Gibson Calls Olbermann a Liar for his Bush Criminal Conspiracy Rant

Photo of Noel Sheppard.

As NewsBusters reported, MSNBC's Keith Olbermann went on a ridiculously disgraceful rant during Monday's "Countdown" claiming, amongst other things, that "[T]he presidency of George W. Bush has now devolved into a criminal conspiracy to cover the ass of George W. Bush."

On Wednesday, Fox News's John Gibson, during his radio program, took issue with Olbermann's tirade, and actually called the former sportscaster a liar for misrepresenting what former acting Attorney General Daniel Levin wrote about the interrogation procedure known as waterboarding.

Gibson accurately pointed out (audio available here courtesy our friend Johnny Dollar):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Bathtub Boy [Keith Olbermann] was saying that Bush should go to prison because there was a certain official of the Justice Department whose name was Daniel Levin who had himself waterboarded, declared it to be torture - legally torture, practically torture, ethically torture - and that he wrote a report about it, and that Bush went ahead and waterboarded people, like Khalid Sheik Mohammed, who, by the way, gave up the goods when he got waterboarded within two minutes - and said that on the basis of this Mr. Levin's report, Bush was therefore a criminal.

[...]

Turns out that according to Radar Online, the original report which Bathtub Boy used to write this thing which demanded that Bush go to jail, Daniel Levin did not decide that waterboarding by the U.S. is torture. He just thought we might be doing it wrong. According to the original ABC report, "Levin, who refused to comment for the story, concluded waterboarding could be illegal torture unless performed in a highly limited way, and with close supervision."

The actual text of the November 2 "World News with Charles Gibson" report Gibson was referring to is:

JAN CRAWFORD GREENBURG (ABC NEWS) (Voiceover): Levin concluded the only way waterboarding could be done and not cross the legal line of torture was in a highly limited way with close supervision.

An ABCNews.com article concerning this segment made Levin's position on waterboarding a bit firmer (emphasis added):

The administration at the time was reeling from an August 2002 memo by Jay Bybee, then the head of the Office of Legal Counsel, which laid out possible justifications for torture. In June 2004, Levin's predecessor at the office, Jack Goldsmith, officially withdrew the Bybee memo, finding it deeply flawed.

When Levin took over from Goldsmith, he went to work on a memo that would effectively replace the Bybee memo as the administration's legal position on torture. It was during this time that he underwent waterboarding.

In December 2004, Levin released the new memo. He said, "Torture is abhorrent" but he went on to say in a footnote that the memo was not declaring the administration's previous opinions illegal. The White House, with Alberto Gonzales as the White House counsel, insisted that this footnote be included in the memo.

Clearly, this was not what Olbermann said Monday evening:

All the petulancy, all the childish threats, all the blank-stare stupidity, all the invocations of World War III, all the sophistic questions about which terrorist attacks we wanted him not to stop, all the phony secrets, all the claims of executive privilege, all the stumbling tapdancing of his nominees, all the verbal flatulence of his apologists, all of it is now, after one revelation last week, transparently clear for what it is, the pathetic and desperate manipulation of the government, the refocusing of our entire nation towards keeping this mock President and this unstable Vice President and this departed wildly self-overrating Attorney General and all the others from potential prosecution for having approved or ordered the illegal torture of prisoners being held in the name of our country. Waterboarding is torture, Daniel Levin was to write.

As such, Gibson drove the point home: "Well, no, he didn't write that...I guess he would be a liar."

In the end, this is just another example of how Olbermann says whatever he wants regardless of facts.

NBC and parent company General Electric must be so proud.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

For what its worth, I cant

For what its worth, I cant understand how Obie is still on the air waves. His mouth is spewing nothing but hate and lies. But, then again, thats what MSNBC is known for anymore.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Well, as long as his ratings

Well, as long as his ratings beat out the crap Chris Matthews, Nancy Grace, and Anderson Cooper come out with, Keefy will be around.

Keefy has ratings? Chris

Keefy has ratings? Chris has almost 8 people watch his show, whats Keefy got? 9.5? :-)

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Keefy has carved out a niche

Keefy has carved out a niche among the Hufftard crowd.

Ratings seem to be

Ratings seem to be secondary to ideology in the MSM...

BATH-TUB-BOY...

