‘Nightly News’ Leads With ‘Jena 6,’ Ignores Beaten White Kid

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
By Noel Sheppard | September 21, 2007 - 12:36 ET

When members of the Duke University lacrosse team were falsely accused of raping a black stripper last year, media focused great attention on the woman in the middle of the controversy, and the supposed crime.

Yet, as pointed out Thursday by NewsBuster Matthew Balan, as the press report activities in Jena, Louisiana, the name of the white boy who was beaten by the "Jena 6," Justin Barker, is rarely mentioned, and the assault which precipitated the arrest of the "6" is either ignored, or downplayed.

Such was certainly the case on Thursday's "Nightly News" which led with the day's civil rights protests in Jena, but, for all intents and purposes, ignored the assault which precipitated the arrests of the six students in question.

Ironically, NBC's Brian Williams began the broadcast:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓
"Even though a lot of Americans still don't know the story of what happened in the small town of Jena, Louisiana, tonight thousands of Americans have converged on that town."

Well, Brian, Americans who watched your broadcast last evening still don't know the story of what happened in this small town because you and your correspondents didn't mention Justin Barker's name, and severely downplayed what the Jena 6 were arrested for.

Here's how correspondent Martin Savidge described the issue at hand:

The journey to Jena began 13 months ago when white students at the local high school hung nooses from a shade tree after an African-American student asked to sit beneath it. Over the next few months, there were verbal and finally physical confrontations. In the end, six black students were charged with crimes, initially including attempted murder. But no whites, not even those who admitted hanging the nooses. Seventeen-year-old Mychal Bell was the first to go to trial and found guilty. Last week his conviction was overturned, but the high school football star remains in jail.

Amazingly, Savidge didn't mention Barker, nor the fact that he was allegedly beaten by the six boys in question. However, the name of the person found guilty was prominently displayed.

Sadly, ABC didn't do a much better job. With this also the lead story of Thursday's "World News with Charlie Gibson," the anchor glossed over the seriousness of the beating in question (from closed captioning):

Tensions escalated, until the day six black students attacked a white student. The students were arrested, charged with serious crimes.

ABC's Terry Moran downplayed the crimes:

Six, black teenagers, some minors, charged as adults, after a schoolyard fight that resulted in no serious injuries.

The good folks at NBC and ABC should not only be ashamed of their casual treatment of the attack on Justin Barker, but also should be humiliated by being outdone by their competitor at CBS.

After all, during the "Evening News's" coverage of the events in Jena, CBS News national correspondent Byron Pitts at least had the decency of informing viewers of the crime the Jena 6 were accused of:

Soon protests lead to fistfights, a school building set on fire. And finally, six black students stomped and beat a white classmate unconscious. They were charged with attempted murder.

Unfortunately, even CBS chose not to put a name and a face on the person who was attacked.

As a result, it once again seems that media in our nation, when it comes to stories surrounding race, aren't interested in merely reporting the events. Instead, underlying virtually every article and news segment involving such delicate matters is a desire to inflame racial tensions in our society rather than assist in quelling them.

Such was certainly the case in how Hurricane Katrina was reported in 2005, how the Duke lacrosse "rape" was covered in 2006, and how the Don Imus and Jena 6 stories have been presented this year.

Makes one wonder how much better race relations would be in America if media weren't always doing their darnedest to fan the fires of discontent.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I'm confused

I'm confused, yall. Didn't Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson and 50,000 protesters AND MEDIA  go down to Jena to make sure that these 6 young men were given a fair trial and then convicted and hung for their beating of this other young man? Huh? Huh? Huh? Huuuuuhhhhhh?

Now wait a minute;;;;I thought thats what they did at Puke University!!!!! WHAT! YOU SAY IT WAS JUST THE OPPOSITE?????

My word;;;that would not be racism would it? No, I didn't think so;;;;just listen to the media. 

As screwed up as this case

As screwed up as this case in La. is look at the larger
problem.

Watch your crime pages. They will say the robber had a white
shirt on with black pants and a New York Yankee hat on, but some how the color
of that person is NEVER MENTIONED.       

Look I don’t want it slanted toward the white, just tell it
like it!!

