Skip to main content
  • CNSNews.com
  • MRC TV
  • Biz & Media
  • Culture & Media
  • TimesWatch
  • Take Action!

Join Us @:
Facebook
Twitter
Amazon Kindle

Tell the Truth campaign logo
NewsBusters.org logo

May 27, 2012
  • Home
  • Blogs
  • About
  • Forum
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Search
  • Account
  • RSS

Hot Topics

  • Anti-religious Bias in the Media
  • Same-sex Marriage
  • 2012 Presidential Race
Home » Blogs » Noel Sheppard's blog
  • Ashley Judd to NBC: Republicans Are 'Really Dumb,' Obama Has 'Flowered'
  • Bozell Column: Canada's 'Scientific' Museum of Smut
  • CBS: 'Troubling Signs' For Obama, Like Bush in '92, But President 'Cannot Control' Economy
  • On and On It Goes: Networks Cover 'Predator Priests' As They Stay Silent on Catholic Liberty Lawsuits
  • NBC's Williams Touts L.A. Banning Plastic Bags As Effort to Keep Them 'Out of the Natural World'
  • Bozell, Carlson Note Media's Silence on Obama Supporter's Bribe to Hush Rev. Wright
  • Very Annoyed Matthews Rips ‘Horse’s Ass Right-Wingers’ Who Cite ‘Thrill Up My Leg,’ Calls C-SPAN Host a ‘Jackass’
  • CNN Asks Tony Perkins 'Why Do Homosexuals Bother You So Much?'

How Would Media Have Responded If Sherrod Worked For George W. Bush?

By Noel Sheppard | July 31, 2010 | 10:41

Change font size:  A |  A
Noel Sheppard's picture

We're fast approaching the two week anniversary of the Shirley Sherrod affair, and I have yet to hear anyone honestly answer the following question concerning the controversy:

How would the media have handled this matter if it happened when George W. Bush was President?

Would the press have acted the same, or would somebody else be taking the heat?

Before you answer, consider the following hypothetical scenario: 

  • On July 19, 2006, Markos Moulitsas publishes the same excerpted videos of Sherrod at Daily Kos
  • She is scheduled to appear at 8PM EDT with Keith Olbermann on MSNBC's "Countdown"
  • Hours after the video's release, the NAACP condemns her actions in a written statement
  • Hours after the video's release, she is forced to resign from the USDA
  • Olbermann plays the video on his July 19, 2006, program as do other MSNBC hosts after him
  • On July 20, 2006, Sherrod appears on CNN's "American Morning," and tells the hosts the whole story while blaming MSNBC and the Netroots. 

Under that scenario, what would happen next?

Would the NAACP reverse its condemnation and point accusatory fingers at MSNBC and Moulitsas?

Would the resulting media firestorm be days of allegations of racism hurled at MSNBC, Moulitsas and Olbermann?

Assume days later Sherrod announced that she was going to sue Moulitsas for starting the whole controversy. Would press outlets appear supportive of her case and discuss its merits?

OR, would all the blame be given to George W. Bush for his hapless handling of this matter?

After all, what has been mostly glossed over by the Obama-loving press is how easily a competent president could have resolved this controversy.

As soon as the Administration became aware of the Sherrod videos, Mrs. Sherrod should have immediately be summoned to the White House and told not to speak to any media members until after the meeting.

The full video of her address should have been obtained, and NAACP members in attendance at the March 27 event should have been contacted to get their take on what transpired. At the same time, the head of the NAACP should have been contacted and asked not to issue a statement until after the White House had time to investigate the matter.

If the Obama administration had done all this, Sherrod NEVER would have been fired, and the controversy likely would have been over by Wednesday.

Of course, none of this would have sheltered Andrew Breitbart from the usual media haranguing, but it would have been far less if Sherrod was never forced to resign.

As such, going back to our hypothetical scenario, if this all happened in 2006, would the media be going after MSNBC, Moulitsas and Olbermann, or would virtually all the blame be placed on George W. Bush's doorstep?