He's still on the air because those running MSNBC are rewarded well for being the 3rd place horse in a 3 horse race, way off of the pace. Think about that, they just had a 10th "birthday" party for Hardball, Gibby & whatever CNN has put on over the years have been kicking Mathews @$$ the whole time. They reward failure there, BathTubBoy is another example of this. Things will change when the shareholders demand that MSNBC quit being a money pit. GE & Microsoft did'nt become the monsters they are by funding money losing projects for very long. I would hope this would be coming to an end soon, it's turned into Air America Television News.

BTW, I did hear this segment Gibson did, I listen to his show on a regular basis on XM, he has been going after this idiot big time. He worked with him, or should I say instead of him when they were both at MSNBC years ago. That's when he would'nt get out of his tub during the Clinton/Monica blue dress days, then Gibby would get the call to do Olbermann's show. Hence the moniker BathTubBoy.

"Some of us are wise, some of us are otherwise"  Mark Levin

Keefy puts BoR and Larry

Keefy puts BoR and Larry King shame when it comes to spackling on the pancake....

"...like Khalid Sheik

"...like Khalid Sheik Mohammed, who, by the way, gave up the goods when he got waterboarded within two minutes..." 

That's really all I needed to know. Thank you.

**My Daughter at the WWII Memorial

Two Minutes, What A Wussy

I seriously don't understand all of the whining about waterboarding.

My former (for obvious reasons) dentist had a hygenist who couldn't figure out how to raise her own chair. The solution? Tilt the patient chair until my head was only about a 15 inches off the floor, considerably lower than the rest of my body, so she could be comfortable while accomplishing the task. She then proceeds to pump who knows how much water directly into my mouth during a cleaning that lasted about 10-12 minutes.

I've watched the videos of waterboarding, and really can't see any difference between that and a dental procedure for which I paid over $100. Yes, I'll agree that it's uncomfortable, a bit disorienting, and maybe even a little scary if one has an irrational fear of drowning on dry land, but calling it torture? Get real.

Maybe we should send the UN after the American Dental Association.

Given the choice between being forced to watch an hour of Olbernutjob, or being waterboarded for two hours, I'll take the waterboarding.

 


Thompson/Giuliani 2008

Bombthrowing

Once again, Olbermann is just a bombthrower, and he'll throw anything to get attention. This time, the bomb was a factually incorrect story that Olbermann used as evidence of a Bush conspiracy. Sooner or later, he'll run out of things to throw, and like Frankenstein's monster, he'll throw whatever's available. If people get hurt, he won't care -- it'll help his ratings.

If people get hurt, he

If people get hurt, he won't care -- it'll help his ratings.

Yeah, he's shooting for the moon...to have 100 viewers someday!!

Why can't this Keith

Why can't this Keith guy mention anyones name without prefacing it with name calling first?

 

OK, this is sort of OT, but

OK, this is sort of OT, but it is about Olbermann: Why is he called "Bathtub Boy" and who started it?

Gibson calls him bathtub boy

Gibson calls him bathtub boy because Gibby often had to sub for Olbermann because he didn't want to get out of the tub to do the show himself, or something like that. If you listen to the piece, Gibby explains why.

Got it!

Thanks. That was driving me nuts (I hate being out of the loop! LOL)

I Like It

I like the fact that Gibson calls Olbermann Bathtub Boy. I actually find it very funny, and I will start calling Olbermann Bathtub Boy from now on here. I am a big fan of the conservative voices on Fox News, (including Bill O'Reilly, though he calls himself independent),though I disagree with them on certain issues.

"Kame-Hame-HAAAA!!!!!" - Son Goku, destroying Usama Bin Laden.

Mr. "Countdown to no

Mr. "Countdown to no Ratings" lied? That can't be right.

If George Bush and Dick

If George Bush and Dick Cheney are so evil why is "Bathtub Boy" still around?

You would think George and Dick would have the Olbie Lama of stupid disappear. Kind of like the poor basters on the Clinton's list of doom. 

olberman

i don't have the stomach to watch this arrogant, obnoxious, hate filled man. i never understood how homicide bombers, chavez, the nut in iran and other dictators never made the "worst person in the world " list. it was always a conservative or someone in the Bush administration. a sad man is keith.

Keith Dolberman

If his ratings weren't so crappy I might be concerned.  This guy mirrors the Daily Kos/Moveon.org hate mongering drivel.

The self-righteous Left is always going on about how knuckle dragging Republicans are too quick to demonize America's enemies ("axis of evil" etc.), but then the Left spends every waking hour demonizing Republicans.

In other words - murderous, terror funding, genocidally bigoted dictators around the world are to be treated respectfully, but its open season on the "evil" conservatives.

What is wrong with this picture?