Just report it all..

My examples:

3 Duke white (innocent) men reportedly rape black woman=
racist.

White athletes raping woman= national news! NON-STOP,24/7.

 

As many as 10 Black athletes raping a Hispanic  child= barely local new. This happened
in July 2006!!! Have you heard of it???

http://www.gwinnettdailyonline.com/GDP/archive/articleDDF6CC244326420E9EBF2111FC492485.asp

 

http://www.blackamericaweb.com/site.aspx/bawnews/rapecase711

 

While I was looking on the internet I found this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wichita_Massacre

(has any one heard of this?? Not me and watch the news all
the time..)

 

How may people have heard or remember this story????

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1403529/posts

 

Or horror of horrors: No national coverage!!!!!!!!!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Channon_Christian_and_Christopher_Newsom

 

Now because of the race merchants Jackson, Sharpton we hear
this.

 

 

Kids sitting under the “white tree” racist.

Kids suspended (and should have) for hanging a noose in a
tree racist.

Six black kids beat up white kid, not racist??

 

One of the speakers at the rally said:

"We're nonviolent when people are nonviolent with
us," one speaker said. "We're not nonviolent with people that are
violent with us.

Hey dumb ass, 6 black kids beat a white kid until he was
unconscious.

 

And before you trolls start with me, my best friend is black
and we spent the better part of a week fishing about 6 weeks ago. As well as he
was in my wedding party.

These are the boys of Pointe du Hoc.
Ronald Reagan- 40th Anniversary of D-Day

Duke rape case: 2,060,000..

Duke rape case: 2,060,000.. that is 2 million..pages on Google  

 

Fresno City college football
team rape:345,000 pages on Google.

 

Murder of Channon Christian
and Christopher Newsom: 47,900 pages on Google

 

Wichita Massacre murder: 533,000 pages on Google

 

Jena 6 (are you ready for
this).. 5,080,000 pages on Google

 

What are we missing here??

These are the boys of Pointe du Hoc.
Ronald Reagan- 40th Anniversary of D-Day

One Crime

There was only one crime committed in Jena, LA.  That was the crime that was committed when Justin Barker got beat up.  If Justin was black and got beat up by 6 white kids I would expect this circus, but Jesse and Al are on the offense trying to spare these 6 from the justice that is due them.  They are trying to intimidate the law enforcement officials.

Law enforcment needs to sit tight and wait for the circus to leave town then do what the law requires.  The DA needs to file charges for assualt and battery and a hate crime, if Louisianna has such a thing. It is time someone stands up to the race merchants. Send them packing.

“Government’s first duty is to protect the people, not run their lives.”  Ronald Reagan

From what I've heard there

From what I've heard there were other fights going on between white and black students, but they were typical schoolyard fights between two students and the matters were handled within the school. I think that when you have two folks beating each other up, you have a fight. When you have six guys beating up one guy, that's a different situation.

Hate Crime?

What if it had been 6 white kids and a (name your race) student instead? Where is JJ and Sharpton for the white kid?

This kid had nothing to do with the nooses hung in the tree.  He was in the wrong place, at the wrong time, and the wrong color.

Why are these kids not charged with a hate crime also? Oh I'm sorry, only those of color can be discriminated against.  How non-liberal of me to think this way.  Now I will be called a bigot for pointing to the obvious.

Sounds like racism is on the other foot to me.

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

DOWN WITH WHITEY DOWN WITH

DOWN WITH WHITEY DOWN WITH THE WHITE BLUE EYED DEVILS BEEN KEEPIN US DOWN FOR 500 YEARS

I can almost guarantee that some of this has been said during these protests. One comment I have seen compared this atmosphere to that of the 50's and 60's. Please. These protests yesterday and today are nothing more than 6 delinquents trying to avoid their just punishment.

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

 I know... I detest the

 I know... I detest the "Dixie" Chicks too..  they give Dixie a bad name.

If you don't stand behind our troops; please feel free to stand in front of them!

"The journey to Jena

"The journey to Jena began..."  Instead of "13 months ago" why dident he just go back a little farther? Like 200 years ago? When these young lads forefathers were wrenched from their homeland of Africa by brutal white slave traders?

