More Evidence Good News From Iraq Not Getting Reported

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

On October 7, NewsBusters shared the astonishing statements of journalists from the Washington Post and CNN as to why good news from Iraq should not get reported.

Two weeks later, the Iraq Interior Ministry announced: "Violence in Iraq has dropped by 70 percent since the end of June, when U.S. forces completed their build-up of 30,000 extra troops to stabilize the war-torn country."

Such was reported by Reuters at 1:01 PM EST Monday. Not surprisingly, the major American media outlets ignored the good news.

Deliciously coincident, military blogger Michael Yon posted a piece at his website Monday appropriately titled "Resistance is futile: You will be (mis)informed" that should be must-reading for all Americans, especially elected officials (emphasis added throughout):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

I was at home in the United States just one day before the magnitude hit me like vertigo: America seems to be under a glass dome which allows few hard facts from the field to filter in unless they are attached to a string of false assumptions. Considering that my trip home coincided with General Petraeus' testimony before the US Congress, when media interest in the war was (I'm told) unusually concentrated, it's a wonder my eardrums didn't burst on the trip back to Iraq. In places like Singapore, Indonesia, and Britain people hardly seemed to notice that success is being achieved in Iraq, while in the United States, Britney was competing for airtime with O.J. in one of the saddest sideshows on Earth.

No thinking person would look at last year's weather reports to judge whether it will rain today, yet we do something similar with Iraq news. The situation in Iraq has drastically changed, but the inertia of bad news leaves many convinced that the mission has failed beyond recovery, that all Iraqis are engaged in sectarian violence, or are waiting for us to leave so they can crush their neighbors. This view allows our soldiers two possible roles: either "victim caught in the crossfire" or "referee between warring parties." Neither, rightly, is tolerable to the American or British public.

[...]

Anyone who has been in Iraq for longer than a few months, visited a handful of provinces, and spoken with a good number of Iraqis, likely would acknowledge that the reality here is complex and dynamic. But in the last six months it also has been increasingly hopeful, despite what the pessimistic dogma dome allows Americans and British to believe.

In fact, this is what American media, hoping that Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Cal.) have the public support to force an expeditious retreat, are immorally withholding from the citizenry:

I wasn't back in Iraq three days before this critical disconnect rocketed up from the ground and whacked me in the face. There I was with British soldiers, preparing for a mission with a duration of more than ten days in the southern province of al Basra, when someone asked me about the media reports alleging that Basra city had collapsed into violent chaos. Not wishing to trust solely to my own eyes and ears, I asked around and was able to quickly confirm what I'd already noted: conditions in this region had improved dramatically in the months since my previous embed with the Brits.

[...]

No one who's actually been to this area in the last month could honestly claim it was swarming with violence. I've been with the Brits here for more than two weeks, during which time there have been only a few trivial attacks that could easily have been the work of an angry farmer with extra time on his hands and a mortar in his backyard. As to serious attacks on British forces, in the last eight weeks, there have been exactly zero. So, any stories that make it sound like Basra is in chaos are shamefully false.

[...]

But it wasn't until I spent that week back in the States that I realized how bad things have gotten. I believe we are witnessing a conspiracy of coincidences conflating to exert an incomprehensibly destructive force on the free press system that we largely take for granted. The fact that the week in question also happened to be when General Petraeus and Ambassador Crocker were delivering their reports to Congress makes me wonder if things are actually worse than I've assessed, and I returned to Iraq sadly convinced that General Petraeus now has to deal from a deck clearly stacked against him in both America and Iraq.

Clearly, a majority of Americans believe the current set of outdated fallacies passed around mainstream media like watered down drinks at happy hour. Why wouldn't they? The cloned copy they get comes from the same sources that list the specials at the local grocery store, and the hours and locations of polling places for town elections. These same news sources print obituaries and birth announcements, give play-by-play for local high school sports, and chronicle all the painful details of the latest celebrity to fall from grace.

Eric at Classical Values commented Monday:

The post is an eye opener, and it makes me very angry, because I think that the general public is fatigued to the point of being burned out. While this is often thought of as war fatigue, unfortunately it takes the form of information fatigue. People just don't want to hear any more. Part of the reason is because they have already heard too much, and they are tired of being scolded in a partisan manner if they so much as utter a war related thought.

A good friend recently told me that he supports the war in silence, and he absolutely refuses to talk about it any more.

Bloggers, I am sorry to say, cannot fix this problem. Most people do not get their information from blogs, and those who do are usually on one side or the other, so their minds are not likely to change.

Take me, for example. I can write this blog post, but I am not in Iraq, and I am relying on what I have read in Michael Yon's blog and a few others. However, I do watch mainstream media reports pretty closely, and what I have noticed is that at the same time the situation in Iraq improved, mainstream news reports seemed to dwindle in a direct relationship to the improvement. To me, that's a clue. But to others (especially the more "normal" people who rely on news accounts) no news is not seen as evidence of good news, but just a relief from news. Unfortunately, all they remember is the steady drip drip drip of bad news from Iraq. Without any news, they're probably just hoping that the channel has been changed.

Maybe so, but I find Yon's conclusion quite uplifting:

The only antidote for this toxic press is a steady dose of detailed stories about the amazing men and women who serve in the United States military. People like Lieutenant Jeffrey Pettee, Iraqi Army Captain Baker, USMC SSG Rakene Lee, and LTC Fred Johnson. Each of these soldiers is a credit to every human being.

