Nightline Attacks ‘Edible Food-Like Substances’ in One-Sided Report

By Nathan Burchfiel | May 9, 2008 - 14:59 ET

Mother knows best?  Or journalist does?

ABC's "Nightline" seems to think so when it comes to nutrition advice. The May 8 broadcast featured health tips from a writer with no scientific background encouraging viewers to only eat food their mother would recognize.

Michael Pollan, a long-time opponent of "agribusiness" - the food industry - was featured in a segment on his new book, "In Defense of Food: And Eater's Manifesto." Pollan advocates a return to an all-organic diet and offers tips for healthy eating.

Pollan praised "the authority of mom" and lamented that "the holders of culture when it comes to food (mothers) have been undermined by both the scientists and the food marketers."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

"There is food and there is what I call ‘edible food-like substances,'" Pollan said. "These are things we invented in the last 50 years or so that, you know, smell like food, taste like food, look like food, but they're very different than the kinds of things people ate 100 years ago."

Reporter John Donvan gobbled it up. He joined in the attack on processed foods, calling them "the edible equivalent of waxed fruit." Donvan's segment offered no input from the food industry to defend itself, nor nutritionists who might disagree with Pollan's claims.

Donvan was so busy chewing the fat the Pollan he forgot to note that the journalism professor and contributor to The New York Times has no scientific background. Viewers wouldn't know that without reading supplemental coverage of the story on the ABC News Web site. Donvan also failed to mention Pollan's history of anti-industry work.

He recently railed against "decrepit food factories" in a piece published in The New York Times. In another Times report, Pollan praised rising food prices - a result of increased demand for corn as ethanol mandates hoard supply - because, he said, they will "level the playing field for sustainable food that doesn't rely on fossil fuels."

"People like their convenience food," he said. "But this experiment of outsourcing our food preparation to corporations has failed us. I mean it's left us really unhealthy and really unsatisfied and I think it's undermined family life and undermined community."

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

"Pollan praised rising food

"Pollan praised rising food prices..."

"Let them eat boutique farmed radicchio and artisanal camembert..."

I'm all for organic foods

I'm all for organic foods and whole foods, etc.  The problem is, when Liberals get involved in something that's basically good, or neutral, they always take it to an extreme, setting up simplistic good guy vs. bad guy scenarios, and the Capitalist always turns out to be the bad guy. There is no earthly reason why healthy foods can't be mass produced. 

Here's a good piece that would have brought some balance to that Nightline segment. (Which I watched - btw)

 

blanket condemnation

"...it's left us really unhealthy and really unsatisfied and I think it's undermined family life and undermined community..." We have amazingly long life spans. We have amazingly low child mortality. And it's all the 'fault' of the food industry. I'm confused.

I'm sure some of these preservatives and things are probably not the best thing for young growing bodies, but take a look at the kids in your neighborhood. Our yard apes are as healthy as they get. What's not healthy is the crap that passes as education today. It will rot your mind. He's a great example.

"Nothing is so bad it can't serve as a good example." anon.

Eddie Murphy praised his Mother's "Big Mac"...

...or something to the effect of all the kids on the street saying,"We got McDonald's..."

Here's the Video...What a riot!

http://www.youtube.c...

Moms know best!

Syrius

"...the dire consequences to society when people begin to believe that by
renaming someone to erase their humanity opens the door to the
devaluation of everyone's life..."-dscott

 

The outsourcing isn't the problem.

It's the bipartisan subsidy-spending addiction (see especially the excellent cartoon).
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.

Sar

Dont you know Manhattan farmers need it?So do Letterman and Scotty Pippen.Around where I live Developers are drawing farm subsidys.Pretty amazing.

http://theelectoralmap.com/2007/11/12/mapping-out-ridiculous-congressional-legislation/

Yes, that's why I liked

The cartoon. I don't think he could have made the pig any bigger. :) Let's pray my old prayer for a veto. Bush has nothing to lose and everything to gain from it.
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.

