Newspapers Bristle at Thought of Liberalism Being Mocked in 'The Goode Family'

  • Bookmark and Share

ABC’s new series "The Goode Family" poking fun at liberalism and political correctness has predictably been greeted with disdain by the establishment media.

The running theme in reviews of the series is that it is unoriginal, flat, and not funny. Not that the folks at the New York Times and the San Francisco Chronicle are able to laugh at themselves, anyway…

The Times’s Ginia Bellafante said:

But the show feels aggressively off-kilter with the current mood, as if it had been incubated in the early to mid-’90s, when it was possible to find global-warming skeptics among even the reasonable and informed. Who really thinks of wind power — an allusion to which is a running visual gag in the show — as mindless, left-wing nonsense anymore?

The Chronicle’s Tim Goodman said:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Yes, making fun of people who shop at a market not unlike Whole Foods is pretty easy. Same goes for hybrid car drivers, liberals who tear themselves up over what to call minorities, recycling, etc. Too easy, really.

If it is so easy, why aren’t there any other shows on network television engaging such topics?

It’s easier for television networks to attack conservatives, like they do on "It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia," "30 Rock," "Rescue Me" and late night television.

Hybrid drivers, liberals who tear themselves up over what to call minorities, and Whole Foods shoppers have become the status quo—in Hollywood at least—so isn’t it pushing the envelope more to parody the progressive academics who can’t be seen in church than to throw up the same tired jokes about uptight Christian conservatives and their irrational belief in abstinence?

Just last month, Miss USA judge called Carrie Prejean a “dumb b****” for her views against gay marriage. CBS has been attacking her viciously over personal matters. After making an issue of Bristol Palin’s pregnancy during the election, CBS is still using her to attack abstinence.

So it is fitting that attitudes such as these are lambasted in "The Goode Family," where daughter Bliss’ parents are shocked to find that the "Purity Ball" they take her to involves a pledge of abstinence and where they are less concerned about her being exposed to the Pussycat Dolls than to “some sexually repressed religious fanatics.”

The dismissive attitudes of the Times and the Chronicle frame the comedic necessity of this show perfectly. As Ms. Bellafante’s review suggests, liberals think no “reasonable and informed” person should ever question the “scientific consensus” of manmade climate change. The left needs to lighten up. It’s refreshing to see a show that takes shots at these targets like no other show will.

UPDATE: NPR attacked it, too, here: "Mike Judge's Disappointing New Comedy."

—Mitchell Blatt is the editor of the foreign affairs blog Bombs and Dollars.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The left needs to lighten

    That's really funny.  In their attacks on the show they become the characters in the show.

  Exhibit A:   Who really thinks of wind power — an allusion to which is a running visual gag in the show — as mindless, left-wing nonsense anymore? 

   Talk about being clueless in a liberal bubble.

It's not "too easy" to make

It's not "too easy" to make fun of all that if you do it well, and Mike Judge usually does things well. 

(I would note, being a big 30 Rock fan, that Liz Lemon's hang-ups are mocked on the show, too, poking fun of her too-earnest, too-concerned ways. Balboa out.) 

No sense of humor

I know that this is not original and how many times does it need to be confirmed, Liberals do not have a healthy sense of humor. They only think something is funny if it mocks, derides, lambasts, insults or otherwise skewers only traditional or conservative values. I like South Park, they are equal opportunity offenders. When someone or some ideology takes oneselves too seriously it borders on the Insane. This country is now being run by a bunch of loons and the evidence is being supplied daily by the very oh so serious ones running this country into the ground.

The left is full of

The left is full of infantile bullies.

Its not nice to mock the mentally ill

:-^)

-Dave

I will continue

I will continue to mock any and all who deserve such mocking regardless of race, creed, gender, political persuasion or mental ability.

Hmmm.

The more they bitch about it, the more I want to see it. :>)

"This liberal would be all about socialize -- uh, uh, would be about basically taking over and the government running all of your companies."-Maxine Waters 2008

Hilarious Stuff

You have to read all the liberal quotes in the article to yourself using Rush Limbaugh's liberal voice, ie 'Mither Limba...'.

These people can become characters in next week's episode.

Remember, 9pm ET tonight. Sorry Shawn.

 Who really thinks of wind

 Who really thinks of wind power — an allusion to which is a running visual gag in the show — as mindless, left-wing nonsense anymore?

  Perhaps if the NYT was hooked up to windmills and they could only operate their offices and publish when there was sufficient wind they would maybe 'see the light'.

That is a brilliant idea,

That is a brilliant idea, then maybe we would see less of their nonsense.

And in other news, how did

And in other news, how did Nixon get elected?  Not a single person I know voted for him.

Sheesh...

I guess Gina doesn't go out much. We're out here Gina Baby! And we're reasonable and informed.

