SF Chronicle Reporter: Pelosi 'Torture Woes' Politically Motivated

  • Bookmark and Share

So how does the Washington correspondent for Nancy Pelosi's hometown newspaper, the San Francisco Chronicle, explain away Nancy Pelosi's disastrous news conference on Thursday in which she accused the CIA of lying?

Simple. Blame it all on the evil Republicans and portray the House Speaker as the victim of political gamesmanship.

Such was the laughable premise of Carolyn Lochhead in her Chronicle article:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The furor over House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's accusations against the Central Intelligence Agency serves a purpose beyond finding out how the United States came to embrace torture. The San Francisco Democrat, deeply partisan and often ridiculed, offers Republicans their best shot yet at blocking a popular president whose poll numbers have so far defied gravity.

See, Pelosi's ever changing positions on what she learned at the CIA briefings is just a political opportunity for those nasty Republicans to take shots at our beloved President. And of course, our ultra-pure Nancy Pelosi herself would never ever lie while the CIA is known to be damaged goods, at least according to Lochhead:

Ironically, the controversy has come down to a credibility test pitting Pelosi, whose modus operandi has never been known to include lying, against the Central Intelligence Agency, an institution deeply damaged by the use of flawed intelligence to invade Iraq and now on the defensive for its use of torture.

Of course, there is the problem of the Democrat CIA Director, Leon Panetta, backing up the agency's account of the Pelosi briefing:

Panetta is considered a wise man of California and national politics who worked for years with Pelosi as a congressman from Monterey. On Friday, he reiterated his statement that agency records show CIA officers briefed lawmakers truthfully in 2002 on the interrogation methods, but also said it is up to Congress to draw its own conclusions.

So how to explain this away? By coming up with a "party lines" memory lapse whopper:

The fact is, no one knows what happened in the Sept. 4, 2002, briefing at issue other than those who were in it. Their memories diverge along party lines.

And you know this as "fact," Ms Lochhead?  This sets the stage for Lochhead to make her "party lines" sales pitch for Pelosi.

 Pelosi radically notched up the stakes Thursday when she accused the CIA of lying after several Republicans, including former Bush White House political czar Karl Rove, accused her of the same. The fight comes on the heels of internal GOP polling warning Republicans against simply opposing Obama.

So poor Pelosi is the victim of "internal GOP polling." At least that is the premise of Carolyn Lochhead. 

This article generated over 800 comments and, despite the liberal Chronicle readership, even many of them weren't buying into the Lochhead spin machine:

{GOP SEES GAINS OVER PELOSI TORTURE WOES}/// What a headline, as if to imply that Pelosi is a victim of politics. THIS STUPID, FANATICAL WOMAN BROUGHT IT UPON HERSELF with her lies and vengeful partisanship. Even Obama's gotta be thinking "clamp it, hag"! Unfortunately, she'll come through unscathed, save a little embarrassment at being publicly proven a liar, because her constituents are A-OK with this kind of asinine behavior and will continue to support her.

Nice spin Chron. Nancy got caught lying.

The problem with Pelosi isn't what she knew and when. there is little doubt there. Her problem is being hypocritical. You don't look good when you go bashing someone for doing something that you condone.

Of course, being San Francisco, there were also the Pelosi defenders in the comments section. Many of those comments sound as if they were posted from a psycho ward so here are a couple of nuggets for your comedic entertainment:

This is crazy. Bush Cheney Rove lied us in to a war that cost 4000 plus lives. They lied about 9-11 and covered up the truth. Its not a controlled demolition because we removed the evidence and stonewalled the investigation. And just because Bushs grandfather made money from the Nazis in WW2 and Karl Roves grandfather [Karl Roverer]built the ovens in the Nazi concentration camps we are to believe their grandkids are any different . How much money did Bushs corporate friends make from the war. The CIA has been dirty for decades. Take Iran for an example in the fifties the CIA took out a democratically elected Mossaddeq and put the Shaw in his place that led us to the current government. The Iraq war is a scam and we Americans are paying the price for it .

