Wednesday’s American Morning program ran a report by correspondent Abbie Boudreau that desperately tried to criticize vice-presidential candidate Sarah Palin for a "Road to Nowhere" that was part of the infamous "Bridge to Nowhere" project. Boudreau interviewed Bob Weinstein, the Democratic mayor of Ketchikan, Alaska, who claimed that the Alaska governor "spent $26 million out of a federal earmark for the Gravina access, a.k.a. 'Bridge to Nowhere' project, on this road that will not go to a bridge." Boudreau also interviewed a toll booth operator and a former Palin campaign coordinator to agree it was a regrettable boondoggle. Throughout the report, the on-screen graphic proclaimed, "Road to Nowhere: Another Sarah Palin Project." CNN was implying to its viewers that both the infamous Bridge and the road from it were "Palin projects," as if she originated them, instead of appearing on the scene halfway into the story.
Weinstein claimed Palin could have stopped the project. At the end of the report, the correspondent explained that Meg Stapleton, Palin’s campaign spokeswoman, had said that "under ordinary circumstances, Governor Palin would not have allowed the Gravina road project to move forward. But given the federal earmark was granted and because the contract for the road was already signed before she got into office, the governor was left no viable alternative." Therefore, CNN devoted nearly four minutes to Palin critics insisting she was responsible for a boondoggle….that they favored.
Boudreau, who is part of CNN’s so-called Special Investigations Unit, traveled to Ketchikan and Gravina Island and walked down the "Road to Nowhere" with Weinstein, the Democratic mayor. In her introduction to the first of two clips with Weinstein, Boudreau stated that the mayor "calls it Governor Palin's ‘Road to Nowhere.’" After taking P.J. Murphy, the toll collector, to the road for her take on it, she played the second clip from Weinstein, as the two of them walked down the empty road. He made light of how the only people using the road at that point were the two of them. The correspondent then went to a clip from her interview of Mike Elerding, the former Palin campaign coordinator. She asked him if he thought it was "a waste of taxpayer money." He answered, "Without the bridge, yeah. Yes."
Boudreau did not emphasize that both Weinstein and Elerding were backers of the Bridge to Nowhere who are now angry with Palin for reversing course. They also failed to note that Weinstein ran the local Democratic campaign against her in 2006, as the Anchorage Daily News reported two days after Palin became McCain's running mate.
Mayor Weinstein said many residents remain irked by Palin's failure to come to Ketchikan since that time to defend her decision -- despite promises that she would.
Weinstein may be especially sore -- he helped run the local campaign of Palin's 2006 Democratic rival, Tony Knowles. But comments this week from area Republicans show bitterness there too.
Bert Stedman, a Sitka Republican who represents Ketchikan in the state Senate, told the Ketchikan Daily News he was proud to see Palin picked for the vice-president's role, but disheartened by her reference to the bridge.
"In the role of governor, she should be pursuing a transportation policy that benefits the state of Alaska, (rather than) pandering to the southern 48," he said.
Businessman Mike Elerding, who helped run Palin's local campaign for governor, told the paper he would have a hard time voting for the McCain ticket because of Palin's subsequent neglect of Ketchikan and her flip-flop on the "Ralph Bartholomew Veterans Memorial Bridge."
Despite trying to smear Palin with this project, CNN didn’t reveal the extent of the plagiarism controversy which rocked the failed 1988 presidential bid of Palin’s opponent, Delaware Senator Joe Biden, during their hour-long special look at the Democratic vice-presidential candidate earlier in September, which was anchored by Boudreau.
The full transcript of Abbie Boudreau’s report, which began 17 minutes into the 8 am Eastern hour of Wednesday’s American Morning:
(CNN CHYRON: "Road to Nowhere: Another Sarah Palin Project")
JOHN ROBERTS: 17-and-a-half minutes now after the hour. So, who hasn't heard Governor Sarah Palin say that she told Congress thanks but no thanks on that 'Bridge to Nowhere?' Most people have heard that. But did you know that leading up to the non-existent bridge that she was for before she was against is the little-known 'road to nowhere,' and it is very real. Our Special Investigations Unit correspondent Abbie Boudreau found it, drove it, and reports now on how it came to be.
