Milbank and HuffPoster Heatedly Debate Press Conference Plants

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

As NewsBusters' Tim Graham reported, the Obama administration planted Huffington Post blogger Nico Pitney to ask a question at Tuesday's press conference.

The following day, the Washington Post's Dana Milbank also took the White House to task for this shameful episode. 

On Sunday's "Reliable Sources," Milbank and Pitney had a rather heated debate about what transpired that included, according to Pitney, the WaPoer calling him a "d**k" (video embedded below the fold with transcript):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

HOWARD KURTZ, HOST: A presidential news conference usually proceeds from the AP reporter, to the network correspondents, to the major newspaper writers. But President Obama set off plenty of chatter at this week's presser by giving the second question to a "Huffington Post" blogger. It wasn't just the selection of Nico Pitney -- Obama has called on "The Huffington Post" before -- but the way the president seemed to invite a particular question.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

OBAMA: Nico, I know that you and across the Internet we've been seeing a lo of reports coming directly out of Iran. I know that there may actually be questions from people in Iran who are communicating through the Internet.

Do you have a question?

NICO PITNEY, HUFFINGTON POST: Yes, I did. But I wanted to use this opportunity to ask you a question directly from an Iranian.

"Under which conditions would you accept the election of Ahmadinejad..."

(END VIDEO CLIP)

KURTZ: All right.

Nico Pitney, you said the White House notified you that you would probably get a question at the news conference. Everyone assumes what we just saw was orchestrated.

PITNEY: No. From beginning to end, there was no planning involved. I was the one who posted that I was going to be soliciting -- that I was soliciting questions from Iranians. I chose the question.

The reason President Obama made that comment is because he was trying to make a point that he was taking a question from an Iranian. And it's interesting that Dana, of all people, wrote this column very negatively. I mean, this is a person, Dana, who, when he had a chance to ask Obama a question, he approached him in the hall during the campaign and asked him not one, but multiple questions about how he looked in a bathing suit.

I mean, that to me is pathetic, and I would -- you couldn't stage manage me into that, Dana.

DANA MILBANK, WASHINGTON POST: Well, Nico has some -- evidently, some very interesting things to do.

What I have never done in my life, Howie, is worked in collusion with an administration, whether it's this one or another one. I believe that whether it's Nico Pitney, with "The Huffington Post," or whether it's Carl Cameron, with Fox News, the White House should not be calling somebody the night before saying, we are going to call on you if you ask a question on a particular subject asked in a certain way.

PITNEY: But I was...

MILBANK: Nico, the night before, sent out an e-mail to his colleagues -- "Some big news. The White House called earlier this evening and asked if I could ask a question of President Obama at his press conference tomorrow on behalf of an Iranian. I'm about to post a solicitation to the blog Facebook, Twitter, et cetera. It seems fairly like that this will happen, but as they told me, this is not 100 percent."

PITNEY: This is exactly as I described it. I posted an initial solicitation.

MILBANK: At the request of the White House.

PITNEY: No.

MILBANK: No, it says right here in your e-mail that that's what you did.

PITNEY: No, it doesn't. In fact, it's exactly what I wrote...

MILBANK: "I'm about to post a solicitation to the blog Facebook, Twitter," after hearing from the White House.

PITNEY: Facebook, Twitter, exactly. So, my solicitation was merely over e-mail.

When I found out that the White House was going to potentially take this question, I went to a Farsi language social network site, to Twitter using a Farsi message, to Facebook. I tried to -- if I was going to have that opportunity, I was going to canvass as many Iranians as possible.

MILBANK: That's fine.

PITNEY: So it is -- and, you know, for -- this is someone -- Dana's column...

KURTZ: Do you think there's some jealousy involved by maybe the establishment in the fact that you got that very prominent second question?

PITNEY: Oh, I mean, I think it's jealousy. I think it's hypocrisy.

You know, Dana wrote a column, as his colleague at "The Washington Post," Greg Sargent, pointed out, hailing the "Mission Accomplished" banner moment in May, 2003, the day after.

MILBANK: What?

PITNEY: I mean, it's...

MILBANK: Look, there's plenty of fiction here, but I brought some other -- shall we go through the record here, Nico?

PITNEY: Go through what record? MILBANK: Your Web site was complaining about I was not holding the Bush White House to account. I'd like to say that here's a full list of documentation of me holding the Bush White House to account.

PITNEY: Well, I'm not sure where...

MILBANK: Your colleagues at "The Huffington Post."

Let's pose -- can we just pose one question, Nico? If the White House called up Fox News and said, "Major Garrett, we will call on you tomorrow if you ask a question about health care, and you ask it in a certain way?" Would you say that's OK?

PITNEY: They didn't say in a certain way. See, this is dishonest. And it's been dishonesty and errors from the beginning.

Your initial piece on this posted an hour after the press conference, had two errors, which you acknowledged to me an e-mail. You said you had corrected them. It took seven hours.

MILBANK: Is that right, Nico?