I'm not watching ABC

I'm not watching ABC anyway...except for NFL if they still carry it.  Necessary evil, but, there again I watch less football than I did a few decades ago.

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 61% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory (yep...approval for Congress now at 39%...do you believe that!?).

Mike Judge has struck gold

Mike Judge has struck gold with this show!!!!

As long as there continue to be the above reviews this show will NEVER run out of material. If the left cannot see the irony in their complaints about the show, and the shows actual content then there is no hope for them. I can't wait to actually watch this and enjoy.

Mitchell...thanks for the

Mitchell...thanks for the reminder about this show tonight...I'm looking forward to it.

This will most likely be a big hit just reading the reaction from the left....they will do their best to destroy this too...if you don't see things through their View-Finder in life, they will attempt to destroy you.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

The current mood???

This is great...

"But the show feels aggressively off-kilter with the current mood, as if it had been incubated in the early to mid-’90s, when it was possible to find global-warming skeptics among even the reasonable and informed."

"...when it was possible to find..."

So, if you don't drink the liberal/MSM kool-aid, you are not "reasonable and informed."  Wow, that's the best laugh all day (hoping for a better one tonight, when i watch the show in question).

I think the reason that libs don't have a sense of humor is that they base their positions on emotions and not facts or an understanding of history.  Conservatives often poke fun at themselves because they're secure in their knowledge of history and facts (and values). 

When you poke fun at a liberals cause, it's like telling a parent that their kid is ugly... they take it personally.  And, the uglier the kid is, the more the parent will get ticked off at you.

I hope Judge will bring back that wussified whacko enviro...

...kook character from King of the Hill.

LOL-He totally cracked me up.

-Dave

I just wished it wasn't on

I just wished it wasn't on at ten at night our time...I wanted my husband to be able to watch it too with me...he is snoring away by then during the week, I told him about the show...early to bed... early to rise...oh well, this summer will be a different schedule...then he can catch it.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

Or maybe the hippy guy that

Or maybe the hippy guy that sang about lesbian seagulls in Beavis and Butthead.

Watching this now

Kinda clunky. Some good parts. Might grow on me.  

It did try to position

It did try to position itself as anti-liberal a little bit too much in the first episode.  The way they went into explaining how their dog was vegan and explaining other aspects of their liberalism just to show how irrational they were was not the best writing.  You've got to show, not tell, so hopefully they will do more of that in future episodes when they don't have to be such an anti-liberal novelty.

But the jokes were pretty good.

Mitchell, Agreed. I saw

Mitchell,

Agreed.

I saw this as opposite King of the Hill.  Too extreme and too heavy handed to be any good.

Disappointing and boring.

Forgot about it and only saw

Forgot about it and only saw the last ten minutes. King of the Hill seemed slow to warm up as well. But the characters seemed interesting enough. I don't know if ABC will be as kind to a new show as Fox was in the early days.

The early episodes are

The early episodes are probably the hardest for this show, to establish the characters. It's worth a second look, but definitely too heavy handed. 

Despite that, there were some good jokes. 

Watched the whole show. I

Watched the whole show.

I want my 21 minutes back.  Thank god for DVR or it would have been 30 minutes lost.

For how many minutes can the same joke possibly be funny?

South Park this is not.

I can't wait to watch

I can't wait to watch "That's My 'Bama." Timothy Bottoms can do Biden.

More people probably

More people probably watched it than read those newspaper stories.

I thought is was O.K.  The African American white adopted kid was a good gag.  "Since the election we can all wear American flag pins" was a good line.

I'll watch it again.

→ It's a step

Needs a little more edge, but I'll watch it again in hopes it hits harder.

 

watchd the show, enjoyed it

I don't think they're being cruel to liberals, so much as mocking their anxious need to appear PC to their fellow PCers.  There's a lot of subtle humor that us cons won't get, such as the adopted son named "Ubuntu"--go look it up on Urban Dictionary, pay particular attn to #7.  (I had to have a young person point this out to me)  

 The amusing part to me was when the wife went to Whole Foods, where the other wives mocked her for being POOR.  (Not able to shop at Whole Foods on a regular basis) 

I watched it. Che the dog is my fave character so far.

-Dave

I only caught the last half

I only caught the last half because of a phone call...but what I saw of it...I think, or better yet, hope it will improve with time...like all new shows do to develop what direction the show is going to go, characters etc.

Could be promising... in my eyes anyway. 

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

Re Che

Agree on Che. Let's give it a few more episodes, it takes time and you burn up a few episodes introducing all the characters. Making fun of liberals and especially greenies is so easy, these scripts must write themselves.

Ubuntu is a wonderful poke in the eye to those that hyperventilate over white Africans that emigrate to America calling themselves 'African-Americans'. Also enjoy the ridicule of Octomom and the celebrity adoption trends.

So much material, only half an hour.

