Media Ignore EPA Suppressing Skeptical Global Warming Report

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

The day before the House was to vote on a controversial energy bill destined to be the largest tax hike in American history, it was revealed that the Environmental Protection Agency had suppressed an internal report challenging the entire global warming myth.

Despite the importance of this study, and how it related to a debate about to ensue on the House floor, its existence and suppression went almost completely ignored by America's media.

This, of course, comes in stark contrast to regular and frequent news reports in previous years accusing the Bush White House of intentionally censoring the science of climate change.

Making matters worse, the media have no excuse for this current oversight for several House members held a press conference about this issue early Thursday afternoon (h/t NBer Joseph Johnson):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

REPRESENTATIVE JOE BARTON (R-TEX.): Well, good afternoon. I'm Congressman Joe Barton the ranking Republican on the Energy and Commerce Committee, and we're here today on a very serious matter.

We have the Obama administration, which was put into office on the pledge and the promise of openness and transparency and full disclosure and a new change in government. And one of their biggest issues is the issue of climate change and whether we should move a massive reorganization of our entire economy because of CO2 emissions.

In order to move forward, the EPA administrator had to find an endangerment finding, which is a legal term meaning the EPA administrator had to declare that there was an endangerment to human health, and, therefore, we needed to regulate this substance -- in this case, CO2.

There is a group within the EPA that's tasked with doing some of the economic and environmental analysis. And a career scientist in that group prepared an extensive report, close to 100 pages in length, in which he found that there were very serious concerns about going forward with the finding of endangerment. And that's the substance of this press conference, is how that report was suppressed, censored, prevented from going through the review process.

Also in attendance at the press conference which took place at 12:32 PM EDT Thursday were Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-Wisc.), Rep. Mike Pence (R-Ind.), Rep Greg Walden (R-Ore.), Rep. John Shadegg (R-Ariz.), Rep. Steve Scalise (R-LA), Rep. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.), and Rep. John Fleming (R-Louis.).

Yet, despite this press conference, and the significance of this revelation just before a key House vote, LexisNexis identified not one television news report on this subject.

Not one.

As for the print media, at 11:09 PM EDT, hours after Friday's vote, CBSNews.com published this piece at its Political Hotsheet blog:

The Environmental Protection Agency may have suppressed an internal report that was skeptical of claims about global warming, including whether carbon dioxide must be strictly regulated by the federal government, according to a series of newly disclosed e-mail messages.

Less than two weeks before the agency formally submitted its pro-regulation recommendation to the White House, an EPA center director quashed a 98-page report that warned against making hasty "decisions based on a scientific hypothesis that does not appear to explain most of the available data."

The EPA official, Al McGartland, said in an e-mail message to a staff researcher on March 17: "The administrator and the administration has decided to move forward... and your comments do not help the legal or policy case for this decision."

The e-mail correspondence raises questions about political interference in what was supposed to be a independent review process inside a federal agency -- and echoes criticisms of the EPA under the Bush administration, which was accused of suppressing a pro-climate change document.

Alan Carlin, the primary author of the 98-page EPA report, told CBSNews.com in a telephone interview on Friday that his boss, McGartland, was being pressured himself. "It was his view that he either lost his job or he got me working on something else," Carlin said. "That was obviously coming from higher levels." 

Bravo, CBSNews.com. But why not begin revealing this on Thursday evening and Friday morning BEFORE the House voted on the American Clean Energy and Security Act? And why not do it on television, hmmm?

As for major print media, the only article I could find on the subject was published some time on Friday by the New York Times. As this was a piece originally published Thursday by Environment and Energy Daily, it seems this only appeared at the Times website and not in its print edition.

And that's it.

One has to wonder why the suppression of such information by the EPA is suddenly not considered newsworthy given the media's fascination with what it consistently depicted as scientific censorship when George W. Bush was in the White House.

A Google search using the words "Bush censors science" produced 752,000 results. 752,000!!!

Such included this one published by ABCNews.com December 10, 2007:

House Democrats and Republicans traded rhetoric Monday over a new report claiming White House officials sought to suppress scientific views of global warming that clashed with Bush administration policies.

The report -- originally undertaken as a bipartisan effort -- leads to what the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee calls an "inescapable" conclusion that "the Bush administration has engaged in a systematic effort to manipulate climate change science and mislead policymakers and the public about the dangers of global warming."

Considering the 752,000 reports about Bush censoring science, it appears the news media don't mind aiding and abetting such suppression when it furthers their agenda.

Be afraid, America. Be very afraid.

*****Update: Power Line's John Hinderaker took the Obama administration to task for its behavior concerning this report --

If the Obama administration gets its way, Americans will not become aware of the scientific evidence: Obama's EPA suppressed the Carlin/Davidson report and tried to keep it secret for political reasons. The emails obtained by the CEI are revealing. [...]

