2007 Hurricane Forecast Reduced, Will Media Care?

Photo of Noel Sheppard.

In May, when the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration predicted an above average hurricane season, the media reported the announcement with a vigor.

Two months later, with no serious hurricanes yet hitting the mainland, a private forecaster has reduced its tropical storm expectations.

Less hurricanes should be good news, especially for folks along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts, right? Shouldn't this get aggressively disseminated by media outlets that certainly have a public service responsibility?

Before we get there, the following was reported by Reuters Tuesday evening (emphasis added):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The 2007 hurricane season may be less severe than forecast due to cooler-than-expected water temperatures in the tropical Atlantic, private forecaster WSI Corp said on Tuesday.

The season will bring 14 named storms, of which six will become hurricanes and three will become major hurricanes, WSI said in its revised outlook. WSI had previously expected 15 named storms of which eight would become hurricanes and four would become major hurricanes.

"Because the ocean temperatures have not yet rebounded from the significant drop in late spring, we have decided to reduce our forecast numbers slightly," said Todd Crawford, a WSI seasonal forecaster.

[…]

WSI's Crawford added that wind conditions due to the lack of an El Nino event were less conducive to formation of tropical storms.

Now, compare that to NOAA's May 22 announcement (emphasis added):

"For the 2007 Atlantic hurricane season, NOAA scientists predict 13 to 17 named storms, with seven to 10 becoming hurricanes, of which three to five could become major hurricanes of Category 3 strength or higher," said retired Navy Vice Adm. Conrad C. Lautenbacher, Ph.D., undersecretary of commerce for oceans and atmosphere and NOAA administrator. An average Atlantic hurricane season brings 11 named storms, with six becoming hurricanes, including two major hurricanes.

Climate patterns responsible for the expected above normal 2007 hurricane activity continue to be the ongoing multi-decadal signal (the set of ocean and atmospheric conditions that spawn increased Atlantic hurricane activity), warmer-than-normal sea surface temperatures in the Atlantic Ocean and the El Niño/La Niña cycle.

Last year, seasonal hurricane predictions proved to be too high when an unexpected El Niño rapidly developed and created a hostile environment for Atlantic storms to form and strengthen. When storms did develop, steering currents kept most of them over the open water and away from land.

"There is some uncertainty this year as to whether or not La Niña will form, and if it does how strong it will be," said Gerry Bell, Ph.D., lead seasonal hurricane forecaster at NOAA's Climate Prediction Center. "The Climate Prediction Center is indicating that La Niña could form in the next one to three months. If La Niña develops, storm activity will likely be in the upper end of the predicted range, or perhaps even higher depending on how strong La Niña becomes. Even if La Niña does not develop, the conditions associated with the ongoing active hurricane era still favor an above-normal season."

As can be plainly seem, so far, NOAA has been dead wrong, as its prediction that water temperatures would rise has not panned out. You would think this should be newsworthy, as this May 22 announcement was covered by media for days.

Leading the hurricane charge was CBS News, which not only discussed the pending announcement during the "Early Show" that morning, but highlighted the forecast during its "Evening News" tease that night, and followed not only with a full report on NOAA's predictions, but also a piece on how New Orleans isn't ready for the upcoming season.

The following morning, NOAA's forecast was reported during the "CBS Morning News," as was New Orleans' lack of preparedness. Shortly after, the announcement was covered again on the "Early Show."

NBC was just as focused on this report, as the May 22 "Today" show actually began with a detailed report concerning the pending announcement. I kid you not.

Later that day, Brian Williams actually began his "Nightly News" tease and the program with this announcement, both coming prior to coverage of the agreement reached in Congress that day to continue funding the war in Iraq!

The following morning, the "Today" show repeated the information.

For its part, ABC also previewed the imminent release of this forecast on the May 22 "Good Morning America." Charles Gibson reported the actual announcement that evening on "World News," as did "Good Morning America" the following day.

