Media Disgrace America, Israel and Themselves

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

Thursday May 15, 2008, American media hit a new low. To paraphrase Michelle Obama, I have never been less proud of my country.

On the occasion of Israel's 60th anniversary, President George W. Bush gave one of the greatest speeches of his career.

Yet, America's media could only see this event through the tiny prism of the upcoming presidential election, and thereby totally ignored virtually everything that was said by the most powerful man in the world to one of our nation's greatest allies.

From a speech that lasted over 20 minutes -- interrupted eight times by applause from Israeli Knesset members -- America's media exclusively reported 83 words they felt insulted the candidate for president they have been unashamedly supporting for over a year.

Everything else in the President's stirring and emotional address went completely ignored, so much so that the other 2,400 words were totally irrelevant, as was the signficance of the day and the moment.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The President spoke of the founding of Israel, and America being the first nation to recognize her independence.

American media didn't care.

The President spoke of the history of the Holy Land, and the miracle that was the creation of a democracy in the center of a region violently opposed to such a political structure.

American media didn't care.

The President spoke of "the matchless value of every man, woman, and child," how "democracy is the only way to ensure human rights," and the sad reality that "the United Nations routinely passes more human rights resolutions against the freest democracy in the Middle East than any other nation in the world."

American media didn't care.

The President spoke of religious liberty being "fundamental to a civilized society" while condemning anti-Semitism.

American media didn't care.

The President spoke of nations having "a right to defend themselves," "that no nation should ever be forced to negotiate with killers pledged to its destruction," and "that targeting innocent lives to achieve political objectives is always and everywhere wrong."

American media didn't care.

The President spoke of the fight against terror and extremism as being "the defining challenge of our time...a clash of visions, a great ideological struggle."

American media didn't care.

The President spoke of folks that "suggest if the United States would just break ties with Israel, all our problems in the Middle East would go away. This is a tired argument that buys into the propaganda of the enemies of peace, and America utterly rejects it."

American media didn't care.

The President spoke of freedom yielding peace, and how we "must stand with the reformers working to break the old patterns of tyranny and despair...give voice to millions of ordinary people who dream of a better life in a free society," and above all, "have faith in our values and ourselves and confidently pursue the expansion of liberty as the path to a peaceful future."

American media didn't care.

The President spoke of the Middle East 60 years in the future:

Israel will be celebrating the 120th anniversary as one of the world's great democracies, a secure and flourishing homeland for the Jewish people. The Palestinian people will have the homeland they have long dreamed of and deserved -- a democratic state that is governed by law, and respects human rights, and rejects terror. From Cairo to Riyadh to Baghdad and Beirut, people will live in free and independent societies, where a desire for peace is reinforced by ties of diplomacy and tourism and trade. Iran and Syria will be peaceful nations, with today's oppression a distant memory and where people are free to speak their minds and develop their God-given talents. Al Qaeda and Hezbollah and Hamas will be defeated, as Muslims across the region recognize the emptiness of the terrorists' vision and the injustice of their cause.

Overall, the Middle East will be characterized by a new period of tolerance and integration. And this doesn't mean that Israel and its neighbors will be best of friends. But when leaders across the region answer to their people, they will focus their energies on schools and jobs, not on rocket attacks and suicide bombings. With this change, Israel will open a new hopeful chapter in which its people can live a normal life, and the dream of Herzl and the founders of 1948 can be fully and finally realized.

This is a bold vision, and some will say it can never be achieved. But think about what we have witnessed in our own time. When Europe was destroying itself through total war and genocide, it was difficult to envision a continent that six decades later would be free and at peace. When Japanese pilots were flying suicide missions into American battleships, it seemed impossible that six decades later Japan would be a democracy, a lynchpin of security in Asia, and one of America's closest friends. And when waves of refugees arrived here in the desert with nothing, surrounded by hostile armies, it was almost unimaginable that Israel would grow into one of the freest and most successful nations on the earth.

