US Economy So Bad Illegal Aliens Heading Back to Mexico

Photo of Noel Sheppard.

Just how bad is the economy doing?

Well, according to Reuters, it's so bad out there that illegal aliens are heading back to Mexico.

Almost sounds like a joke the late night hosts would make during their monologues, doesn't it?

As a result, when I first saw this last evening (thanks to whoever sent it to me with apologies for not being able to identify who it was!), I thought it had to be a satire.

However, this morning, the link still works, and it is indeed a Reuters piece posted at Yahoo Sunday (hysterical emphasis added throughout):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Mexican illegal immigrant Lindi sat down with her husband Marco Antonio in the weeks before Christmas to decide when to go back to Mexico.

She has spent three years working as a hairdresser in and around Phoenix, but now she figures it is time to go back to her hometown of Aguascalientes in central Mexico.

"The situation has got so tough that there don't seem to be many options left for us," Lindi, who asked for her last name not to be used, told Reuters.

The couple are among a growing number of illegal immigrants across the United States who are starting to pack their bags and move on as a crackdown on undocumented immigrants widens and the U.S. economy slows, turning a traditional Christmas trek home into a one-way trip.

Checking that link about now to make sure I didn't slip in the bit about the economy slowing? I understand. I've checked it thrice.

But that was the beginning of the hysterics:

The toughening environment has been coupled with a turndown in the U.S. economy, which has tipped the balance toward self deportation for many illegal immigrants left struggling to find work.

What turndown in the U.S. economy? According to the Department of Labor's enterprise survey, employers have added 400,000 jobs since July, and 1.1 million so far this year.

Furthermore, the broader household survey identified an astounding 1 million gain in workers since August.

With that in mind, what jobs are these illegal aliens seeking that are in such short supply? Without appearing insensitive, are these folks all in the lending or banking industries?

But there was more:

Other returning immigrants cite a slowdown in the U.S. economy as a factor, and the falling value of the U.S. dollar against other currencies, which has eaten into the value of remittances sent to support families at home.

I'm sorry for not warning people to put down their coffee cups before that last quote. However, since I ruined my laptop when I saw this inanity, why shouldn't you?

That said, let's take a moment to imagine how many illegal immigrants in this nation are actually concerned about the value of the U.S. dollar. Maybe more important, unlike most currencies, the peso is actually DOWN in value this year, and has largely been declining since 2002:

Despite the stupidity of this Reuters piece, the peso ended 2006 worth 9.24 cents. The March contract which trades on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange closed last Friday at 9.18 cents.

Maybe more important, the peso was worth almost 9.6 cents in early 2006, and 11 cents in 2002. So, for the most part, in the last five years, illegal immigrants sending money back to Mexico were benefiting from exchange rates NOT being penalized as this Reuters piece suggested.

Aren't facts a terrible thing?

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Democrats declare

Democrats declare recessions racist...

Illegals

Illegals are beginning to feel that they are not welcome here...Guess what? They're not! Go back home and come back only when you are ready to obey our laws. If you all go away, our Congress can continue to disregard its responsiblity without hurting the country the way it does now.

NEVER, NEVER trust a "liberal"

BTW, for all those who are having an epiphany about "liberals" and the way they "think", this is a great posting. Thanks, Noel.

This is like the "Deaths Down, Gravediggers Suffer" story

Enforcement is working and the predicted self-deportation is beginning.   But the liberal media can't allow that good news to just sit out there.  

The point is Noel, the

The point is Noel, the illegals believe what the MSM says, so this is not a bad thing, let them self deport, we're not stopping them.  Adios, senors. What I want to see is the unemployment rate drop significantly.  If this is a recession, it will be the first one in which the unemployment rate either stays the same or decreases.  To qualify for a recession in any case is 2 consecutive quarters of negative GDP, we have yet to even have one negative quarter so it is premature for anyone let alone the MSM to shoot it's mouth off about a potential recession. The so called journalists obviously don't understand the concept of a diversified economy.  One sector (real estate) in trouble does not a recession make. Considering the Fed and the banks are pumping liquidity, any cascade effect from the real estate sector will be mitigated.

