NYT's Giuliani, Ailes Attack Falls Flat

Photo of Matthew Sheffield.

Will the fear and loathing among the liberal press for all things Fox never cease?

In the latest installment of the media's Fox Derangement Syndrome, the New York Times, the self-styled paper of record, has spent hundreds of hours researching and trying to dig up dirt on the friendship between Rudy Giuliani and Fox News Channel head Roger Ailes. This article was all they could come up with, a semi-conspiratorial bit that is more sizzle than steak and more hype than substance.

Yes, as reporter Russ Buettner discovered, the former New York mayor and Ailes are friends and have done a few activities together. Yes, Giuliani tried to get his city to carry FNC shortly after its launch when local cable monopoly TimeWarner, then in the process of buying CNN, refused to carry the channel (something it would do throughout the country, incidentally but never mind). That, however, is it as far as "dirt" goes.

Sure there's more stuff in the article but it's all innuendo coming from a paper with an agenda of its own. Did you know, for instance, that even though the Times does mention that during Bill Clinton's presidency, CNN was headed up by a friend of his named Rick Kaplan, that the Grey Lady never bothered to mention this fact at the time? The contrast is stark.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Rudy Giuliani is a candidate for president but since both he and Ailes are Republicans, any shred of relationship between the two men is automatically suspicious. Meanwhile, Bill Clinton, the actual president, had a personal friend of his overseeing the coverage of his every move at CNN and before that at ABC.

The Times's eight-year lack of interest in the Kaplan-Clinton relationship was hardly for want of material. In 1998, for instance, Vanity Fair published a lengthy article which detailed how Kaplan skewed coverage in favor of his friend. The January 14 MRC CyberAlert from that year summarized some of the more damning facts:

  • How Kaplan once hired Hillary Clinton.
  • How he not only advised Clinton about how to counter Gennifer Flowers, a pretty well known event, but had earlier counseled Clinton on how to recover from his too-long 1988 convention speech.
  • How he had been a political operative for a liberal presidential candidate before jumping to journalism.
  • How he made calls to console Hillary Clinton after Vince Foster's death and to Web Hubbell after he resigned.
  • How he killed a Whitewater piece from "World News Tonight," discouraged reporters and producers from pursuing the topic and only ran an in-depth look one night in 1994 because "Nightline" was about to grab it.

Since the Clinton years, Kaplan didn't exactly disappear from the face of the earth, either. After failing at CNN, he was later appointed to be the president of MSNBC. Meanwhile, Clinton's wife, Hillary, began her own run for the White House. Nary a peep from the Times.

There's a reason behind all this. The media left views anyone with any sort of conservative reputation as inherently invidious. Liberal friendships or cooperation are either nonexistant or not worth noting at all. The paranoia and political bigotry is palpable.

Update 11:44. Thomas Lifson has a great post on Fox chief Rupert Murdoch and NYT exec Pinch Sulzberger (h/t JDW)

—Matthew Sheffield is Editor of NewsBusters.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Here's an article from that

Here's an article from that era about the controversy. Notice if we had actual capitalism instead of these monopolies people just assume should-exist, this problem would entirely go-away...
JMR

Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.

"Is it just me or is the

"Is it just me or is the left increasingly becoming the modern-day McCarthyites?"

One dependable aspect of the lefties is that they accuse others of what they do themselves. The charge of "McCarthyism" has always been a false one against Joe McCarthy, but it is a time-tested tactic of the Left.

From the BRADLEE professor

This is the thing that gets me (emphasis mine).

“Few, if any, presidents have taken office with a close friend at the helm of a network news division, said Thomas E. Patterson, the Bradlee Professor of Government and the Press at Harvard …” (NY Times)  

Far be it from any president to have a close friend at the helm of a news operation. (Jeez. You’d think this guy, of all people, would have heard of Ben Bradlee.)

Imagine

Wow what great investigative journalism. The Mayor of the City of New York was actually trying to promote a local business, Fox News Channel  to another New York business, Time Warner Cable.  Why would any  Mayor want to do that? Go figure. Darn Republicans.

 

I think the real question

I think the real question to ask is "why should any mayor need to do that?" Under actual capitalism instead of monopoly, business does not seem to need any political help.
JMR

Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.

Exactly so. See, I don't

Exactly so. See, I don't entirely hate you. <g>

Who is "Russ Buettner." Is

Who is "Russ Buettner." Is that his real name?

And can we really trust a guy whose surname has the word BUTT in it?

What's HIS relationship with the Clintons?

Did Russ go to college with people who had high level jobs in the last Clinton administration?

How long has he been producing hit-pieces on Guiliani? At least ten years as far as I can see.

Did he contribute to Hillary Clinton's Senate campaign, monetarily, or in other ways, such as "research" on her opponents?

Anyone with a Lexis Nexis should get some background on Russ, because I can find no reference to him on Yahoo, except articles written by him.

Tracking his links with Democratick party hacks will, I strongly suspect, be very rewarding.

Check out my latest YouTube...but only if you support the troops and their mission: Better Men Than Me/The Battle For Fallujah

}}}----> Russ Unbuttner

You must be referring to Russ Unbuttner who is responsible for Hillary's latest fashion statement.

LOL cool. Very

LOL cool. Very fast.

Wasn't that one of Bill's official titles..


The Unbuttoner-in-Chief

Check out my latest YouTube...but only if you support the troops and their mission: Better Men Than Me/The Battle For Fallujah

why just be a referee when you can be a player?

so asked  L. Brent Bozell III in 1997 while attacking CNN/Kaplan/Clinton relatinship.  Will Bozell follow through with a condemnation of the FoxNews/Roger Ailes/Giuliani  relationship?

Kaplan's relationship with

Kaplan's relationship with Clinton was closer than Ailes's relationship with Giuliani.

The fact also remains that more than half of Giuliani's airtime on FNC has been courtesy of Sean Hannity whose show topics are not set by any higher-ups at all.

Not to mention the fact that

Not to mention the fact that Hannity has mentioned several times that Guiliani is one of his favorite people and guests.