"This president who travels the world apologizing for his country couldn't quite apologize for himself."
So said Brit Hume on the most recent installment of "Fox News Sunday" as the panel discussed Barack Obama's handling of the Henry Louis Gates affair.
Adding insult to injury, there was virtual unanimity that the President erred in this matter, and erred badly (video embedded below the fold with partial transcript):
BRIT HUME: Well, I think Robert Gibbs didn't add a lot, probably trying not to add a lot on this -- on this issue, but, you know, what's striking about this is the president was clearly trying to get this over with, put the firestorm out, and yet, in the end, he couldn't bring himself to actually apologize for himself.
This president who travels the world apologizing for his country couldn't quite apologize for himself. He spoke of not calibrating his words perfectly. He suggested he didn't mean to malign the -- the police officer in question or the Cambridge police department. But he said they acted "stupidly." If you say something like that, you obviously malign them.
So, in the end, this controversy may be nearing an end, but if he had made an outright apology and said he never should have waded into it in the first place, and it wasn't -- shouldn't have been a question of calibrating words; he shouldn't have said any words -- if he'd said that, it would be over. Yet here we are, talking about it still. I don't think he got the -- the job done.
BRET BAIER: Mara?
MARA LIASSON: I think he went a long way to tamp this down. I think the president did something really unusual, and really interesting, in that press conference, which is, usually, he's very, very careful when he talks about race. It's always, kind of, on the one hand; on the other hand. He, kind of, rises above the conflict, puts thing into a context, kind of abstract.
This was very personal. And he reacted, I think, very viscerally. This was a friend of his. He thought the police department shouldn't have arrested him; they acted stupidly. It was really like, almost -- you know, it sounded like a real heartfelt sentiment.
BAIER: And Gibbs said they did prepare for that question.
LIASSON: Yes, yes.
And then, you know, he talked to his advisers and his wife, and he saw the press conference, or he heard about the press conference, at least, from the Cambridge police, and he decided, I think rightly, that he needed to come out again and walk back the word "stupidly," which he did.
You know, he could have said "that was stupid of me to say stupidly."
He invited them both to the White House, which is a very Obama thing to do. That's the kind of thing we're used to. He's going to bring both sides together; there's going to be a teachable moment.
(UNKNOWN): Who's going to get taught?
(LAUGHTER)
LIASSON: You know what? Everybody since the initial incident, which Maureen Dowd, I think, rightly said was a mixture of race, class and testosterone -- I mean, everybody is trying to walk down, here. The policeman said he supports Obama 110 percent.
Everybody, I think, needs to climb down. As the president said in his briefing room comments, you know, "Everybody overreacted."
I think the big outcome of this is that this was supposed to be a week when the White House wanted to focus like a laser on health care, and nobody, as the president acknowledged, paid any attention to that.
BAIER: Bill?
BILL KRISTOL: You know, I think they should have taken Mara's -- the president should have called Mara instead of talking to Robert Gibbs and others.
And that's a very charming formulation you had, that the president could have said, you know, "That was a stupid thing for me to say." But he can't say that for some reason. You know, that would be too self-deprecating. And I think he is an arrogant man, and he feels entitled to pass judgment on Cambridge cops or on pediatricians who allegedly are referring people to get tonsillectomies, that the cops are stupid; they pediatricians, I suppose, are greedy and venal.
He feels entitled, as president of the United States, to stand up there and pass these judgments. One of them backfires politically, and he tries to walk it back -- oh, everyone should calm down; I'll have them for a beer at the White House.
He can't say that he said something stupid.
JUAN WILLIAMS: Well, he's going to have to walk it back some way. I mean, obviously, this is politically damaging to him.
BAIER: Even more?
WILLIAMS: Yes, I think there's -- I mean, they're going to have the meeting at the White House, I hear, this week, with Crowley and Gates. And it's just -- the issue's going to continue to boil.
And if you look at the poll numbers that are out, some initial poll numbers indicate -- I think it's, like, 26 percent of Americans think he handled it well. Overwhelmingly, there's been a negative response.
Now, in the black community, I think it's, like, high; 71 percent think that what he said was appropriate. But if you stop and think about this for a second, that means that about a third of black America thinks he didn't handle this well.
(LAUGHTER)
And that's, kind of, surprising because, as I can tell you as a black person sitting here, there's a lot of tension between black men and police. And people are, sort of, instinctively given to the idea that, you know, police can overreact quickly.
But in this situation, the president spoke without the facts. And so you can't have a teachable moment if it's based on a lie.
And what happened was the president reacted and spoke -- he spoke about things like racial profiling, and pointed out that he had acted on this as a state legislator.