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Jena

I can't tell if you're being sarcastic, but in case you're one of the people that learned their History from Alex Hailey, I'll point out to you that there is no evidence that Whites EVER "wrenched" anyone from their African homeland.

The "capture" of slaves was done by their fellow Africans.

It's funny just how wrong someone can be with facts when distributing propaganda.

The only racism I see are in

The only racism I see are in the faces of the protesters. So if someone is black than they are automatically innocent like OJ and "Tookie Williams". When has anyone seen a crowd like that calling for the release of a white guy?

Jena

I don't know where to begin.  Going by what Savidge said, hanging a noose from a tree is equal to a gang beating someone enough that they have to be hospitalized!

The insinuation is, of course, that the white students are to blame.  Can you imagine if six whites beat up a black student!  So much for a colorblind society.

Who is it that keeps

Who is it that keeps reminding us about the "racism" in America?

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

This is a perfect example

This is a perfect example of why I included the MSM in my list of culprits in the alleged deteriorating race relations we hear about so much. They are harming our society by their biased reporting. They are inciting and provoking people with misinformation.

Actually, race-relations are better now than they were when I was a kid. I have black, white and hispanic relatives...this would have been unheard of a generation ago.

Stories like this, and like Duke, and like the Imus fiasco, emphasize the tabloidization of the MSM and demonstrate how dangerous the media can be in the wrong hands.

Any media outlet using this story to incite racial strife and gin up emotions, whether it's for political reasons or for mere ratings/sales, is an enemy of American civilization.

Well Jackson and Sharpton

Well Jackson and Sharpton gota holt of another "incident" to keep racisim alive in America. Just great!

They obviously needed somthing after the Duke Lacrosse fiasco where they got their candy asses kicked by the *gulp* TRUTH!

God bless these race baiters! Without their ilk, America would have to struggle by without an oppressed minority. What a shame that would be.

Nooses schmooses, that black kid shoulda tied yellow ribbons around the nooses on the tree and sat there anyhow. He would have made laughing stocks out of the noose punks.

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Or even better, put an old

Or even better, put an old tire in it and given himself a tire swing to hang around on.

Frankly, I think just the

Frankly, I think just the fact that they call these guys "the Jena 6" gives them a cachet that is unseemly, to say the least. Wasn't it in the days of the civil rights marches that they used to talk about "the Montgomery 7" or "the Selma 5" or something like that? Am I mistaken? Is this an attempt to create an illusion of a group of discriminated-against young black men?

The Jena 6 incident is going to set race relations back 20 years

Which is what I believe the liberal MSM wants.

Both Al Sharpton & Jesse Jackson have been steadily losing influence in recent years. This ludicrous liberal MSM-manufactured incident is going to be the vehicle they will use to attempt to regain it.

Based on the abject ignorance I have seen displayed on the part of the "protesters" down in LA, along witht the disinformation being purpousely spread by the MSM, it just may work for them, too.


When I'm president, privatization is off the table because it's not the answer to anything.
-Hillary Rodham, September 3, 2007 AARP Legislative Conference.

Awimawe!

"The lyin' roars tonight..."

Sinking to new lows.

"... after a schoolyard fight that resulted in no serious injuries."

It's statements like this that disgust me the most about the way most of the media is handling this situation. The attack in no way, shape, form, or fashion was merely a "schoolyard fight". But, much like the Duke incident, we can't let facts get in the way of a good story.

In the end, six black

In the end, six black students were charged with crimes, initially including attempted murder. But no whites, not even those who admitted hanging the nooses.

The quote above is what concerns me most.  If I understand the story here it was the 6 black kids that beat up the white kid.  Perhaps attempted murder may be an extreme charge, but that can be worked out in the courts, I don't know the extent of the injuries.  The big question insinuated here is that the white kid should also be arrested.  For what?   I think the media should try and gives us the facts of the case and not try to create a controversy. 