Yet each one of these transformations took place. And a future of transformation is possible in the Middle East, so long as a new generation of leaders has the courage to defeat the enemies of freedom, to make the hard choices necessary for peace, and stand firm on the solid rock of universal values.

American media didn't care.

No, none of this was important to Obama-loving press members, who in an effort to frame the President's 2,500 words into a soundbite that would embarrass him while giving the junior senator from Illinois and fellow Democrats fodder to elucidate their foreign policy vision, ended up stealing this marvelous speech from the American people.

In so doing, our press disgraced our nation, our one true ally in the Middle East, and themselves.

As you ponder whether this is too harsh, consider how Agence France Presse reported this speech to its readers in an article entitled "Bush Basks in Israel's Love" (emphasis added):

Facing dismally low approval ratings at home, US President George W. Bush basked for three days in near-adulation as he joined Israel's 60th anniversary festivities.

Bush, who was to head on to Saudi Arabia on Friday, returned the favour, hailing the close US ally as a mighty democracy where liberty and justice thrive.

Just about every moment appeared to be devoted to mutual expressions of admiration and friendship, which also offered Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert a respite from the latest police graft investigation against him.

His speech to the Knesset, the Israeli parliament, drew him standing ovations and earned him ecstatic praise from right-wing parties.

The Jerusalem Post published a piece entitled "If Only Israel's Leaders Would Speak as Bush Did" (emphasis added):

Sometimes, when you're knee-deep in the day-to-day, when you're just struggling to get by, when you're facing forces that seem so much bigger than you, there is a need for someone from the outside - someone bigger and more powerful - to come by, pat you on the back, tell you that you are not alone, and remind you both of your inherent worth and that it is all inherently worth it.

That is what the Bush did Thursday in the Knesset. [...]

Were that Israel's own leaders would speak in similar terms; were that Israel would believe as much in itself. [...]

When, during our current bout of self-doubt and fear, was the last time an Israeli leader stood up and with a conviction that made you believe he meant it, not that he was just mouthing tired phrases, said - as Bush did Thursday - "Masada shall never fall again."

And then, even more importantly, Bush added, "Citizens of Israel: Masada shall never fall again, and America will always stand with you."

Words? Maybe. But they are important words, because if ever this country is again to take another calculated risk for peace, it will have to know that the US stands completely behind it.

Words? Maybe. But if ever the Arab world will ever come around to accepting Israel's existence, it will have to know that it cannot drive a wedge between Jerusalem and Washington.

The speech, at parts elegantly phrased, also echoed sentiments many of us feel, but rarely hear aired outside the shtetl. [...]

Remember, Bush didn't have to utter these thoughts: his political carrier is over, he no longer needs the Jewish vote or campaign support - further proof he actually meant what he said.

Sadly, American media didn't hear any of that. Instead, this is all that got through their bias filters:

Some seem to believe that we should negotiate with the terrorists and radicals, as if some ingenious argument will persuade them they have been wrong all along. We have heard this foolish delusion before. As Nazi tanks crossed into Poland in 1939, an American senator declared: "Lord, if I could only have talked to Hitler, all this might have been avoided." We have an obligation to call this what it is — the false comfort of appeasement, which has been repeatedly discredited by history.

The rest they stole from us, and for this we are owed an apology that certainly will never come, for instead of Americans being proud of the job our President did representing our nation on this historic visit, this day will live in infamy rather than immortality.

How truly sad we've come to this.

Picture courtesy AFP.

*****Update: Marc Sheppard over at the American Thinker cleverly points out something else media have missed in this marvelous speech:

What the "outraged" Democrats and mainstream media are completely ignoring in Bush's "appeasement" words used in yesterday's Knesset speech is that they addressed concerns originally raised by Ariel Sharon.

Shortly after the 9/11 attacks, then Israeli Prime Minister Sharon warned the United States not to "appease the Arabs at [Israel's] expense." Sharon made reference to the catastrophic consequences of European democracies appeasing Hitler prior to World War II, specifically citing the Munich Pact of 1938 which ceded Czechoslovakia's Sudetenland to Germany:

''Don't repeat the terrible mistakes of 1938, when the enlightened democracies in Europe decided to sacrifice Czechoslovakia for a comfortable, temporary solution. [Israel] will not be Czechoslovakia.''

