On his program on Monday evening, CNN anchor Lou Dobbs criticized the proponents of the theory of manmade global warming in response to a report by correspondent Ines Ferre about the latest climate data: “[T]hey bring this thing to a personal belief system. It’s almost a religion, without any question...” He went on to criticize the “crowding out of facts and objective assessment of those facts...there’s such selective choices of data as one discusses and tries to understand the reality of the issues that make up global warming.”
Dobbs set the tone early as he introduced Ferre’s report, which began 41 minutes into the 7 pm Eastern hour of the CNN program: “The issue of global warming is, of course, a controversial and divisive topic, and it has been such for some time....Either way, somebody gets offended. Well, tonight, relax, we have another report for you, and all of who you believe in global warming will be challenged, and the facts, if you’re not interested in the facts, you shouldn't pay attention, as Ines Ferre reports.”
Ferre outlined how the data from this past year painted a “confusing picture of our world’s climate.” Apparently, 2008 was “the ninth or tenth warmest year since 1850, when record keeping began, but it also was the coolest year since the turn of the 21st century.” Later, she played two clips from manmade climate change skeptics. She also briefly discussed the possibility that “future regulations on greenhouse gas emissions could include what could amount to a cow tax.”
After her videotaped report concluded, Ferre introduced another possible explanation for climate change -- the sun’s natural cycle of sunspot activity: “There are also more questions over claims that so-called global warming is manmade. Scientists are looking at sunspot activity. They're linking the presence or absence of sunspots to warmer or cooler temperatures on earth.”
The full transcript of the segment from Monday’s Lou Dobbs Tonight:
LOU DOBBS: The issue of global warming is, of course, a controversial and divisive topic, and it has been such for some time. This broadcast has, on occasion, been criticized by either side for challenging global warming theories, or simply saying why not accept the idea of global warming as a basis for stewardship of the planet? Either way, somebody gets offended. Well, tonight, relax, we have another report for you, and all of who you believe in global warming will be challenged, and the facts, if you’re not interested in the facts, you shouldn't pay attention, as Ines Ferre reports.
INES FERRE (voice-over): A confusing picture of our world’s climate. Three independent research groups found that 2008 was the ninth or tenth warmest year since 1850, when record keeping began, but it also was the coolest year since the turn of the 21st century. New data from the University of Illinois says ice levels are roughly the same as those seen 29 years ago. But after decades of ice-melt in the Arctic, that may be of little comfort. The increase is because of the formation of thin ice which melts easily once the winter is over. Even so, one climatologist skeptical of global warming feels the entire debate is muddled with selective data.
JOSEPH D’ALEO, CLIMATOLOGIST: We are too short-sighted, or certainly the -- those who believe in it are not looking at the all -- big picture, which needs to include other factors -- the natural cycles in the ocean and of the sun, that are the real drivers.
FERRE: NASA scientists report that more than 2 trillion tons of land ice in Greenland, the Arctic, and Antarctic have melted since 2003. Some farmers fear future regulations on greenhouse gas emissions could include what could amount to a cow tax. The United Nations calculates livestock are responsible for 18 percent of greenhouse gas emissions worldwide.
PAT MICHAELS, CATO INSTITUTE: Extremism in the pursuit of climate policy is certainly no virtue, and what's really going on is we have rather a moderate increase in temperature, so why would one jump off the bridge and take money away from people?
FERRE: The Environmental Protection Agency says methane, a greenhouse gas associated with livestock, is ‘not being considered for regulation at this point.’
FERRE (on-screen): There are also more questions over claims that so-called global warming is manmade. Scientists are looking at sunspot activity. They're linking the presence or absence of sunspots to warmer or cooler temperatures on earth. Lou?
DOBBS: Yeah, the one -- the one issue here, and as we have examined and reported on the issue of global warming, it is so clear that on both sides, but particularly the pro-global warming, if there is such a thing, if I can put it that way, they are -- they bring this thing to a personal belief system. It’s almost a religion, without any question, and what we’re watching now -- we’re, what, the second year of the solar sunspot activity cycle, an 11-year cycle, and many scientists are saying, my gosh, compared to what our sun can do, man has minuscule influence.
FERRE: And there’s some scientists that say that, for example, last year, there were 266 days out of all of last year that there was no sunspot activity, and so they’re saying now this is going to indicate cooler temperatures on earth. But yeah, I mean, people are very passionate about this topic.