ABBIE BOUDREAU (voice-over): Take a look down there. That's the City of Ketchikan. And over there across the Tongass Narrows -- that's Gravina Island, and that's where the local airport sits. To get there from Ketchikan, you have to take the ferry. It takes about 10 minutes. So that brings us first to the plans for the notorious expensive 'Bridge to Nowhere.' It would have crossed the Narrows here, but to get to the airport, they needed a road. But here's what happened: when the political outcry about the bridge got so loud and they killed it, well, it was too late. They'd already signed a contract for the road project, so they built it.
BOUDREAU (on-camera): This is Gravina Island Highway. It runs about three miles long at $8 million per mile, paid for by your tax dollars. But there's no one on this road. Many locals call it the 'Road to Nowhere.'
BOUDREAU (voice-over): The Democratic mayor of Ketchikan calls it Governor Palin's 'Road to Nowhere.'
MAYOR BOB WEINSTEIN, DEMOCRAT, KETCHIKAN, ALASKA: She's been saying, 'I told Congress thanks, but no thanks. I stopped that "Bridge to Nowhere" project.' In fact, she didn't tell Congress, thanks, but no thanks, and spent $26 million out of a federal earmark for the Gravina access, a.k.a. 'Bridge to Nowhere' project, on this road that will not go to a bridge.
BOUDREAU: Weinstein says, of course, a road would have made sense if a bridge had been built, considering how now, locals and tourists have to take a ferry to the airport. While we were on the road, we met P.J. Murphy, who works on the island.
P.J. MURPHY, TOLL BOOTH COLLECTOR: Not many people are coming out yet.
BOUDREAU (on-camera): No. Why did you call?
MURPHY: Well, I'm the toll collector down there, and I wanted to see where it went and what it looked like.
BOURDREAU: What do you think?
MURPHY: It's a nice road. It's a nice road. It's a lot better than the road I drive on to go home.
BOUDREAU: And what do you think about where it ends?
MURPHY: Well, it's the 'Bridge to Nowhere.' I mean, come on.
BOUDREAU (voice-over): Mayor Weinstein came with us to see the road, too.
BOUDREAU (on-camera): I mean, who is using this road? Since we've been here we haven't --
WEINSTEIN: Well, currently, you and I are using the road.
BOUDREAU (voice-over): He can joke about it now, wearing a 'Nowhere, Alaska' t-shirt. But he says that earmark money could have been used to fix roads and sidewalks in town that people actually use.
BOUDREAU (on-camera): Simply put, what could Governor Palin have done? If she says she's against earmarks, what could Governor Palin have done in this case?
WEINSTEIN: Governor Palin could have stopped construction of this road.
BOUDREAU (voice-over): Back up in the helicopter -- another reality check.
BOUDREAU (on-camera): It kind of just curves around then it just stops. That's where the bridge was supposed to pick up, right there.
BOUDREAU (voice-over): We tried to find someone in town who supported the road. So we contacted Palin's former campaign coordinator, an avid Palin supporter. But even he had a hard time not backing the project.
BOUDREAU (on-camera): Do you think it's a waste of taxpayer money?
MIKE ELERDING, FORMER PALIN CAMPAIGN COORDINATOR: On the road?
BOUDREAU: Yeah.
ELERDING: Without the bridge, yeah. Yes.
BOUDREAU (voice-over): Meg Stapleton, a McCain/Palin spokesperson tells us the governor had no choice, and that's why the project moved forward.
BOUDREAU (off-camera): It's hard to imagine that the governor wouldn't think that that's a waste of money -- taxpayer money.
MEGHAN STAPLETON, MCCAIN-PALIN CAMPAIGN SPOKESPERSON: The governor could not change that earmark. That earmark was given. That earmark was dictated. That had to be spent on the Gravina road and nothing else, and so, the governor had no options.
