when they're up there on the tee-vee making millions of dollars.  I take all of them with a grain of salt and always consider that they could be spreading disinformation no matter how anti-Communist it sounds.

I haven't seen where he's twisted much of anything thus far.  However, I'm still wondering about that whole FEMA camp thing...?

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 86% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.