Media Exhibit Cognitive Dissonance Over Global Warming

Photo of Noel Sheppard.

Psychologists define cognitive dissonance as the angst caused by possessing two conflicting thoughts at the same time.

According to prominent climate realist Philip Stott, this is the condition global warming obsessed media members are currently experiencing as a ten-year cooling trend -- clearly visible to all that can read a thermometer! -- refutes Nobel Laureate Al Gores's junk science concerning increased CO2 emissions causing rising temperatures.

As Stott wrote Tuesday (emphasis added throughout):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

I must ask a very serious and urgent question of our media. Why do you continue to talk glibly about current climate ‘warming’ when it is now widely acknowledged that there has been no ‘global warming’ for the last ten years, a cooling trend that many think may continue for at least another ten years? How can you talk of the climate ‘warming’ when, on the key measures, it isn’t? And now a leading Mexican scientist is even predicting that we may enter another ‘Little Ice Age’ - a ‘pequeña era de hielo’.

Such media behaviour exhibits a classic condition known as ‘cognitive dissonance’. This is experienced when belief in a grand narrative persists blindly even when the facts in the real world begin to contradict what the narrative is saying. Sadly, our media have come to have a vested interest in ‘global warming’, as have so many politicians and activists. They are terrified that the public may begin to question everything if climate is acknowledged, on air and in the press, not to be playing ball with their pet trope.

After discussing the cooling that has occurred since 1998, and some of the possible reasons, Stott continued to point to media's psychological malady:

So, why are newspapers, magazines, radio, and television not telling us all this? Because they have invested so much effort over the last ten years in hyping up the exact opposite. Moreover, it is especially pathetic sophistry to claim, as dedicated ‘global warmers’ are wont to do, that ‘natural forces’ are having the temerity to “suppress” ‘global warming’. The fundamental point has always been this: climate change is governed by hundreds of factors, or variables, and the very idea that we can manage climate change predictably by understanding and manipulating at the margins one politically-selected factor is as misguided as it gets. [...]

If this cooling phase really does persist, it will be illuminating to observe how long our media can maintain its befuddled state of ‘cognitive dissonance’.

To best exemplify the problem media are facing, one must go back to 1957 when cognitive dissonance was first proposed as a psychological affectation (forgive the Wiki citation, but it sums it up best):

Social psychologist Leon Festinger first proposed the theory in 1957 after the publication of his book When Prophecy Fails, observing the counterintuitive belief persistence of members of a UFO doomsday cult and their increased proselytization after the leader's prophecy failed. The failed message of Earth's destruction, purportedly sent by aliens to a woman in 1956, became a disconfirmed expectancy that increased dissonance between cognitions, thereby causing most members of the impromptu cult to lessen the dissonance by accepting a new prophecy: that the aliens had instead spared the planet for their sake.

Does that mean climate alarmists like Gore are going to continue to push this myth even if global temperatures continue to decline in the coming decades?

Well, if you had all of your money invested in this canard, wouldn't YOU do everything within your power to perpetuate the hysteria?

Yes, that's a rhetorical question, because most people reading this have scruples, unlike those that certainly know they're lying to the public for their own financial gain.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters.

Read commentsFree bias alerts

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I find myself getting more

I find myself getting more and more confused over this issue. I believe I have read posts by folks such as Popular Tech that Mars is getting hotter because the sun is heating up. Now I read that the earth is getting cooler. None of this makes any sense..I think I'll vote for Ron Paul.

mandrake, science always is ah changing... like the sun cycle

At one time the planets were heating up, as late as last 2006. Now the sun sun cycle is at a nosunspot zone; today.. More clouds, cooler weather ahead.

That's why FAY didn't become a # 5 hurricane...and the next 4 weeks are the maximum for storm strength.

Hope we do not get an early freeze.

plug the nose & vote for mc rino

Liberals62%


IranianUranium

Climate Change on other Planets

The point is that there is evidence of climate change on other planets which means the real source of climate change is the sun not CO2.

- Carbon Dioxide is 95.3% of the atmosphere of Mars (NASA)
- Average Temperature on Mars is -80°F (NASA)

- Carbon Dioxide is 0.038% of the atmosphere of Earth (NASA)
- Average Temperature on Earth is 57°F (NASA)