DOBBS: Well, and passionate -- we’re all concerned about this planet. We’re concerned about our atmosphere, our air, our water, and our children’s futures. But there seems to be such a crowding out of facts and objective assessment of those facts, and as the scientists, the climatologist in your report suggests, there’s such selective choices of data as one discusses and tries to understand the reality of the issues that make up global warming. Thank you very much, Ines Ferre -- nice job.
FERRE: Thank you.
—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
In spite of his conversion
January 6, 2009 - 17:10 ET by Chris NormanIn spite of his conversion to populism, Lou Dobbs occasionally swerves towards common sense. However, he will always be limited by the fact he appears on CNN and has to work with staff and guests from the CNN pool. He can only go so far...
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
Almost is not the word.
January 6, 2009 - 17:13 ET by mattmAlmost is not the word.
Sun, Sun, Sun
January 6, 2009 - 17:16 ET by NorthCoasterWill wonders never cease, an MSM journalist. Thank you Lou Dobbs!
Here is a link to Joseph D'Aleo's website! It's a very good place to start!
http://icecap.us/index.php
Extensive evidence that the Sun controls the climate
January 6, 2009 - 20:31 ET by PopularTechTheir is extensive evidence that the Sun controls the climate.
Unstoppable Solar Cycles (Video) (10min)
The Cosmic Climate Connection (Video) (1min)
The persistent role of the Sun in climate forcing (PDF) (The Danish National Space Center)
100,000-Year Climate Pattern Linked To Sun's Magnetic Cycles (Dartmouth College)
Breathing Cycles in Earth's Upper Atmosphere Linked to Solar Wind Disturbances (University of Colorado at Boulder)
Changes In Sun’s Intensity Tied To Recurrent Droughts In Maya Region (University of Florida)
Cosmic Rays Linked To Global Warming (University of New York)
Evidence For Sun-climate Link Reported By UMaine Scientists (University of Maine)
Flares From Sun's Far Side May Affect Space Weather Of Inner Planets (Swedish Institute of Space Physics)
Greater Solar Activity May Bring United States More Gray Days (NASA)
Holes In Sun's Corona Linked To Atmospheric Temperature Changes On Earth (Long Island University)
NASA Finds Sun-Climate Connection in Old Nile Records (NASA)
NASA Study Finds Increasing Solar Trend That Can Change Climate (NASA)
New Analysis Shows Earth's Lower Stratosphere In Synch With Solar Cycle (National Center for Atmospheric Research)
New Experiment To Investigate Effect Of Galactic Cosmic Rays On Clouds And Climate (CERN)
Northern Climate, Ecosystems Driven By Cycles Of Changing Sunlight (University Of Illinois)
Regional Variation In Warming From Sun During Solar Cycle Shown By Satellite (University of Colorado)
Scientists Determine Biological And Ecosystem Changes In Polar Regions Linked To Solar Variability (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory)
Sun's Direct Role In Global Warming May Be Underestimated, Duke Physicists Report (Duke University)
Sun's Magnetic Field May Impact Weather And Climate: Sun Cycle Can Predict Rainfall Fluctuations (University of New England, Australia)
Sun's Past Strength Took Toll On Tropical Glaciers, Worsens Today's Outlook (University of Alberta, Canada)
Surface Warming And The Solar Cycle (University of Washington)
The Sun's Chilly Impact On Earth (NASA)
The Sun Is More Active Now Than Over The Last 8000 Years (Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research)
Read the sunspots (R. Tim Patterson, Ph.D. Professor of Earth Science)
Carbon Dioxide (CO2) is Not Pollution
Wow PT!
January 6, 2009 - 20:43 ET by RukusExcellent links! Haven't perused them all but great sources! Global Warming hoax being dissected bit by bit. Rock on!
Gary
"Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch. Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote."
Sunspots, Sunspots, Sun...Oops!
January 7, 2009 - 02:26 ET by nofateNC: good link. It led me to Dr. Roy Spencer whose link in my favorites had gone dead.
2008 ended with a blank sun. 2008 was a year with low sunspot numbers, in fact it ranked on the high side for days with "blank" suns. Dr. Hathaway has had to revise the predictions for sunspot activity levels several times as the sun does not seem to want to cooperate with NASA's predictions. But not to fear, we can play "find the sunspot" in this picture. SpaceWeather.com says there is one there. I have my doubts Galileo or even the guys at the National Solar Observatory could see this without a satellite umpteen million miles out in the clear in space.
