CNN's 'Hologram' Toy Gets Panned by CNET News

  • Bookmark and Share

CNN has a wonderful new toy that they seem to love playing around with. It's called a "hologram." I put "hologram" in quotes because according to an annoyed Don Reisinger of CNET News, it's not really a hologram. You can get an idea of just how upset Reisinger was with the CNN "hologram" by the very title of his CNET story, "Stop the Insanity: CNN's 'hologram' was horrendous."

Can someone please explain to me why so many people are making a big deal about this CNN "hologram" that the channel unveiled during election coverage Tuesday night?

See, Don, CNN found a new toy that they are going to play with while pretending to deliver the news.

According to CNN, it was real "hologram" technology that beamed Jessica Yellin, a CNN correspondent from Chicago, to the CNN press center in New York, where Wolf Blitzer could grill her about what was going on in Chicago.

First off, let me say that it wasn't even real "hologram" technology, which annoys me from the start. Don't say it's a "hologram" technology unless it really is. If CNN was truly using a "hologram," it would not have employed a green screen and overlay images. Instead, it would have captured scattered light and then reconstructed it back in the studio.

Oh, and it probably would have bankrupted CNN too.

Bankrupting CNN? And that would be a bad thing?

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

But I digress. Everywhere I turn, someone is saying how "cool" CNN's so-called "hologram" was. Uh, no.

Allow me to explain something to those who probably also get excited about buying a new hammer or watching a new Starbucks open up in their neighborhood: the "hologram" technique made the show look shoddy and stupid, and made Ms. Yellin look like a well-designed video game character.

I've got news for you, Don. Most CNN shows already look shoddy and stupid. 

Now, I know what you're saying: "But Don, you see, by using its 'hologram,' CNN is embracing technology and taking news reporting one step further."

Sorry, but I think that if you believe that, it's time for you to stop drinking Wolf Blitzer's Kool-Aid.

Nothing about the CNN "hologram" made sense. Part of the value of sending reporters to different areas to cover what's going on is to allow viewers to look beyond the onscreen reporter, and see the raucous environment. And it also affords the reporter the opportunity to walk around and show viewers some of the visual highlights at the event.

But with the help of its "hologram," CNN destroyed the value in sending a reporter, and instead made it, in the paraphrased words of Wolf Blitzer, "a more intimate setting" for the interview that eliminated all the noisy people that would have been standing behind her.

Spoken like a true apologist.

Just because the idea of a "hologram" is interesting, it doesn't mean that every time that someone pretends to use one, we have to think that it's the greatest thing in the world. The "hologram" looked ugly, made Ms. Yellin look awkward, and it didn't provide any real value to the viewer.

Your humble correspondent interrupts to pose a legal question. All through that interchange between Wolf Blitzer and Yellin the "Hologram," I kept hoping that Wolf would do something really cool like sticking his arm into the "hologram" or tossing a Dixie cup through it. So my question is, could it be considered sexual harrassment to do that to a "hologram?" I will await an answer from the legal scholars.

I applaud CNN for at least trying something new. But if show producers are smart, they'll shelve their "hologram" idea, and move on to something bigger and better, like transporting Ms. Yellin back and forth between Chicago and New York next time. I think that'll keep them busy for a while, and help us enjoy some quality programming, while they're trying to figure out how to reconstruct atoms.

I know the idea of a "hologram" is alluring to some. But let's not allow our hopes for the future cloud our judgment.

CNN's "hologram" was dumb.

Apparently the readers of this CNET story thought the CNN "hologram" was dumb too as you can see by their comments:

Thank you, Don, for the first reasonable answer behind this "hologram" nonsense. CNN should be slapped around for calling it a hologram in the first place, but more importantly for making such a big deal of it.

Thanks, Don. I've been saying this for a while but everyone seems to be impressed by shiny objects. These "holograms" are nothing more than chroma key + the NFL "1st down" tracker. i.e. green screen over lay combined with an angle of viewing calculation to display the proper camera.

You can't blame CNN for trying. They've been falling behind Fox News in ratings and MSNBC in production quality for years.

CNN stop outsourcing American jobs to holograms!

Perhaps CNN will someday have the technology to beam real holograms into our homes. So if ol' PJ wants the news delivered to him personally he just orders, say, a Petra Verkaik Playmate hologram to materialize in his very private computer room. Just lean over and whisper the latest news into my ear, Petra. It makes no difference what the news is. Hee! Hee! It can even be boring crop reports from North Dakota and...GOOD GRIEF!!! CNN, you sent a Helen Thomas hologram into my room by mistake!!! And I can't get rid of her because my hand goes right through her when I try to shove her out the door! AGGHHHHHH!!!! 

—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Chris is getting that thrill again

This is enough to make Chris Matthews move to CNN. He can summon a hologram of his beloved Barack anytime he needs another thrill.

Good grief, Chris. Did you have to demand another hologram of me again? I'm in the freakin' bathroom!

 

This 'hologram' crap

was the most egregious display of style over substance 'journalism' I saw all election night.  And given all the touch screens and flying maps, that's saying a lot.

Memo to CNN: the time to capitalize on the popularity of Star Wars was back when Star Wars was popular.

I was half expecting that

I was half expecting that CNN "hologram" say, "Help me Obi Wan Kenobi. You're our only hope"...

MSNBC had their stupic graphics too

What was with the 3D graphics coming out of the floor on MSNBC?  I thought that was pretty dumb too, but then again, I guess you have to cater to your audience.  The on screen "talent" had to walk around the half circle like the graphic was really there popping out of the floor.  It was ridiculous.

 Every channel is getting dumbed down, now even the news, for our dumb and numb Nanny state society.  Bravo really used to show arts and entertainment.  The Discover channel used to have science shows.  Now it is all just drivel for the masses.

Drill here, Drill Now!

I agree. It's not ready for

I agree. It's not ready for prime time. It looked very fake, and the "distance" between Blitzer and Yellin was unnatural for a face-to-face conversation. Heck the "holograms" in Star Wars (the original 1977 cut) looked better than this.

"An armed society is a polite society. Manners are good when one may have to back up his acts with his life." --Robert A. Heinlein, "Beyond This Horizon", 1942

Hologram was a flop. Like

Hologram was a flop. Like you, I thought of Star Wars. I kept waiting for one of the interviewees to say "Help Obi-Wan. You're my only hope."

Intimate setting

I think Wolf wanted to turn the lights down put on a little Barry  "Hussien Obama" White and get intimate with the "Hologram"

Did she just call BHO "Boy"?

 

 

Laughable

Boy, maybe they should  put as much money, time and effort into doing their actual job, investigative journalism. I might have actually enjoyed it  if they had beamed in George Takei, and just had him laugh over and over. 

Jindal/Ryan 2012

A better hologram

Musion systems creates a hologram effect that's pretty cool. While not a 100% true 3D hologram, you can present it in front of a live audience.

http://www.musion.co...

I use a slightly smaller version to freak out kids at Halloween similar to this one: http://www.youtube.c...

phony

See, Don, CNN found a new toy that they are going to play with while pretending to deliver the news.

CNN's 'hologram' is really just a 'smoke screen' to cover up the fact that their reporters lack journalism ethics!