If the answer is Bush, then why are Fox News, Glenn Beck and Breitbart taking all the heat now instead of the current White House resident?

Yes, that's a rhetorical question. 

Share this

About the Author

Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Click here to follow Noel Sheppard on Twitter.
  • Andrew Breitbart
  • Barack Obama
  • George W. Bush
  • Markos Moulitsas
  • Shirley Sherrod
  • Noel Sheppard's blog
  • Login to post comments
  • Printer-friendly version
Donate to NewsBusters

  • Is liberalism dead? (Roger L. Simon)
  • The media's next move on same-sex marriage (Get Religion)
  • Senate Dems pay women staffers less than male staffers (Washington Free Beacon)
  • Left targeting Chief Justice Roberts in attempt to save ObamaCare (IBD)
  • Walker's chance of defeating Wisc. recall looking great (Ace of Spades)
  • Ex-prez Bill Clinton poses for pic with porn stars (Fox Nation)
  • Protests against conservative group ALEC draw pitiful numbers (YouTube)

Donate to NewsBusters Today!

This form needs Javascript to display, which your browser doesn't support. Sign up here instead

User Shortcuts

Log in

  • My account
  • My buddylist
  • Log in to check messages
  • RSS feed
  • About NB
  • Contact us
  • Jobs
  • Advertise on NB
Scott Rasmussen
Rasmussen Column: 'Austerity' Talk Is Just Political Cover for More Government Spending
Walter E. Williams's picture
Walter E. Williams
Walter Williams Column: Should Black People Tolerate This?
Cal Thomas's picture
Cal Thomas
Cal Thomas Column: The Media's Religion Deficit
Chuck Norris's picture
Chuck Norris
Chuck Norris Column: IRS Gives Billions in Tax Refunds to Illegals
Michelle Malkin's picture
Michelle Malkin
Michelle Malkin Column: How the Gay-Marriage Mafia Slimed Manny Pacquiao
More >

RSS FeedAmazon KindleFacebookTwitter

Recent comments

  • Yeah. That's a great idea.
    1 min 29 sec ago
  • Like John
    6 min 50 sec ago
  • Great
    7 min 22 sec ago
  • Republicans...
    9 min 45 sec ago
  • Republicans...
    10 min 15 sec ago
More >

More Like Farcebook
more cartoons
  • Howard Stern Hasn't Been 'King of Prime Time'
  • All Purpose Weekend Open Thread
  • NPR Celebrates Transgender Olympics Hopeful as Hammer-Throwing 'Jackie Robinson'
  • Bashir to Facebook Co-Founder: Go 'Play with the Traffic'
  • Piers Morgan Whacks 'Little Wretch' Who Says He Taught Phone-Hacking
More >
NewsBusters

Executive Editor
Matthew Sheffield

Editor at Large
Brent Baker

Senior Editors
Tim Graham
Rich Noyes

Managing Editor
Ken Shepherd

Associate Editor
Noel Sheppard

Contributing Editors
Tom Blumer
Geoffrey Dickens
Dan Gainor
David Limbaugh
Lachlan Markay
Mithridate Ombud
Clay Waters
Scott Whitlock

Senior Contributor
Mark Finkelstein

Contributing Writers
Matthew Balan
Michael M. Bates
Erin R. Brown
Jack Coleman
Kyle Drennen
Douglas Ernst
P. J. Gladnick
Stephen Gutowski
Matt Hadro
D. S. Hube
Kathleen McKinley
Dave Pierre
Amy Ridenour
Julia A. Seymour
Terry Trippany
Rusty Weiss
Brad Wilmouth

Publisher
Brent Bozell

Site Design
Dialog New Media

 

  • Home
  • Blogs
  • About
  • Forum
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Search
  • Account
  • rss
  • CNSNews
  • MRC TV
  • Biz & Media
  • Culture & Media
  • Take Action!
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Amazon Kindle
  • Advertise
  • Jobs

Copyright © 2005-2012 NewsBusters. Terms of Use.