Journalists Out of Work? Resurrect Leftwing Federal Writers Project

  • Bookmark and Share

Mark Pinsky, writing for the New Republic, has an idea of what to do with all the journalists currently being laid off by the dying newspapers around the country: put them on the public payroll by hiring them for a resurrected Federal Writers Project. This was the New Deal project which provided funding for works which were primarily of a leftwing nature. And any current version of this government program is likely to have the same political ideology as its predecessor. Pinksy explains his dream of subsidizing unemployed journalists (emphasis mine):

Barack Obama sounds like he wants to reach back to the New Deal's Works Progress Administration to jump start the economy with an economic stimulus proposal featuring infrastructure repair. If so, it may be time for the man who would be FDR to take a look at another successful--but largely forgotten--jobs program from the Depression era: the Federal Writers Project.

America's newspaper industry has been imploding in the last few years, a development that predates the Wall Street collapse but has been hugely accelerated by the economic meltdown, forcing thousands of journalists onto the street. Hundreds more have now joined them from retrenching magazines and faltering websites, bringing the year-to-date total to 14,683 according to the tracking website Paper Cuts. Hundreds more have now joined them from retrenching magazines and faltering websites. Every day the journalism clearinghouse Romenesko links to stories of layoffs and downsizing--Gannett has been cutting 2,000 jobs across the chain, and Newsday has just announced another five percent in the last week alone. Any federal effort to put back to work the hundreds of thousands thrown out of work in the nation's hard-hit industrial, construction, airline, and financial sectors should consider displaced news media workers--including those newly laid off from the publishing industry--as well.

And don't forget that the Tribune Co. is about to go bankrupt and the failing Miami Herald is now up for sale. Oops! Sorry for interrupting Mark Pinsky and his fantasies about New Deal writer glories updated for the 21st century:

The Federal Writers Project operated from 1935-1939 under the leadership of Henry Alsberg, a journalist and theater director. In addition to providing employment to more than 6,000 out-of-work reporters, photographers, editors, critics, writers, and creative craftsmen and -women, the FWP produced some lasting contributions to American history, culture, and literature...

...Today, there are many dislocated "old media" journalists from newspapers, radio, and television on the street--here I declare my personal interest, as one of them--who could provide a skilled pool to staff a new FWP. But since these journalists represent only a fraction of the larger displaced workforce, it is fair to ask what the public benefit would be of money spent.

This time, the FWP could begin by documenting the ground-level impact of the Great Recession; chronicling the transition to a green economy; or capturing the experiences of the thousands of immigrants who are changing the American complexion. Like the original FWP, the new version would focus in particular on those segments of society largely ignored by commercial and even public media. At the same time, the multimedia fruits of this research would be open-sourced to all media, as well as to academics. As an example, oral history as a discipline has made great strides in the past 70 years, and with the development of video techniques, the forum of the Internet could make these multi-media interviews widely available to schools and scholars, as well as to average Americans.

Yup! It sure sounds like a leftwing project. And anyone who doubts it, check out how Pinsky thinks it should be administered:

How would it work? Administering the new FWP as an individual grant program through community colleges and universities could minimize bureaucracy and overhead. In consultation with the Obama administration--perhaps through the National Endowment for the Humanities--and Congress, guidelines could be established and a small staff assembled in Washington to oversee the projects, in the form of grants, rather than hourly wages. Projects could be pitched locally to colleges, or suggested and posted by them, vetted preliminarily and then approved or rejected by the national staff.

And "in consultation with the Obama administration and Congress" guess what sort of projects would get the funding? I guarantee you that any writing project casting doubt on Global Warming would be quickly rejected along with any other writings that question liberal ideology. The main result of any new Federal Writers Project would be as a subsidized propaganda arm for liberals.

—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The Myth of FDR and the New Deal

It is unbelievable how brainwashed liberal socialists are with FDR. I am now firmly convinced that they are all high on pot. Socialize journalists? What? Are we becoming the USSA (United Socialist States of America)?

FDR's policies prolonged Depression by 7 years, UCLA economists calculate (UCLA)
How FDR Made the Depression Worse (Robert Higgs, Ph.D. Professor Emeritus of Economics)
The Mythology of Roosevelt and the New Deal (Robert Higgs, Ph.D. Professor Emeritus of Economics)
How FDR's New Deal Harmed Millions of Poor People (Jim Powell, Historian)
Should We Try Another New Deal? (Jim Powell, Historian)
Tough Questions for Defenders of the New Deal (Jim Powell, Historian)
Why Did FDR's New Deal Harm Blacks? (Jim Powell, Historian)
The New Deal Debunked (Thomas J. DiLorenzo, Ph.D. Professor of Economics)
The New Deal Debunked (again) (Thomas J. DiLorenzo, Ph.D. Professor of Economics)
Three Myths of the Great Depression (Burton W. Folsom, Ph.D. Professor of History)
The Truth about FDR (Thomas E. Woods, Jr. Ph.D. History)

Censored Global Warming Videos

Put Brokaw's plan into operation

Let them all pay $4.00 gas. "No one should go around thinking they can fill up their cars on $20 ever again".

After all, Brokaw is a "Journalist" and they need to stick together, don't they?

___________________________________ 

If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber

Someone should

Take away Brokjaw's farm subsidies.