Joseph D'Aleo had this to say at Watts Up With That?:
And, speaking of the National Solar Observatory, here is an article in Watts Up With That? about a much non-ballyhooed paper by two scientists at that observatory:
I can't wait to find out what happens. That's the year I turn 65 and start collecting my big fat SS checks. Can't wait for that either.
And, speaking of "non-events" (i.e. those that will probably not see the light of day in the MSM), Joe Bastardi of AccuWeather.com has this doozy, from Watts Up With That? (again!):
"The future is not set. There is no fate but what we make for ourselves."
michaelyon-online.com
Job well done Dobbs and
January 6, 2009 - 17:19 ET by bigtimerJob well done Dobbs and guest.
If people wre in my ares the last few years, especially this one...they would just about choke anyone if they used the words, global warming, climate change, ect ect.
It is and ha been indescribable...I just wish this for the east coast...for a long time...especially D.C.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Lou Dodds Creating Global Warming For the Left
January 6, 2009 - 17:23 ET by The Smokin FrogYes, I agree. Lou Dobbs can sometimes, many times, be quite good. He has his glitches, but so does everyone else.
I had heard he was friends with Al Gore, but I have no idea if it's true. If it is true, I think inventive Al must be creating a lot of global warming all on his own over some of the things Lou Dobbs says.
http://www.cafepress...
I think it is so bizarre
January 6, 2009 - 17:26 ET by thebutlerdiditI think it is so bizarre that if people are so concerned as a whole, instead of a select group, why is it that the Prius, and other hybrid cars didn't make the top ten most purchased cars of 07? Why was it big pickups, and midsize cars, and not a single one that got 35 mpg? If given the choice, people in general just don't want them. And this was at a time when gas was so high. The sales in EU for hybrid cars plunged last year. So, why is it that if we are so worried about it, didn't we make purchasing a hybrid or small car a no. 1 priority? I think this is just like everything else, people want to say they support GW, but most when it comes to their car, say I think I'll get what I will enjoy/need.
Almost? There's no question
January 6, 2009 - 17:54 ET by sentforth5A core belief in Global Warming IS a religion, and it's nothing new. Here, here for Mr. Dobbs bringing forth stories like this. There have always been "tree-huggers", but this latest foray into Earth worship brought to us by the profit Algore has been very effective. It is a particular evil as it feeds on the weak-minded and it is child abuse by deception.
James 4:4 Ye adulterers and adulteresses, know ye not that the friendship of the world is enmity with God? whosoever therefore will be a friend of the world is the enemy of God.
Yeah, count me out..I don't wanna get gored.
Job Ch.40 God describes a dinosaur.
The Devine Creator
January 6, 2009 - 18:02 ET by dboHere's yet another example of how James Hansen "creates" global warming.
http://www.americant...
Coulter
January 6, 2009 - 18:36 ET by sawing battaisnt this Coulter's point? that Global Warming is the religion of the Left...
http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=19927
She's now been branded unfit for NBC audiences...Lou better cork it or the politburo will excommunicate him, too.
I don't who coined the
January 7, 2009 - 07:05 ET by BigSky1970I don't who coined the phrase, but I've heard Rush Limbaugh refer to global warming as a left-winged religion and Glenn Beck has referred to it that way too.
C02 causing global warming is false
January 6, 2009 - 19:19 ET by needleHarold Ambler in the HuffintonPost essentially proves that man-made global warming is false.
An excerpt is provided below (the bolding is mine):
Meanwhile, the theory that carbon dioxide "drives" climate in any meaningful way is simply wrong and, again, evidence of a "flat-Earth" mentality. Carbon dioxide cannot absorb an unlimited amount of infrared radiation. Why not? Because it only absorbs heat along limited bandwidths, and is already absorbing just about everything it can. That is why plotted on a graph, C02's ability to capture heat follows a logarithmic curve. We are already very near the maximum absorption level. Further, the IPCC Fourth Assessment, like all the ones before it, is based on computer models that presume a positive feedback of atmospheric warming via increased water vapor.
4. This mechanism has never been shown to exist. Indeed, increased temperature leads to increased evaporation of the oceans, which leads to increased cloud cover (one cooling effect) and increased precipitation (a bigger cooling effect). Within certain bounds, in other words, the ocean-atmosphere system has a very effective self-regulating tendency. By the way, water vapor is far more prevalent, and relevant, in the atmosphere than carbon dioxide -- a trace gas. Water vapor's absorption spectrum also overlays that of carbon dioxide. They cannot both absorb the same energy! The relative might of water vapor and relative weakness of carbon dioxide is exemplified by the extraordinary cooling experienced each night in desert regions, where water in the atmosphere is nearly non-existent.