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

agreed Noel

Obama is making a very bad impression on Israel that he uses their anniversary to throw a tantrum about a supposed political attack. Nowhere in any of his whining has he ever begun with, "I'm so sorry Israel's celebration is being tainted with this."

As far as Jews and Evangelicals are concerned, Obama (who was already weak on Israel to begin with) has thoroughly painted himself into a corner by allowing Bush's Hitler analogy to stick to him. All the pandering he's done the past year was undone by this single blowup.

If he wins the White House, look for Israel to throw down with their enemies more so than ever because they know Obama won't do crap. The cards are fixin to be pulled off the table.

Liberals do not have a

Liberals do not have a concept as to how small Israel is. Nor do I think they understand the concept of how harsh that can of Israeli whup-ass is going to be when they finally decide to open it up. 

mr. joseph, Here a comparision

Hawaii is over 6,000 square miles; Israel is about 9,000 sq mi.

The POPE says, GOD BLESS AMERICA!!


Liberals/need/help/IranianUranium/<sleep>

It is Small

Israel is about the same size as New Jersey.

Bravo, Noel! Truer words

Bravo, Noel! Truer words were never spoken. They have truly embarrassed themselves. Unfortunately, in the process, they have embarrassed our country also.

Dana Perino was exactly right when she said (paraphrasing) I realize when you're running for President, you think everything is about you. But it's not.

The media are so blinded by their hatred of Bush and their adoration of the Obama, that that's the only lens they are able to view everything through. Every word, deed and event is seen in the prism of "will this help or hurt our guy?"

They should all be ashamed of themselves. But they have no shame.

Democrats and the MSM were

Democrats and the MSM were simply looking for their own "Wellstone funeral" to criticize Bush, and, in their minds, they found it. Of course there's not going to be much debate about the rest of his beautiful speech...why show "the context" when they have (what they believe) something to run with and criticize?

Shameful

I agree.  The leftists in this country are disgraceful.

I was watching Hannity & Colmes last night and couldn't believe that Alan Colmes was arguing about this.  Being a Jew himself, he should have concentrated on the celebration of Israel and not on what could be read into a speech given by a man who is not even running for office.

Goth, sometimes I think

Goth, sometimes I think Colmes doesn't really believe his own arguments. I think he just gets paid for being a Liberal A-hole. His wife is a conservative from what I've heard. I think he's less liberal than what he let's on.

Alan Colmes - I'm not a liberal, but I play one on tv

I had heard someone say that he attends the Catholic Church with his wife so you could be right.  But if he's stirring up liberal hatred for a paycheck, that's a horrible career choice.

It is very disgusting

and unfortunately it's the norm now. The liberal leadership, Hollywood and liberal media have become complete bullies who want anyone who doesn't agree with them shunned. They don't want debate and they could care less about truth. They only want power.

Noel, This has been one of the most despressing weeks in

the news ever...

And no! you are RIGHT ON about the stinking MSM.

I awoke to the cheering gays in California..

And Bush came up dry in Saudi Arabia..

When exactly are rev. wrights comments about gd America comming true? oil $128/ a bbl. ..

However I'm still coasting on what the Pope said:

The POPE says, GOD BLESS AMERICA!!


Liberals/need/help/IranianUranium/<sleep>

Bingo

Beautifully composed, NS.

On the day prior, members of the Arab League, notably Saudi Arabia, found it within themselves to add a bit of their own form of civil sanity to the mix, when they threatened to sever ties with Iran (and I believe the connection was made to Syria, as well) over it's support and direction of Hezbollah's radical terror in Lebanon. This also speaks to President Bush's understanding that at certain times, one cannot simply appease the nuts out there - there is nobody there to talk to.