PITNEY: And the signal is you are very quick to malign and very slow to correct.

MILBANK: Look, Howie, I can't deal with fiction on this show. I mean...

KURTZ: All right. I'm going to -- you two are going to have to take this outside, because I want to get Amanda Carpenter in.

As an interesting sidebar, Pitney is claiming Milbank called him a d**k.

As a result, this story is likely far from over...stay tuned.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I had a blast watching

I had a blast watching these two leftists go at each other today...I'm telling you it was the most fun I've had in quite awhile when it comes to something like this...

Dana baby's question about Fox and Garrett was great...what would have been better yet though if he had asked if it had been Pres. Bush calling on a blogger from NBs, Freepers or Redstate etc that was set-up by the WH in the first place.

Nevertheless...I still couldn't help but get a kick out of the back and forth with these two leftist Twits.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

Proof...

some animals eat their own! No offense ladies, but it was like watching a valley girl fight. Two hissy fits in one.

Like ya jdly.... ....None

Like ya jdly....

....None taken....it's sooo like cool.

You're right...they were.   ;-)

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

Like...

... gag me with a spoon.

it was like watching a

it was like watching a valley girl fight. Two hissy fits in one. 

And I'll bet Howie had to end the segment because they both threw their skirts up over their heads.....

I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows.  -Bart Simpson

 

Is there a cookie cutter mold out there?

That they create these obnoxious lefty blog guys from.  This Nico db is indistinguishable from losers like Markos and dozens of other 30 something liberal blogger a-holes.

Arrogance is such an ugly

Arrogance is such an ugly thing...it clouds your vision and makes you argue from a really stupid point of view. The media is this county should be dismantled and restarted from "j" school forward.

Is it just me--is this a gay romance gone wrong?

The pretty man-child with the Audrey Hepburn eyes, the older guy trying to touch him...

2 gays having a hissy fit.

2 gays having a hissy fit.

Very Oscar Wilde

and Dorian Gray.

Something I haven't heard yet

The White House solicited Pitney to ask a question. Why?

Logic suggests they wanted Pitney to ask a question for some reason. How's this for a possibility? They wanted Pitney to tell them the question before the press conference.

  • It may be true that the White House didn't give Pitney the question. Pitney may have chosen it on his own.
  • But it's still possible that after Pitney decided on the question, he informed the White House what his question was going to be.
  • That would have given Obama and his staff time to prepare an answer.
  • And as they said, Obama dodged the question, but without the usual stammers.

After all, why would the White House pick on this particular guy? It's not like he's trying to woo the Huffington Post to his side; they pledged their soul to him long ago. So why turn to this guy, of all people? They wanted something.

tool

A propaganda tool to hear a message to a successful dodge? If that is true, then the dodge is what is important for someone to hear. 

Listening carefully we hear a speech that seems to support the cause of the Iranian people while implying the US will do nothing. Both the dictator and the people can take what they want from the message and feel positive even though it means nothing. It's a staged opportunity to look good, unless you see through the hollowness of it.

Watch it again and note his eyes periodically return to the podium! He glances down from time to time to get his exact points. I'll bet the actual answer is there in some form.

 

He has already failed... his country.

Suprise

Wow, what a surprise. Before reading Noel’s sidebar comment I had assumed Nico was a girls name.

I think

it goes either way (forgive the pun) as a nickname for Nicholas or Nichole.

 

"If everyone is thinking alike, someone isn't thinking." - General George Patton Jr

Too bad Dana wasn't geared

Too bad Dana wasn't geared up in his other garb....his manly look, he may have had better luck!

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

So this Huffie, in full

So this Huffie, in full denial mode, is addressed in the press conference -

"You had a question?" 

And he responds

"Yes, but..."

Then he proceeds to talk about another question he has from an Iranian.  So he had two questions?  Which one was the one the WH wanted him to ask, his or the Iranians?

Confusing to say the least.

 

Gotta side with Milbank on this one

Pitney sure looks and acts like a d**k.

So the liberal is

So the liberal is confronted with hard evidence to disprove his lies and comes out sounding like Porky Pig, well I uh well uh....

To CNN:  any question the president asks you to ask at a press conference is not a legitimate question.  The legitimate question is why do you want us to ask that question?

They are attacking each

They are attacking each other.  I love it.  Where is your orange hunting vest and hat Dana?  What an jerk Milbank is.  He got a real ??$A$$ kicking on this one. I love it, two liberals arguing over which is the truest liberal.

did you hear nico at end of video say set up question?

Did I hear Nico say at end of video that that it would have been a strange conspiracy for the president to dodge a set up question or something like that? He just busted himself on the question being a set up. Am I wrong?

No

There was an "if" that was spoken over.

Too bad Pitney couldn't control his infatuation. He could have simply passed this as "Hey, going 2 teh presser tmrw & 1drd if Iranians had ?s for Prsdnt." But, alas, he had to tell all his friends of the Obamalove he was gonna get. Sad, sad man.