With that in mind, as the news concerning this hurricane season appears to be improving given this recent forecast out of WSI, will the media feel it important to share with the public?

Or, might such a revelation once again point to just how difficult it is to predict weather events months away, thereby making it even more preposterous for anthropogenic global warming alarmists to suggest that computer models can actually forecast climate into the mid and latter parts of this century?

Stay tuned.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Thank You Dr. Gore!!!!!

The reason for the downgraded forecast is because of a decrease in GH gasses from SUVs, the fact that over 100 people are using less toilet paper than before, Al Gore's carbon offsets and over seven Hollywood celebrities have gone to CF lightbulbs in their mansions.  All proof that Gore's policies are in fact working and that we should all vote democrat in November, 2008.  But, mind you, if we do have any hurricanes, it's because Bush did not sign Kyoto. 

You got that right!

Blame Bush rules...and if AG does receive that doctorate (has he already and I haven't heard) SHAME on the university that bestows it!

Melting Glaciers are Cooling the Atlantic .......GW reason 118

No..No...Dudes, GW has melted the Ice up north and all that melting ICE cooled the Atlantic, and then that caused the hurricanes to Dissappear....Right ?

I realize this is Good news caused by GW enthusiates, but ya gotta still explain the Hurricane Season in Terms of GW, after all, GW causes everything....uhhh...uhhhh..Unless Al Gore visits a Volcano in the next Year or so, and then it's gonna be Lava is gonna Bury you by 2099, and we have to put Glaciers in the Volcano cones to cool off the impending eruptions.  

It all has to make sense to the "liberal" mind.....  

  

 What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

Jay Tee

JT,

Actually, if you recall, that was indeed the entire premise of "The Day After Tomorrow." :-) ns

Noel........Movies are Fiction and so is Hollywood

nOeL......are you saying we have been "pre-disposed" via the movie Industry to accept the GW theories ? 

 I thought the Movie was a Comedy....maybe it was "Future Documentary" of GW.   

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

That was funny!

Loved that one.  Had to share it with some friends.

Never argue with an idiot.  They'll drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.

 <cue music from The

 <cue music from The Twilight Zone>

Are we stuck in a time loop?  Isn't this the exact same scenario as last year's hurricane season predictions?  I seem to recall predictions of a higher-than-average to record season prediction for number of storms/hurricanes/major hurricanes, all due to global warming, and these early predictions were shouted all over the news.  When the predictions were reduced, barely a whisper.  And, at the end of the season, the lack of storms was also blamed on global warming.

It's deja vu all over again.

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

Yeah, and then they had the

Yeah, and then they had the gall to blame El Nino for "blowing the tops off the hurricanes before they gathered strength" So now that El Nino is subsided again what's the excuse??? LIARS every damn one of them. Agenda! Agenda! Agenda! The war drums beat on...

You can't save the Earth unless You're willing to make other people sacrifice. Dogbert the Green Consultant summing up the elite left.

Okay, so back in April this

Okay, so back in April this numbnut  says to look for an active 2007 hurricane season. He’s the same buffoon that predicted a big 2006 season. Guess his "guru" status may be in jeopardy.

These "gurus" only reinforce the fact that the predictions of "global warming" are only that, predictions. And actually as the facts roll in, spurious predictions at that. They can't can't figure out what is going to happen within a few months and we're supposed to believe these "experts" on what is coming in 10 years???

Cooler than expected water??? What the …! The Rove weather machine again I guess.

"All generalizations are false, including this one.” Mark Twain

This really is good news,

This really is good news, but let's talk in mid-November or so. The hurricane season is far from over, and the historically-most-intense months are still to come...
JMR

Sarc

J,

So, we can't talk about this now? Why?

Furthermore, if you believe reduced forecasts should be boycotted, shouldn't all forecasts be ignored?

I seem to remember you making this same "Let's wait until November" argument last year at this time as forecasts were being reduced. Do you disagree with my recollection?