Global warming zealots are a bit like Iran's mullahs. They are fanatically devoted to a series of false propositions. Unable to win an open scientific debate, they consistently resort to bullying and brute force to suppress their opposition. Once again, we see the Obama administration taking the lead in this regard, putting political ideology above scientific truth and demanding that all others do likewise.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Wasn't the Denier Fired

James Hanson is a "brave" hero, who attends rallies where laws are broken and who bravely fought against the evil Bush Administration which tried to supress his work.

The dissenting EPA employee   is a denier, undeserving of whistle blower status.

"Carlin was advised to get

"Carlin was advised to get an attorney--and has since been reassigned to mundane work, some of which is normally performed by outside contractors." Source

Limited Disclosure:  I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.

Suppressing Suppression

Suppressing the suppression story.

When?

When will the American people finally have enough? What will it take for them to realize that we have the most corrupt government in our nation's history? From the "stimulus" bills to this latest cap and tax fiasco, a small number greedy, ignorant, unpatriotic people are making fools of the rest of us. Our Constitution is being trashed. Ten percent (and rising) of our workers are jobless. Those who are working are becoming economic slaves. We no longer have a "representative republic". Congress doesn't even read the bills they are voting for. Is this some kind of bad joke? We are quickly losing the freedom upon which America was founded. Yes, "Be afraid, America. Be very afraid."

 

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

Are MSM Taking Payoffs?

At the point where one has to wonder if at least some members of the MSM aren't taking money.

I can understand that they are in love with Obama...what I can't see is how they continue to supress facts that the DNC doesn't want to see the light of day.

Have the MSM no obligation to their news consumers?

Is somebody paying them off?  I'm just askin'.

One of many paths to riches via our tax dollars

NBC is owned by GE,  GE makes lots of green stuff, Sales of green stuff shall go WAY UP, when this spending bill passes.

Invent a product , then pass a law, that you MUST have it...

It's getting COOLER umm so what, tear out that evil wood burning fireplace NOW!

Reagan VS Liberalism

Add in health care

 
I work in a hospital and GE is very vested in medical technology.  I'm sure health care "reform" will figure into that as well. Go figure.

Gary

I want my country back!

GE = Gravytrain E-ticket

The scuttlebutt has been that GE already has the inside track to develop and sell a standardized national Electronic Medical Records software.  This would represent a no-bid contract.

Combine this with GE's huge monetary support of Obama and the Dems in the election, near unwavering support for the Global Warming scam and "Greening of America" on their TV channels, their positioning of their consumer and industrial products towards this phoney GW paradigm, and continuing of defense contracts relationship, and you can see how Obama, the Dems, and GE are nearing an incestuous relationship with the medical software (and its complimentary mandatory hardware purchases, training contracts, service contracts and version upgrade contracts).

We're talking Dick Cheney "Big Time" money.  Actually, even bigger Big Time money.

(Just kidding about Cheney to humor the trolls.  I respect and like the man.  Wish his health were better so he could run for President.)

*

Glad for the latest

Glad for the latest up-dates above....great info., for me anyway.

Couldn't agree more about VP Cheney either strat....I've stated such sentiments also...Liz is going places....I love the gal, her knowledge, quick wit and how she handles the msm just as her parents do, and they cannot handle it, she is who they should really fear.

...I've posted Cheney/Cheney 2012 before...doing so again, just to irk the trolls myself.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

Liz Commands Respect

Don't tell anyone, but, I have a secret crush for Liz Cheney.  I can't help it - I like smart women.  :-)

The lady is going places.  I think the only obstacle for her is her own aspirations, and I don't think we've seen how high she can soar yet. 

I look forward to seeing her again on TV soon.  Not many political people I can say that about.

Cheney/Cheney 2012 - I like it!  Thanks for giving me a few moments of comfort away from the incessant National Asinine Man-Barry Love Association , AKA, NAMBLA.

→ strat

Liz is a conservative man's dream girl.

Under my plan of a cap & trade system, electricity rates would necessarily skyrocket - BHO

She is indeed,

She is indeed, Cool.

Unfortunately, Liz doesn't know I exist.  :-(

But that's a good thing.  I don't want to distract her from her duties with my Consevative manliness.   ;-)

The MSM

I believe the MSM are ideologues. An ideologue doesn't care about consequences for the common good.  An ideologue acts according his/her own selfish motives ( a la Barry Obama). Add to this that most of the MSM are immature, pooly educated, and emotionally challenged. They, like our public officials and our "educators, live in their own little bubble with no relationship to the real world. Yet they truly believe that they can tell others what to think and how to live. Nonethless, their "payoffs" come in the form of their getting rich by towing the party line. Sad.

 

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

Is this a bad dream or what?