Jupiter - New Storm on Jupiter Hints at Climate Change (Space.com)
Jupiter - Researcher Predicts Global Climate Change On Jupiter As Planet's Spots Disappear (Science Daily)
Jupiter - Turbulent Storms May Be Sign Of Global Climate Change (Science Daily)
Mars - Climate Change Hits Mars (The Times, UK)
Mars - Evidence Of Climate Change, Icy Region Observed On Mars (Science Daily)
Mars - Evidence for Recent Climate Change on Mars (Malin Space Science Systems)
Mars - Global Warming Hits Mars Too (Mars Daily)
Mars - Mars Melt Hints at Solar, Not Human, Cause for Warming, Scientist Says (Khabibullo Abdusamatov, Ph.D. Astrophysicist)
Mars - NASA's Global Surveyor Sees Possible Climate Change On Mars (Science Daily)
Neptune - Suggestive correlations between the brightness of Neptune, solar variability, and Earth's temperature (AGU)
Neptune Moon Triton - MIT researcher finds evidence of global warming on Neptune's largest moon (MIT)
Pluto - Global Warming on Pluto Puzzles Scientists (Space.com)
Saturn - Hot shot of Saturn's 'hot spot' (BBC)
Saturn Moon Enceladus - Saturn moon delights and baffles (BBC)
Uranus - Hubble Discovers Dark Cloud In The Atmosphere Of Uranus (Science Daily)
Uranus - Planet Uranus rings the changes (BBC)

Unstoppable Solar Cycles (Video) (10min)

The Anti 'Man-Made' Global Warming Resource

it's not that confusing

Mandrake, the temperatures of several planets we watch (including Earth) heated up simultaneously up until about ten years ago (1998). At that time solar activity waned and the temperatures plateaued and then started downwards. The last year or so has seen the greatest amount of cooling (on Earth). Globally the temperatures dropped so hard we've just about wiped out a hundred years of increasing temperatures. If this winter goes as cold as the last one, that'll be it for "warming". We'll be at the global temperature of roughly the year 1850.

The AGW/CC hoax is politics, not science.

The "theory" of man-made global warming/climate change has been
disproven! Anyone that believes otherwise is a supporter of economic terrorism (or
just plain stupid). All the facts are here.

someone once said there's a

someone once said there's a sucker born every minute

that's alot of liberals 

Journalism is the opium of the liberals

there's a sucker born every minute

Hi TruthMonger, This story fits just right with the global warming lie!!   Pat

http://www.historybuff.com/library/refbarnum.html

  Isn't their excuse that

  Isn't their excuse that there was no credible evidence the reason they couldn't report on the john edwards affair?  They couldn't just report 'rumors' and 'theories'.

Translation

Here is the English translation of that article by the Mexican Scientist, Victor Manuel Velasco Herrera, according to Babel Fish:

They augur brief was of the ice in 2010 The global heating must include/understand another class of factors, like volcanos and the human action, but also external like the solar activity, says to Victor Velasco, of the Institute of Geophysical. An expert of the Independent National University of Mexico foretold that around ten Earth years he will enter a “small era of ice” that will last of 60 to 80 years and will be caused by the diminution of the solar activity. Victor Manuel Velasco Herrera, investigator of the Institute of Geophysical of the UNAM, maintained the previous thing during a conference that impartó of Sciences in center Applied and Technological Development. In the act, the specialist in systems of remote perception said that the recent breakage of the Argentine glacier Skillful Colored person, unusual by to have produced austral winter in the heat of, not had to the global heating. The event had, said, to a natural process brought about by the temperature and the precipitation of the river. Velasco Herrera described as erroneous the prognoses of the Intergovernmental Panel on Cambio Climático (IPCC), according to which the planet is undergoing a gradual increase of the temperature, the call global heating. The models and prognoses of the IPCC “are incorrect because they are based on mathematical models and only they present/display results in scenes that they do not include, for example, the solar activity”, also said specialistic in image processing and signal and prevention of natural disasters. The phenomenon of the climatic change, added, must include/understand another class of factors, internal, like volcanos and the own human activity, and external, like the solar activity. “Peculiarly, the star never it has been seen him like a heating but cooling agent, but it has papers both”, aimed. At present, it assured, the world lives a stage on transition where the solar activity falls considerably, “so, in two years approximately, there will be a small era of ice that will last of 60 to 80 years”, and the immediate consequence of it, added, will be the drought. The term that the investigator used already has been used previously to indicate cooling periods. In particular “Small age of the ice” exists the call, with which it is alluded to a cold period that lasted since the beginning of century XIV until half-full of the XIX. The analyses of the IPCC concluded that it was about regional phenomena or local accentuation; “the present evidence does not support synchronous periods of anomalous cold generally or heat in this temporary frame”, said its report of 2001. Velasco Herrera said in his conferecia that the glacier landslides are periodic events that even occur in winter, as it were the case of the Brown Expert. “The process begins when the formation, located in one of the arms of the Argentine Lake, advances until the end of the peninsula of Magallanes, covering the drainage routes”, indicated. When cutting itself the exit routes, the water raises of level 20 meters and, therefore, it exerts more pressure on the ice, “which culminates with the loosening of immense ice blocks, like happened the past the 9 of July”, explained. The Brown Expert, of about 200 squared kilometers, is in the mountain range of The $andes, between Argentina and Chile, and is one of few stable glaciers of the world. The front of the glacier measures about 2,8 kilometers in length and has a height of about 70 meters on the level of waters of the lake, although the ice wall arrives at his I milk. In the zone they are signals that the glacier, whose previous breakage took place in March of 2006, was much more extensive centuries ago. “In this century the glaciers increase”, as it is possible to be observed in the Mountain range of the $andes, with Brown Expert, Logan, the highest mountain of Canada, and with the Franza-Josef glacier, of New Zealand, Velasco Herrera said. Keys Dates The prognosis on the appearance of a new small Era of the Ice has uncertainty as far as its dates. Most recent, according to Victor Manuel Velasco, it could arrive approximately in two years. In another conference that he the past gave at the beginning of December, the same expert had said that cooling would arrive within 30 or 40 years. And at the beginning of July, Velasco Herrera said that the satelite data would indicate that global cooling period could even have begun already, from year 2005. Mexico. EFE