The reality is, Sarc, that I believe quite sincerely that since Katrina, these folks in this industry are skewing their data to the upside not only to make headlines, but to protect themselves for underestimates.

After all, if they come out with tame predictions that end up being shy of reality, that would likely be lambasted by media much more so than over-predicting and being wrong. Would you agree? ns

I agree!

even if Sarc doesn't!

No, go ahead and talk, but

No, go ahead and talk, but just keep in mind that the part of the season we've seen so-far is the part (like late in the season) that would tend on average to produce weaker (but still scary) storms. To each his own, but F=MV squared, and I start paying attention when V exceeds 100mph. And yes, I say that every time there's a slow start to the season. Sometimes, like last year, I'm wrong, and sometimes, as with Hurricane Andrew, I'm also righter-than-I-wanted-to-be. That's the reality, or at least how I recall it. If I'm somehow being inconsistent, I fail to see it, as all I'm really predicting again is stronger storms in the middle part of the season, and that's historically been a pretty safe one.
JMR

And Camile came ashore on

And Camile came ashore on Aug 17th. Betsy was Sept 9th. I danced with both of those ladies.

Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of truth and knowledge will be shipwrecked by the laughter of the Gods. Albert Einstein

Noel Maybe it's because

Noel Maybe it's because I've been through too many of these things. IMHO These guys aren't that good at predicting these things or seasons.  One way or the other. (When they're right it's a suprise.) Seems people who don't live with hurricanes and warmers think they're better than they are.

Please keep pointing out the hype. Every year the bad storm is supposed to hit us. Every time we get a tropical storm you'd think we were dealing with a cat 5. Tropical storm means turn over the light lawn furniture, take in the trash can, and don't plan to go boating or on a picnic. Maybe check the flash lights. And keep an eye on it in case it intensifies a lot.

Maybe I'm supersticious. But the real storm season isn't for 2-3 weeks more. And will last into october maybe november for those farther south.

Though the cooler Atlantic and gulf is a good sign, but with the bad track record. I'd rather not predict one way or the other.

Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of truth and knowledge will be shipwrecked by the laughter of the Gods. Albert Einstein

You just might be a RedNeck...iF

One Exception Danbo....

If you live behind a Levy to keep out Lake Poncetrane, and you Live behind a Levy to keep out the Mississippi, and you live behind a Levey to keep out the Gulf of Mexico, You just might be a Redneck livng in the WRONG Place.       

 

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

Nope. I'm a coona$$ not a

Nope. I'm a coona$$ not a redneck.

I don't live behind a levee. But using that logic we'll have to move everyone inland about 60 miles along all coasts. Everyone off rivers. (There are far more levees along rivers than on the gulf or lake.) Everyone living on or near a geologic fault should be forced to move. Including much of the midwest because of the Mississippi, Ohio rivers and the New Madrid fault. Everyone living in a tornado area should move. And all the people of Holland should move to Germany. The little bit of land safe from nature (if there is one) will be real crowded.

Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of truth and knowledge will be shipwrecked by the laughter of the Gods. Albert Einstein

St. Louis only has one Levee....

Danbo....How about if you live behind a Levee thinking the Govt. is going to take care of you  ?

People living in Calif. on the Fault line.....need to stock food for a Disaster....people living behind a Levee, need to have an ESCAPE Plan...etc..eTc...

Plan for where you live.......or play the Blame Game.  I still can't understand why I'm still hearing about Housing Problems for Catrina Victims...how long will it go on....?    

 

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

I'm not expecting the

I'm not expecting the government to take care of us. This is our home. I expect us to rebuild. I would like the same amout of help that would be given any other part of the country in a national disaster. Noting more nothing left.

The people rebuilding the coast and Louisiana are the people living here. It's been a long time and will take a long time. Just as I suppose will happen after the next San Francisco quake. And people are still living in trailers as they work to rebuild.

