Doubts about the veracity of highly sensationalized accounts from Iraq written by a pseudonymous person claiming to be an American soldier have finally compelled the liberal New Republic magazine to launch an investigation, the New York Times reports:
The author, who used the pen name Scott Thomas, has written three articles for the magazine since February, describing gruesome incidents in Iraq. Last week, The Weekly Standard questioned the veracity of the New Republic articles and invited readers with knowledge about the military or Baghdad to comment.
Since then, several readers and a spokesman for the base where the soldier is supposedly based have written in, raising more questions.
“Absolutely every piece of information that’s come out since we put that call up has cast further doubt on that story,” said Michael Goldfarb, the online editor of The Weekly Standard. “There’s not a single person that has come forward and said, ‘It sounds plausible.’ ”
Franklin Foer, the editor of The New Republic, will not reveal the author’s identity but says the magazine is investigating the accuracy of his articles. In the late 1990s, under different editors, the magazine fired an associate editor, Stephen Glass, for fabrications. [...]The magazine granted anonymity to the writer to keep him from being punished by his military superiors and to allow him to write candidly, Mr. Foer said. He said that he had met the writer and that he knows with “near certainty” that he is, in fact, a soldier.
What was that about being the "reality-based community" again?
—Matthew Sheffield is the creator of NewsBusters and its Executive Editor. You can follow him on Twitter here.






















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
SOTC: Seriousness Of The Charge
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 00:24 ET by Pragmatic-ManThe seriousness of the charge trumps every time. Forget the facts, forget journalistic integrity.
It is so rampant with the leftists that it deserves its own acronym:
SOTC
Except when it's a Democrat
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 00:27 ET by Free StinkerExcept when it's a Democrat that stands accused.
Right
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 00:28 ET by Matthew SheffieldThat is the essential corrolary to almost any political statement
Wow. Now they're making
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 00:25 ET by dahliatraversWow. Now they're making stuff up to nudge us out of Iraq.
Not New
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 10:48 ET by Challenger GrimThis is NOT the first time they've had a fake soldier.
What's the matter? They can't find a REAL liberal soldier for commentary? Hmmm.....
Be sure to get your daily Fred Thompson Fact!
Good that the New
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 00:34 ET by bigtimerGood that the New Republic are finally investigating now...after the attention has finally been brought to this situation by the Weekly Standard and others...
After the damage they intentionally had an agenda to inflict could be done...
Pathetic.
Nothing will be done most likely except someone forced to resign...after-all it will be a leftist with an agenda to hurt our military, Victory... ect in any way possible.
I am just surprised the NYT's printed this.
Our republic is in serious trouble.
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 02:51 ET by Dave RIf this were the "Civil War" era, the "writer" in question would have been hunted down, and, in the event he was taken alive, would be spending the duration carving his "stories" into the underside of the floor of the prison cell he would be occupying, with his bare fingers.
If this were even as recent as WW II, there is a very good chance something similar would befall such a person as "Scott Thomas."
Sadly, over the last sixty years, something has gone hideously awry in this country. We won WW II (barely) by sheer ruthlessness, as we bombed Germany nearly flat and nuked two cities in Japan, which resulted in an unconditional surrender in both cases.
This country has not really won a war since.
I truly fear we are going to lose this country, and most of us are going to live to see it.
And my wife keeps asking me
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 02:56 ET by tracheostomyAnd my wife keeps asking me why I'm putting off having kids.
So I remind her like Dave R. just wrote. And then she walks away without comment.
-PJ
"Trake: Your lofty convictions are another blemish on the rump of congregational sectarianism." -Tumbler 5/15/07
Well now what is between
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:09 ET by bigtimerWell now what is between you and your other half about having kids is your business...
I for one will never believe we as Americans will never ever let this country be lost.
Ever.
Jeez...you guys are depressing...I know life is at times, but to have such a defeatist attitude in this country with the American people, just try to remember how this country came together in unison after 9/11.