Everyday the people that are supposed to be speaking truth to power (MSM - Mighty Stupid Media) seem to be asleep at the switch. I think they are so in love with Erkle Obama that they are afraid of reporting to the rest of us what these knuckleheads are doing. Yes America, be very afraid...

Is anyone surprised

that NOT reading a report is what congress does? I'll trade my 1993 Derek Jeter SP card to anyone who can account for 90% of the congress who has read the Bill, before it was voted on, including the 300 pages that were added hours before the vote was taken. Takers? Especially those cowards among us in the media (present company at NB excepted). 

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

jessieH          

jessieH              Corrupt people like the ones in office don't give a rat's a-s about US. WE need to change a law. "No person, running for, or holding office, or family member, can hold stock or bonds in any company or corporation, untill he/she has left office". This will eliminate about a 3rd. of the corruption in washington. " Nor shall they vote on any bill that would put money in their pocket". Only a patriot who has the best intrest in our country, would run for office. " The house & senate can not hold office no more than 2 terms". This would eliminate another 3rd. of corrupt slackers.

A wholesale house cleaning is required in Washington

I pray we can elect a conservative President in 2012 and give him or her a majority in Congress and the Senate of like-minded conservatives to reel in all the damage that has been done over the years and is currently being done.  I hope he or she will not give in to liberal name-calling and screaming and will have the cojones to do what needs to be done.. 

They will need to reduce the federal government by at least 40% and rid us of the EPA, DOE and pare back every single agency except military and intelligence.  Oh, a full investigation into ACORN, voter fraud, campaign fraud and, once and for all, where Obama was born!  If he is found to have been born in Kenya, I expect to see him behind bars along with those who covered for him!

Angry White Dude

www.angrywhitedude.c...

95% of those who call themselves "journalists"...

...are a disgrace to the profession.

Hypocrite Extraordinaire

Amazingly, Gavin Schmidt (official apologist of innumerable James Hansen propaganda gaffes) condones this practice of covering up information, just because he doesn't happen to agree with the science.

If I were the authors, I'd suppress this myself, and then go for a long hike on the Appalachian Trail….

We've seen that first hand.

We've seen that first hand. Though he was nice enough to admit I was correct. I was banned after pointing out one inconvenient fact. Ask Noel.

Gavin Schmidt is afraid to go anywhere he can't control what's said. 

Limited Disclosure:  I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.

A Burnt Child Dreads The Fire

Gavin Schmidt is afraid to go anywhere he can't control what's said

That's probably because two years ago he got caught playing with matches outside of his echo chamber. The result-he got badly burned!

Was that when he got his

Was that when he got his butt kicked by Richard Lindzen? Or am I thinking of another kicking.

That was a nice box of buttered popcorn night to watch that fight. Poor Gavin.

Limited Disclosure:  I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.

Administration Transparency

is easy to see. It's EVERYWHERE:

It's easy to see that the WH has no regard for the people of this country.

It's easy to see that the only thing that is happening in D.C. is that the American people are being abused.

It's easy to see that Obama, Reid and Pelosi are beholden to no one, except George Soros,  just political idealogue PACs.

It's plainly obvious that anyone or anything that poses a threat to the One's policies or plans shall be laid to waste, as written in "Rules for Radicals."

It's plain to see that soon enough Carlin and Davidson will be under the Obamabus, unemployed and destroyed by the media without their report being given any criticism, just them.

We can see through all of the WH rhetoric to see the forthcoming impoverishment that threatens to destroy this country.

We can see right through the nomination of Sonya Sotormayor and what her seat on the SCOTUS bench will do to years of established law.

We have to find a way to tear down the curtain of transparency and wipe the blind obedience from the MSM off the TV once and for all.

Transparency is see to see when you know it's there!

 

If you can read this, thank a teacher. If you can read it in English, You're welcome - Deskpilot, AM(H)1 (AW), USN (Ret)

Anyone who knows anything

Anyone who knows anything (truly knows and is not just drinking the kool aid) about global warming and this includes the Venerable Prophet Gore...knows that the ship is sinking fast as the cooling or leveling off occurs. The need to keep the fanatics whipped into a frenzy and suppress reports counter to designs is imperative as fortunes lay in the balance. Anything to stop this cash cow for a select few and economically disastrous for America cap and trade fiasco will be done. The corruption, greed and flat out stupidity of our current representation from the White House down is at unprecedented and downright criminal levels.

I don't know if I should be

I don't know if I should be running for office just to vote "no" on just about everything or if I should be hording ammo.

Not just Ammo. Gasoline,

Not just Ammo. Gasoline, generators, parts for your car, light bulbs, toilet paper to name a few. 

Even if you don't need they you can sell them on the black market. We'll be like cuba. All driving around in and rebuilding 20 year old cars.

Because the experts in washington know what you really need.

