New Republic: TV Networks Should Treat Town Hall Protesters Like Unruly Sports Fans

  • Bookmark and Share

ObamaCare supporter Anthony Wright has a suggestion for TV networks in their coverage of the town hall protests: treat the protesters the way ESPN covers unruly sports fans. In other words, avoid pointing the cameras at them. Here are some of Wright's thoughts about censoring the town hall protesters published in The New Republic:

The Fox network has done more than any other network to showcase the protesters at health care town halls. And the coverage has been a lot like Fox’s reality shows: The more outrageous, the more likely you’ll end up on TV or YouTube. A sign referencing Nazis will get you on the local news. Shouting in a Senator’s face gets an radio interview afterwards. Bring a gun, and you get your full interview on a cable news program. After the first gun-toter made the rounds, the question wasn’t why there was a dozen folks packing outside the next presidential event, but why weren’t there more?

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Sigh! First of all Nancy Pelosi was the first one to bring up the Nazi reference by claiming that protesters were bringing swastikas to the town hall meetings. A search was done and the closest thing to that claim was a protester outside a town hall meeting holding up sign with a "NO" symbol over a swastika. As to the Obama as Hitler signs, they are being displayed by the far left Lyndon LaRouche supporters, not conservative opponents of ObamaCare.

Everybody deserves a chance to speak his or her mind; nobody disputes that. But how much attention should the media give these people? It seems to me this is one case when the political media--or, at least, Fox--could take its cues from the sports media.

Stand by now for the "Wright" advice on how to treat legitimate protesters like a bunch of unruly sports fans:

When fans at a professional sporting event try to make a spectacle of themselves--by being unruly or abusive, or running onto the field--the networks go out of their way to avoid showing it. Why? Because providing airtime to the disrupters would give too much incentive for others to do the same at stadiums across the country. Similarly, the media should focus on the issues of health reform, rather than the rude and belligerent behavior of a relative few.

Of course, that "unruly fans" advice only applies to conservatives. Wright would never think of treating leftwing protesters like a bunch of unruly sports fans.

It seems clear to me that the protests are less about the substance of the health reforms--which is often attacked with claims that have no basis in reality--and more about a vehicle to oppose President Obama, for whatever reason. They are merely the second episode to the “tea party” programming that Fox News sponsored earlier in the year, where the channel even provided the headline speakers across the country, including here in Sacramento. (Those were similarly disconnected from actual policy, as it was an anti-tax protest directed at the stimulus which actually included a major tax cut.)

No basis in reality? Like the absurd claim that ObamaCare would be "deficit neutral?" And where is that stimulus tax cut?

Wright follows his slam at town hall protesters with some wishful thinking about who is now showing up at the town hall meetings:

 The only saving grace is that now that the story that has fully migrated from Fox to the mainstream media, the turnout at these town halls meetings has shifted in favor of supporters--at least based on my experience in California and what I’m reading from around the country. Within 24 hours of hearing about a protest in front of an office of Senator Diane Feinstein, health reform supporters turned out and outnumbered them five to one. A town hall last week with Representative Adam Schiff, a Californian Blue Dog who supports health reform, turned out nearly 3,000 people--hundreds for both sides, but with supporters outnumbering opponents. As much as my organization and allied groups would like to take credit, you wouldn’t have had that kind of turnout from either side if this hadn’t turned into a media phenomenon.

You also couldn't have had the leftwing turnout (exaggerated by Wright) without SEIU and ACORN bringing them in to hold fancy pre-printed signs. If you want to see astroturf protesters, look no further than those two leftwing groups.

And, finally, a parting shot by Wright who is upset about citizens letting their voices be heard:

But even with supporters consistently outnumbering opponents of health reform, it still only takes a small number of rude, outrageous, and badly-behaved folks to dominate a meeting. By rewarding unruliness, by letting a small group of screamers shove their way onto television news and into the national conversation, the media may have set a standard they’ll come to regret later.

Unless it comes to covering leftwing protesters, right Wright? And remember, New Republic, the NewsBusters Eye of Sauron remains upon you.

—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Wish me luck

I'm going to Sen. Mary Landrieu's TH meeting in Reserve, LA this afternoon!

 

----------------------------------------

Government's first duty is to protect the people, not run their lives.

--Ronald Reagan

Good Luck!

Hope some of these questions are on your list for Senator Landrieu.

Town Hall

Went to one in NC with Sue Myrick (one of the good guys).

I had video camera in hand hoping for someone to embarrass themselves and become the next Youtube star.

Very uneventful. Damn Conservatives are too civil.

You trying to say Jesus Christ can't hit a curveball?

new republic

Where was the New Republic during the Bush years with all this civil advice? OOPS! It was their guys that were the problem, can't criticize potential subscribers, can we?

One commenter (yes

One commenter (yes commenter, there were more comments than questions during the 90 min I sat there) asked Mrs. Myrick to fight and "fight outside the box, because your opponents are."

He even slipped and said the the Repbulicans have had their asses handed to them. He caught himself and corrected it to butts.

Conservatives are wanting a fight and even to fight dirty, we are also wanting a leader.

You trying to say Jesus Christ can't hit a curveball?

Control

It's all about controlling what people get to hear.  Liberals obviously feel like their objectives are more important than the constitution.

By the way, sports fans are ignored because they are disrupting the event.  Town Hall meetings are held specifically so people can express their opinions.

 

"I support the President but not his policies" - Blonde

You need to tell your Rep that

Town Hall meetings are held specifically so people can express their opinions.

 Unfortunately, this fact is ignored by most in Washington when they come back to their districts.  These people think that the point of a Town Hall meeting is for THEM to tell the people what they are doing, why and to convince them that what they are doing is right.  This is why they are so upset when they are interrupted.  They actually think the Town Halls are held so THEY can speak and are quite offended when  the people do the talking.

 

"To send men to the firing squad, judicial proof is unnecessary."

--Ernesto "Che" Guevara

But, But, But

Then we wouldn't have the faces of hundreds of ACORN, SEIU, and CraigsList workers deliberately bussed in from outlying counties and pretending  to be part of the opposition on camera!

But, Mr Anthony knows that.

              

                     I have never heard of Wright, but he doesn't seem to bright.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               

aint it great

...and you still wonder how the Germans didn't know?

 

They claim the people don't

They claim the people don't know what's in the bill, we have senators who admit it's too long and complicated to read.

This attack on the protesters is just another debate-dodging effort which it so typical of the left.  They don't want to debate the merits or demerits of the issue and come to a conclusion that is beneficial to all, they just want to ramrod socialism down everyone's throats.

Funny how "Liberals" have such disdain for liberty and participatory democracy.

 

The premises

  • Fox is bad
  • Heathcare is good
  • Protesting against healthcare must be misguided

Once you start with those premises, and unless you start with those premises, the rest follows.

 

 

Healthcare?

You mean IRS-collected health insurance?

Oops

We've tossed around "healthcare" so much that I used the term to refer to the liberal atrocious "reform," and not to the actual practice of medicine. My bad - you're right.

The government run media

The government run media has done worse than ignore the "disrupters" they have only showed them to then vilify them.  They don't dare show a "disrupter" making a fair point and then discuss what that person had to say against what is in HR 3200.  Further, they have representated far left protesters as conservative ones particuarly when it came to showing a depiction of the president as a Nazi. 

Meanwhile, Fox News is gaining more and more ground.  O'Reilly alone has more viewers than CBS News now.  Add up the Fox News lineup and it is approaching the agregate of the three networks news programs plus CNN and MSNBC. 

So, go ahead government run media.  Ignore, vilify and bear false witness to the "disrupters."    It's working . . .

Tut tut

Well, I just treat New Republic readers like loud library patrons.