It will be interesting to

It will be interesting to see how this sorts out. The outcome that should occurr is that the so-called Jena 6 are tried and convicted. If that doesn't happen, expect one or more of these same black men to committ other crimes with excalating violence and mayhem. If you don't think this is a valid prediction, look at the FBI crime statistcs. Black men committ the MAJORITY of the crime in America. While the black race represents just under 13% of the population. 50% of the crimes are committed by them. In regards to the Duke case, note that the woman who accussed the LaCross players of crimes is still walking free. She was never charged with any crime even though she lied to the police and made up false charges.

Don't you get it?  Al and

Don't you get it?  Al and Jesse are smart guys... they know they don't have the power to change this statistic by reducing the number engaged in crimes without reducing their potential future income. So they're trying to fudge the numbers by discouraging people from reporting, prosecuting, and convicting criminals solely on the basis of race.

Moral relativism

Moral relativism in action.  Right or wrong depends on the race of the perpetrator and race of the victim. Years ago "liberals" ripped the blinfold from the face of lady justice and assaulted the Constitution of the United States of America. 

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

No ABC,NBC,CBS or CNN for me

I suppose the only way to get the truth is to do everything but watch these networks and their trained goons.  FOX once in awhile has problems but on the whole I believe it to be the most fair in reporting.  However, talk radio still rocks!!!

They beat (almost to death) a kid

And the one who was beaten (almost to death) was not even involved in the original provocation.

Rev. Al is alsways fighting for the double standard.

This is the dream that Rev. King had?

 



The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back!  Fred08.com

Ja Rule is Angry

Ja Rule is just Angry because this chick kicked his butt. ;-)

ABC's Terry Moron: "Six,

ABC's Terry Moron: "Six, black teenagers, some minors, charged as adults, after a schoolyard fight that resulted in no serious injuries."  A "schoolyard fight"?  Six thugs attack and beat a person, and Terry Moron calls the mauling a "schoolyard fight"!!!  ROTFLMAO!!!  "[N]o serious injuries" according to whom?  Terry Moron?  I've seen the photos of the victim, and he had a hell of lot more serious injuries than someone sprayed with a water pistol.  Should we be happy that Terry Moron is "reporting" on these six thugs rather than "reporting" on Washington politics or the 2008 election?

look at the facts

first of all the victim threw out racial slurs at the attackers and # 2 he coudlnt have been that hurt if he went to a party the same night.

i absoultely agree that the boys who beat him up should be brought to justice as should the young men who hung those nooses but i believe that as always the punishment should fit the crime

attempted murder? really? k probably the district attorney told those boys that he could take their life away with the stroke of his pen well he did by trying them as adults which is a travesty of the law considering the nature of the crime. and the age of the accused and the instigation behind it ,these boys are obviously minors and now that they are being charged in juvie , justice for the victim can push through without making his attackers victims as well.

if someone calls me a nigger, a name i dont allow my friends to call me you can bet id beat some ass!

hanging those nooses was racially motivated and tension in Jena arose from it, in the opinion these boys were protecting their civil rights which while living in Jena was greatly hampered

i think we should look at other instances in jena to back up the claim of racial tension and if we look at what happened when a white man in Jena held up a shotgun to some black teens and threatened to kill them it is obvious that my claim is true , in this case the boys took the shotgun from him and refused to give it back, and were charged with robbery

look at the facts dont approach this with ignorance, knowledge is the key to understanding what in all truth is going on in Jena, watch the newws and see all the events that that have taken place but not been publized to us, its all about the context clues

 

}}---> We don't get the facts

It's only after weeks of uproar that the building blocks start to be uncovered.  And the links among victims of various attacks are never made clear.

It seemed for about three weeks a new "they did this before we did that" was dropped onto the canvas.

All I can deduce from this ball of wax is that a cowardly incident involving nooses was wrongly treated more as a prank than a crime.  And a boy was beaten by a group of six cowards.  There still hasn't been any information to link the beaten boy to the noose incident.

There was little said about the two other times the predominantly White community made sure their football star Mychal Bell skated on charges.

I think there's lots we don't know.  That's the nature of racebaiting in America.

~LYDSEXICS UNTIE!~

}}---> Then there's Mellencamp

Just sat through John Mellencamp's latest offering JENA. Caution: Not for young children or human beings.  His message is obvious and heavy handed.