"The future is not set.  There is no fate but what we make for ourselves."

michaelyon-online.com

Global Warming Consensus

Don't you guys know there is a journalistic consensus on Global Warming? How better to advise us than egotistical journalists.

Check out this image of the

Check out this image of the sun, then check this site for recent sunspot activity.  These watermelons are due for a big letdown, sooner rather than later. 

 

"The future is not set.  There is no fate but what we make for ourselves."

michaelyon-online.com

Financila gain and of

Financila gain and of course political power...at all of our expense. 

Speaking of that...gosh we had over a hundred degrees here the last few days...now we'll have to start a fire in about three hours....I just love those global warming dips...especially in August.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Whether the Earth's mean temperature

Whether the Earth's mean temperature warms, cools, or remains stagnant, it will always be blamed on the actions of humans.

The very idea that man's activities have any affect whatsoever on the weather, temperature, or (lol) the phases of the moon is, and has always been, an absurdity. 

AGW, or whatever they may wind up calling it down the road, is nothing but a global income redistribution scheme.

It is a total and utter fraud, and I am now questioning the intellectual aptitude of anyone who still buys into it, to the point where I no-longer can even be civil to them.

Which is why I pretty much stay away from AGW related threads these days.

-Dave.

Question their intellectula aptitude

or their motives

Nortonalec

 

Norton...

Always! 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

45 Communist Goals for America http://www.nationmakers.com/com_goal

The whole Global

The whole Global Warming>CO2>Human Activity chain has always boiled down to one tenet: Man is the supreme intelligence. As such, he is the creator and destroyer of worlds. 

As with several other "scientific" endeavors, the goal is not so much enlightenment, but the desire to lock "God" out of the picture. CO2 is the only avenue to put Man in control. Solar activity and natural variation are out of man's hands. Hence, they are the providence of "gods".

Every other abuse of AGW theory results from opportunism.

               A gun in your hand beats a cop on the phone.

Noel, yeah but... How do

Noel, yeah but...

How do we fight it when we have the APA wanting to help brainwash the rest of us that still use common sense as a guide?

 

45 Communist Goals for America http://www.nationmakers.com/com_goals.htm

Making fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.w

If temperatures do

If temperatures do decrease, Algore will insist we are making progress thus proving we can lower temperatures through legislation and being green, but that won't be enough. It will get spun by the old media as progress, "but a lot more work" to be done.

And Yet They Wonder...

...why their readers and viewers disappear in droves, and why even CNN, the most trusted of the lot has a 70% disbelief rate.

Someday, I don't know when, there will be a great reckoning for all those who have drunk the MMCC kool-aid.  Rest assured that by the time it happens, the MSM will have thought through a set of excuses they can offer up to defend their behaviour.  I suspect that academia will be where the "great reckoning" will be felt the most harshly.  After all, for almost 15 years, lot's of research money has been siphoned from other, worthwhile research proposals to fund MMCC studies; careers have been made and destroyed; many have abandoned prized scholarly principles and ethics over MMCC.  When the dam bursts and the reckoning begins, I suspect it will be done with a vengeance in the ivy-covered halls of academe.


"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."

- Edmund Burke (1729 - 1797)

www.conservativeboot...

I have a feeling something

I have a feeling something different may happen...

Once the cooling is more obvious Algore and friends will take credit for it, and probably demand some payoff for their services.

iC... I wouldn't doubt it

iC...

I wouldn't doubt it one bit....

He would say he saved us all from the Planetary Emergency he warned us about....

With the talking heads spinning away for him.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

BT, IC, I have to

BT, IC,

I have to disagree with you both; there will be no credit to be had because there will be no pay-off.  If humans aren't influencing the climate through CO2 emissions from hydrocarbons then Gore makes no money on his carbon credit boondongle.  If the temperatures are decreasing their M.O. switches from 'global warming' to 'climate change'.

