NPR Plays Up Latino Republicans' Fury at 'Divisive' Immigration Tone

On Monday's Morning Edition, NPR's Carrie Kahn followed her network's standard operating procedure by omitting anti-illegal immigration conservatives from a report highlighting Latino Republicans' concern over the apparently "rough" language from GOP presidential candidates. Kahn cited one activist who bemoaned that the "the harsh talk is making it difficult to recruit new Latino voters."

During his introduction for the correspondent's report, fill-in host Ari Shapiro acknowledged that "Mr. Obama has lost popularity with Latinos recently, mostly due to the economy," but then added that "Hispanic voters looking for alternatives are not too happy with the Republican slate either." Kahn continued by playing up how "if you've been listening to the GOP presidential candidates lately, the talk about immigration control is getting rough."

After playing a clip of candidate Herman Cain's controversial remark about placing an electrified fence on the southern border, the journalist continued that "Cain somewhat apologized for the comment, but Michele Bachmann says she'd build two fences, and candidates Mitt Romney and Rick Perry continue to argue over who's hiring, as they say, the illegals. It's rhetoric that drives Latino Republican activists mad."

For the reminder of her report, Kahn played six sound bites from the Hispanic Republicans "mad" at such rhetoric, including Deedee Garcia Blase of Somos Republicans in Arizona, who, according to the NPR correspondent, stated that "its hard to get new voters to consider the party when they hear the candidates being so disrespectful....[She] says the candidates can't wait until after the primaries to moderate their tone on immigration. With social networking and the Internet playing a bigger role than just four years ago...it won't be as easy as to take back past comments."

Back in May 2011, NPR's Mara Liasson did something similar during a report on Morning Edition by also leaving out anti-illegal immigration conservatives, playing only clips from President Obama, Democratic Rep. Luis Gutierrez, and Republican consultant Marty Wilson, who claimed that the "hardline approach on immigration...isn't going to work." Liasson did the same during a March 18, 2011 report on Utah's new and "milder" guest worker law.

The transcript of correspondent Carrie Kahn's report from Monday's Morning Edition:

ARI SHAPIRO: President Obama is on a campaign swing through the west this week. He's making stops in California, Nevada, and Colorado. Those are all states where Hispanic voters could play a crucial role in next year's election. Mr. Obama has lost popularity with Latinos recently, mostly due to the economy.

And as NPR's Carrie Kahn reports, Hispanic voters looking for alternatives are not too happy with the Republican slate either.

CARRIE KAHN: If you've been listening to the GOP presidential candidates lately, the talk about immigration control is getting rough. Here's candidate Herman Cain on improvements he'd make to the U.S.-Mexico border fence.

HERMAN CAIN: Electrify it- (audience cheers and applauds) with a sign on it on the other side that says it can kill you.

KAHN: Cain somewhat apologized for the comment, but Michele Bachmann says she'd build two fences, and candidates Mitt Romney and Rick Perry continue to argue over who's hiring, as they say, the illegals. It's rhetoric that drives Latino Republican activists mad.

ELYSE MONROY: It's divisive rhetoric, and it's off-putting language.

KAHN: Elyse Monroy heads a group called Nevada Latinos for Prosperity. She says the harsh talk is making it difficult to recruit new Latino voters.

MONROY: It is going to be an uphill battle because we're fighting against the rhetoric, but we're not asking the party to change their policy. We're asking the party to change their tone.

KAHN: DeeDee Garcia Blase of the group Somos Republicans is also worried about the rhetoric.

DEEDEE GARCIA BLASE: It's hurting us. It's hurting the Republican image.

KAHN: Garcia Blase is in Arizona, where the state government has enacted some of the toughest anti-illegal immigration laws in the country. She says its hard to get new voters to consider the party when they hear the candidates being so disrespectful.

BLASE: They're ruining it. How in the heck can you overcome that?

KAHN: One way is to change the subject to the economy. (clip of Spanish language ad) Republican groups ran this ad predominantly in Western states. In it, the clearly worried woman says she supported Obama because he spoke so eloquently. But since he's been in office, things have gone from bad to worse.

Republican strategist Javier Ortiz says the President is vulnerable with Hispanic voters when it comes to the economy.

JAVIER ORTIZ: It is, without question, a place where the President has lost the interest and the focus that Hispanics may have had with him in the past.

KAHN: Recent polls show that President Obama's once sky-high approval rating has dropped below fifty percent with Hispanic voters, and his record on immigration isn't helping either. His administration has deported record numbers of illegal immigrants, and his promise to pass comprehensive immigration reform never happened. So both parties have their work cut out for them.

But Arturo Vargas of NALEO, a non-partisan group of Latino elected officials, says Republicans have a bit more to worry about. If they want to win the presidency, they have to get more than 35 percent of the Hispanic vote. George W. Bush did it in 2004. McCain couldn't in 2008.


ARTURO VARGAS: How they are going to secure that 35 to 40 percent of the Hispanic vote if they're going to continue the kind of rhetoric that we're hearing now on immigration?

KAHN: DeeDee Garcia Blase of Somos Republicans says the candidates can't wait until after the primaries to moderate their tone on immigration. With social networking and the Internet playing a bigger role than just four years ago, Garcia says it won't be as easy as to take back past comments.

BLASE: In the information age that we are in now, it is going to be hard to retract what has already been said.

KAHN: Then there's always the fear that Hispanic voters may be turned off by both parties and just sit out the election altogether. Carrie Kahn, NPR News.

Matthew Balan
Matthew Balan
Matthew Balan is a news analyst at Media Research Center