Read the whole thing here: Harold Ambler: Mr. Gore: Apology Accepted
It is amazing that this has not been generally known until now; another important example of how the MSM has completely failed to do its job [deliberately!]
Impunitas semper ad deteriora invitat.
Finally Lou Dobbs is coming around
January 6, 2009 - 20:23 ET by PopularTechGlobal Warming is a religion because their is no science to support the man-made global warming theory, just faith.
Environmentalism as Religion (Michael Crichton, A.B. Anthropology, M.D. Harvard)
Gore's Global Warming Religion (Ann Coulter, Human Events)
Carbon Dioxide (CO2) is Not Pollution
The 'Religion of Global Warming'
January 6, 2009 - 20:24 ET by Retired GeekWhere is the separation of religion and state?
Across the world there are reports of unseasonal snow and plummeting temperatures last month, from the American Great Plains to China, and from the Alps to New Zealand. China’s official news agency reported that Tibet had suffered its “worst snowstorm ever”. In the US, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration registered 63 local snowfall records and 115 lowest-ever temperatures for the month, and ranked it as only the 70th-warmest October in 114 years.
Yet the 'Religion of Global Warming' Nasa’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS), which is run by Al Gore’s chief scientific ally, Dr James Hansen, and is one of four bodies responsible for monitoring global temperatures, announced that last month was the hottest October on record.
What!
Huh!
Kids all over America are complaining to there mom's about having to shovel 'Global Warming' off the sidewalks and driveways.
If Al Gore or Barack Obama said it, don't believe it, that settles it.
October Surprise
January 6, 2009 - 21:03 ET by dboAfter Hansen's embarrassing "October surprise" and admission they have little quality control, I noticed GISS has started to cover their butt a little with a new policy.
http://data.giss.nas...
But, if (as they told us.)
January 6, 2009 - 21:24 ET by danboBut, if (as they told us.) there's only .25 or .5 FTE generating these numbers. And little if any transparency. Holding it a little longer isn't going to do much.
Limited Disclosure: I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.
S. Fred Singer
January 7, 2009 - 02:32 ET by nofatedanbo: you may have it, but I just got a book by Singer, "Unstoppable Global Warming: Every 1500 Years" that I find very interesting. I wrote about it here, if you haven't read the book, you may find it interesting.
"The future is not set. There is no fate but what we make for ourselves."
michaelyon-online.com
"Some farmers fear future
January 7, 2009 - 00:44 ET by ckc1227"Some farmers fear future regulations on greenhouse gas emissions could
include what could amount to a cow tax. The United Nations calculates
livestock are responsible for 18 percent of greenhouse gas emissions
worldwide."
Baaah, just slap a solar panel on each cow. Problem solved.
"Libs never let you down. You don't have to talk to one very long before the stupid comes out."
Al Gore and 'Cow Flatulence'
January 7, 2009 - 02:31 ET by Retired GeekAl Gore will soon release his study on 'Cow Flatulence', the Liberal Genuis has determined the following:
One Trillion Cow Farts Released Into Atmosphere Yearly.
1000 cow farts = 1 Megafart
1,000,000 cow farts = 1 Gigafart
1,000,000,000 cow farts = 1 Kyotofart
1,000,000,000,000 cow farts = 1 AlGorefart
Al Gore is expected to sell cow fart credits to cover those who fly in private jets and ride in limosines. A personal cow fart certificate signed by Al Gore will show your cow fart support.
Get your cow fart certificate today!!
Al Gore first 'Fart Czar' and Elevator Music
January 7, 2009 - 02:15 ET by Retired GeekBarack Obama is so excited with the work that Al Gore has accomplished in 'Global Warming, that Obama will name him 'Fart Czar' to head up the 'New Alternate Energy Commission on Human Flatulence'.
Al Gore industries, has designed a new 'Human flatulence collector' that will be a major source of energy under the Obama administration.
Obama will 'Mandate' that a 'Al Gore flatulence collector' be placed in all elevators in the United States.
Obama will further 'Mandate' that all American citizens will be required under the 'Cap and Collect Mandate' to hold all human emissions until fully entered in the elevator and the door is closed and then they can expell the gas.
Al Gore stated that "the equipment works best with an elevator full of people."
The new project will probably replace Elevator Music all over America.