Correspondent Lisa Stark’s report on ABC’s World News on Sunday almost completely slanted in favor of President Obama’s decision to overturn the ban on federal funding of stem cell research which destroys human embryos. Stark minimized the controversial nature of the research, devoting only one sound bite out of four to a critic of the president’s move.
Anchor Dan Harris introduced Stark’s report by selling the apparent promise of embryonic stem cell research: “President Obama is going to fulfill one of his campaign promises by ending restrictions on federally-funded research using embryonic stem cells. This could lead to better treatments and possibly cures for many diseases. But it will not end a visceral debate.” Despite this mention of the “visceral debate,” the report almost entirely focused on the hype from supporters of the research.
The ABC correspondent began by introducing Roman Reed, a paralyzed man who gushed over the president’s support for embryonic stem cell research: “President Obama cares. He’s taking a stance on suffering. He’s taking a stand for cures.” The graphic on the screen merely labeled Reed as a “research advocate,” and Stark added the word “tireless” to describe the disabled man and his parents. Reed gave an additional plug for the research in a second sound bite: “I have held in my hand a rat that can -- completely paralyzed -- embryonic stem cells were put in, and that rat is walking again. Embryonic stem cells are the key. This is huge.”
Stark then gave an additional plug for the research, playing up the potential cures that could result: “Researchers believe they may produce the next revolution in medicine, including treatments for conditions such as spinal cord injuries, Parkinson’s Disease, diabetes, and Alzheimer’s.” After describing that the embryonic stem cells “come from discarded human embryos, which are destroyed in the process,” she played the sole clip from an opponent of the research, William May of the typically liberal Catholics for the Common Good.
As she introduced Dr. George Daley, another supporter of the embryo-destroying research, Stark underlined how the previous ban on the research led to scientists having to “segregate their labs.” Dr. Daley, in his sound bite, used the Obama administration’s talking points about ending the ban on federal funding for the research: “The new Obama decision is really putting patients first. It’s putting patients over ideology. It’s going to allow the science to move forward as quickly as possible.” Is this an ABC News report or a paid political advertisement in support of embryonic stem cell research?
The full transcript of Stark’s report from ABC’s World News Sunday program:
DAN HARRIS: President Obama is going to fulfill one of his campaign promises by ending restrictions on federally-funded research using embryonic stem cells. This could lead to better treatments and possibly cures for many diseases. But it will not end a visceral debate. Here’s Lisa Stark.
ROMAN REED, RESEARCH ADVOCATE: President Obama cares. He’s taking a stance on suffering. He’s taking a stand for cures --
LISA STARK (voice-over) Roman Reed was paralyzed playing college football. He and his parents have been tireless advocates for embryonic stem cell research, and will be with the president when he opens the door to federal funding.
REED (on-camera): I have held in my hand a rat that can -- completely paralyzed -- embryonic stem cells were put in, and that rat is walking again. Embryonic stem cells are the key. This is huge.
STARK (voice-over): Embryonic stem cells can develop into any cell in the body. Researchers believe they may produce the next revolution in medicine, including treatments for conditions such as spinal cord injuries, Parkinson’s Disease, diabetes, and Alzheimer’s. The cells come from discarded human embryos, which are destroyed in the process.
WILLIAM MAY, CHAIRMAN, CATHOLICS FOR THE COMMON GOOD (on-camera): This decision to push the kind of stem cell research that involves killing innocent human beings is -- is embracing the culture of death.
STARK (voice-over): That’s the argument that swayed President Bush to limit federal funding, forcing researchers to find private dollars.
DR. GEORGE DALEY, CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL, BOSTON: So all of this has been purchased with private money --
STARK (voice-over): Scientists, such as Dr. George Daley, have had to segregate their labs. “NP” means “non-presidential.” Not a drop of federal money can be used here. Now, that will change.
DALEY (on-camera): The new Obama decision is really putting patients first. It’s putting patients over ideology. It’s going to allow the science to move forward as quickly as possible.
STARK (on-camera): But not overnight -- it will take the government a couple of months to draw the ethical guidelines necessary to cover this sensitive research.
STARK (voice-over): Roman Reed is convinced, one day, that stem cell research will allow him to walk again. The first step, he says, will come tomorrow at the White House. Lisa Stark, ABC News, Washington.
—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.





LISA STARK (voice-over) Roman Reed was paralyzed playing college football. He and his parents have been tireless advocates for embryonic stem cell research, and will be with the president when he opens the door to federal funding.