"RIGHT WING WATERBOARDS HOUSE SPEAKER" may be a more fitting title to the current controversey. "...liar, liar, liar, liar, liar...", they cry as the accusations pour forth. Hang in there Nancy. They run out of vitriol eventually. Time for those of us tired of decades of REPUBLICAN IRRESPONABILITY AND CORRUPTION to speak up. Support building a better future for all people, not just big business and the white establishment. Thier numbers are dwindling each passing year. Stand up against exploitation, against greed, against those that would steal our government from us for thier own gain. Let them hole themselves up in thier useless fortresses of money and power. In the end those defenses behind which they hide will crumble. There have always been more of us than them. Unite, stay focused, don't stop until thier like is driven from this land. It's an old story, same as before, the rich get rich and the poor get poorer. At some point we'll be "MAD AS HELL, AND WON'T TAKE IT ANYMORE".

And with "friends" like that, Nancy Pelosi doesn't need enemies. (And who knew there was a "Shaw" of Iran?)

—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

You know,

this would be funny, or maybe even sad, if it weren't so serious.  Any criticism against any Democrat on any issue becomes a personal attack on the phenomenally popular President (even if he isn't).  The world has seen this trick before, 70-80 years ago.

But you gotta love this part:  "Pelosi, whose modus operandi has never been known to include lying,.."   As opposed to cheating and stealing.

Never been known for lying

Never been known for lying -- there are workers in American Samoa who would care to disagree with Ms Lochhead.

Redemption of Pelosi

I said this yesterday, Pelosi has been punished enough, time for the MSM to start helping her back to the forefront. It's all the Bushies fault anyway!

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

What Carolyn Lochhead

What Carolyn Lochhead misses is obvious.  Pelosi and other Democrats have become accustomed to having willing allies in the press who will not ask too many questions of the Speaker for fear of embarrasing her.

But Pelosi took too much advantage of this situation and now the press, afte trying to hide it for so very long are being forced to tepidly investigate her statements.

If she had simply made one or two BDS fostering comments she would have been fine and the press would continue to carry her water for her.  But her continuous abuse of the press's alliance with the liberals has forced them to act.

THey will tepidly report on her statements and hope they will not be forced to report on her loss of the speakership.

Nancy opened this door

It's not surprising the the GOP would walk through this door, but it was San Fran Nan who threw it wide open.  When Clintonista Leon Panetta, now head of the CIA, takes her on, you gotta know she's in big, big trouble.

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

Nancy Pelosi must resign!

History is replete with examples of politicians who, for the good of the party and the country, have left public service. Now that it is obvious to any but the most partisan Pelosi supporter that she has been caught in a web of lies, she should follow their example rather than continue the infighting that has rendered congress impotent for the last three years.

Or maybe not? Maybe an impotent congress is the best kind? Nope! When the attention of the media is on the Pelosi scandal, their eyes are even less on the schemes of the administration. 

Besides, since Barack had a lift kit put on the bus there's plenty of room underneath for Nancy and a few others.   

How can she be a liar, she's a Democrap

This is the funnest, and stupidest piece of media bias I have ever seen here.  Are there really folks who beleive this stuff? 

Hello, my name is Ron, but everyone calls me Mo, I dont know why? 

This is crazy. Bush Cheney Rove lied us in to a war that cost 4000 plus
lives. They lied about 9-11 and covered up the truth. Its not a
controlled demolition because we removed the evidence and stonewalled
the investigation. And just because Bushs grandfather made money from
the Nazis in WW2 and Karl Roves grandfather [Karl Roverer]built the
ovens in the Nazi concentration camps we are to believe their grandkids
are any different

This has Dummy Funnies written all over it, Thanks PJ

My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

Pelosi is nothing but

Pelosi is nothing but "political gamesmanship" to the core. 

"DumbAssity of Dope"

Tortured Logic

Humm.. it seems that the San Francisco Chronicle is using tortured logic to excuse Nancy's tortured explanations as to whether or not she actually attended "torture" briefings.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

Chronicle's Moniker

"If you print it -- they will believe".