But, you know what, this was not about racial profiling. This was about a guy breaking into his house. The neighbor appropriately calls the police, who come and respond to that. And once the police come, ask "Who are you," ask "Who else is in the house?" And then Professor Gates, according to the police report, begins to berate the officer, make demands on the officer, talk about his mother, and ask, "Do you know who I am? You don't know who you're dealing with," and continues this even after the president says that Gates is pulled out of his house. In fact, Gates pursues the officer out of his house. The officer, according to the police report -- I might add, there's a black policeman, a Hispanic policeman on the scene, and they corroborate this -- the officer pulls out his handcuffs and tells Gates to stop, and Gates pursues -- continues, persistently, to berate the officer.
Now, you tell me what -- is this an instance of, you know, a poor black kid being, you know, treated badly by a cop, you know, some some kind of police harassment?
No, I don't think so at all. And apparently the president wasn't aware of any of this when he spoke out.
BAIER: And Mr. Gates, in accepting the invitation for the beer, said he really hopes it helps, especially when it comes to the issue of racial profiling.
So you're saying it's going to continue even as this summit continues over the beer at the White House?
WILLIAMS: Well, you know what? It seems to me that, if you bring this issue up -- and this is so key. The president -- part of the president's appeal is that he is a racially healing force in our nation. I think a lot of people voted for him hoping, get us past this point.
Instead, he has injected himself in such a way -- he said he ratcheted it up. He has done such a -- such a disservice to us, in terms of racial understanding, here, that he has hurt the country at this moment and, I think, hurt himself.
HUME: It is testament to the American people's belief that racism is a bad and evil thing, that "racist" is such an insult, such a dirty word. It is really quite a terrible in contemporary America to be labeled a racist or thought a racist because the judgment against it is virtually unanimous. It is unacceptable behavior.
And it is -- unfortunately, that fact has placed into the hands of certain people a weapon. That word itself is a weapon. Note how quickly this professor was to hurl it at this police officer.
And his continued compliant that racial profiling, his insistence that racial profiling was involved here -- he continues to wield this weapon.
This is, as Juan correctly points out, the very kind of thing that one hoped that Barack Obama would get us past, and that the fact that this election would help to get us past.
But that -- as long as that word is hurled around willy-nilly, the way it seems to be, and freely as it is used indiscriminately and unwisely as it was in this case, I think we have a way to go.
—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Ouch...
July 27, 2009 - 09:28 ET by superconThe best zingers are always true.
Glad to see Brit again.
" if Republicans are able to stop Barack Obama on health care, 'it will be his Waterloo, it will break him...." -Sen. Jim DeMint
Yes, now if they could just
July 27, 2009 - 09:30 ET by nolotrippenYes, now if they could just get this worked up about the Democrats (and some Repubs) robbing us blind and turning us into a socialist paradise.
he tried to manipulate
July 27, 2009 - 09:38 ET by larry on LIthe facts into a "teaching moment" and failed miserably, however he was successful in drawing attention to his biases.
Opening the Gates
July 27, 2009 - 15:29 ET by LynnThanks, Obama, for opening the race can of worms even wider.
You fraud, you don't have the gift of gab without your teleprompter. Your followers are having their illusions shattered as they learn that your "competence was only a pose."
By the way, I think that question was pre-arranged.
Gotta love Juan-And Crowley is stupid for going to the WH
July 27, 2009 - 10:07 ET by political mavenIt implies he has something to patch up. He did nothing wrong. For them both to go and "iron it out" implies moral equivalence.
Barry and Gates should go to Crowley and appologize~!
Gates is the Racist, Barry is the racist, THEY profiled, by assuming that a white cop is automatically motivated by race!
Who and what needs teaching here?
July 27, 2009 - 10:32 ET by Chris NormanFar better and more just that Gates be sent to a seminar teaching that it's a citizen's duty and a good idea to obey the reasonable orders of a police officer.
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
Crowley going to WH
July 27, 2009 - 10:39 ET by SickofLibsIf I were him, the only way I'd go is if a neutral third party (ha!) taped it and also provided a transcript of the conversation. Gates is not going to back down one inch.
Otherwise, Crowley is just foolishly playing into Obama's screenplay - the one where he comes out portrayed as the wise King Solomon and the omnipotent transcender of race, instead of the jerk who was spraying charcoal lighter onto to an already-lit fire.
If It Was Me...
July 27, 2009 - 11:13 ET by Wildcatter1980...I would refuse the invitation unless and until the President issued a nationally-published formal written apology for his appalling comments during his presser last week.
And, it would serve the President right because the apology demand would be the very same tactics he used as a "community organizer", only used against him instead of by him.
