
Now that the dust has settled on both parties' vice presidential picks, it's time to take a look at how the media treated Joe Biden and Sarah Palin in the crucial early hours after they were announced as running mates.
This analysis is the first of several "Quick Study" reports we'll be running this election season to give a snapshot of press coverage, primarily through the lens of cable television.
Looking at the transcripts of CNN, FNC, and MSNBC during the two "primetime" hours of the day John McCain and Barack Obama announced their running mates, a trend becomes quite clear: The media were much more likely to report negative information about the Alaskan Palin than the Delawarean Biden.
Perhaps unsurprisingly given its decision to market itself as the network of the far left, MSNBC was the most unfair of the cable news channels. After Democrats learned Biden would be their vice presidential nominee August 23rd, MSNBC aired 47 positive statements about Obama's running mate. The network aired just 4 about Sara Palin when she was announced August 29th, making it 12 times more likely to praise Biden than Palin.
MSNBC skewed leftward when it came to negative information about McCain's running mate. It aired 20 negative statements about Palin and 14 about Biden.
Compared to CNN and MSNBC, Fox News was the fairest network. Biden was the recipient of more positive statements than Palin (25 versus 15) but he was also the recipient of more negative statements (31 versus 10).
As for CNN, while the first cable news channel was not as effusive in its praise of Biden as MSNBC (the network aired 29 positive statements about the Democrat versus 15 about Palin), it actually outstripped MSNBC in attacking Sarah Palin.
Particularly notable in the negativity department for CNN was Campbell Brown who repeatedly slammed Palin, making a point to question her experience as she did just after 8pm on August 29th:
Political insiders were pretty impressed when there was all this talk about who was on McCain's short list of vp candidates. Most pretty well-known Republicans, but he didn't choose any of them. Instead everybody now getting to know Alaska Governor Sarah Palin tonight. Some are calling this a pretty risky move by Senator McCain.
John McCain has said that he would pick a running mate who would be able to step into the president's shoes on day one. I don't have to tell you, Sarah Palin's only been governor for less than two years. Of all the Republicans out there, is she really the most qualified person to be commander in chief in a crisis?
Brown also seemed to focus on how McCain's pick of Palin somehow undermined his case against Barack Obama for being inexperienced (ignoring the fact that being ready to be president is quite different from being ready to be vice president).
"So much of your campaign's case against Senator Obama has focused on how little time that he's been in the Senate and how inexperienced he is on matters of international affairs, on military affairs. I mean, doesn't naming Governor Palin as his running mate undermine your entire argument against Senator Obama?" she asked McCain strategist Michael Duhaime.
Brown continued her negativity this week, getting into a verbal spat with GOP strategist Tucker Bounds which was so notable, it caught the attention of McCain himself who canceled an interview with Brown's CNN colleague Larry King over the incident. She hardly appears to be alone as a quick glance at the NewsBusters home page shows.
| Palin News 7:00 PM to 9:00 PM 8/29/08 | |||
| CNN | Fox | MSNBC | |
| Positive | 15 | 15 | 4 |
| Negative | 27 | 10 | 20 |
| Neutral | 26 | 37 | 13 |
| Total | 68 | 62 | 37 |
| BIDEN News 7:00pm to 9:00pm 8/23/08 | |||
| CNN | Fox | MSNBC | |
| Positive | 29 | 25 | 47 |
| Negative | 14 | 31 | 14 |
| Neutral | 65 | 51 | 61 |
| Total | 108 | 107 | 122 |
—Matthew Sheffield is the creator of NewsBusters and its Executive Editor.



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
You know what's wrong with Washington, inside the beltway?
September 2, 2008 - 23:38 ET by KC MulvillePresidents come and go, congresses rise and fall, supreme courts surf the tides ... the only ones who remain, sustaining the cemented status quo ... is the liberal media. Hell, they're still fighting the Vietnam War.
You want change? Change three network heads, a dozen producers, and the editors of the New York Times and Washington Post. Don't worry about the anchors, they only read what's teleprompted in front of them. You change those two dozen (or so) people, and everything else will follow.
Shhhh Rush Limbaugh wouldn't want you telling
September 3, 2008 - 01:27 ET by Lame CherryMr. Sheffield while you match numbers Rush would be the first to sigh in not wanting you mentioning all the press Sarah Palin is getting for the simple reason you perhaps have not noticed the disappearing Obama and the vanishing Biden from all the press.
Cynthia McFadden tonight dedicated it all to Sarah Palin and Vietnam POW's. She was literally spitting contempt over Gov. Palin on Nightline.
None of these liberal dolts have figured out John McCain knew if he gave liberals a new toy to play with that they claim they hate that they will still be playing with it and leave the Obama doll stuffed under their dirty clothes.
None of the smears are working as John McCain knew they would not and the American people are turning to her and the first rule in all situations is everyone knows the pretty girl always gets all the attention as the shine wears off the exotic Arab black African they have been pulling on for four years.
The more they play with Sarah telling the world not to like her the world will love her more.
I know I let the cat out of the bag, but sometimes I enjoy seeing liberals mouths drop open after they been gotcha'ed.
Now the problem is they know, but do they play or go back to boring Obama when everyone wants Sarah Palin.
Shhhh it's tough being an Obamaniac now in the press.
*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS
Lame Cherry
September 3, 2008 - 04:03 ET by Rush FanGood analysis. I hope you are correct.
----------------------------------------------------------
The liberal media continues to sacrifice ethics and morals for the greater cause: This time for the Election of a Democrat to the Presidency of the United States.
The foolish media in this
September 3, 2008 - 02:00 ET by ConservativeRexThe foolish media in this country will be the cause of death for thousands of people in this country. Do they not realize that the enemies of our country pay attention to what they see on American television?
Biden is qualified
September 3, 2008 - 05:44 ET by Cool ArrowCan we just agree Joe Biden is uniquely qualified to speak from personal experience on any issue he has no personal knowledge of?
LYDSEXICS UNTIE!
Last night after the speeches.....
September 3, 2008 - 07:50 ET by connmanI was watching CNN when Blitzer announced that McCain would not do the King interview because of the Brown interview with Tucker Bounce. They then went to her interview when she was pouncing on Tucker to give her one example of Palin as Commander in Chief of the AK national guard. Tucker was tripping over his tongue and was trying to give her a little party line but she woudn't relent. She was practically jumping out of her seat at him and he really didn't give her a sufficient answer and CNN made it look like the McCampaign was acting a little childish. (Which I kind of think they were).
Anyhow Brown was back live after the taped segment acting all smug and said that they asked someone in the AK NG if they knew if SP had at anytime directed the NG on any mission, and the answer was yes. She sent them out to help with forrest fires. Brown finished it up by saying that if McCains people had done their homework they would have known that.
Yea Campbell, and if he had replied with the forrest fire answer I'm sure you would've let it go at that.
This lib media is reaching new lows!
This town needs an enema! - The Joker
Hillary replaces Biden
September 3, 2008 - 15:05 ET by Jerry MackLiberals like Campbell Brown are furious that John McCain picked a female for VP. She is definantly not qualified if she is a Republican. Everyone should know that all intelligent women are dimicrats.
It would not surprise me that after Barry looks at his lack of bounce from their convention and stagnant poll numbers that he will replace Biden with Hillary.