I believe we have that same spirit...if need be.
Which we may well...
In the meantime...have those kids.
Time goes by too fast, you can always find bad news, doom and gloom ya know trach.
Just want ya to be happy and enjoy life while you should when young yet, it slips by so fast you would not believe it ...
Trust me...
Hope you took that as I meant it....just an itsy bitsy teeny weeny bit of friendly advice/knowledge.
}}}----> Pollyanna Bigtimer?
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:14 ET by Cool ArrowAnd just how high was that tea tax we revolted against?
Ah gosh cool... I'm just
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:18 ET by bigtimerAh gosh cool...
I'm just a gal and a mom...what can I say?
Give me a break.
I just knew I shouldn't of.
}}}----> sorry bigtimer
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:26 ET by Cool ArrowYour outlook is certainly no more destructive than mine. I'm of the opinion there is little I can do to change the course of this once proud Nation. I think we've done too much.
No apology necessary
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:36 ET by bigtimerNo apology necessary cool...
Sometimes I am too much of an optimist I know.
WE all look at things like life differently due to our own experiences ect.
I know this country is in a mess, you must know that by what I have posted at times since you have been here Riled One...but I have been hearing that since I can remember.
Anyway...are your text letters or whatever the proper term is getting bigger or should I have a strong shot?
LOL...
I like it....
The compose letters are bigger now
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:44 ET by Matthew SheffieldI figured out a way to fix them for the create comment box.
Should be an end to the headache-inducing font size we had before.
Matthew... Well here I am
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:56 ET by bigtimerMatthew...
Well here I am again thanking you.
One for increasing the FONT size....(I knew text wasn't the proper term, just couldn't think of it, I leave it up to the younger generation to be quick on the draw...lol)
...but most of all for taking the time to tell us all what is going on, even when we are just posting each other.
}}}----> Text Letters
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:45 ET by Cool ArrowMy letters got larger, but I can't complain. Getting too old for my current trifocal scrip. Much too vain to switch to lined lenses.
:pat on back: BT, you point
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:34 ET by tracheostomy:pat on back:
BT, you point me in the right direction with the most positive, large-scale, and objective goal you can assign, and I'll fight for the cause even if I think it's a losing one. I mean that.
-PJ
"Trake: Your lofty convictions are another blemish on the rump of congregational sectarianism." -Tumbler 5/15/07
trach... What can I say
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:39 ET by bigtimertrach...
What can I say but those words mean a lot.
Thank you.
I meant the best, that is all.
bigtimer, I agree. I know I
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:47 ET by Conservative Voicebigtimer, I agree. I know I have had similar thoughts, but then I get reminded on how cool Americans can be, especially from those in the military. For a while I was nervous having kids. Now that I have one, I think how cool it would be to have a whole van full of mini CVs running around. As the democrats need illegals and felons to keep them in power, lets generate some kid power to overtake the next generation! :)
CV... LOL... That's
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:58 ET by bigtimerCV...
LOL...
That's as good a reason as any that I've ever heard to have a few rug-rats!
}}}----> Wallabe Praised
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:13 ET by Cool ArrowI'm afraid you may be right Dave R. There aren't enough of us to stand up to the PC pansies who would gladly sell their daughters into subjection to mutilating Radical Islamists rather than admit there really is a Higher Authority over America.
What the heck, we'll demand products containing Olestra warn consumers "may cause anal leakage" but just try informing a young woman that abortion may cause depression or suicidal tendencies.
When B. Hussein Obama and Hillary Clinton take the White House a year from January, look for all hell to break loose in this country. We cannot continue to laugh squarely into the face of God and not expect judgement.
Every society deserves the worst possible government it will abide. Human greed, depravity, and powerlust will ensure that. Even the government we enjoy at present is serendipitous as we pry humongous chunks from the God fearing document our forefathers solemnly swore to uphold with life, fortune, and sacred honor.
Tody, instead, you will most likely find a far different understanding when the term "four fathers" is used. It's more likely all the "uncles" mom visits with.
