Joe Klein: 'Obama is the precise opposite of Mountain Man Todd Palin'

  • Bookmark and Share

Remember all those months of the MSM building up the myth of Barack Obama, the Lightworker of unique spiritual powers whose image was frequently photoshopped to present his blessed head surrounded by a halo? Well, now Time magazine columnist, Joe Klein, is upset that Americans are supporting Sarah Palin because of another "myth" of a small town frontier America. Those who create the myths really shouldn't be complaining about what they perceive as myths but that is exactly what Klein does in his column (emphasis mine):

Sarah Palin has arrived in our midst with the force of a rocket-propelled grenade. She has boosted John McCain's candidacy and overwhelmed the presidential process in a way that no vice-presidential pick has since Thomas Eagleton did the precise opposite — sinking his sponsor, George McGovern, in 1972. Obviously, something beyond politics is happening here. We don't really know Palin as a politician yet, whether she is wise or foolhardy, substantive or empty. Our fascination with her — and it is a nonpartisan phenomenon — is driven by something more primal. The Palin surge illuminates the mythic power of the Republican Party's message since the advent of Ronald Reagan.

Sorry, Joe, but if you live by the myth created by the MSM then you shouldn't complain when you die by a "myth."  First Klein builds up the Palins...but only for ulterior purposes:

To start with the obvious, she's attractive. Her husband ("And two decades and five children later, he's still my guy...") is a hunk. They have a gorgeous family, made more touching and credible by the challenges their children face. Her voice is more distinctive than her looks: that flat, northern twang that screams, I'm just like you! Actually, the real message is: I'm just like you want to be, a brilliantly spectacular...average American. The Palins win elections and snowmobile races in a state that represents the last, lingering hint of that most basic Huckleberry Finn fantasy — lighting out for the territories. She quoted Westbrook Pegler, the F.D.R.-era conservative columnist, in her acceptance speech: "We grow good people in our small towns..." And then added, "I grew up with those people. They're the ones who do some of the hardest work in America, who grow our food and run our factories and fight our wars. They love their country in good times and bad, and they're always proud of America." 

And now for the shootdown:

Except that's not really true. We haven't been a nation of small towns for nearly a century. It is the suburbanites and city dwellers who do the fighting and hourly-wage work now, and the corporations who grow our food. But Palin's embrace of small-town values is where her hold on the national imagination begins. She embodies the most basic American myth — Jefferson's yeoman farmer, the fantasia of rural righteousness — updated in a crucial way: now Mom works too. Palin's story stands with one foot squarely in the nostalgia for small-town America and the other in the new middle-class reality. She brings home the bacon, raises the kids — with a significant assist from Mr. Mom — hunts moose and looks great in the process. I can't imagine a more powerful, or current, American Dream. 

During the past 50 years, the rest of the country has caught up to the South in the nostalgia department. We lost a war in Vietnam; Iraq hasn't gone so well either. And there are two other developments that have cut into the sense of American perfection. The middle class has begun to lose altitude — there isn't the certainty anymore that our children will live better than we do. More important, the patina of cultural homogeneity that camouflaged 1950s suburbia has vanished. We have become more obviously multiracial. There are lifestyle choices that were nearly unimaginable in 1960 — the widespread use of the birth control pill, the legalization of abortion, the feminist and gay-rights revolutions, the breakdown of the two-parent family. With the advent of television, these changes became inescapable. They intruded upon the most traditional families in the smallest towns. The political impact was a conservative reaction of enormous vehemence. 

Enter Reagan. His vision of the future was the past. He offered the temporal pleasures of tax cuts and an unambiguous anticommunism, but his real tug was on the heartstrings — it was "Morning in America." The Republican Party of Wall Street faded before the power of nostalgia for Main Street...at least a Main Street that existed before America began losing wars, became ostentatiously sexy and casually interracial. In his presidential debate with Jimmy Carter, Reagan talked about an America that existed "when I was young and when this country didn't even know it had a racial problem." The blinding whiteness and fervent religiosity of the party he created are an enduring testament to the power of the myth of an America that existed before we had all these problems. The power of Sarah Palin is that she is the latest, freshest iteration of that myth.

Get it? People didn't really agree with Reagan but they liked the Main Street "myth" he perpetrated. Of course, the absurd Lightworker myth gets a free pass from liberals.  Klein then asserts that Obama was never a part of what he claims is a myth:

The Republican Party's subliminal message seems stronger than ever this year because of the nature of the Democratic nominee for President. Barack Obama could not exist in the small-town America that Reagan fantasized. He's the product of what used to be called miscegenation, a scenario that may still be more terrifying than a teen daughter's pregnancy in many American households. Furthermore, he has thrived in the culture and economy that displaced Main Street America — an economy where people no longer work in factories or make things with their hands, but where lawyers and traders prosper unduly.