Ignorance Is Strength

Senor Obama could hire the unemployed writers to work for his new federal Ministry of Truth in Washington.  Former "journalists" for the New York Times, Washington Post, Newsweek, etc., would probably find that their new job responsibilities (i.e., promoting Obama's public image and policies) were almost identical to their former duties during the 2008 campaign.  The only difference would be who signed their paychecks.

Sounds like...

...a federalized version of GM's "jobs bank", only at least the GM people had something resembling appreciable skill...

Listen, I have

Listen, I have no appreciable writing skills and no desire to acquire any but I'd like a government stipend from the writers jobs bank for the rest of my life (I could live on a couple of hundred grand a year).

I promise I will never do anything to justify it and will not produce anything publishable.

Aww....go look for a real job

So they're whining that their left wing drivel isn't read by most normal Americans who don't agree with their radical views and they're going to lose their jobs?  Tough.  You sure as hell aren't using my tax dollars to fund ridiculous points of view that Capitalist America drove out of the marketplace.

As Judge Smails said in Caddyshack, "The world always needs ditch diggers".

"What you can not enforce, do not command" -Sophocles-

Wanna bet

 You sure as hell aren't using my tax dollars to fund ridiculous points
of view that Capitalist America drove out of the marketplace.

 Careful what you claim, these are strange times.

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

Even More Useless

Yeah, lets make failed journalists even more useless than tits on boar hogs.

The FWP was one of the most effective propoganda efforts in history. How could anyone in the project question the effectiveness of Roosevelt's failed programs that continued to worsen the Great Depression. They called him pragmatic. If it weren't for World War II and Arthur Schlesinger, history would judge FDR as a miserable failure.

Get ready folks. The left is going to make a huge power grab after their prince is coronated.

Maybe these out-of-work journalists can find spots in Barry's Civilian Defense Force.

Hail Obama!!

Actually, 10ksnooker makes

Actually, 10ksnooker makes a great point.  Well done!

Now,  it's not as if the leftists don't have any outlets for their drivel.  Only every magazine and newspaper that you pick up. 

And now, we have to use our tax money to help them spread their BS?  You talk about a tax revolution! 

But by all means dems, try this.  Conservatives always need more issues to hammer you with in 2010.

I always said liberals will buy the rope that they hang themselves with. And no, this is not a noose reference. ; )

 

why sure

Then Obama can take all the starving artists, actors, playwrites, and musicians, and put them on the government payroll too.  

I'm a typical white person.

bad idea

Come on. I'm part of this "evil media" who narrowly escaped the bloodletting and think this is a bad idea.

Maybe this guy has never heard of journalismjobs.com (though admittedly, I have noticed a few less jobs being posted each day, but that also might be because we're nearing Christmas, when hiring slows down a little bit as people look ahead to the New Year).

WPA FWP "Left wing?"

Mr. Gladnick:  You state as a fact that the WPA FWP "...was the New Deal project which provided funding for works which were primarily of a leftwing nature."

Yet the source you cite says that the best known FWP effort - the outstanding American Guides series - was basically non political in nature.  Those Guides remain excellent reference works - and the Library of Congress has made readily available the transcripts of the interviews that per a major resource for those Guides.

In your opinion the FWP may have been "left wing."  And if you want to predict that a 2009 version would be so that is, again, an opinion.  Neither are facts.

 

Government sponsored

Government sponsored 'make-work' jobs created to satisfy no particular legitimate demand are by their very definition, left wing ventures.

sounds like...

communism to me.

 

 

Never under estimate the power of stupid people in large groups.

Hi Jackie... Remember...

Hi Jackie...

Remember... "The way of Communism is peasentry".

Obama’s Honeymoon Over?

 

 Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

Give them WPA Jobs

If we're going to have all these "WPA" jobs to rebuild roads, bridges, etc., give unemployed journalists shovels. It wll be the first time many have done honest work.

BW222

Retraining requirement....

Under the new new deal program they can be retrained (with great effort) to pour concrete or pound rocks into gravel. One out of a thousand may be trainable to pound nails without bending so many they cost the builder more than they're worth. If they were qualified as real reporters of the 'news' instead of political hacks they wouldn't be out of work.

My real thought was, BWA HA HA HA HA while rolling on the floor.

Old, Retired and glad of it.

Oh goody...another

Oh goody...another old leftist program revived.... under the Fairness Doctrine guise...just had to throw that in there.

Just think Helen Thomas and forward...all the same end results.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

I'll pass

According to this, the author says writers will be needed to:

begin by documenting the ground-level impact of the Great Recession; chronicling the transition to a green economy; or capturing the experiences of the thousands of immigrants who are changing the American complexion.

 Dude, we already have this, everywhere. If not there's always the internet. Plenty of folks that aren't professionals will be posting,  I don't see a shortage of info coming anytime soon. Plus, when did this become the "Great Recession?" Did I sleep through it? I was under the impression that we have only had 2 quarters of neg. growth, and regardless of what the lefties say, we haven't been in a real recession for a year. I also didn't know we were transitioning to a "green economy," unless by green he mean "green backs," I'm not interested. And they wonder why people don't want to pay them to write! Have any of you read any of Pinko's articles at New Republic? He is a fruitcake.