"Liberals"

The "liberals" continue to deny the truth. These protests are sincere; they come from average citizens who are simply fed up. But their mocking, dismissive attitude is backfiring--big time. The more they mock, the more ridiculous they look. Their absurd comparisons evince who they are---left-wing anti-American elitists who think they can get away with modern fascism. But the little secret is that THEY are the ones who are afraid. These immature, ignorant relativists are coming to the realization that they are being exposed and they are shaking in their boots as real Americans are standing up and being counted. And their biggest fear now--the 2010 elections! Lick your chops and rub your hands together! 

P.S. Be sure to stand right up to Barry's club-wielding thugs at the polling booth. Fight them--Eric Holder,AG, sure won't. 

 

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

500 Demonstrations

Wait, later this summer and once Congress reconvenes, the liberals are planning 500 demonstrations in support of Obamacare to help push it through. Every one of those demonstrations will be covered Cindy Sheehan at Crawford-style, and it will be on the news every day. Those protesters will not be considered 'rowdy sports fans', they will be worshipped by the liberal media as concerned citizens.

Then we will see the the outrageous and obvious bias in the media.

Liberals hate "Free Speech". They tell us that every day.

This is just one more example.  I am glad Liberals have "Free Speech" and no one from the right is trying to stop them.  The more they talk, the more they lose.  Jim Webster

for the first time

in my adult life I am truly afraid for my country.

 

Wake Up Lefties

People are not yelling for the sake of yelling at these town hall meetings or to get on network TV.  They are yelling because the Democrats have unveiled their masks as the party of predatory parasitical sociopaths and the American people are fed up with them.

pointvcounterpoint.com

Good idea!!

Agreed..leave the children at home so there can be honest debate.

Howie Tells the Truth!

Sounds like the title of a children's book, but Howard Dean admitted at a townhall meeting that Obamacare does not dare take on tort reform because those in Congress fear the trial lawyers!

Howard Dean: There's No Tort Reform in Obamacare Because We Fear the Trial Lawyers: http://townhall.com

Unruly sports fans?

Naw, they can do better than that! We're more like t'd off patriots determined to take back our country from the clutches of dictatorial socialists bent on destroying our nation.

I am amazed how absolutely arrogant the MSM really is. They actually believe that they are the majority voice despite the fact that their network ratings are horrible, their newspapers unsellable, their false messiah's polls are plummeting, and people are coming out in droves to town hall meetings to confront them. 

Reminds me of the ostrich that sticks his head in the hole pretending like the world around him will just disappear if he can't see it.

 

 

"If God is dead, somebody is going to have to take his place. It will
be megalomania or erotomania, the drive for power or the drive for
pleasure, the clenched fist or the phallus, Hitler or Hugh Hefner."
— Malcolm Muggeridge

Senator benett of Colorado is havin' a meeting

 

I sent him this response.

I
see a lot of buses from out of town whenever my representatives show up
to hold 'townhall meetings' and I've always wondered who pays the
wages, travel expenses, buses, meals, lodging etc for these
cheerleaders that make you feel good whenever you appear in Colorado?

Are
they paid to disrupt and cause problems for the people that actually
live in those areas? Or is that just a side benefit due to the quality
of people you hire for this job?

Do you ever get bored preaching to the same crowds with the same faces everytime you put on one of these shows?

Do you ever wish that you could be man enough to talk to the PEOPLE whom you actually are supposed to represent?

Please
feel free to answer this by email so I can attach your response to this
entry onto the numerous websites around Colorado to which I will post
it.

 

No answer yet.....

http://gjresult.com

 

free speech

Bill of Rights:  Freedom of Speech.

Correct

The right to protest.

Right

The right to protest a healthcare bill

Correct

The right to protest a War in Iraq.

Right

The right of assembly

Correct

This are life and death issues

Right

But don't kill each other for exercising their rights.

That's Correct