BOUDREAU: Could she have stopped construction?
STAPLETON: My understanding is that -- you know, I'd have to look into that for you. I don't know.
BOUDREAU: Stapleton did get back to us. And she says, under ordinary circumstances, Governor Palin would not have allowed the Gravina road project to move forward. But given the federal earmark and because the contract for the road was already signed before she got into office, the governor was left no viable alternative. Abbie Boudreau, CNN, Anchorage, Alaska.
ROBERTS: But it is a lovely road.
—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Keep it up, CNN. You're
September 24, 2008 - 14:24 ET by NewsbusterbrownKeep it up, CNN. You're just antagonizing more and more conservatives with your outright lies and obfuscation.
“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)
it makes no sense
September 24, 2008 - 14:36 ET by docbShe stopped the bridge [NOT]but kept and spent the money--yet, she could not stop the road!!!
Bullcrap, hogwash....Liar Liar...I have worked with Gov'ts for many years and we revise, amend, and cancel contracts ALL THE TIME....
The State offical is CYA-ing for her boss...probably at the the Mcsame campaigns request...
Could she have cancelled the
September 24, 2008 - 14:39 ET by Matthew BalanCould she have cancelled the contract outright, even with the federal earmark and/or mandate?
Once that contract is
September 24, 2008 - 19:54 ET by Dan The Man 2Once that contract is signed the bonding kicks in and all sorts of liabilities, not to mention the lawsuits. So it was better to build the thing once contracts are signed. In my line of work I deal with contracts and once they are executed they are rock solid.
Besides it is a toll road which means the road will be paid for with tolls. Just because there are none now that doesn't mean there wont be traffic down the road.
Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.
I guess you're a world
September 24, 2008 - 15:09 ET by marvlI guess you're a world authority on this, huh? You were in charge of the toilet bowl cleaning contracts for the city of Barstow? Yep, I suspect you're as half-cocked and empty-headed as those CNN bozos.
I guess the explanation escapes the simpletons (i.e. leftists).
September 24, 2008 - 15:18 ET by Joe C.Palin is for a bridge to connect the island to the airport, just not that expensive a bridge. The road had to be built eventually, since the money and contract were already in place, why stop it? All that would have done is increase the cost of the road later. Sheeesh!
You people are so blind to find any little fault that the obvious and logical complete evades you (and CNN). Y'all need to grow up.
Liar Liar
September 24, 2008 - 16:09 ET by CobraManLiar Liar, you the liar!
No governor can cancel an existing construction project once the project, and the funds for that project, has been approved by the state legislature as it becomes state law when that legislation is signed. To cancel that construction project would require another legislative act. The only time a governor can "cancel" a project is BEFORE that governor signs legislation approving that project. They do this by use of a line-item veto, which is how Palin "canceled" the Bridge to Nowhere. She wasn’t the governor when the legislation that authorized the construction of the road itself was signed, so there was NOTHING she could do about that road.
On edit: that's construction project and not construction contract as originally posted.
Obama: My job is above my pay grade
I see Dick Cheney in a Beehive
September 24, 2008 - 16:54 ET by BlondeIs still chapping your cheeks, docb.
How are you liking that?
And you're a fine one to post "Liar Liar" after your repeated "Wet Start" smears of John McCain here.
Who's the liar, docb?
You are, of course.
David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive
Sheesh!!!
September 24, 2008 - 17:40 ET by DoktorFrankenCan't the 0bama campaign afford a better (more intelligent) class of troll? This is NewsBusters, for cryin' out loud!
Good to see that everyone's on their toes.
I'm tellin' ya, Doc,
September 24, 2008 - 19:00 ET by Indiana JoeWe get no respect, no respect at all, I tell ya!
"... smells like... victory." - Robert Duvall
I always thought it was CNN
September 24, 2008 - 14:36 ET by Clear thinkerI always thought it was CNN that was on the road to nowhere.