Hanlon's Razor: Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity. dscott's corollary: The line between malice and stupidity is called depraved indifference.

Definition of a Recession

DScott, your definition of a recession, of course, is the old "white male" definition. The new Dim/Lib definition is "if one or more people making $80,000/year or less have to pay for their own health care" then it's a depression. Don't forget, it's the potential impact a ression might have that's important, not the actual facts themselves.

___________________________________ 

If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber

I appreciate the Reuter's Lie

For the first time I appreciate a MSM lie. If I had a pocket full of peso I would email the story to all in ole Mexico with some North Korean tidbits of Americans eat foreigners on Thanksgiving.

As a border buster note, I would appreciate it if Newsbusters could have a "what you saw" in Mexicans lately as in moving around in the midwest I have noticed a very odd trend.

For the past years, there were always these peons one saw. You know what I mean in these 5 foot 4 little fellas who all look like when you look at them they are sure you are a federali going to beat their butt.
They always had these tanky big ugly women with them

Then I noticed this past summer what appeared to be mules or tall English speaking Mexicans assimilating these peons.

Now the past months, I have been seeing these 6 foot 4 light skinned Mexican men.....and the frumper Mexican chica is gone as they are all pretty, tight bods and usually have a few little kids.

This is intrigueing to me as in Mexico the ruling class like in India are all fair skinned and they do not venture out to America as they already are rich. These are not "Mexicans" but the Spanish bloodlines which California was settled by. A Mexican is a Spaniard crossed with the Indian population and is usually generationally poor and so underfed that you get these little runty people.

So if Newsbusters could run a thread just asking people honestly what they see and the area of the nation they are located it would be most helpful as something has changed in all of this and I would be curious to know is this a planned second wave of the Mexican version of Yuppies instigated to come here by the globalists Rockefeller, MacArthur and Ford Foundation grants as these "Mexicans" are different and while still 3rd world predatory quiet in watching what is going on they do at times react in public.

Thanks

 

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

Bush is a genius! The

Bush is a genius!

The weaker dollar lets Boeing and Caterpillar have an easier time competing with Airbus & Komatsu, and now the weaker dollar is helping drive the illegals back out of the USA, just in time for the new border wall when Fred Thompson becomes President!

 

Newsbusters. Log on and find out What the heck is so yummy over here!

Dang Ferners

You know what I hate, Noel? There are an amazing number of sheeple out there who will regurgitate these lies over holiday meals; garbage in...garbage out. No matter how ridiculous these stories get the idiots out there just take it as fact.

I have a small paint company in a southern state and there is no end to the illegals that ask me for work at 33% or less than my taxpaying employees make. It disgusts me and until more people consider the U.S. their HOME I fear we shall soon lose our sovereignty.

The numbers increase. They NEVER decrease.

Merry Christmas, Ya'll.

Remittences to Mexico

"Jesus Cervantes, a top statistician at the country's(Mexico) central bank, told Reuters remittances would probably only grow by about 5 or 6 percent this year and not likely exceed $24.5 billion."

Holy Moly! Imagine if they spent that money in the US.

I don't see a change here in

I don't see a change here in Bellflower, Ca. NO ONE speaks english. Go to the nearby Walmart or the grocery store, you'd think you walked in to Mexico City. Only the occasional checker speaks English. They drive like idiots over mediums and they use bike lanes. INS and ICE should come to this city and have a field day.

Have seen several stories on

Have seen several stories on self deportation, most chalk it up to enforcement of the laws, but leave it up to Reuters to not only get the facts wrong, but blame America to boot!

Caught red handed

Another excellent article, Noel.  This article proves, without a shadow of a doubt, that Reuters spits out propaganda according to their templates, regardless of the facts. 

Is there any way we can contact Reuters and get some accountability here? 

Right here,

Right here, Tim:

http://reuters-en.custhelp.com/cgi-bin/reuters_en.cfg/php/enduser/home.php 

And where to contact the Associated Press (AP)

http://www.ap.org/pages/contact/contact.html 

Thanks

Thanks for the links.Even it was meant for Tim.I like to email these folks about some of their stories.