Perhaps one of the smartest moves Jimmy Carter ever made was to sever ties with Iran some 28 years ago. Carter's OK to Saddam to invade Iran is a more curious point (one the media would never care to entertain). 

Faculty members [Harvard] yesterday attacked President Carter's announced actions against Iran, his strongest to date, calling them either misdirected or late. ..the President has cut the telephone line. April 8th, 1980

Some things never change.

Redirection 101

DNC memo to all demedia affiliates -- While global warming on self-imposed hiatus....fall back to second greatest threat to world, Bush/conservatives.

Noel Rocks!

Noel you rock!  I'm fed up with the Liberal media.  Their bias is blatant and unforgiving.  It is driving me nuts.  What is the average American to do?

These are the very people

These are the very people screaming about assassinating the good reverend Wright by using selective soundbites....

When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Ex -friggin' - zactly! 

Ex -friggin' - zactly!  These people are such flaming hypocrites it's inconceivable.

MSNBC advertised the Meltdown with Olbermaniac by asking "Is Bush on the wrong side of history?"  Holy $%!#$!!!  His speech is expressly about the fact that it is the Liberal Appeasers who have been on the wrong side  for so long and so often that it defines them!

Excellent piece

Excellent piece Noel...

You and I may butt heads from time to time, but let me assure you that I have all the respect in the world for you.

Once again.... Excellent piece! 

"Abstain from McCain"

In the tank

If you had any doubt about how the MSM was going to report the coming
election; yesterday you got the opening salvo/preview of coming attractions.

You knew of course they would be biased and spin
like mad for the Democrats, I think the only open question was just how far
they would go.

The answer(which is no surprise, really) is that the Obama campaign
are not just on the reading from the same page they are in fact a joint
operation, working together to produce the page.

It is not that Obama's campaign makes a statement and the MSM
responds favorably; instead its is the MSM conferring in advance with the Obama
campaign about what the statement should be.

The relationship is like that between the author of the screenplay, the
author of the original work the screenplay is based on and the director of the
movie.

We need to be calling hat AP, NBC, CBS, ABC, CNN, NYT, WP, MSNBC are doing
what it truly is, not spin, but collaboration.

Completely agree

Noel, you not only captured the facts, you also captured the emotion of this MSM disgrace. When the media is so complicit in the distortions, it leaves you with a feeling of disgust.

Great write up, Noel. I

Great write up, Noel. I completely agree. It's so frustrating to watch the media turn the country into a cesspool. I wish there is something more we can do to get the word out to people, like my Mother, for instance. She grew up when the News was a way to get information, not opinions; therefore, she believes anything she hears on the News. Unless we have a conversation about it, my mother would believe anything that the MSM is saying. She takes what they say as gospel. My mother is a Democrat because of this...she's anti-abortion, but for some reason, she does not associate this with the Democrats. I can't tell you how frustrating this is as she is a strict Catholic. No wonder my Dad (he was a staunch conservative)and her would argue like crazy during an election year.

The speed

With the speed that this has came to be a Obama bash has to have something to do with the old game of telephone. One reporter most likely from MSNBC told someone what they wanted to hear and then it spread like wild fire. The reaction came from this interpretation of the speech and not was really said. For Joe Biden's BS comment came from one. The question was somthing like; "Bush just refered to Obama as a Hitler appeaser was are your response".  Not what was said, "Some seem to believe that we should negotiate with the terrorists and radicals, as if some ingenious argument will persuade them they have been wrong all along." This is how Obama has got all his support, his ingenious charisma and argument that Only he can "Change". Also they are all tired of bashing fellow dems in the primary go back to the old staple blame the GOP and Bush.  

One has to wonder what the press will do when they get Obama elected and all his promises of change fail and nothing is done. Will they then jump ship or just rearrange the deck chairs and blame Bush

This was great Noel

Thank you.

I've shared it with family and friends

Professional Dignity ..or lack thereof

Great write-up Noel! You captured both the spirit of Bush's talk and the disgrace of the MSM's coverage of it.