I agree

This is just another "vote for me" bill.

Production

Times report, Pollan praised rising food prices - a result of increased demand for corn as ethanol mandates hoard supply - because, he said, they will "level the playing field for sustainable food that doesn't rely on fossil fuels.

In past 23yrs we have cut our oil production in half. How much of our food is filling that demand today? Tomorrow?

JDW

If you mention ANWR it means you don't care about the environment but when congress says ANWR it means you don't care about the gasoline prices

 

Doesn't rely on fossil

Doesn't rely on fossil fuels? What are we going back to using oxen and plows for agriculture.

"They need to have a course in college called common sense and everyone should take it. Problem is there isn't too many people that could pass or teach it." -my grandfather

Maybe he means that we

Maybe he means that we should pay more for food, just like liberals say we should pay more for gas; then we wouldn't be so piggish.

Apparently he dislikes foods that "rely on fossil fuels" but he doesn't have a problem with fuels that rely on food....

More for gas

Libs have always wanted higher gas prices, they are just PO'd that "Big Oil" gets it instead of "Big Government" via taxes. 

"Big Government" makes far

"Big Government" makes far more on a gallon of gas than "Big Oil" does. The guv'mnt's just P.O.ed that they can't take all the profit for themselves (although they certainly will try!).

"the edible equivalent of

"the edible equivalent of waxed fruit." Wouldnt that just be fruit?


What doesn’t kill you, only makes you pissed off. -Children of Bodom  

I've mentioned this before

I've mentioned this before and this is a good post to mention it again. I like to cook and I used to read both Gourmet and Bon Appetit magazines every month. In the last couple of years, both magazines (Gourmet much more noticeably), have begun inserting a liberal/environmentalist political point of view in their stories - under the guise of "sustainable agriculture", "healthy food production", and the environment (yes, "Global Warming" is mentioned frequently). I began skipping issues where there was covert political content. However, I bought a Gourmet last month. When I opened it, there was a story covering the new Farm Bill moving through Congress, with Sen. Tom Harkin (D-Iowa) as it's authorative source. That was the straw that has broken the camel for me. It only proves the old addage that any organization or publication that doesn't start out specifically designed for conservatives will, in time, turn liberal - a freakin' cooking magazine, no less.

let's cash in, let's have a

let's cash in, let's have a chicken place that serves free-ranged fried chicken, and other home-grown soul-food fare. when customers want a chicken wing, serve only the left wing!

 

 

I hope you took it off your

I hope you took it off your "regular read" list!

They had a thing on Food Network the other night about Las Vegas and the new upscale restaurants opening there. One of the most popular, I think it was called "Wynn" features only organically grown and produced food...everything. The prices are outrageous, and apparently people willingly pay them. It's the new "in" thing.

 

 

mb,I just use

mb,

I just use www.epicurious.com now. It's their recipes without the editorial tripe. I guess the new editors decided they needed to make cooking more "socially relevant" - grrrrr.

I'm sure if Steve Wynn is connected to that restaurant, it's going to be "$$$$$".

With no scientific background?

Since when is that important?  Google: "Al Gore global warming farce" for more info.

MMMM-MMMM-Good

Foods Mom would recognize

Liver dumpling soup

Kiska(hurka) 

Kuchina (pigs feet)

head cheese, souse

Does this guy live in a fantasy world. Some of the stuff his Mom and or Grandma may have eaten probably would harden his arteries on site.

Anyone else have memories of  Mammas favorite foods

 

 

Beef Stroghanoff, chicken

Beef Stroghanoff, chicken and dumplings, cornbread and sausage dressing, peach cobbler... We used to tease my Mom that she must have made a deal with devil that if she made us kids fat she would stay thin her entire life (5'7" 115 lbs.) Man, I wish I could have some of her great cooking now...

Many

Tuna,peas and gravy over homemade biscuts.

Tuna casserole

Clam chowder

Sheperd pie.