Right, we're still
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:38 ET by tracheostomyRight, we're still not "fed up" enough yet. A few of us are, but not enough to rally or split the majority.
Me? This blog is as politically active as I get. Which is pretty pathetic, I'll admit.
-PJ
"Trake: Your lofty convictions are another blemish on the rump of congregational sectarianism." -Tumbler 5/15/07
}}}----> Gotta start somewhere Trake
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 03:55 ET by Cool ArrowWho knows for sure how all the threads contained in "Common Sense" were distilled into a brew of potency sufficient to launch a Nation.
Maybe our little contributions to A Return to Common Sense (can I get credit for the title?) are, as we speak, being mulled over by the next Thomas Paine. We can hope.
Cousins?
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 08:55 ET by EllisWyattMaybe Scott Thomas is a distant cousin of Jalil Hussein.
As for the other comments about most of us being around for the end of the United States, I'm with you. I often feel like my children will have to be a real life Luke and Leia Skywalker. I'll have to hide them on Tatooine to protect them from Emperor Hillary or Emperor Obama. Question is, who will be their Yoda? :)
If you're not outraged at the media, you haven't been paying attention.
I wonder...
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 09:36 ET by dmntd1I wonder if the commanding officer of the base in question, during the time period in which these offenses allegedly occurred can file libel/slander charges against the newspaper, as these charges certainly would have defamed his character, leadership ability and brought into question his judgment in the field of battle...
Just a thought...
I really think that questioning others' masculinity is a game probably better left to people who haven't had more cock in and out of them than a Tyson Chicken regional distribution center. AceOfSpades 06162007
Fake Iraq War veterans
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 09:40 ET by Carl KolchakHere are some links exposing fake stories.
http://greensickle.com/2006/06/stolen_valor_part_five_myspace_1.html
or
http://archive.southcoasttoday.com/daily/03-05/03-24-05/a02wn438.htm
"I'm a man of means by no means, King of the Road" 'King of the Road'
Here's more from B.G. Burkett
Tue, 07/24/2007 - 13:10 ET by Carl KolchakHere's another example of B.G. Burkett busting fake atrocity stories. This is from a segment from "60 Minutes" back in the 80's in which Burkett decides to investigate and tear down their stories. Here's a quote from the link below.
"The truth was uncovered by B.G. Burkett, a Vietnam veteran and author of Stolen Valor: How the Vietnam Generation Was Robbed of its Heroes and its History (with Glenna Whitley). Burkett discovered that only one of the vets had actually served in combat. Steve Southards, who'd claimed to be a 16-year-old Navy SEAL assassin, had actually served as an equipment repairman stationed far from combat. Later transferred to Subic Bay in the Philippines, Steve spent most of his time in the brig for repeatedly going AWOL.
And George Gruel, who claimed he was traumatized by the sight of his friend being chopped to pieces by a propeller? Navy records reveal that a propeller accident did take place on the Ticonderoga when Gruel was aboard — but that he wasn't around when it happened. During Gruel's tour, the ship had been converted to an antisubmarine warfare carrier which operated, not on "secret mission" along the Vietnam coast, but on training missions off the California coastline. Nevertheless, Burkett notes, Gruel receives $1,952 a month from the Veterans Administration for "psychological trauma" related to an event he only heard about.
Mikal Rice — the anguished vet who claimed to have cradled his dying buddy in his arms — actually spent his tour as a guard with an MP company at Cam Ranh Bay. He never saw combat. Neither did Terry Bradley, who was not the "fighting sergeant" he'd claimed to be. Instead, military records reveal he served as an ammo handler in the 25th Infantry Division and spent nearly a year in the stockade for being AWOL. That's good news for the hundreds of Vietnamese civilians Bradley claimed to have slaughtered."
http://www.nationalreview.com/comment/morse200409150552.asp
"Well I got nothing against the press, they wouldn't print it if it wasn't true" 'Sunday Papers'