Their home countries do NOT want them back!

Nowhere mentioned in the article is WHY the difficulty in returning to their home countries. Assuming they entered the U.S. illegally, the process should be nothing more than identifying themselves as here illegally then be deported. Not so fast! Their homes countries do NOT want them back! And they will do everything possible to keep them here. Besides the billions sent back to relatives each year, illegal immigration is the "safety valve" these, mostly, autocratic governments require to avoid civil unrest and even uprisings at home. Short of repeating the arduous and dangerous trek through the desert that got them here, they are stuck. Illegal aliens who now want to go home but can't!

For years I've asked a simple question of those who are for open borders and cite the standard "they pay for themselves and do jobs Americans won't do". "What happens next if these jobs disappear for any reason (i.e. recession)?" We will be finding out "what happens" in the next few years.

Many millions of unmarried, minimally educated (average education of an illegal alien is sixth grade) under 40 year-old males with no income and nowhere to go is a prescription for painful civil unrest; but here, not in their native countries. The most serious right now is the drying up of jobs in new home construction. Jobs that pay well and that Americans WILL do! Construction is an industry where it is quite easy to keep workers off the books. While Fast Food minimum wage jobs are quickly filling up with Hispanic female workers (some fluency in Spanish is now a requirement for management jobs at many McDonalds and other such places of business), the males, used to making $20/hour tax-free in construction are NOT flocking to flip burgers. There are many jobs illegal aliens also will not do!

Their home countries are the ones stopping their return home. The United States only wants to say "good bye!" If the jobs illegal aliens mostly fill continue their free fall, we're poised to have some various serious problems in our society. Even the most ardent "undocumented worker" proponents will be forced to admit they were wrong. Actually, as is the way of all those of the left, they will just change the subject leaving the rest of us to deal with another one of their failed social experiments. The next few years don't look good although the rate of immigrations may begin to fall with well paying jobs no longer waiting for them across the border. That will just leave the most desperate and most uneducated young hispanic males coming through the desert with only a hope of "something" when they reach the "promised land" they've heard others speak of. Just the kind of immigrants we most need! No skills, uneducated and unable to return home.

The next ten years are not going to be pretty.

 

As Curly Bill would say...

Well................................
bye.

No New News From Know Nothings

Long before everybody with a computer keyboard and a pulse appointed themselves as experts on Mexican immigration, I had plenty of direct hands-on involvement in the realities and the economics involved in the topic.

Coincidently, this was also long before the lefties in the MSM decided it would be a smart strategy to stir up a decades-old policy issue in an effort to factionalize some of the not-so-bright folks on the right, all but guaranteeing the Dimocrats a win in 2006 and 2008.

The truth about this so-called "exodus" is that it happens every year in mid-December, only to be follwed by a mass return in mid-January.

Sure, a minority of Mexical illegals stay in the U.S. year-round, but the vast majority (somewhere between 2/3 and 3/4) are truly "migrant" workers who come here for 10-11 months of work, live off a fraction of their pay, sending most of it back home, and then go home to spend the holidays with their families in Mexico before coming back and starting the whole cycle all over again.

Am I surprised that some MSM lefty managed to use enough leading questions to get an ESL interviewee to come up with the allegedly "quoted" response? No, not a bit. But this is what happens when people who know nothing about a topic start pretending to be experts.

 


Thompson/Giuliani 2008

Mexicans

Living for most of my 80 years within 19 miles of the mexicam border you are right on. Also I learned early on that there no "Dumb Mecicans" cross the river and get all the benifets of real citizens and no taxes.