--
We already have term limits. They are called elections. We can & should vote out those who do not represent & serve us! - Me
Perfect
July 27, 2009 - 12:20 ET by BlondeAbsolutely perfect.
Bravo!
I hope he fails, too.
Nah a secretly taped
July 27, 2009 - 20:35 ET by Dan The Man 2Nah a secretly taped conversation is the best. But, it may be impossible. I say Crowley should say let a full recording of the tapes out and let that be my statement.
Juan amazingly has one leg out of the tank on this one
July 27, 2009 - 10:24 ET by StarAZJuan said someplace he told his kids to be polite to cops. Good idea. We have plenty of cop interaction in Joe Arpaio's Phoenix, and it does not pay to mention their moms, no matter what your skin tone. Jeez. Think about it. This is prudence, not some knuckling under, subservient thing--it's just smart. Juan says he lets them in to look in cupboards when his alarm goes off. I advise against that--say you will step out. And don't mention their mother.
Teaching moment here (for
July 27, 2009 - 10:39 ET by Ruths husband BenTeaching moment here (for us). Juan is obviously liberal and obviously a decent guy. We tend to forget that ideology does not always define a person's moral compass, sometimes it just describes where their sympathies/empathies lay.
Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. - Groucho
Personally I would not go to the White House
July 27, 2009 - 10:27 ET by sevans1956But if I was forced to go, I might pour my beer over the General Secretary...er President's head and say "Now THAT is acting stupidly!"
Seriously, I would want to look into Gates eyes and say "What set you off?" and "If I were black would you have treated me the same way?" and then "Why did you think yelling at me, would change my behavior?"
There is no excuse to act in the manner that Gates did. If he really was being hassled, his best recourse is stay calm and gather information for his lawyer.
But like I said, I would politely tell the President that I do not drink on the job.
Brit Hume
July 27, 2009 - 10:42 ET by maryerinBrit Hume is so well spoken! All of his points are absolutely correct. The term 'racist' is used way to frequently and way to flippantly.
The big print giveth, and the fine print taketh away.
Fulton
J. Sheen
If Crowley attends this
July 27, 2009 - 10:44 ET by ckc1227If Crowley attends this meeting at the White House, he'll no longer have my support on this issue. I'll just have to assume that he DID do something wrong.
Re Crowley
July 27, 2009 - 11:18 ET by slickwillie2001Maybe he can go, but he damn well better not apologize for anything. I don't see how the next 'burglary in progess' 911 call might be handled any differently.
At Cambridge press conference going on right now, City Manager says that CDs with audio recording of communications with Crowley and the 911 call will be distributed.
the cambridge commissioner of police was
July 27, 2009 - 12:05 ET by larry on LIquoted stating "a 'version' of the tapes will be released". should we expect an edited or complete version?
Nah -- he cannot NOT
July 27, 2009 - 11:15 ET by Jack BauerNah -- he cannot NOT attend. It would seem churlish -- and you can imagine what the state media would be saying about refusing to meet TWO black men.
I just think he should ask Clarence Thomas to attend with him.
Apparently Gates doesn't think Justice Thomas is black. That would be fun.
Call me cynical
July 27, 2009 - 11:24 ET by Paul Atreidesbut I have a suspicion that, lo and behold, somehow some dates would get "mixed up" and the Congressional Barack Caucus would show up at the same time and they would all play a game of Pin the Blame on The Honkey.
~OMO!!
July 27, 2009 - 12:50 ET by choselife3xPin the Blame on The Honkey.
That is so far beyond funny I don't think there's a word for it. Thank you, sir.
That high-pitched scream you hear is the troll under my heel.
July 27, 2009 - 10:50 ET by jessieHApologizing for what? For sending food, medicine, & equipment to help the people of other nations? Get this self serving ass out of my face! WE, the People, have nothing to to apologize for, except for our elected officials. I think it's treasonous for obama to bad mouth our country. Who the hell does he think he is? Last time I looked, WE didn't have a king. All WE have is an egotistical, holier than thou, pompas ass........
When has the likes of
July 27, 2009 - 11:43 ET by Paul AtreidesJesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, or Henry Louis Gates ever done anything for black people in Africa? I remember seeing Princess Diana, Audrey Hepburn, and Mother Teresa over there handing out food and aid. The last I heard, there weren't black.
That's because Obama can do
July 27, 2009 - 10:55 ET by wiwfThat's because Obama can do no wrong, Brit!
The Rocky Mountain Collegian: Illustrating Idiocy
The President Does Not Think He Is Wrong About This
July 27, 2009 - 10:57 ET by Wildcatter1980The reality is that President Obama does not think he has anything to apologize for. The President truly believes the Cambridge Police officers exercised race-based judgment on the "distinguished" black Professor Gates.