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
God is not happy...
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 16:48 ET by Mother...This crap goes against every fiber of my being. Now OUR tax dollars are going to be paying for this EVIL.
I'm afraid for all of us as human beings.
"Let the mad scientists free!"
UGH
§ Mother...Cafferty Gleefully cites "American Taliban" e-mail..
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 17:06 ET by TheSterCafferty asks if it is a "Distraction" to lift this "Ban".
He then STARTS the viewer E-Mail with some LOON calling the Religious Right as....wait for it....
AMERICAN TALIBAN.
Hmmmm...
At least he quit SLOBBERING all over Michelle Obama...for now.
Ster.
My mind is a raging torrent, flooded with rivulets of thought cascading into a waterfall of creative alternatives.
I do NOT want my tax dollars to be used for EMBRYONIC ...
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 17:10 ET by Jayke... STEM CELL HELLISH "RESEARCH". If I were God I would DESTROY America. I would start by turning off the sun:
http://spaceweather.com/
Oh, did i mention that BARRKY is the PRINCE OF ABORTION?
How bout if every
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 17:15 ET by TexasteacherHow bout if every conservative in the country didn't pay their taxes this year since prince hairy reid said our tax system is "voluntary". If we got all 42 million of us that didn't vote for komrade obama to not pay our taxes, what are they going to do about it?? To use a slogan from a billboard I saw in Dallas: They can't deport us all.
obama's notion of bi-partisanship is telling conservatives to shut up and do what he wants.
How do you do it?
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 17:49 ET by redmikeHow do you not pay your taxes? It's taken out of your pay before you ever see it. Are we going to all demand to be contractors and get paid in cash?
Double your Deductions!
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 18:59 ET by NortoThere is no law against keeping your money and paying in what you want later. Ask your employer for a new w-whatever and amend it.
LISA STARK
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 16:50 ET by MidAmericaLISA STARK (voice-over) Roman Reed was paralyzed playing college football. He and his parents have been tireless advocates for embryonic stem cell research, and will be with the president when he opens the door to federal funding.
See... right there is the key to all these medical advances. All that was needed was some Obama Bucks. Without Obama Bucks researchers were just unable to find the right cellular techniques.
This Will Solve America's Gravest Concern...
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 17:12 ET by Reaganite RepublicanThat's great- now we can clone The One, so as to solve the only real problem in the world- how will we ever do without him?
http://reaganiterepublicanresistance.blogspot.com
This is in direct...
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 17:20 ET by BKeyserThis is in direct... response?... concert?...sychronization, maybe? with his new health care plan. It is an absolute necessity to counter the affects of Obamacare and here's why-
Now, I'm not suggesting the Democratic Congressman from New Hampshire, paralyzed for 28 years will, as he believes, someday walk again. I don't know of any proven medical advances made in the stem-cell area, and European scientists have been working on this for years so the lack of US Federal funds under Bush is really a weak argument. But, like funding abortions around the world, and dumping huge sums of money into curbing the effects of Sun Spots, spending Chinese money on a hope and a prayer is pretty natural for this administration...
Stem Cells
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 18:18 ET by CBrauWe saved each of my 3 kids' stem cells from their umbillical cords. Furthermore, adult stem cells are proving worthwhile. Embryonic stem cells are not at the forefront of scientific advances. So why pursue this when there are other sources without the ethical issues?
This "decision" is nothing more than condoning murder of the innocent. Shameful.
→ Mo money, Mo money
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 18:25 ET by Cool ArrowWhat kind of question is that?
If cutting out a living breathing baby's heart could save the life of an important enough person, there would be an ethicist somewhere who would attempt to justify it.
And the people said "Give us Barabas. Let the blood of this man be upon us and our children"
Judgement is coming. We ain't seen nothing yet.
Obama is succeeding and it hurts
I guess no one here has had
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 20:02 ET by bazzarworldI guess no one here has had a relative suffer from alzheimer's, parkinson's, or CP. Compassionate convervatism my ass.
bazz... Heck if I
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 20:12 ET by bigtimerbazz...
Heck if I haven't.
Private businesses are already doing this...but to force tax-payers to pay for something they think is morally wrong is despicable.
I'm not going into all the various new ways they have discovered with stem cells other than an embryo that are well known...have posted about it a lot over time here...this is O paying back his contributers with the ease of the typical baby-killer he is.