Limited Disclosure:  I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.

Carlin

The latest news is that Alan Carlin has been admitted for "observation" at St. Elizabeth's Hospital. His wife said he left for work and within a few hours his supervisor called to ask if he could copy some files Alan created on the home computer, saying Alan was tied up. Friends for years she agreed, but became suspicious when after the visit the computer hard drive disappeared. After a heated discussion when Alan failed to return for supper, she was told her husband attacked the cleaning lady, was sedated, then admitted. As yet the wife has been unable to visit Alan, but has talked to his doctor, Boris Yousindatanko, formerly with Moscow's Institute of Rehabilitation. More later.

Hey

This is an interesting post.  Do you have additional information? 

"If everyone is thinking alike, someone isn't thinking." - General George Patton Jr

Not one televison

Not one televison reporter....not one.

Btw...Thank you Fox.

We are so screwed....and more yet to come.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

Hey BT! Don't forget...

The motto of the looney left is simple: "Our minds are made up. Don't confuse us with the facts!"

"Who am us, anyway?" - Firesign Theatre

Boehner is Right, Of Course...

Obama claimed that the average American would not bear the brunt of this historic tax-increase: he stated that instead ““It is paid for by the polluters who currently emit dangerous carbon emissions.”

Just compare this outrageous falsehood to Ronald Reagans’ famous quote:

“The most dangerous myth is the demagoguery that business can be made to pay a larger share, thus relieving the individual. Politicians preaching this are either deliberately dishonest, or economically illiterate, and either one should scare us.

Business doesn’t pay taxes, and who better than business to make this message known? Only people pay taxes, and people pay as consumers every tax that is assessed against a business.”

And after the way the rammed this through the House with little debate, without legislators even reading it… and while quarantining the GOP from any meaningful input whatsoever, any foolhardy individuals who still believe Obama’s threadbare “bipartisanship” spiel ought to have their head examined.

http://reaganiterepublicanresistance.blogspot.com/

Calling Ben Stein

Time for a sequel to Expelled focusing on government agencies and NGOs.

We had better hope that the

We had better hope that the senate comes to whatever little senses it has and vote this hyrocarbon tax down. 

You think $4 a gallon for gasoline was high.  When it's all said and done, you'll be thinking of the days of $4 a gallon gas as the 'good 'ol days'.  Do these democrats actually think these petrochemical company's are just going to absorb these new cost of doing business? 

The big ones will drag up lock-stock and tower and head to a more amiable climate for business.  These company's don't hold alliegence to nations. They answer to stockholders and their votes. Only. It'll take a few years, but the number of refineries in this country is about to be shrunk down a good bit. Believe me, if they can find an area with access to shipping and rail's they'll be out of here.    

".....You think $4 a gallon

".....You think $4 a gallon for gasoline was high.  When it's all said and
done, you'll be thinking of the days of $4 a gallon gas as the 'good
'ol days'.  Do these democrats actually think these petrochemical
company's are just going to absorb these new cost of doing business?....."

If so, they're idiots.  If not, they simply don't care.  And MAKE NO MISTAKE, when gas prices do rise as you've mentioned, you will see every liberal in America demonizing the oil companies, and we'll likely see the oil company execs again called to DC for a dog-and-pony show.  I believe the Democrats know this about prices, and have this full-bore demonization plan just waiting in the wings.  Watch!

Weird "science"?

Wasn't Obama's administration supposed to be the one that was bringing back "science"? Sounds to me more like a faith-based initiative: despite the mounting evidence of the fraud of man-made global warming, Obama and his Congress are trying to give everyone in America a tax hike to help support his beliefs.

Mr. President, you and your buddy Al Gore can pay for your own "climate change" religion. We don't believe in it and we dang sure don't intend to foot the bill for it!

V5... If any of this

V5...

If any of this passes the Senate, we aren't going to have a choice.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

And not having a choice is

And not having a choice is the plan.  We give over more and more control to the government over every aspect of our lives.  Then the government decides who gets what resources etc. 

Thanks to everyone who voted for Obama.  Are you happy yet?  Or should I ask in another six months when we have high inflation and can only heat our homes to 60 degrees while the Oval Office thermostat is up to 85 degress.

RINO CAP AND TRADERS

John McHugh 23rd Ny was recently nominated t be Secy of Army.  i'm sure his vote on the POS Cap and Trade bill was merely coincidence!

 

CONGRESSIONAL TERM LIMITS!!!

"......For its part, the

"......For its part, the EPA sent CBSNews.com an e-mailed statement
saying: "Claims that this individual’s opinions were not considered or
studied are entirely false. This Administration and this EPA
Administrator are fully committed to openness, transparency and
science-based decision making.
....."

They seem to have left one out of the list..........creating our own definitions of openess, transparency, and science-based decision making.