Quiché with jalepenoes.

 

Visible news-like journalism

In another Times report, Pollan praised rising food prices - a result of increased demand for corn as ethanol mandates hoard supply - because, he said, they will "level the playing field for sustainable food that doesn't rely on fossil fuels."

Two points: 1) While ethanol is certainly a factor, food price increases are also being driven by another major factor, the increasing transportation expenses created by increasing fuel prices. 2) Unless you want to return to subsistence farming, wherein everyone is able to raise only enough to feed their own families, fossil fuels will continue to be a factor because food has to get to market.

Does Nightline produce visible news-like journalism?

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

Rain may reduce corn crop, drive up prices more

As if we're not getting enough bad news lately, the USDA says corn production could drop 7% this year because rain in the corn belt is keeping farmers from planting. That's 7% down from last year's record crop, but still, a smaller corn crop means even higher corn prices. What does it mean? Check out this paragraph from the AP story:

“Today’s report is an indicator that we’re going to
be living with very high corn prices for a very long time, at least
through the next crop year,” said Mark McMinimy, an agribusiness and
biofuels analyst with the Stanford Group in Washington.

 

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

i

I liked the content... shop the perimeters... but he forgot to add, if you're a vegetarian don't eat anything bigger than your head.

Live like times past and die like times past

"These are things we invented in the last 50 years or so that, you know,
smell like food, taste like food, look like food, but they're very
different than the kinds of things people ate 100 years ago.
"

And the people of 100 years ago usually died by the age of 60 from heart attacks, strokes, and food-born illness. I'll stick with today's food and live to a ripe old age of 80 or 90 or maybe even 100, thank you very much.

Is it just me or have others noticed that people tend to reminisce about the "good old days" without remembering all the bad those days use to bring? Organic farming is a good example. Today we have so many people trying to get back to the "good old days" of organic farming because it's supposed to be "healthier," only to hear about a huge increase in e-coli contaminations which is contributed to those same "organic" farms. Hello! Can't you see the forest through all those trees?

The "processed" food we eat today is a thousand times healthier than what was available 100 years ago. When is the last time you heard about a listeria outbreak, or salmonella, or dysentery, or trichinosis, or almost any other food born illness that killed people by the thousands just 100 years ago? Food born illness are rare today, unless it’s a contamination of e-coli which is usually contributed to “organic” foods cross-contaminating the processed foods. Don't you think that the sanitary food processing methods we employ today have something to do with it?

I agree, Cobra. Ditto

I agree, Cobra.

Ditto those terrible "preservatives." Granted, we should be careful about adding chemicals to foods, but I always ask people how they would like throwing away a loaf of bread every other day because it's turned into a dry brick? Or how do they think things like Cheerios even make it to the grocery stores without going stale, never mind stay edible once they get it home! We would not have the myriad food selections that we have without them!

Exactly

It's the ability to transport food around the world that has allowed more people to have better and healthier diets today than at any other time in human history.  Know anybody with goiter, rickets, scurvy, and other diseases that come from malnutrition and vitamin deficiencies?  These food Stalinists who only want us to eat what's locally grown and in season don't care that will drive up food prices and particularly leave the not-so-well-to-do vulnerable to all sorts of health problems.  Ideology trumps everything.

Beware people, the left wants to destroy our standard of living. 

Yep

"Beware people, the left wants to destroy our standard of living."

Yep, and starve over half the world to death in the process. How's that latte tasting now, Pollan?

Michael may celebrate, but

Michael may celebrate, but it is an ignorant celebration, on so many levels. The life span of humans has increased in the last 100 years, in large part because of the foods we eat and medical care. As a perspective, consider the average age of those past.

Classical Greece, 28
Classical Rome, 28
Medieval England, 33
1800's End of 19th Century, 37
1900's Early 20th Century, 50
1940's Circa 1940, 65
Current (in the West), 77-81

Having been born in 1955, he should be dead by now.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!