He had to go back to 1960 to get most of his footage, but we're expected to believe the whole town is as a few acted.

~LYDSEXICS UNTIE!~

Ashamed in La

From what I have heard, 

The kid that was beaten was not involved in the noose hangings

The kids that were involved with the noose hangings were disciplined by the school, suspensions, are my understanding.

If I heard right, the beating started with the kid being knocked unconscious using a bar bell bar?

The protesters were intimidating the locals whom did not ask them to come.

And last, but not least, the trial hasn't even played out. Their are many assumptions that nobody can validate, not the protesters or me.

Living here in La we are all pretty disgusted by the way this has played out. Let the law run its course. If anyone is so delusional to think that the violence should go unpunished, I sincerely hope that they receive the next unprovoked beating. If you want to argue that the noose hangers were not punished enough, well fine that is a valid argument. But don't think for a second it justifies the beating this young man took. I am very concerned that if the protesters don't let the law run it's course, then this will only expand. Knowing the leaders of this mob, maybe that is what they are hoping for.

What is truly unfortunate in my opinion, is there seemed to be a certain amount of segregation that was common at this school. The school and the parents of most of these young men should be fully ashamed of themselves for the level of bigotry achieved here.

Hil-liar-y

What I find amazing is that when Al Sharpton asked Hillary about this incident her response wasn't in ebonics.

Such a shame...

Look at this article:

<a>http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/law/09/20/roland.martin.jena6/index.html</a>

Yet another journalist tries to downplay the actions of the Jena 6. Not only that but suggests that the rally held by Sharpton and Jackson was about equal justice.

Here's my take on things. Martin Luther King Jr praised pacifism. He fought segregation and racism with nonviolence. I do not believe that he would lead a protest in defense of six black men who ruthlessly stomped and beat a white man, no matter what that white man may have said or done to provoke it. Sharpton and Jackson are obviously not MLK Jr and are not even interested in carrying on his teaching of non-violent protest to victims of racism. Instead it seems that they are so consumed with trying to etch themselves into the pages of history that they don't care if they go against the very principles that made the Civil Rights Movement successful. They organize protests that I am sure Martin Luther King Jr would not stand behind. They put their own radical beliefs before the teachings of a man who paved the way to the end of segregation. They feed on the ignorances of people who don't even know their own history, telling them that they should be exonerated for defending their race through violence. The Civil Rights Movement ended just 39 years ago and yet the courage, strength, and dedication of the people who made it all possible is already forgotten. Instead, 6 teenagers who could not keep their cool and end racial tension through education and pacificism are now the Media Icons of Racial Equality.

Sounds about right for the world that we are living in these days.

 

Jena who?

How about this one? On a Cleveland TV station they had a reporter interviewing one of the participants in the support march for Jena that took place in Cleveland.  The reporter ask a female participant why she was there and she said "I just hope things turn out all right for her!"

Huh? This girl had absolutely no clue as to what Jena was! Yet these braindeads are marching in support of it - or her - or whatever!

The left is driven by delusion.

"Yeah, that's the ticket!" - Tommy Flanagan

Biased Media Stokes Jena Fires

BIASED LIBMEDIA STOKES JENA FIRES

How many times have we seen some 200 pound unmarried black woman
screaming or crying when her (known local thug-fornication baby) teen
is finally and naturally arrested for something very serious?
If you read the incomplete intentionally biased Baton Rouge Morning
Advocate (9.22.07) you can't find in the 25 or so race-pandering
paragraphs any mention of this teen's prior offenses. Don't even look.
Instead you get the pandering liberal template where this football star
with a bright college future is somehow a victim (surprise, surprise,
surprise) as Gomer would say. Did I mention knocking someone out off
the field is thugish?
Those unsettling details should be included if the paper is going to
pander anyway. How about telling the whole story? Talk about racism...
if a white troubled gifted thug-ballplayer slammed (was uninvolved) a
black teen head into a wall to send him to the hospital... would the
libmedia be writing these cupcake articles? That is why the libmedia is
part of the problem, part of many national problems, while pretending
they are so objective. Who do they think they are fooling?

Doug Schexnayder, Ph.D. (theconservativecrawfish)