What belied the President in this was his level of animation when answering the question with regard to Gates' arrest. That Gibbs revealed the President was prepared for this question only further cements the reality that he believes what he said during the presser is true.
It appears to me that President Obama spent much time listening to his preacher--Rev. Wright--as well as Ayers and the other radicals he associated with over the years.
--
We already have term limits. They are called elections. We can & should vote out those who do not represent & serve us! - Me
The President
July 27, 2009 - 11:10 ET by rpeeler42Say what will, but President George W. Bush had humility. Our current President thinks he is infallible. He surrounds himself with a..kissers and brownnosers.
He cannot admit to any error, no matter how small.
If I wanted to live in a socialist country I would move to Europe or China. This President is a disaster. He does not have a clue what makes this country great.
They tried to Lynch a Decent Cop...
July 27, 2009 - 11:36 ET by AMR1960It needs to be said, so I'm gonna say it...
Privileged esteemed idiots like Gates exist, Because of Black...Chicano...Asian Studies programs in our Universities. Like a dagger next to society's belly waiting for the next "Teaching Moment" to slice into and wound society; bleeding and weakening us ALL. Gates is a parasite and like one He advances His personal agenda AT the Expense of society in general.
What was started (Race Studies) with the best of intentions, has mutated into a cesspool of racial intolerance and divisiveness. It's rally cry is, Get Whitey! How else can you explain: Gates, the MEDIA & even MY PRESIDENT, out there with initial statements that were in essence a 'Rope' ready to Lynch this Police Officer, for the Bad Behavior of Gates, a self-indulgent & privileged member of the our societal elite.
The road to hell is truly paved with good intentions...
_____________________
Long Live...THE REPUBLIC !
Scum
July 27, 2009 - 11:17 ET by cvgbuckeyeYou can bet the farm that as we speak, all the media is out there frantically scrambling around to dig up any dirt they can find about Sergeant Crowley.
"This just won't do" they are muttering. "No one is going to disparage two of ours, our Messiah and one of our racist black professors. NO NO, this just won't do".
"I know there is some dirt somewhere on this guy, or maybe one of his relatives, or maybe his dog".
It's a good thing
July 27, 2009 - 11:20 ET by Paul Atreidesthat the officer had the presence of mind to have Henry Louis Hates step outside in front of all of those witnesses; there is no telling what all mud he could have made stick to the officer if there was no one around to dispute it other than the officer.
Gates incident...
July 27, 2009 - 12:04 ET by Georgia GirlBrit's comments ring true. And I think it's very telling that Juan Williams is the one who is most vocal and visibly upset about Obama's poor reaction to this incident. Juan has always struck me as a guy who says it like he sees it, and you can just see the disappointment on his face. He seems really upset that Obama's "us vs. them" mentality on race will do more to harm the nation than anything else. Obama's stubbornness on apologizing is revealing & does not surprise me.
Two People I love to hear
July 27, 2009 - 11:34 ET by Airforce_5_OBrit Hume and Charles Krauthammer. When Brit still had his show they both nailed it on the issues.
Brit is right: It is testament to the American people's belief that racism is a bad and evil thing, that "racist" is such an insult, such a dirty word. It is really quite a terrible in contemporary America to be labeled a racist or thought a racist because the judgment against it is virtually unanimous. It is unacceptable behavior.
And it is -- unfortunately, that fact has placed into the hands of certain people a weapon. That word itself is a weapon. Note how quickly this professor was to hurl it at this police officer.
And his continued compliant that racial profiling, his insistence that racial profiling was involved here -- he continues to wield this weapon.
Now Crowley needs to stay in Cambridge and let Gates and Obama have their little hug and squeeze by themselves.
"Obama lied, transparency died!" Michelle Malkin
Gates is no Borat
July 27, 2009 - 12:25 ET by ZuccoZoidGates was arrested for DISORDERLY CONDUCT, and the pic of him with his big mouth open yelling and screaming doesn't help his case of "discrimination" -
Here's the definition: http://www.answers.c...
Gates is a "professor of racism" - nice opportunity to show the world, but Gates, you're no Borat.
Gates - so well studied in "race relations" (nice elite position!) demonstrates wisdom by mouthing off at a cop trying to protect his own home.
BTW, how's that documentary coming along?
I don't know why we as a
July 27, 2009 - 11:41 ET by RR GOPI don't know why we as a society keep skirting around this...makes us feel better about ourselves I suppose. Part of the Sheeple Complex maybe.
