Will Media Report Biden's Exaggerations About Obama's Record?

Photo of Noel Sheppard.

It certainly isn't surprising that Barack Obama and his surrogates are going to need to exaggerate his scant accomplishments in the Senate in order to create the appearance that he's actually qualified for the most important job in the world.

However, an impartial media should be at the ready to point out to viewers and readers whenever claims are made that clearly stretch the truth.

If press members had been listening closely to Joe Biden's speech in Denver Wednesday evening, as well as to what he has said since being tapped as Obama's running mate, they would have found several juicy misrepresentations.

A number of these were pointed out by former Bush advisor Karl Rove in an article published in Thursday's Weekly Standard (emphasis added, photo courtesy AP):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Saturday and again Wednesday night, Mr. Biden also praised Mr. Obama for three specific legislative accomplishments. One of them was an ethics bill, called by Mr. Biden in his acceptance speech "the most sweeping in a generation." However, many critics--including Hillary Clinton--criticized it as weak. [...]

Saturday, Mr. Biden asserted Mr. Obama "made his mark literally from day one, reaching across the aisle to pass legislation to secure the world's deadliest weapons," a claim similar to one Mr. Obama made earlier in the campaign. Wednesday night, Mr. Biden was more expansive, claiming Mr. Obama was a leader "to pass a law that helps keep nuclear weapons out of the hands of terrorists." This implied a big, important controversial measure, passed with difficulty after the intervention of an extraordinary leader.

In reality, the Lugar-Obama Bill was passed on a voice vote on December 11, 2006. It was so routine, there was no recorded vote. The media didn't consider it important or controversial. Neither the New York Times nor the Washington Post reported its Senate passage, though the Post ran a 798-word op-ed by Senators Lugar and Obama the week before it was approved. It was not the subject of a story on the CBS, ABC or NBC evening news--not when it passed, not when it was signed, not ever. [...]
Saturday, Biden proclaimed: "But I was proudest, I was proudest, when I watched him spontaneously focus the attention of the nation on the shameful neglect of America's wounded warriors at Walter Reed Army Hospital." The problem for Mr. Biden (and the object of his praise, Mr. Obama) is the problems at Walter Reed were revealed in articles in the Washington Post, starting February 18, 2007. Unless Mr. Obama writes for the Washington Post under the nom de media of Anne Hull or Dana Priest, he didn't "spontaneously focus the attention of the nation." The two reporters did. The legislation to correct the shortcomings emerged from a Senate committee Mr. Obama doesn't serve on and he played no significant role in drafting or pushing it through the legislative. Mr. Obama is not the real hero of the Walter Reed turn-around, despite Mr. Biden's extravagant claims.

To be sure, Obama's Senate record is so thin that such exaggerations are going to be necessary to convince voters that he really has the experience required for the most important job in the land. 

The question is whether Obama-loving media members are going to do their jobs by pointing out the over-statements or just allow Barack, Joe, and their surrogates to say anything they want with total impunity.

Stay tuned.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Same old song and dance from Joe Biden?

As I listened to Biden's speech last night when he
talked about riding the train and imagining how the
people who lived in the houses he passed lived their
lives, I couldn't help but wonder if he lifted it from
the movie "Shall We Dance."

Here is the trailer:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8W4IJJKYV9s

The trailer does shows Richard Gere riding the train, but the
full movie shows him being able to see into apartments
in Chicago as the L train passed by. He seems to be
thinking about their various lives.

 I think Biden may have committed plagiarism yet again.

Great

There is a commercial that has been out for a while that shows some guy giving this great advice about medical or legal or skydiving or something. There are several versions.

At the end someone asks, "Are you a master sky-diver"? He answers "No, but I did stay at a Holiday Inn last night". Could be some other hotel but you get the idea.

Woudn't it be great if some 527 took a snippet of Obama and dubbed in these words? It would be wonderful, I think.

"Stay tuned" How much

"Stay tuned"

How much longer, Noel? I've been standing by, for like two plus years now, and I'm getting hungry and need to go the bathroom....

McNotObama '08

Biden on McCain

Biden claims, even in his speech last night, to be John McCain's "true friend". Then he goes on to impune John's judgment in what I saw as a  vicious personal attack, replete with innuendos, exaggerations, and outright lies. McCain should simply come out and say, "With "friends" like Joe Biden, who needs enemies". He also should use my tag line, which is proved over and over to be so apropos...