And now we come to the money quote of the column, unusual for Klein due to its dead on accuracy:

Obama is the precise opposite of Mountain Man Todd Palin: an entirely urban creature. He lives within the hilarious conundrum of being both too "cosmopolitan" and intellectual for Republican tastes — at least as Rudy Giuliani described it — while also being the sort of fellow suspected of getting ahead by affirmative action. 

Klein then bemoans what he sees as the problem of the Democrats not having a myth of their own to counter the Republican "fantasy":

The Democrats have no myth to counter this powerful Republican fantasy. They had to spend their convention on the biographical defensive: Barack Obama really is "one of us," speaker after speaker insisted. Really. Democrats do have the facts in their favor. Polls show that Americans agree with them on the issues. The Bush Administration has been a disaster on many fronts. The McCain campaign has provided only the sketchiest policy proposals; it has spent most of its time trying to divert the national conversation away from matters of substance. But Americans like stories more than issues.

You mean like stories about the mythic Lightworker, he of photoshopped haloed head, who would heal the sick and make the sea waters fall? The MSM, which diligently tried but failed to sell the public on the Barack Obama myth, are now complaining about a Republican "myth" which is actually the true story about Sarah and Todd Palin. Klein concludes by complaining about Obama's anecdote gap:

So Obama faces an uphill struggle between now and Nov. 4. He has no personal anecdotes to match Palin's mooseburgers. His story of a boy whose father came from Kenya and mother from Kansas takes place in an America not yet mythologized, a country that is struggling to be born — a multiracial country whose greatest cultural and economic strength is its diversity. It is the country where our children already live and that our parents will never really know, a country with a much greater potential for justice and creativity — and perhaps even prosperity — than the sepia-tinted version of Main Street America. But that vision is not sellable right now to a critical mass of Americans. They live in a place, not unlike C. Vann Woodward's South, where myths are more potent than the hope of getting past the dour realities they face each day.

Perhaps the critical mass of Americans were too savvy to buy into the MSM-created myth of the Lightworker. 

—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

How typical of the liberal 'intelligensia'...

They build up a myth around Obama and try and paint him as some kind of messiah, the one they've been waiting for...and then, when a real life authentic phenomenon like the Palins come along, try and tear them down claiming that they are all just a 'myth' created by the Republicans.

I can hear Klein screeming between the lines: NO! Belive our manufactured myth not their authentic actuality!

 

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

Battle of the myths

Klein's technique is to say anything but the obvious: Obama is an ambitious yet inexperienced politician. Against Hillary Clinton, he was running against someone with all of his same beliefs and assumptions, and so his were never challenged. He only had to be more friendly than the shrewish Cruella de Clinton. Now that he's in a battle on every front, he's clueless about what to do.

There's still a way to go in this election. Obama may yet still win. But if he doesn't, maybe - just maybe - the Democratic party will re-examine it's fundamental commitment to pure pro-choice liberalism. All their assumptions are so much wreckage. The economy is devastated by the banking and mortgage fiasco, and yet it's somehow strong enough to survive. What's really amazing is that the economy is still standing. That's because it's foundations have been built by conservative principles. Iraq is turning around, not because liberals pulled us out, but because a strong military adjusted to circumstances.

They keep trying to explain their failures with any other explanation other than the obvious - liberalism doesn't work.

"Obama is the precise

"Obama is the precise opposite of Mountain Man Todd Palin: an entirely urban creature."

Oh, I totally agree. Gov. Palin has had real jobs, and has produced positive results. The Ob-ma, via his rich history of community organizing in Chicago, can take partial blame in a city that has had more murders this year than U.S. military deaths in Iraq.

But hey, he's producing results as a United States Senator by taking a paycheck, provided by me, whilst campaigning for president for the past year and a half. I wish I could do that with my job. (To be fair, I think McCain should have followed the example of Bob Dole and resigned his seat.)

Sorry, Joe, but if you live

Sorry, Joe, but if you live by the myth created by the MSM then you shouldn't complain when you die by a "myth." 

That says it all, in a nutshell, Mr. Gladnik

The media want to be the ones to decide which "myth" is viable and which isn't.

You really can't make this stuff up! 

Talk about humiliating:  after Obama has been compared to the Republican Vice-Presidential  candidate, Klein is actually comparing him to the husband of the VP candidate!!

Maybe next someone will compare him to Track.  ROFL!!

How looooooow can you goooooooo?  -Chubby Checker "Limbo Rock"

 

"Talk about humiliating: 

"Talk about humiliating:  after Obama has been compared to the Republican Vice-Presidential  candidate, Klein is actually comparing him to the husband of the VP candidate!!"

I had the same thought, mb.

 

"... smells like... victory." - Robert Duvall

Obama polar opposite of Mr. Palin?

Say no more!  I'll take a "regular guy" over a fake, socialist race baiter every day of the week and twice on Sunday!!

Jeff Lebowski

www.angrywhitedude.c...

Couldn't say it

Couldn't say it better.

The major media report only half the news. Why are they surprised they have only half the potential audience?

delete double

delete double

 

 

Todd Palin is the exact opposite of Barack Obama.

THANK GOD for that!    

and following to logical

and following to logical conclusions - this actually then makes Obama just like OBL

Journalism is the opium of the liberals

I find it extremely odd

I find it extremely odd that leftists are desperately attempting to paint Palin as being some kind of redneck alien "other".  But, in the meantime, Obama is supposed to be folksy, every-day American apple-pie.

Right off the bat: Barak Huessein Obama.  Not exactly John Smith.

BHO was born of a muslim father (which technically makes Barak a Muslim by Islamic law).  He was schooled in Indonesia, which is a very strict Islamic country (he was taught to pray as a Muslim).  Not exactly a typical American christian upbringing.

Barak has family in Kenya, a third-world country.  His half-brother literally lives in a shack.  His grandma (on his fathter's side), was recently robbed by thugs, who roam about unchallenged.

And let's not forget Obama's never-ending associations with radical leftists throughout his career, who are far outside the American mainstream.

So we're supposed to think a woman from Alaska, who is a bit rough around the edges (and proud of it), is some kind of freak.  But not Obama?

And that small town myth most likely will put McCain-Palin

in the Whithouse for REALITY.

 

"I need more cowbell!" SNL

This man is bitter

His words drip with bitterness off the page because of something he knows he can't quite grasp.

Live by the mythology, die by the mythology

Imagine, that Americans would respond to a candidate who's goals in life didn't include living off the fruit of their labors and thinking of ways of giving it to others.  Can't imagine why that doesn't resonate.

What polls show that

What polls show that Americans agree with Democrats on the issues? I want to see them.

So now it's our fault that Obama, who was recently touted as a cultured globetrotting man of the world, has no small-town roots to call his own? 

And for the record, there are still many wonderful Main Street American towns out there, but one has to leave the bubble of the urban jungle to experience them.

I'm confused about the whole reason for this article to have been written. 

Joe Klein, like much if not most of the media,

believes in a myth of their own. Small town values don't count any more!  He couldn't be more wrong.

Many of us now living in cities and suburbs, grew up in small town america and still hold on to the values we grew up with. We identify with and admire people like the Palins and understand the challenges they face because some of them are the same ones we face in our own lives.

Sarah Palin is a woman who leads by example and has walked the walk. Barack Obama wasn't a leader in Chicago or in the Illinois House, hasn't been a leader in the senate and  hasn't shown any great qualities of leadership during the campaign. We don't buy the halo.

 

Future

 

The photo in this article shows the dumb expression that "O" Dumby will have when he meets Putin.

 

The caption will read. " Puti made me do it" 

huh?

The culture of "small town America" is obsolete?

And Obama's going to lose the election because he can't fake American Gothic?

Wow. Just wow.

That sound you hear is me running to the store for more duct tape.

'Obama is the precise

'Obama is the precise opposite of Mountain Man Todd Palin'

And may I just say: Hallelujah, praise the Lord!!!  What this country needs are more manly men!   

"Let every soul be subject unto the higher powers. For there is no power but of God: the powers that be are ordained of God."  - Paul (Rom. 13:1) 

Can I sue Klein for making my sides hurt?

Uh....ummm...ah...no...um...uhhh...teleprompter...ahh...er...must...ahh...bloviate...um...ah...ummm...till...ah...um...uhhh...have...um...original...ah...um...uhhh...thought....

"He lives within the hilarious conundrum of being both too "cosmopolitan" and intellectual for Republican tastes..."

Joe, I hardly think too intellectual describes the "Reader".

 

"An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last."  - Sir Winston Churchill

Wow!

I've heard of 'reaching' to make a point, but this clown makes it into a perverse art form!

To quote Bill Clinton; "Nice try, honey, but, no cigar".

 

Wow... just... Wow!

Beyond the obvious "myth-steria" Klein exhibits, he shoots himself and his candidate in the foot too many times and in too many ways to disect in a mere thread posting.

But that won't stop me from trying!

Haven't been a nation of small towns for a century? What? Then how is it that many who are not centenarians can remember what it was like to grow up in a small town? How is it that there are still way more small towns than there are big cities? This is a typical coast liberal, he believes the only places that count are the big cities. You know, the ones that always go Democrat, yet have failed to elect a president more than 12 years in the last 40. And from that fact, he thinks the cities have superceded the "small towns."

And it's the cities and suburbs that "do the fighting now?" Well, yeah, I guess if you mean gang turf-wars and such, yeah, the big cities have a lock on that. But Klein seems to believe that our all-volunteer army doesn't have any rural members. Un... real.

And Reagan merely reminded us of the "good old days." He didn't bring a fresh outlook, a confidence, and some damn fine policies to the office. Just... nostalgia. Un... freakin'... real.

And, sure Joe, Obama is just too "cosmopolitan and intellectual" for us few remaining yokels, who really shouldn't count at all in a fair, enlightened, sophisticated urban country. Whatever gets you through the day.

He says that the Dems spent their whole convention trying to paint Obama as "one of us,"... and failed. So now, being "one of us" is a drawback. This is known as "sour grapes." A guy named Aesop wrote about that one, check it out, Joe.

"No myth to counter this... fantasy?" No, Joe, the Democrats spent enourmous political capital to build up their myth of the "Lightworker," only to find that it didn't take in enough people. So they spent their whole convention (according to Joe) trying to re-invent him, "triangulate" the myth, if you will. Greek columns and all. Gee, how could anyone miss the "I'm just a regular guy" message in that?

"... a multiracial country whose greatest cultural and economic strength is its diversity." No, Joe, that sounds good, and is well-received on the liberal talking-points speech circuit. But diversity for the sake of diversity (ala affirmative-action) is not only a proven failure in terms of any kind of "strength," but is almost a new "third-rail" of politics. In fact, "diversity" fixation is tearing down American culture, substituting a mish-mash of competing cultures. We've turned off the heat under the melting pot, and now the pot is just full of "stuff," un-melted.

I think that about covers it. How does someone who is so clueless get a job writing such drivel? And where do I apply?

 

"... smells like... victory." - Robert Duvall

Wow! Shows how out of touch Klein really is.

"Small town America" counts and is more important than the big cosmopolitain socialist havens that bracket it slong both coasts. Most of the population in this country either live in or grew up in 'small towns'.

"We haven't been a nation of small towns for nearly a century. It is the suburbanites and city dwellers who do the fighting and hourly-wage work now, and the corporations who grow our food."

The view from NY City. This is like one of those funny distorted "maps" that you see where the center of the world is the place you are and the rest of the world gets progresively marginalized the further it is from the center of the 'map', or more importantly, you.

 

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

So now we have gone from

So now we have gone from equating the Democratic Presidential tickets experience to the Republicans Vice Presidential experience, to the Democratic Presidential tickets experience to the HUSBAND of the Republicans Vice presidential ticket?......are these people really that stupid as to not understand how foolish they sound?

Obama vs. Todd Palin?

Like several others here, I, too, am amazed that the liberals are now reduced to comparing Obama, the Chosen One,  with the husband of the Republican Vice Presidential candidate. Oh, how the mighty have fallen! What's next, comparing Obama to the Palin's family dog?

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

Small towns are hardly extinct

He will find out on 11/4 just how many of us still subscribe to that small town "myth".  Most people dont live in metro areas by choice (Google - Top Towns to Live Like Smalltown, USA), most Americans identify with and would prefer to live in small towns.  No further proof needed that the left is full derangement mode than to be comparing a PRESIDENTIAL candidate with the husband of the opposing party's VP candidate.  Oh and Michelle is nothing like Sarah either..........THANK GOD!

Average American? The horror!

Klein betrays his sad elitism (for the millionth time) by charging that Palin is "average", writing: "Actually, the real message is: I'm just like you want to be, a brilliantly spectacular... average American." 

And of course we mustn't allow "average" Americans near our government! Certainly not a government of the people, by the people, and for the people. 

"We the People" had best stand clear and let our superiors handle it. Right. See you in November, Joe!