Liberals Have A New Goddess
Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/
Obama's Sex Ed for Kindergartners Bill
September 24, 2008 - 14:39 ET by deerjerkydaveThis is the same liberal media that is quick to disregard criticisms against Obama's support for the sex-ed-for-5-year-olds bill since it never passed.
Palin
September 24, 2008 - 14:45 ET by rick007The leftest idiots would rather a communist get in office than a smart female.
Two things I would like to see.
Palin with Amadag.
"O" Dumby with Amadag.
She will tell him like it is and "O" Dumby will ask him what he wants to satisfy him. Sounds like the commie Carter. Friends with Castro,Chavez.and Amadag. and three bandaid Kerry.
Hmm if "O" Dumby is 1/2 and 1/2 how come he took the negro side? Could it be that he was assured more monetary assistance than a White?
Obviously, it's lib fems...
September 24, 2008 - 15:00 ET by wnaegele...who most hate Palin. Even CNN has had positive stories about her -- all from male correspondents/anchors...
YYYaaawwwnnn!!!
September 24, 2008 - 15:26 ET by Joe C.How much is missing from the Obama-Ayers Annenberg Challenge again? $50-60 million, you say?
How much in earmarks did Obama request last year again? $900+ million, you say?
Even if Palin was responsible for an earmark and contract signed from before she was governor, she'd be a piker compared to B. Hussein. Plus, it was the right decision as I explained above.
This is so tiresome.....
September 24, 2008 - 15:57 ET by alaskakimI live in Ketchikan and have read and heard enough BS from the lower 48 about a bridge that was promised by the feds 30 years ago when the airport was moved from Metlakatla (Annett IsLand) to Gravina Island. After 30 years of neglect we had it close at hand, at a much higher cost than 30 years ago when promised, then some cute lib. news wannabe down in florida comes up with his witty bridge to no where in a way to slam Ted Stevens.
Bottom line; the bridge was promised and never came through and the only people STILL talking about it are in the LOWER 48. We in Ketchikan, for the most part, have moved on. We'll develop a plan on our own, new ferry, tunnel, options are open.
I wonder where Oakland CA would be if not for the Golden Gate Bridge to NOWHERE as it was known back in the day.
alaskakim... I could not
September 24, 2008 - 16:15 ET by bigtimeralaskakim...
I could not agree more, I was furious how this bridge to nowhere was covered from the beginning, starting with McCain making a huge deal out of it on the Senate floor...adn the left taking off with it...unless people live in Ak. they know not of what they speak, that bridge was important, Sarah was for it before she went against it...I don't care if others here wnat to hear that...I understand very well about the cost BS.
I have posted as such before she was named VP...
I have been furious with the way some have covered and posted about Stevens and I have posted ny thoughts on this too...unless people lived there, plus more importantly watch the Senate in action daily with their speeches and such they just go along to get along with others not knowing the real facts.
Stevens has fought hard for Alaska for years.
But we don't go onto Reid's ethics pages or his financial statements he has changed over time, Rangel is another ...we could go on and on...
I still find it more than maddening.
If any of them are guilty of abuse/fraud/corruption, they should be charged, but it only seems to be those that are with an 'R' behind their name the majority of the time...and there are others in the Senate that I call RINOs that wanted Stevens gone too....plus some in Ak. which goes without saying.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
I suggest a tunnel
September 24, 2008 - 16:16 ET by CobraMan"We'll develop a plan on our own, new ferry, tunnel, options are open."
I suggest a tunnel as, living in a state with harsh winters (though not nearly as harsh as those found in Alaska), I prefer tunnels over bridges as tunnels withstand harsh climates longer, they're cheaper to maintain in the long run (if constructed properly), and they can become a temporary shelters when the weather gets REALLY bad. All in all, they are a better choice even though their initial costs are higher.
Obama: My job is above my pay grade
The only problem with a
September 24, 2008 - 16:28 ET by Matthew BalanThe only problem with a tunnel is the fact that the lower part of Alaska is seismically-active.