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

I said yesterday that Obama

I said yesterday that Obama didn't choose Biden because he was experienced in foreign policy or he secured the electoral votes of Delaware. He was chosen because he is an unprincipled, loud mouthed, hatchet man.

McNotObama '08

hatchet man

Once Senator Biden's job is done do you think he will the fate of so many and fall victim to falling under the Obama Bus.  Then Senator Obama can replace Biden with someone more aligned with the Obama campaign message, like ---- Mao Xinyu.

I think Rush had the right

I think Rush had the right idea about why Biden: two words: white men.

And Obama's not worried about Delaware, but he thinks because Biden was born in Scranton, he can carry PA.

Oh, and about that "change" thing....<waving hand > Nevermind -Barack Obama

I got lucky and caught Rove

I got lucky and caught Rove on Fox this morning talking about all of this...while I was totally enjoying the outright exaggerations with the real facts pointed out by Rove, you can be sure the rest of the msm will conveniently skip pesky little things like the truth when it comes to their messiah.

Truth to power is only used when it serves their own purposes...and this isn't one of them.

The Chosen One is one big phony exaggeration in an empty suit...just a tall sock-puppet...nothing more.

Biden is just doing what he was hired to do, which he has always done so well...lie. 

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

in military terms...

FUBAR BS is DNC SOP

Journalism is the opium of the liberals

I've heard that Obama once

I've heard that Obama once noticed that there weren't any paper towels in one of the restrooms in the Senate.  He didn't pass the complaint to a subordinate, but called Building Services directly himself.  Within an hour a maintenance guy came and filled the dispenser.

There was another time when he lost a dollar in a candy machine.  He went back to his office, wrote a note of warning, and taped it to the coin slot to keep others from losing their money.

We need to give credit where credit is due.

Wow...

Finally, a post that shows he actually accomplished something. 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

45 Communist Goals for America http://www.nationmakers.com/com_goal

Ct ...but can we really

Ct

...but can we really trust this to be true?

Might be just a big exaggeration....ya' never know...

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Personally, I think he put

Personally, I think he put his initials on somebody else's note on the vending machine.

Exaggeration

As we say in Texas, "All hat, no cattle."

Oh, he has cattle. Right

Oh, he has cattle. Right now, a lot of them are corraled in an arena in Denver.

McNotObama '08

Cattle

I believe those are sheep.

Maybe the smell of BS

Maybe the smell of BS eminating from there threw me... 

McNotObama '08

Easy mistake.  It's Hillary

Easy mistake.  It's Hillary who's the one good with cattle.

sheeple

sheeple

Well, just as fast as

Well, just as fast as Michelle has found faith in the American dream, both Hillary and Biden are praising the Chosen one for his great leadership and experience. Funny, just 6 months ago he was "not going to ready on day one". Has anyone in the MSM challenged any of these people to explain themselves?

Confused.....

I am confused.  I watched the same speech as you all did.  I came away with the impression that Obama was always right.  (Like my wife)  And that McCain was always wrong wrong wrong wrong!!  (Like me)

 So how is it that Biden voted for the Iraq war?  And why if he did indeed vote for the Iraq war and tell BO and the rest of the world, that has a television (unlike BOs brother), that Saddam was an SOB and had WMDs that the whole world knew about or at least thought and agreed they knew he had, I wonder why that was not brought up in the speech or the commentary.  My guess is they forgot.  I could be wrong.  How is McCain wrong but Biden right?  How is McCain wrong about everything like the surge, but two lone stand outs, BO and Keith O, are right?

I'm just asking.

The MSM are so enamoured of Obama they will not be critical

They will do all in their power to get him elected, regardless of any qualifications that are sorely missing.

This will turn out to be a disaster for the US if he does in fact succeed in winning (or stealing) the election in November. Our enemies all over the world are salivating and grinning and wringing their hands in anticipation of the possibilities for the next 4 years.

 

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

Don't hold your breath for scutiny. Agenda far outweighs truth!

"The question is whether Obama-loving media members are going to do their jobs by pointing out the over-statements or just allow Barack, Joe, and their surrogates to say anything they want with total impunity."

Those who believe in nothing will believe anything.

Shocking Biden footage

Once this gets out, I don't think Obama's got a chance. 

Torches & Pitchforks

This election

If Obama becomes president, Al Gores plans will most likely come true... read this article..

http://newsbusters.o...

Isn't Al Gore's global warming crap fraud? If not, at what point does it become a crime?