The Butcher of D.C. wants
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 20:33 ET by MidAmericaThe Butcher of D.C. wants his blood sacrifice to 'purify' his liberal revolution.
Why do you ESCR fanatics
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 20:46 ET by GrannyGrump42Why do you ESCR fanatics think that hype about hypothetical cures is somehow more "compassionate" than ACTUAL CURES AND TREATMENTS? Because that's what the conservatives have to offer:
http://www.stemcellresearch.org/facts/treatments.htm
So are all ESCR has produced is tumors, tremors, and dead lab rats. My sister's cancer is in remission thanks to ADULT stem cell treatment. Don Ho's heart was healed with ADULT stem cells. There are doctors in Russia and Portugal helping the paralyzed to walk -- using ADULT stem cells.
Why do you have so much emotional investment in cruel hype, that you can't see the real treatments right before your eyes?
Hi, B...
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 20:48 ET by RightsBelieverThe exec order to halt Government Funded Experimentation. If it's such a good idea, feel free to use the BILLIONS of dollars in medical profit money. Got it?
Obama lied; the economy died.
Tony Blankley
I guess no one here has had
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 20:49 ET by MidAmericaI guess no one here has had a relative suffer from alzheimer's, parkinson's, or CP. Compassionate convervatism my ass.
Oh, the researchers that were going to find the cures for all those ailments? Unfortunately they never got the chance. They were all aborted by their mothers.
What kind of world do we live in where there are no kill shelters for animals but humans are killed and taken out with the trash.
"What kind of world do we
Tue, 03/10/2009 - 10:19 ET by Texasteacher"What kind of world do we live in where there are no kill shelters for
animals but humans are killed and taken out with the trash."
Or where liberals are horrified at the death penalty for murderers and wonder how conservatives can be so cruel, yet they are fine with late-term abortion because an innocent baby has inconvenienced it's mother and wonder why conservatives are so uptight about it.
Or where a person can murder a pregnant woman and get charged with a double homicide, while the mother could have aborted the same baby without a second thought for any reason.
Compassionate liberalism my a**
obama's notion of bi-partisanship is telling conservatives to shut up and do what he wants.
I have family members who
Tue, 03/10/2009 - 10:37 ET by moderncommentaries83I have family members who suffer from ALS, diabetes, and a slew of other diseases.
So don't pretend we don't care. We just don't like the destruction of other human beings in pursuit of cures.
But ESCR has done nothing to help these people. Nothing. Unless you want your loved ones to risk getting cancer or some other negative effect from ESC, because that's all they've done.
And - quite frankly - ESCR is no different than going out and shooting a homeless person in the head for his organs to save another person's life. After all, the homeless man wasn't contributing to society, so he's expendable if it "saves" another life. Right?
The Nazis experimented on Jews - science free of politics or moral influence - why not continue to emulate that evil, huh?
Aut viam inveniam aut faciam
What about the SEVENTY TWO
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 20:41 ET by GrannyGrump42What about the SEVENTY TWO conditions that are actually being treated in HUMANS, not lab rats, using ADULT stem cells?
http://www.stemcellresearch.org/facts/treatments.htm
My sister's cancer is in remission thanks to --- adult stem cells! Don Ho's heart was healed with -- adult stem cells. There's a clinic in Russia that has paralyzed people walking again, using -- adult stem cells.
Who is putting politics ahead of science here?
GG... Bingo!
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 20:58 ET by bigtimerGG...
Bingo!
The Libs Realize That
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 21:42 ET by JDWThe worst problem in my mind is human cloning.
JDW
DAILY WAVE
The government works for me, not the other way around
Come on you MSM/Hollywood
Tue, 03/10/2009 - 01:49 ET by RR GOPCome on you MSM/Hollywood folks...pony up those embryos for research and do us all a favor and end your blood lines NOW!
One of the 24% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 89% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.
Odd...
Tue, 03/10/2009 - 09:12 ET by Meredith1966Odd that the one argument that never seems to come up in Washington anymore is whether or not some spending plan, be it funding for stem cell research or PBS, is in any way mandated by the Constitution. Where does it say that Congress shall have the power to allocate federal funds for medical research? Where is it implied? It is nothing more than a usurpation of the power of the States, or the people, as designated by the 10th Amendment. It would be amazing to see how small our Federal Government would become if they abided by Article II and the 10th Amendment...for a change.
Fat stem cell chance, huh?
"The words of a President have an enormous weight and ought not to be used indiscriminately." - Calvin Coolidge