A Crude Show

I watched it. It did not take a cartoon sitcom to make me realize that these politically correct nutcases are pure loons.

However... the show was vulgar and crude, with far too many inappropriate sexual references for decent folks.  It did NOT make it to my TiVo's Season Pass list.

People Really Don't Get This Show or Mike Judge

He isn't "sending" a message. It's a parody of the mindset much like King of the Hill. However over it's years KOTH has become more than just a "ha look at what they believe" cartoon. They wrote stories that made you care about the characters, showed their faults and positives.

 I hope The Goode Family can evolve into this as I'd liked KOTH in the later years. 

With a few exceptions The Simpsons really sucked the first year.

Homer's voice & the characters were stale at times.  Give this show some time to develop...

IOW's I agree with you.

Even though the make some

Even though the make some pretty lame jokes about conservatives and Christians, 30 Rock regularly makes fun of liberals.  They have thoroughly skewered environmentalists, white guilt and they have endless jokes about the overblown finickyness that liberals display in always applying the latest and most 'acceptable' name to minority groups.  I am a regular watcher and I think they might even give more grief to liberals than conservatives.

Watched it

I watched it - my wife thought it would be funny - and - it was. 

Loved the scene where they were at the check-out of the Organic Grocery store without a re-usable grocery bag. And - Che, the vegan family dog - great stuff.

The liberals must hate this show - it makes extreme left eco types look like fools.

Despite being quite

Despite being quite liberal, I really enjoy humor, even derisive or cutting humor, directed at liberalism.  The caveat, of course, is that it has to actually be funny; and unfortunately, most conservative attempts at such satirical humor in the vein of, say, The Daily Show or The Simpsons, have been just awful.  Like that Fox attempt at being funny where the first episode had President Limbaugh and VP Coulter.

I've always liked Mike Judge, so I watched this show last night and thought it was pretty good...though it would be a mistake to claim that it's not also poking some fun at conservatism here and there.  Nonetheless, it was hilarious when the liberal wife drunkenly asked a black man if minorities have a convention to decide "What they want to call things" and then asked, when he sarcastically indulges this idea, if she can come.

It's certainly not new though.  Judge has been doing this sort of satire of liberalism for over ten years on my personal favorite TV show of all time, King of the Hill.  I'd estimate that 75% of the jokes and obnoxious characters in that show are liberal ciphers.  But I'd also say that if Judge is himself conservative, it doesn't show.  

Mike Judge must be a closet

Mike Judge must be a closet conservative.

One of the funniest King of the Hill eps involved Hank beconing disillusioned at the Mega-Lo Marts cardboard tasting steaks.

He discovered the perfect beef at a hippie run Food Co-Op, but could only buy it if he became a member and worked a few hours a week.

When Hank organized the co-op and starts turning a profit the hippies are intially horrified at this bummer turn of events.

Until the hippies decide to sell the Food Co-Op for millions to -- Mega-Lo Mart!

“I'm with you on a free press. It's the newspapers I can't stand.” Tom Stoppard, Night and Day, 1978

Jack, LOL-If Hank had just grilled those steaks on charcoal...

...as God intended, instead of on a gas grill, they wouldn't have tasted like cardboard to begin with.  :-)

As the proud owner of five Weber kettle grills (all charcoal) one of my favorite episodes of King of the Hill was when Hank came home and found a charcoal briquette in the house and nearly had a stroke.

That was too funny.

-Dave

RD -- that's blasphemy to

RD -- that's blasphemy to Hank!

Hank's 11th Commandment.. Those shalt worship no other grill than a gas powered grill.

“I'm with you on a free press. It's the newspapers I can't stand.” Tom Stoppard, Night and Day, 1978

Two best parts of that

Two best parts of that episode:

Peggy: I didn't know what it was!  Luanne asked me to hold it!  I thought it was drugs!

Hank: There's soot under my boy's nails!  You don't get that with a clean-burning fuel!

Bobby: You don't get the rich, smoky flavor either...

Hank: Shut your mouth.  Now...we're gonna sit here...and pray.

 

[later] Hank: I want you to choose, Peggy.  Charcoal?  Or me.

 

Personally, I think charcoal and propane both have their merits depending on what's cookin', but I only own propane right now because I live in an apartment in the city and it's just easier.  When you don't have a big back porch w/ adjacent kitchen, stacking the briquettes just so isn't quite as appealing.

Exactly.  But doesn't that

Exactly.  But doesn't that cut both ways?  After all, the hippies had the superior beef to begin with, and selling to Mega-lo-mart isn't portrayed as a good thing...

Dude, Mike Judge made

Dude, Mike Judge made Idiocracy.

Nuff said.

It will be hilarious when this show ends up being anti-conservative.

Idiocracy was

Idiocracy was hilarious.