And print it they did -- Ironically, the controversy has come down to a credibility test pitting Pelosi, whose modus operandi has never been known to include lying, against the Central Intelligence Agency, an institution deeply damaged by the use of flawed intelligence to invade Iraq and now on the defensive for its use of torture.

I don't think Chronicle subscribers got their money's worth of truth yet today. 

___________________________________ 

The challenge is to follow a consistent plan despite inconsistent prices - Sarah Palin, State of the State of Alaska speech

And there it is!

"the Central Intelligence Agency, an institution deeply damaged by the use of flawed intelligence to invade Iraq"

So, now it's the CIA who "lied" us into war? I wonder of the SF Chronicle will now apologize to Bush for claiming that is was HIM to "lied" us into war with Iraq? Somehow, I doubt it.

Read it here, folks.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

The Great Mark Steyn nails

The Great Mark Steyn nails Pelosi with flawless logic that should be understandable to leftist dimwits.

To set it up Steyn points out that Dick Cheney has been 100% consistent on waterboarding.

He’s in favor of it. He was in favor of it then, he’s in favor of it now. He doesn’t think it’s torture, and he supports having it on the books as a vital option.

Now for Madam Speakerette

"It’s worth noting that, by most if not all of her multiple accounts, Nancy Pelosi is as guilty of torture as anybody else. That’s not an airy rhetorical flourish but a statement of law. As National Review’s Andy McCarthy points out, under Section 2340A(c) of the relevant statute, a person who conspires to torture is subject to the same penalties as the actual torturer. Once Speaker Pelosi was informed that waterboarding was part of the plan and that it was actually being used, she was in on the conspiracy, and as up to her neck in it as whoever it was who was actually sticking it to poor old Abu Zubaydah and the other blameless lads.

That is, if you believe waterboarding is “torture.”

I don’t believe it’s torture. Nor does Dick Cheney. But Nancy Pelosi does. Or so she has said, latterly."

“I'm with you on a free press. It's the newspapers I can't stand.” Tom Stoppard, Night and Day, 1978

S.F.C.

jessieH         First of all, Obama isn't "our beloved president". Second of all, Pelosi lied, on camera, to everyone.

Sarcasm

I guess you missed the sarcasm.

offers Republicans their

offers Republicans their best shot yet at blocking a popular president whose poll numbers have so far defied gravity.

Are they still trying to sell moderately high poll numbers this early in his presidency as some kind of mystical feat? 

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

I wonder if they would like

I wonder if they would like to submit their boy to another election today? I don't think his msm-pushed poll numbers would stand up very well.

___________________________________ 

The challenge is to follow a consistent plan despite inconsistent prices - Sarah Palin, State of the State of Alaska speech

I agree with Ms Lochhead

If prominent Republicans such as Karl Rove and Dick Cheney hadn't started the whole conversation on "torture" by calling for the CIA memos to be released, and subsequently for the heads of the Bush Justice Department laywers, this whole thing could've been averted. Look, Pelosi supported the measures in 2002, and probably still does today, but with Republicans railing against her, she has no choice but to fight back! Even our President said he wanted to look forward and not back, fighting tooth and nail with the conservative base against releasing the memos, and making this page-18 news!

Poor Nancy's just doing her job- let's not castigate her for that! (sarc)

 

Oh yes...another "vast, right-wing conspiracy"...

Nancy Pelosi's lies and distortions are the result of Republican political maneuvering and attacks.

Right...The evil Republicans put a spell on Pelosi which made her lie and tell 5 different versions of her recollections concerning the terrorist interrogation briefings. That must be what happened...It's not her fault...It's all those nasty Republican's fault...   

"The problem is not that people are taxed too little...the problem is that government spends too much." ~President Ronald Reagan

The excuses the left are

The excuses the left are using to circle the wagon for Pelosi are getting to be the usual already....but this takes the cake...it would be Comedy Central if this was a laughing matter.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart