You can almost hear the violins playing while reading U.K. Guardian writer Zachary Roth bemoan the "swiftboat" labeling of Barack Obama by those wascally Republicans:
Over the last few months, Barack Obama has been variously labelled an "elitist", a naïve softie and simply "out of the mainstream" in his lifestyle and associates. And lately, in what appears to be the centrepiece of the GOP's attacks, Republicans have focused on portraying Obama as arrogant and self-interested.
...The "arrogant" label could well damage Obama. That's partly because, as with Kerry's rep for flip-flopping, it might contain a kernel of truth. At the very least, Obama is prone to gestures that can come off as cocky: his fist bumps, his habit of running up the steps to the stage before a speech, even his tendency to address a crowd by the name of their city or state ("Understand this, Houston,") as if he were in a rock band on tour ("Hello Cleveland!").
Hello London! Are all of your writers so vapid? Now comes Roth's comedy highlight. Obama is misinterpreted as being arrogant primarily because of his ability to produce "transformational change" unlike an ordinary politician of, say, a Chicago Machine variety:
But there's a deeper reason why the charge of arrogance could hurt. As McCain's clever stump speech line suggests, the label goes to the heart of the rationale for Obama's candidacy: that he can change how politics works. If the notion of Obama's alleged arrogance breaks through into the mainstream campaign narrative, he'll have to be far more careful about invoking his ability to produce transformational change, or risk reinforcing the "arrogant" meme. After all, portraying oneself as capable of changing politics as we know it does require a healthy self-confidence, to put it mildly. In this way, the "arrogant" label paints Obama into a box. Once that happens, the race becomes a more conventional contest between two politicians, neither of whom can truly deliver change, but one of whom is a war hero who's "tougher" on terrorism. That, of course, is a race that John McCain can win.
If Obama wants to avoid the "arrogant" label, he'll definitely have to avoid the condescending attitude of Roth towards what he calls "low-information" voters:
The tactic could prove particularly effective with those white working-class voters we've all heard so much about lately. It was this group that was most sceptical about Obama's promise of a new kind of politics during the Democratic primaries. They also tend to be low-information voters - a group that Newsweek recently proclaimed this year's "It demographic" - meaning they're more likely than their better-informed brethren to be swayed by negative character attacks.
Roth does take some solace in what he sees as Obama's political brilliance which could keep people from viewing him as arrogant:
That's not to say Obama is doomed to suffer Gore and Kerry's fate, of course. He's a far more skilled politician than either of them, and by continuing his efforts, launched during the primary fight, to engage with working-class voters on bread-and-butter economic issues, he can make clear that he doesn't see himself as too lofty to worry about the day-to-day concerns of ordinary Americans.
Almost hear those violins playing did I say? Listen carefully and you can now hear them play the new Obama theme tune, as conducted by one starry-eyed Zachary Roth: "You're Just Too Good to be True."
—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.














Editor at Large

Comments Policy
Arrogance
July 3, 2008 - 22:11 ET by Jay in NHI was farmed out to a junior college for a semester after some academic inconsistencies: Obama reminds me of a somewhat clever prof at that place who was revered in a big fish, small pond sort of way. It really can only be a matter of time until he is caught out at this level, despite the JC hangers on that the MSM are here. By the way, don't you think smug captures him better tan arrogant?
Jay in NH... One
July 3, 2008 - 22:17 ET by bigtimerJay in NH...
One word...
....Yes.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
I disagree; I like
July 4, 2008 - 07:33 ET by motherbeltI disagree; I like "arrogant."
"smug" means self-satisfied. He may be that too, but "arrogant" is soooo much more! I've always said he has that "cocky teenager" kike of arrogance.
Shoot 'em all; let God sort 'em out! - Marge Simpson
Well ...
July 3, 2008 - 22:16 ET by 10ksnookerAt least until every body gets tired of his lies. It's already grating on a few of my Democrat friends. Obama is a pathelogical liar, but unlike Clinton, Obama doesn't have the skill or finesse to make it stick. He just goes on as if nothing happened before.
Might have worked for community organizer, and in Rev Wright's church, where jive talking was popular, doubt it works for President. No one likes a lair for long.
"You're Just Too Good to be
July 3, 2008 - 22:21 ET by bigtimer"You're Just Too Good to be True" ....
Perfect.
What more can one say.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Morning, bt and Happy
July 4, 2008 - 07:38 ET by motherbeltMorning, bt and Happy Independence Day.
I'm Googling around and trying to find the article I read a while ago where the woman who wrote it actually said that we don't deserve him, he is too good for us! If I find it, I will PM it to you.
Shoot 'em all; let God sort 'em out! - Marge Simpson
I Just Ordered me a NOBAMA T-Shirt, to wear in dwntwn Seattle
July 3, 2008 - 22:34 ET by JayTeeI'll be wearing it on Weekends......if you don't hear from me for Weeks on end.....well, it's been FUN.
Wait a minute....I've never Met an Obama Supporter I couldn't WHIP.....nevermind.
I like Fox's new Fox, with Daily recaps of the MSM "Obama Gushers"
What's her name ...uhh...uhh...BT, you shouldn't have bought me that Margarita...
The Republican Revolution will not be Televised
LOL JT... ...don't blame
July 3, 2008 - 22:46 ET by bigtimerLOL JT...
...don't blame this gal...
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
JayTee, lol-good luck with that NOBAMA shirt.
July 3, 2008 - 22:54 ET by R D HelmHope you don't take one in the, ahh, back. Or, does that only happen in San Francisco?
:-^)
The truth is insensitive. - Neal Boortz
This Place, NEEDS ME (Seattle)
July 3, 2008 - 23:13 ET by JayTeeI've been Converted
And it was FUN...
The Republican Revolution will not be Televised
Jay Tee...
July 3, 2008 - 23:20 ET by Clear thinkerI would wear the shirt also, but I would wear it with the full knowledge that those you poke fun at are a bunch of mean little bastards. Seriously, expect some really angry whacked out lefties screaming at you like you are some sort of baby killer.
As long as you understand the above, I say GO FOR IT!
45 Communist Goals for America http://www.nationmakers.com/com_goals.htm
Cleartinker....I have alread witnessed the ..
July 3, 2008 - 23:44 ET by JayTeelocal "angry wacker out" people...My First week here, I was asked for FREE $$$'s by street people by the Dozens.
No wonder the MSM thinks Viet Nam Verterans are Homeless...everyone here is holding up "Homeless VETERAN" signs..on the street Corners. It's a Liberal Plague...but outside of Seatlle, the People are real...just drive North/south/east/west of King County...
I lived here in the Early 80's before Microsoft, had a Son born here...watched Mt. St Helens erupt and put out more Global warming Gas than Al Gore ever dreamed of....as Jack N. says....
I'm Baacckkk !!
The Republican Revolution will not be Televised
Given the fact that most
July 4, 2008 - 00:19 ET by Prez RudyGiven the fact that most of "His Obamaness's" followers are none too bright, they probably won't even notice the shirt anyway JT...They will most likely have to do a quadruple-take before they even understand what it sais..
"...white man's greed runs a world in need." Barack Obama
If I were you,
July 4, 2008 - 01:03 ET by Eileen RightI'd use public transport...
I am not a "nasty
July 3, 2008 - 23:41 ET by mostlymoderateI am not a "nasty republican" and I find Obama very arrogant. Unfortunately, I find his wife even MORE arrogant.
Moderation...the MSM forbids your Opinion
July 3, 2008 - 23:59 ET by JayTeeJust because Michelle doubled here Salary when Obama was elected Senator, doesn't mean She's Arrogant....$300,000 a Year in income, will change your Attitude ....not hers, YOURS !
The Republican Revolution will not be Televised
→ Stay with "elitist"
July 3, 2008 - 23:57 ET by Cool Arrow"Elitist" is the term we've chosen, and the one we should stick with. It perfectly describes Senator Obama.
There's an old Southern term for "arrogance" waiting in the wings to be sprung upon us at time of the left's choosing.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
Arrogant
July 4, 2008 - 00:49 ET by FAQsI did think it was a little arrogant when he took credit for stopping the ocean level from rising. Actually, he really is not all that arrogant when you compare him to Al Gore or John Kerry. But, I have no doubt he could catch them after a couple terms in office.
I can't say...
July 4, 2008 - 09:09 ET by Copperhead Ridge...that I'm a nasty Republican, but I guess I'm a nasty conservative. I've disassociated myself with the GOP after the national party became "Democrat Lite."
Barak Obama's public persona comes across as arrogant, very arrogant. Whenever I hear him speak -- either giving a speech or talking to the press -- I wonder if he's capable of having fun. Actually, I wonder this about a lot of liberals I know. They are humorless, condescending, and so tight that it's a wonder that they don't explode when they get the vapors.
Obama is very typical of most liberals I know.
Oh yeah, liberals will challenge my assessment of them. They'll swear that they have a sense of humor, but 99% of their humor is maligning individuals. They all have a very biting sense of humor.
Interesting, huh? They have no problem at shredding individuals, but they'd never malign a group of people (in public). It's evidence of their anti-individual bent.
How many liberals does it take to change a light bulb?
The answer is zero.
They have to make sure that the light bulb does not offend anyone; write an environmental impact study; hire liberal biased consultants to conduct an economic justice assessment; make sure a union worker will receive the prevailing wage to change it; make sure that women and minorities have an equal opportunity to change it and that if they change it, they won't be perceived as performing menial labor; and create a commission on changing the changing of light bulbs.
They whine about being in the dark and the oppression they suffer by being there. They use taxpayer money to empower women, minorities, and immigrants to coerce other people into changing the light bulb.
When an evil conservative comes along and changes the light bulb, they submit hundreds of press releases describing why the conservative exploited them by changing the bulb. They'll also whine about the horrors of incadescent lighting.
They're going to regain control in January.
If you consider that
July 4, 2008 - 09:34 ET by Jabba the TuttIf you consider that "swiftboat" means to tell the truth about Democrats, then calling Obama "arrogant" is indeed a "swiftboat" attack.
Exactly so
July 4, 2008 - 11:33 ET by ReaverThat is the MSM definition of a swiftboat attack. My favorite part of the article- That's partly because, as with Kerry's rep for flip-flopping, it might contain a kernel of truth. "A kernel of truth?" I would call that "whole grain truth."