I could not help but wonder how the reporters who ignored 95% of this speech would feel if they read your analysis of their coverage. Would they be embarrassed? Their coverage amounts to writing a feature story on a dropped hot dog in the stands at a World Series game. They completely missed the point, and missed it so badly that, if they had any pride at all, they should be too embarrassed to show their face in public.

I frankly wonder how many of them heard or read the entire speech. I am guessing many did not, relying instead on the stampede of their liberal peers in the media to tell them what is important to cover. That indicates not only incompetence and lack of professionalism, but simple laziness. Those who did read the entire speech and still decided and that only a single passage warranted reporting to the American Public are even worse. They have become the Winston Smiths of Orwell's 1984 world. Orwell had it right, just the date wrong!

Excellent

Thank you for that...you said everything that needed to be said

Beautiful piece Noel...you

Beautiful piece Noel...you said it all.

Since you posted the speech last night and I commented I haven't been able to comment anymore I am so disgusted with the enemy within...to intentionally do what they did yesterday to such a great speech full of wisdom was beyond contempt...let alone the arrogance of Obama and the dems/leftists...

President Bush will go down in history as one of the best defenders of our country and freedom everywhere...no matter what the likes of the msm talking heads and filthy rotten congress-critters inject.

I thank God for his back-bone...and him, when this country has needed it more than ever.

Lord help us all with what is to come. 

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Hi, Bigtimer, I too am so

Hi, Bigtimer, I too am so disgusted by these MSM reptiles. And I agree with you about the President. I just wish he'd defend himself more. I don't know, maybe he just thinks he's above it, and that may be true, but I would love to see him throw a good verbal punch in his own defense sometimes. He's dealing with a terrible enemy...not only the terrorists, but the American press. It's really sad. God bless him though.

Howdy back mar... I am so

Howdy back mar...

I am so sick of what the msm has intentionally done to this man from just about day one, I don't care if it is an hour press conference on important issues in this country like drilling here, or a pretty danged good speech, the ignore it or rip into it...and move on...they make me puke.

I have had major differences with the Pres. and how he has handled things, but to intentionally attempt to destroy him is and has been beyond contempt to me...he and the military most likely have helped save their sorry arses for their freedom of the press...unfortunately, while they have done everything they can to defeat him and this war on terror...IMO at the moment...

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Thank you, Noel. Again the

Thank you, Noel. Again the MsM show their ignorance of history in their zeal to attack Pres. Bush and play politics with anything and everything he does. Isn't it interesting that it's the MsM and the Dems that are always talking about how the rest of the world doesn't respect America because of Pres. Bush's policies.

 

I am the exotic Queen Mum, and I approved this message.

MSM and Obama, Osama & Momma

Noel, you pegged it perectly. The MSM in this country have gone so far left that Stalin, Mao, Hitler, Castro, Chavez must be in awe of their complete hatred of America.

I consider C ommunist B roadcast S ervice, N eanderthal    B roadcast C orporation, A ntiAmerican B roadcast C orporation, C ommunist N ews N etwork, M arxist S ycophant N eanderthal B roadcast C orporation to be so out of touch with reality that I will not allow their vile spew to be heard in my home, car or anywhere I am. They are worse the Osama, equal to Obama and of course Momma Clintonista.

Those Americans that watch and  believe their daily attacks on our troops, our President and the Christian nation are either severely stupid, bordering on retardation or so brain washed and corrupt that they deserve what they will get when this screed gets into office. I am truly amazed at the shear magnitude of Americans who are so dense they cannot see them destroying our Nation...

Kudos, Noel

You said what needed to be said. Every newsperson complicit in this abomination should have your article shoved in their faces, and be made to read it.

This isn't news, it's an obscene side-show. And, as you say, a complete disgrace.

Prime analysis -- Just

Prime analysis -- Just plain beautiful

 Give a Liberal a thought and he'll repeat it mindlessly all day.  Teach a Liberal to think for himself and he'll vote Republican (or, preferably, Libertarian) for the rest of his life.