Most of these black folk despise whites. Don't know why we insist on pretending they want to hold hands with us and sing songs around the campfire. I don't think most of us whites really care about them one way or another-they can sink or swim on their own merits like the rest of us. We're not out to get them. But, that's not what many of them want to hear.
So when they mouth their racist BS we just sit back and take it. Don't want any trouble. Don't want to make waves. Don't want to have other white people going 'tsk tsk' and saying something about your hood or your burning cross so they can feel superior and above the fray.
One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 61% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory (yep...approval for Congress now at 39%...do you believe that!?).
Sweet
July 27, 2009 - 13:06 ET by Ruths husband BenSweet. "As always, whitey now sits in judgment of me,
preparing to cast my fate. It is your decision either to let me blow
with the wind as a nonentity or to encourage the development of self.
Allow me to prove myself." - Louis Gates in his Yale admission letter. (Can you find the racist in the Oval Beer Garden?)
Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. - Groucho
Oh,...
July 27, 2009 - 13:08 ET by Ruths husband BenAlmost forgot: I vote for the "blowing in the wind" option.
Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. - Groucho
I read the Yale link
July 27, 2009 - 14:23 ET by ZuccoZoidGates is from a different generation: he may indeed have suffered indignities in earlier years, but where is the wisdom? Clearly he's learned nothing except how to profiteer from racism - and it sure looks like he sought to exploit that with his embarrassing public display.
This so-called "teacher" taught a lot of young people the wrong lesson. He should be stripped of his tenure [never happen, I know] and concerned parents should check out Gates' agenda more thoroughly.
And here comes THE SPIN, damage control by AP:"An Intellectual Drawn Into the Arena" - yep, he's a victim:
http://www.wtop.com/...
I find it interesting that
July 27, 2009 - 13:35 ET by HelenSI find it interesting that this Gates person had previously declared his intention of making a documentary on racism. But then he hit a snag: no racial incidents he could personally attest to. So, no problem, he orchestrates a "racial" incident and totally over-reacts and gets all hysterical and loud. Only to end up being the jackass in his own story. Everyone else was trying to do their job, behaving professionally and with dignity.
I don't know how anyone can fall for this fraud ...oh wait, we have another fraud that 52% of the population bought, hook line and sinker, so this old blow-hard shouldn't really surprise me.
But as Rush said, no one hit Gates, no one shot him, no one hurt him. How bitterly disappointing to him that his carefully set-up incident proved to be so banal - with himself as the idiot in the mix.
Me - "The libs/dems of today are the Quislings of former years - the cowards who would vote a fraud into office in exchange for handouts from the devil."
Will best buds, Obama + Gates, double team Crowley at WH?
July 27, 2009 - 13:49 ET by ekslibMara said, "This was very personal. And he reacted, I think, very viscerally. This was a friend of his."- end quote
Yes, Mara.
Obama and Gates are best buds, who plan to share a beer with Crowley at the White House.
1) Shouldn't they meet with Crowley in a neutral place, rather than at the home of Gates' most powerful friend?
How about meeting at a hamburger joint?
2) Does Crowley get to bring along a best bud, or will he be double teamed by Obama and Gates?
Comin apart at the seams
July 27, 2009 - 14:03 ET by hughglassIf you want to understand the degree to which the impending collapse of the obamatuer hour has got left pundits in a panic, look no further than Mara. She, along with Juan have always been my favorite (read sane and usually reasonable) liberals. Over the years, on the all stars, she has frequently made sense and brought something to the intellectual discourse. Now, as she scrambles to defend the indefensible, she is turning into a blithering idiot! With each, almost daily gaffe, Mara tries to defend the idiot in the WH and sinks deeper and deeper into the black hole of partisan nonsense. Sad. I wonder how long smart folks on the left will continue to sell their intellectual souls to pretend to make sense of Bozo's lunacy.
hughglass...
July 27, 2009 - 14:53 ET by Georgia GirlI noticed the same thing about Mara. She was really on the defensive and looked ... well, irritated. She usually is calm and good-natured, like nothing gets to her. The tension between her and Brit during this topic was intense. By the time the entire panel was done talking about it, I felt uncomfortably embarrassed for her. She just kept sticking to her ineffective talking points, even though all of them were thoroughly and intelligently refuted -- and when Juan got done describing the incident in detail and applying sound reason to it, I thought: "Mara has nowhere to go. She will be forced to back down."
But she didn't, and I realized she has it. The disease. The "I-am-looking-the-other-way-even-in-the-face-of-fact-and-reason-and-sticking-to-my-nonsensical-talking-points-because-I-have-no-recourse"-itis.
And the more people have to do this for Obama, the more irritated they get and more dim they seem.