Also, is it me, or does it seem now that oil and gas prices (at the pumps that is) are coming down we are starting to see the ugly fake monster known as 'global warming/climate change' rearing its hideous head again??  The left must have a hierarchy of pet agendas to promote.  Big oil isn't directly in the gunsights anymore so 'warm up' the climate crisis stories again........

"Controlling carbon is a bureaucrat's dream. If you control carbon, you control life," Richard Lindzen - March 2007.

----

Once the cooling is more obvious Algore and friends will take credit for it 

They would have no basis to do so.  The theory of AGW, in addition to being wrong, is too specific for them to duck out or change their tune in the face of pesky things like facts. 

See, the greenhouse gases generated by man has caused and will continue to cause global temperatures to go up, up, up with no end in sight.

Except whoops, no, that's not what's happening.  Man's greenhouse gases have increased (because developing countries want silly things like heat, electricity and cars) but global temperatures have not.  They are now flat line from the 1800's, when global warming was supposed to have started.

So, if Al G and James H try to claim that they accomplished something, they will be ripping apart their own theory.

P.S.  Just one more time, Al, let's hear you say it:

"The planet has a fever"

Ahhh.

Noel, have you seen this on

Noel, have you seen this on Climate Corruption?

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/18/nyregion/18windmills.html?_r=2&oref=slogin&oref=slogin

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

45 Communist Goals for America http://www.nationmakers.com/com_goal

Great Article

Just a few excerpts:

“It really is renewable energy gone wrong,” said the Franklin County district attorney, Derek P. Champagne, who began a criminal inquiry into the Burke Town Board last spring and was quickly inundated with complaints from all over the state about the wind companies. Attorney General Andrew M. Cuomo agreed this year to take over the investigation.
The industry appears to be shying away from trying to erect the wind farms in more affluent areas downstate, even where the wind is plentiful, like Long Island.
But corruption is a major concern. In at least 12 counties, Mr. Champagne said, evidence has surfaced about possible conflicts of interest or improper influence.
Moreover, under a program begun in 2004, the state is entering into contracts to buy renewable energy credits, effectively subsidizing wind power until it can compete against power produced more cheaply from coal or natural gas.
...in June, Iberdrola S.A., which is based in Spain and is one of the world’s largest energy producers, announced its proposal to invest $2 billion to build hundreds more towers here.
“You’re talking about a poor farming community out here,” said Brent A. Trombly, a former town supervisor of Ellenburg, which approved a law to allow and establish regulations for the wind towers in 2003. “Our only natural resources are stone and wind.”

It's about the money.  It always has been.  Watermelons. 

 

"The future is not set.  There is no fate but what we make for ourselves."

michaelyon-online.com

In his blood to lie

Does that mean climate alarmists like Gore are going to continue to
push this myth even if global temperatures continue to decline in the
coming decades?

When asked in an interview about whether or not he was intentionally scaring people with exaggerated predictions in An Inconvenient Truth in order to motivate them, Gore replied

"Nobody is interested in solutions if they don't think there's a
problem. Given that starting point, I believe it is appropriate to have
an over-representation of factual presentations about how dangerous [AGW] is, as a predicate for opening up the audience to listen to what the solutions are..."

Sounds like he has a

Sounds like he has a promising second career selling vitamin supplements.

               A gun in your hand beats a cop on the phone.

Just for its and giggles

There must be, MUST BE  Somwhere, a few millionares who would consider gathering together, to form a new "mainstream"  cable news network, featuring a RIGHT way of thinking, all the time.

FOX is sometimes there, but here is a chance for someone to make Trillions...IMHO..

If Rush can do it, So can You! ...We...Us..

its and giggles, any thoughts?

JN... Couldn't agree

JN...

Couldn't agree more....it has been suggested my times before....I'm still waiting.

Like anyone knows it will take money...lot's and lot's of money as the song goes.... it would make back all and gain tons in the long run.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Thanks BT

  I Allways Apprieciate and look forward to reading your comments here. I cant tell you how many times!..

Why do every day peons not stand up for the right thing, and allow the evil to rule?

A new, cable channel, right leaning, is begging to RULE.

We are here..waiting for it!

I am aware of the FAIRNESS DOCTRIN. So...I will prolly go to my end without any fairness..

Shucks..But, I still think it can be done!

global warming -> climate change

After decades of the phrase "global warming," now all of a sudden it is referred to as "climate change" because the earth has cooled since 1998.  That's an inconvenient truth.

 

http://www.AlexaShrugged.com

It's a lie!

Common now, "...caused by possessing two conflicting thoughts at the same time." Now you expect me to believe libtards can actually possess two thoughts at the same time? Yeah. Sure. Since when?

;-))