The truth is anyone who wants to return to rebuild, can. I have to question if those who haven't returned yet want to.  We have a lot more to do.

There are some people who are waiting for us to rebuild. then go get them and move them home. But when I see people living a hundred miles away coming home every weekend to rebuild their homes.

I don't wish this on anyone. but I hope the people waiting for us to rebuild stay where ever they are. I'd rather have the illegal Mexicans as neighbors.

Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of truth and knowledge will be shipwrecked by the laughter of the Gods. Albert Einstein

Sarc does have a point.  

Sarc does have a point.   http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20070725/sc_nm/weather_hurricanes_dc;_ylt=AuLmh7Zi4.xARNRDh7pr0OCs0NUEBut  The first couple weeks of August should give us a better picture of what the season will really hold.  However, the fact that WSI has revised it's prediction and apparently Gray is coming out on Aug 3rd with his revised forecast.  In any event, AGW doesn't have squat to do with Hurricanes.  

 

“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane"

Noel, As we native

Noel,

As we native Floridans (and danbo should be included here with his first hand experience of hurricanes) know, the "mean season" doesn't really heat up until August.  August and September are the months where the killer storms get cranked up.  Once we get to Columbus day, it's usually downhill.

October storms (and later) usually head south due to the steering currents at that time of year.  Wilma (October 26th) hit the Yucatan at CAT 4, then veered back across Florida.  It was the oddest track in years. 

Your points about the hype are spot-on (remember Tropical Fizzle Ernesto here?).  For crying out loud, they named a tropical wave this year, just to add to the fear factor (and perhaps to hype AGW???).

This is a little off topic, but I found an absolutely amazing map on the Weather Channel.  Here's the link.  You can go to the main page of the Weather Channel, then Select Other Maps.  Choose the Interactive Weather Map. Position the cursor over your area, and keep zooming in.  This is a satellite photo mosaic overlaid with weather data.  When you zoom in far enough, you can see the cars in your driveway.  It's really cool.  I suspect the photo mosiac is about six months old....my neighbor just had a new driveway put in and the old one is in the pic.  Where I live, if I zoom over to the right a bit, I can see pretty good detail of the reefs and stuff.  Enjoy.

 

Has Karl been under the

Has Karl been under the weather lately?

 

Hysterical

Rog your next stop is Def Comedy Jam.

Karl Rove's Weather Machine

Karl Rove's Weather Machine has been working overtime to hold off those pesky hurricanes.  Good news though is all that overtime pay has really boosted the economy in the Virgin Islands (just east and a little south of Puerto Rico).  Take the link and zoom in on Cramers Park on the east end of St. Croix, then switch to aerial view! -- heh heh

Too many hurricanes =

Too many hurricanes = global warming

Too few hurriccanes = global warming

Average amount of hurricanes = global warming

Very cool summer here in NE USA = Global warming

Car needs new battery = Global warming

 

(Why am I on bold?)

 

This is bad news for AlGore

This is bad news for AlGore after the "Inconvenient Truth" won an Oscar and his big "Live Earth" concerts you just know he was waiting for a Hurricane to wipe out a city so he could end the year proving he's right about Global Warming.

*Sheehan-vs-Pelosi*
"This could get ugly"

*Sheehan-vs-Pelosi*

*Sheehan-vs-Pelosi*
"This could get ugly"

Throw in someone like Arnold S. and you have "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly"!

<pudum pum> He'll be here

<pudum pum>

He'll be here all week folks!  Try the Veal.

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

NS - Great observations!

"Or, might such a revelation once again point to just how difficult it is to predict weather events months away, thereby making it even more preposterous for anthropogenic global warming alarmists to suggest that computer models can actually forecast climate into the mid and latter parts of this century?"

When will they ever learn?  What other job in the world could be performed so poorly and still be considered as a reputable source of information???? 