“I'm with you on a free press. It's the newspapers I can't stand.” Tom Stoppard, Night and Day, 1978

Jack, I thought it

Jack,

I thought it started out really strong and hilarious, but it dragged a bit towards the end.  The premise is great

Definitely worth watching, although I can imagine some of the more rural newsbusters being offended.

Jason -- the hippies only

Jason -- the hippies only sold the beef.

It was the farmer who raised the cattle to taste so delicious. The hippies were pilloried from start to finish as hopeless boobs.

Hank made them profitable and good. They sold out agisnt Hank's wishes-- the pay off gag.

Mega-Lo Mart is just a running gag in King. Whatveer - it's always funny gentle humor.

Oh and IDIOCRACY was Hilarious.

“I'm with you on a free press. It's the newspapers I can't stand.” Tom Stoppard, Night and Day, 1978

Some "Goode News" ... finally

I'm thinking it will be such a hit that season two will be taken over by the government and handed over to writers with more diverse views.

Btw ... has anyone noticed that the NSIDC daily graph showing Arctic ice extent has been down again?

http://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/

After nearly reaching the average for 1979-2000 levels in late April, the recent data had shown an unusual and abrupt dive indicating, as was the case in January, either the satellite sensors are going out again or someone is fudging the data.

The mainstream media is hiding the story of what's really going on in the Arctic. Anyone who has walked out of his or her house this spring and noticed the mild, cool, and even chilly temperatures doesn't need a weatherman to know which way a chill wind blows.

metaphorsbwithu

First of all, the show is

First of all, the show is brilliantly funny - especially for conservatives.  But even my left-leaning wife thought it was funny.   She hasn't bought into the green propoganda.   Nice to actually be able to laugh at the ludicrous antics of the left, on a mainstream media network like ABC none-the-less.   All of the bad reviews are from liberals who can't laugh at themselves.  I'm sure a show about crazy Christians (think Ned Flanders) would be greeted with open arms by the libs.  Is the show over the top?  Sure, it is - but it really serves to showcase all of the silly things people do and say to make themselves feel better about 'saving the Earth', and the intolerance towards those who are not in lockstep. But the icing on the cake, was during a commercial break, our local ABC affiliate promoted a story about packing a "green" lunch.  The timing was impeccable!

 

And The MSM Didn't Notice When KOTH Did It?

At least here on this show, the liberal characters are the core of the cast, so shouldn't that please the MSM? I mean, how come they praised King of the Hill even though its core cast was a right-of-center Methodist Christian family and their neighbors, who at first glance from the politically correct, would be redneck-like? I don't get that at all. They prefer the realistic caricature of a conservative Christian family to the realistic caricature of a liberal secular family? The Hills actually seem like the most realistic American family depicted on television in the last two decades because you could believe the kind of situations that a politically correct society would bring upon the Hills. And the butt of the jokes were usually skinny government social workers from L.A. ("Outta my way, twig boy!"), animal rights protesters ("Would it kill a tree for them to wear a bra?"), and, drumroll please... The MSM! Yay! (clap-clap-clap-clap)

I was being sarcastic about clapping for the MSM.

I caught the whole episode, and my impressions were that it has promise, but some things need to be improved. The cold opening and first act seemed to be the weakest parts of the episode, which you would expect from the first episode of any TV show, but a Mike Judge show? The problem was that the exposition on the family was too distracting from the actual plot of the episode. At least on the first KOTH episode, there was some leeway for some plot development while introducing the characters. I would say it gained momentum at the second and third acts with the whole plot (which they probably should have saved for episode 2 just like on KOTH.) The scene stealer was the mother who was inebriated and just asked frankly to her black neighbor if there's a convention that decides on how black people should be called. He just plays along and mutters "Memphis." That was classic. So, not bad, but it could have been better.

Mike Judge Conservative?

Before everyone starts high fiving each other over this supposedly  conservative cartoon, you should keep in mind that this show was created by the same guy that brought you Idiocracy.

Watch that movie before you proclaim him the savior of conservative humor.  

My bet is you will hate it.

...

I dunno. I can't see liberals liking it, and if it doesn't pick up an audience pretty early on it will be off the air. This is an experiment of sorts by ABC. I think they're exploring to see just how much money they might stand to make if they actually started catering to real America, instead of insulting them all the time.

I could be wrong, of course, but the whole "stealth liberal" theory just doesn't quite ring true to me.

To be honest, I can't

To be honest, I can't really see anyone like it enough to generate a following.  It just seemed to cheesy and forced to me.  Extremely uninteresting.

I think most prime time television already caters to real America.  Good old fashioned wholesome family tv dominates in the ratings (e.g. Dancing with the Stars, Extreme Home Makeover, etc.)

 

I guess it's a plus for

What better endorsement to watch the show than to have it ridiculed by the 'liberal' people whom the show ridicules.

I forgot to watch the first episode but I better remember this week - heh, heh!