JS Skeptic, Noel focused on the portion of the Reuters story

that blames the U.S. "recession", but if you go back and read the entire story, you'll see that the annual Christmas "holiday" is addressed:

"...a growing number of illegal immigrants across the United States who are starting to pack their bags and move on as a crackdown on undocumented immigrants widens and the U.S. economy slows, turning a traditional Christmas trek home into a one-way trip."

and;   "...many of whom simply head south over the border with their belongings packed into a car during the annual Christmas exodus, or board scheduled flights for other destinations. Mexican consular sources in Phoenix say they are seeing a spike in the number of immigrants applying for Mexican citizenship for their U.S.-born children, which will allow them to enroll in schools in Mexico. They are also seeing a rise in requests for papers enabling families to carry household belongings back to Mexico, free of import duties."

My guess is these self-deporters are planning to lie low in Mexico for now, and that they expect to return when enforcement loosens again.    

Mr. Gaynor clearly started

Mr. Gaynor clearly started out with a preconceived view of the type of story he wanted to write and then fit isolated bits of facts (dollar decline), pseudo-facts (slowing economy?) and anecdotes to buttress his thesis.

Some people say he's making news and not reporting it.

I'm one of those people.

 

Arizona new laws

I think the fact that Arizona has new immigration laws starting in January has a bigger effect on leaving than the economy, but they can't blame Bush for Arizona new laws. But they can blame him for the economy.

Tj...

You have it exactly right. It's enforcing the tougher laws sending them packing not the jobs market. 

Rush Limbaugh stated that of the top 5 Republicans running for the presidency, only one was a true conservative. http://www.fred08.com/ 

How could it be the job

How could it be the job market if they are doing jobs Americans won't do????

Not only that...

...but if we have this surplus of jobs, why are folks still on welfare?? Do away with the dole and maybe some p!ssed off couch potatoes will take care of the illegals while we sleep!

ooops!

oooops!

Yeah, I can hear Johnny

Yeah, I can hear Johnny Carson now if he were still around....

Carson: "The economy is so bad..."

Audience " Howwwww baaaaad is it???"

Carson: "It's so bad that illegal immigrants are deporting themselves back to Mexico!!"

And the audience, collectively, collapses in hysterics.

Except for the liberals, who get up and leave in a huff at Carson's insensitivity to the plight of illegal aliens.

You beat me to it

I imagined the same myself...,  does sound like a hilarious Johnny Carson skit

 

LMAO!Did I read one-way

LMAO!

Did I read one-way trip back home? Did I read self-deportation? 

Wow, we won't need the caravan of buses after-all if the economy keeps up like the leftists want us to believe...at least some of the illegals seem to.

Cry me a river...

You gotta' love this by the AP! Too bad the majority of what they print isn't true....

Illegal Invaders leaving because the grass isn't greener here

Oh, too bad. (please pardon the dripping sarcasm)

Like all parasites, the

Like all parasites, the invaders are leaving what they perceive to be a sinking ship. If they were real immigrants, they would be pitching in to help.

AP - More FOREX Stupidity

Noel,

From AP "Business Writer" Leslie Wines, via Drudge.

"Foreign Buyers Snap Up 2nd Homes In US."

".....The currency advantage is greatest for British citizens, given that each pound is worth well over $2. By contrast, the euro currently is worth about $1.45 while the Canadian dollar in recent weeks is hovering near parity with its U.S. counterpart....."

Oh, the poor Japanese!  Since the yen is "worth" less than one USA penny, they can't afford to buy anything in America!

This kind of reporting is so ignorant, I have no idea what to say.

Does this reporter actually believe that the "normal" rate of exchange for a "strong" dollar is one-for-one with other currencies?  

"Mexican illegal immigrant

"Mexican illegal immigrant Lindi sat down with her husband Marco
Antonio in the weeks before Christmas to decide when to go back to
Mexico.

She has spent three years working as a hairdresser in and
around Phoenix, but now she figures it is time to go back to her
hometown of Aguascalientes in central Mexico."

Wow, who knew hairdresser was one of those jobs that Americans won't do? Makes you wonder how an illegal can get a license to practice hair, because there is no way she would practice hair without a license. That would be illegal.

CKC1227: You answered

CKC1227:

You answered your own questions about the hair dresser. The money quote is she worked three years "in and around Phoenix" .

She probably drove to the client's home, or they all came to her's Anyhow, it's good money as long as you can stand the consequences!