»→ Matthew
September 24, 2008 - 16:34 ET by Cool ArrowThat's why you're so smart. 'Cuz you're always thinking.
"Don't taze me bro" - Joe Biden
Matthew...I was going to
September 24, 2008 - 17:02 ET by bigtimerMatthew...I was going to post that...glad you did...didn't want cobra to think I was intentionally trying to argue with him.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Why would I think that?
September 24, 2008 - 20:16 ET by CobraMan"didn't want cobra to think I was intentionally trying to argue with him"
Why would I think that?
Obama: My job is above my pay grade
Good point
September 24, 2008 - 20:15 ET by CobraManGood point, I forgot about that.
Obama: My job is above my pay grade
I was raised in Ketchikan,
September 24, 2008 - 17:12 ET by ElyasI was raised in Ketchikan, and the "Bridge to Nowhere" become a distant reality to us a long time ago. We understood that it would not be built and were already examing other options. And I agree about the "Nowhere" part being a bit misleading. The bridge would have led to massive development on Gravina Island. There are already a few houses on the island, but if the bridge had been built there would have been a huge expanison on Gravina. Our town(Ketchikan) is slowly fading every since Clinton's environmental policies stopped up from logging in our own forests and this type of growth would have surely helped.
Thomas Jefferson once said, 'We should never judge a president by his age, only by his works.' And ever since he told me that, I stopped worrying. - Ronald Reagan
Did you guys ever try
September 24, 2008 - 17:18 ET by Clear thinkerDid you guys ever try explaining to Clinton that trees grow back?
Sorry, I'm not picking on you, just showing frustration with Dems and their stupid ideas.
No Debate Drives Libs Nuts
Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/
Elyas... It would make me
September 24, 2008 - 17:32 ET by bigtimerElyas...
It would make me furious...Murkowski would be on the Senate floor time after time explaining about mills being shut down statewide little by little, just like here in the NW too...last time I heard him talking there were only two mills left I think he said, always talking about Ketchikan..my husband and friends logged in Ak too..it was diminishing then with the BS that went on..we had to take other jobs to supplement out income also...from fishing boats to a lot of things...if people knew or understood how much of the huge state the fed. govt. owns they may have more understanding...
Doubtful though.
Btw...we put in a bid on some logging that was starting to be beetle killed on the Kenai Peninsula...environs stopped any logging...while the whole damned forest got ate up about two years later..it was and is a crying shame.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
I use to live in Ketchikan,
September 24, 2008 - 17:17 ET by ElyasI use to live in Ketchikan, and had met Bob Weinstein. He has always been a squeaky wheel, and if he doesn't get his way then he just constantly complains until he does.
So basically, your typical liberal (And a lawyer).
Thomas Jefferson once said, 'We should never judge a president by his age, only by his works.' And ever since he told me that, I stopped worrying. - Ronald Reagan
Obama & Biden voted for the bridge, then against bridge repairs
September 24, 2008 - 17:54 ET by Gary HallAn important note for this item. Obama & Biden voted for the bridge, then voted against transfering that funding to bridge repairs - in New Orleans, mind you.
First. Senator's Obama and Biden voted for the bill with the Bridge to Nowhere earmarks in it.
Second. Sen. Coburn (R.), with whom Obama has worked, put forth a measure in front of the Senate which would strip and transfer the funds from the Bridge to Nowhere in Alaska, to funding the reconstruction of the Lake Pontchartrain Causeway, in New Orleans, which was severely damaged by Hurricane Katrina.
Both Senator's Obama and Biden voted against that measure. Now, that is a front page story the voters and taxpayers need and deserve to hear.
Third. File this under: Obama's Gazebo to Nowhere.
This just in... Obama
September 24, 2008 - 18:57 ET by JerryThis just in... Obama failed to stop the O'Leary's cow from starting the great Chicago fire. Un-named sources say he may even have caused the cow to kick over the lantern by repeatedly "pushing" the cow from the rear.
When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).