I'm sure the generator manufacturers have been pleased with the predictions, but as you so aptly stated, IT REALLY ISN'T POSSIBLE TO SEE INTO THE FUTURE...when will those who are out there trying to scare everyone to death with global warming get the message?

The earth-huggers are in a

The earth-huggers are in a win-win situation.

When it gets hot, they say it's because of us.

When the weather cools off, its becasue of the "steps" taken to control global warming.

idiots

Champion for AGW---GMA's Sam Champion aka pretend climatologist

Did anybody catch Good Morning America's cheerleader for AGW Sam Champion?  To his credit, he did reported on the forecast for less named storms this season but did it quickly and spoke thru his teeth the whole ~25 second segment.  It was delicious to watch him begrudgingly discuss the cooler tropical waters of which he quickly jumped past and IMMEDIATELY went to the heat wave in the mid-west.  Here he elaborated on how HOT everything was and moreover, how some of these areas were 10-15 and even 20 DEGREES ABOVE NORMAL!!

 I still think it must be incredibly hot standing in front of all of those big screen monitors!

Surely.. it's caused by GW, Noel

Surely.. it's caused by GW, Noel. Give them a day or two. The cooling of the N. Atlantic sea must be caused by all of the ice melting in the arctic and Greenland, which of course is caused by my car (and my compost pile).. thus, fewer hurricanes this year is caused by GW. In other years, more hurricanes are caused by GW.

 When GMA talked about it

 When GMA talked about it this morning, I picked up on the "cooler than expected ocean temperatures."

Hmmmm, does that mean AG is wrong about global warming?

That darn sun just refuses to cooperate with the AGW crowd.

No RINOs in '08 - Thompson/Hunter would be a good ticket; Thompson/Steele would be a great ticket

Ah, come on Noel, we may as

Ah, come on Noel, we may as well just rub it in with the local forecasters who can't with any certainty predict the weather a week in advance.  What's the stats on a one week weather forecast being right?  Isn't something like 25%?

Now that the forecast is being revised, I demand a reduction of my property insurance!!!!!  These moron insurance programs factoring in the hurricane occurance is just plain faulty as the IPCC GCM computer models.  Both have the same result, fleecing of the public's pockets!  I demand an inquiry into this price gouging.

“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane"

What do you mean a week?

The sucker that does the local weather here can't even get it right 3 days out. Since I live only about 45 miles from the NC coast I don't care if we ever had another hurricane. Floyd did me in even though my property survived, many other properties around me didn't.

 

A bonafided and certified member of the beer guzzling, NASCAR watching middle class.

Solar Warming Destroys Hurricanes

What the Global Warming crowd does not want to face is hurricanes spawn along an equatorial zone which is now warmer from the solar radiation bandwidth and has created "dead air". Hurricanes require like all weather uneven heating and cooling of air OVER LAND. That land is Africa and that air is deadened as is the air over the oceans in that latitude.

By contrast the temperate zones with the air tidal waves of summer and winter heating and cooling over land are experiencing these fluctuations of unseasonal heat and unseasonal cool every other week. This is why London was flooding as the storm generation has moved into the temperate zones by solar energy.

So the "experts" have been proven wrong again. They were screaming remember of super storms in hurricanes and never took into account that the God created earth atmosphere has a failsafe to cutting off storm strength.

The only thing which is happening which is good is more water is falling in arid America as the sun is misting more vapor into the weather fronts coming in. As for England, God made floods too to cleanse the land of refuse and the silt from rivers actually rejuvenates the soils flooded.

All is working very well.

 

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

I remember back in May of

I remember back in May of this year when alarmists in the media were breathlessly reporting about subtropical storm Andrea.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/18573390/

Noel Sheppard Hit This One Out of the Park

Noel Sheppard pinned Big News Media down on this one.  They love to

scare the public over horrible predictions, but when it doesn't materialize

the same conviction vanishes into thin air.  Keep up the good work Noel.