It is important that Americans let their best and clearest voices be heard around the world. If the world contained only twenty people, only one would be American. We represent about 5% of the world population. What those other nineteen people think about America is truly very important to each one of us. We cannot afford to let the media around the world continue promulgating so many recycled misconceptions about our soldiers and the character of our nation.

Quite right. And, maybe more importantly, we cannot afford our own media promulgating such misconceptions.

Thank you, Michael, for all you do.

And, for those that are or aren't familiar with Yon's work, please read this entire marvelous piece.

*****Update: There was a notable exception last evening concerning the reporting of good news from Iraq as Brent Baker pointed out.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Why should we expect any

Why should we expect any different from the media who sided with the USSR and extolls Fidel Castro as a brilliant political thinker?

Smart people know the media is lying. Stupid people believe the media above all else. That's the simple formula here. 

 

card holding member of the vast right-wing conspiracy

There's only one problem with that

and that is there is no test to determine "stupid/not stupid" before voting!

Bush should come out and

Bush should come out and officially declare victory and demand that any remaining insurgents lay down their arms and either return to their home country or sign a loyalty oath to the Iraqi government.

Then, lets see the Left writhe and wriggle like salted night-crawlers!

"Bush should come out and

"Bush should come out and officially declare victory and demand that any remaining insurgents lay down their arms and either return to their home country or sign a loyalty oath to the Iraqi government."

Fantastic idea!

Ditto agreed

Remarkably good political idea as it would make enemies of them of the entire Iraqi people and isolate them.

Perhaps a nice bounty on them would help in being paid to the province and individuals as money has worked in Iraq lately to form a more cohesive and profitable building of Iraq.

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

We have had the deck

We have had the deck stacked against us in the information war since the P-gon conceded the field to the MSM and dissolved the nascent Office of Information warfare that was being stood up shortly after 9/11.

That will undoubted proved to be the biggest mistake of the GWOT for our side and will take extra time, effort and weathering of future casualties before it is remedied.

If only we had had balls enough to say "Screw you, we need this if are gonna win this fight."

no news

Just how long will it take the MSM to get that no news is good news, unless it is (not) coming from Iraq and start to report not on the killings that are not there but, the mundane things of life in a big city like simple robberies and corruption (all blackwater related). Even small bad things from Iraq will get attention when the big bad things are not there. Yet, no big good things are there to be reported.

Hence....

...Henry Whackjob now going after Blackwater for supposedly not paying taxes.  Can't go after the military situation so they have to turn their guns on other things.

I wonder when they'll start up on Abu Ghraib again?

In respect to Muslims of Iraq

I have been one of the most critical of people in historical and modern Islam along with the followers for their herd mentality like communists, liberals and how many times innocent Jews are herded by the elite to keep control of them, but there only seemed to be Iraqi Kurds who were capable of reason.

In stating above though, since America has been killing the Islamocommunists and Islamofascists in Iraq the Iraqi Muslim as much of the Afghanistan Muslims have shown wonderful courage and insight in tossing out the trash and becoming independent Muslims living their lives.

Enough can not be stated about these people of the Chaldeas showing a remarkable ability to throw off the worst of the worst in the cartel media of Europe and America who are all communists at heart.

So in respect to now all Iraqi Muslims from Kurd to Shia to Sunni, they are a humane example in a sea of al Jazeera hatred. In accepting the United States Military in friendship helping them, they deserve to be commended.

Democrats and the MSM who caused so many deaths in Iraq deserve nothing but contempt.

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

More 'news'

AP- President promises federal help

Boxer complained: ...the ability of the state's National Guard to respond to disasters like the fires has been compromised because too much of its equipment and personnel are committed in Iraq...

Everything is Bush's fault.

Good news is yet again bad news in Iraq.

What the hell would Southern CA look like today if attacked by terrorists?

The libs are in the stadium listening to incredible music, eating gourmet food, getting massages, and described by AP as 'very happy'.

Ms Boxer needs to spend some time with Mr Reid, Ms Pelosi, Mr Stark, Ms Clinton... in the anti-hate room discussing how much they adore their country.

JDW

Sen Clinton: Founder of Media Matters

 

As far as I know, the 40th

As far as I know, the 40th ID (California National Guard) has not been deployed to Iraq or Afghansitan YET!!!!!

a friend of mine

in the CA Guard has been to Iraq

"The more I study science, the more I believe in God."     Einstein

40th ID? I have not seen

40th ID? I have not seen them on the deployment rolls. As a matter of fact, I have looked and found:

1.)  the Red Bulls of MINN/IOWA three times,

2.)Rainbows of NYonce,

3.) The 442nd of Hawaii once,

4.) T-pathcers of Texas once,

5.) The Tough Hombres of New Mexico  once,

6.)  The Electric Sunset of Oregon once.

7.) And the Thunderbirds of the 45 ID

but no Sunbursts of the 40th ID.

Did you get OPCON'd to any of the other units?
Regardless, the CA National Guards largest unit is NOT deployed at this point.

Hen Wax man

 PROUD AMERICAN

Wouldn't be ironic, if the WAX man went to Iraq and his nose was supposed to be protected by the GENTLEMAN of Blackwater. I would simply LMAO

 

In our dreams!

if only.....................