CNN correspondent Tom Foreman omitted identifying a "foreign policy expert" as a former member of Bill Clinton’s National Security Council during a report on John McCain’s strong position towards Russia on Wednesday’s Election Center program. This expert, Charles Kupchan of the Council of Foreign Relations, accused McCain of becoming a belligerent position towards the country: "Well, over the last few years, McCain's views on Russia seem to be getting more and more confrontational, and I think he's really aligned himself with the far right, not with the centrists within the Republican Party. And, in some ways, it almost appears either if he thinks the Cold War is still on or that he wants it to return."
Kupchan, a professor of international relations at Georgetown University, served as Director for European Affairs on the National Security Council during Clinton’s first term. He also has complimented Barack Obama for his willingness to "engage adversaries," which to him is "a sign not of naiveté or inexperience, but of hard-headed realism." Foreman used two sound bites from the professor during his report. At the beginning of the segment, the CNN correspondent played Ronald Reagan’s famous "tear down this wall" line from 1987 as he introduced McCain’s position on Russia: "In the final years of the Soviet Union, as Ronald Reagan was thundering at the Russians, John McCain was a first-term senator cheering him on, and, 21 years later, he still distrusts Russia."
After playing a clip of McCain speaking about Russia during a campaign spot, Foreman introduced Kupchan as a "foreign policy expert," and played his "far right" comment. During the second sound bite, Kupchan outlined what he thinks might happen concerning U.S.-Russia relations if McCain became President: "I think it's arguably dangerous in the sense that by assuming that Russia may be more aggressive than it is, and by pushing Russia's back up against the wall, it's possible that one can produce a self-fulfilling prophecy."
Despite using Kupchan’s liberal rhetoric, Foreman acknowledged that "McCain's stance on Russia has been consistent, and it has brought many admirers to his side, other Americans who also believe that the Russian bear is best kept on a short leash."
One of the last times CNN used a sound bite from Kupchan was when correspondent Paula Newton reported on Cindy Sheehan’s trip to the UK in 2005. The anti-war activist tried to get then-Prime Minister Tony Blair to change his position on the Iraq war, and Kupchan commented on the potential fallout if Blair shifted: "If Blair were to go wobbly, if he were to begin to say, it's time for us to begin to head for the exits, that would certainly increase the pressure on Bush to follow suit."
The full transcript of Foreman’s report, which began at 8:22 pm Eastern during Wednesday’s Election Center:
CAMPBELL BROWN: As we mentioned before the break, some of the toughest talk about the Russian invasion of Georgia is coming from the campaign trail. Today, Secretary of State Rice revealed that she has been in regular contact with both Barack Obama and with John McCain as this crisis unfolds. Now, McCain, of course, has been blasting the Russians ever since the story broke last week, and it had us thinking whether or not there may be something going on beyond the headlines, something a little more visceral for him.
Tom Foreman has been digging into McCain's record with the Russians, and he's joining us from the CNN Election Express, Joliet, Illinois, with the very latest on this.
TOM FOREMAN: Well, Campbell, there's no question that John McCain has more hands-on experience with Russia than Barack Obama does, and he's been presenting himself as both the voice of reason and of strength in this latest clash. But some foreign affairs experts are not buying it.
RONALD REAGAN: Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall.
FOREMAN (voice-over): In the final years of the Soviet Union, as Ronald Reagan was thundering at the Russians, John McCain was a first-term senator cheering him on, and, 21 years later, he still distrusts Russia. Listen to what he said campaigning in Michigan.
SENATOR JOHN MCCAIN: ...And I am interested in good relations between the United States and Russia. But, in the 21st century, nations don't invade other nations.
FOREMAN: A tough line, especially for a supporter of the Iraq invasion. But, he goes on:
MCCAIN: My position vis-a-vis the now-prime minister of Russia has been very clear for a long period of time, that I have been very concerned about Russian behavior in a broad variety of areas.
FOREMAN: And now listen to how this foreign policy expert is reacting.
CHARLES KUPCHAN, COUNCIL OF FOREIGN RELATIONS: Well, over the last few years, McCain's views on Russia seem to be getting more and more confrontational, and I think he's really aligned himself with the far right, not with the centrists within the Republican Party. And, in some ways, it almost appears either if he thinks the Cold War is still on or that he wants it to return.
FOREMAN: McCain has been critical of efforts to reach out to Russia politically and economically, even those of President Bush. He has repeatedly attacked Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, who is a former KGB boss.
MCCAIN: I looked into Mr. Putin's eyes, and I saw three letters, a K, a G, and B.
FOREMAN: McCain wrote in Foreign Affairs magazine: 'Today, we see in Russia diminishing political freedoms, a leadership dominated by a clique of former intelligence officers, efforts to bully democratic neighbors, such as Georgia, and attempts to manipulate Europe's dependence on Russian oil and gas.' McCain has pushed to have Russia thrown out of the G-8, that group of the world's largest democracies formed to promote economic and political cooperation. He has fought to bring the Soviet Union's former republics into NATO, a military alliance of Western powers formed to oppose Russia's military might.
KUPCHAN: I think it's arguably dangerous in the sense that by assuming that Russia may be more aggressive than it is, and by pushing Russia's back up against the wall, it's possible that one can produce a self-fulfilling prophecy.
FOREMAN (on-camera): Still, McCain's stance on Russia has been consistent, and it has brought many admirers to his side, other Americans who also believe that the Russian bear is best kept on a short leash. Campbell?
BROWN: Tom Foreman tonight -- Tom, thanks.
—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
While giving regards to Kupchan
August 14, 2008 - 16:33 ET by DEVILDOCMOMI certainly do not see putting the words "realism" and hard-headed" together in a sentence when discussing bho's views. As I read the remainder of the article I found not one problem with anything quoted from John McCain. I could not agree more with his statements and beliefs.
Anyone in the last century who has trusted the Russians is very, very naive. Putin has begun to twist the history of the USSR by "commissioning guidelines and books that present a more balanced picture of Joseph Stalin, described in one approved volume as "the most successful Soviet leader ever." (reasononline, 9/05/07). Wooh, if that isn't scary, nothing is.
McCain will gain traction
August 14, 2008 - 16:31 ET by bigtimerMcCain will gain traction from this...the majority of the msm who are in desperation mode now because of The One's poll numbers, let alone a roll call vote coming in Denver for Hillary, they will do their best to tear him down....
Newsflash...It isn't going to work.
I'm no McCain lover, or even liker, but when it comes to national security....and matters like Georgia/Russia/Putin, he has it all over Obama and the msm, hard as they try.
By the way, as far as I am concerned...McCain is right.
As an aside...if anybody has watched the pathetic reporting from Foreman over the years....he fits the description of a leftist wussy.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Yep,
August 14, 2008 - 16:36 ET by DEVILDOCMOMwe are on the same page on this one, bt. BTW, the dims convention will be fun from the standpoint of roll call vote for hill.
Hi Devil Doc... I am so
August 14, 2008 - 16:43 ET by bigtimerHi Devil Doc...
I am so looking forward to it...now I see today that Obama has announced he is unison with a roll call vote, it will unite the party and all that jazz...
Yeah right...
Maybe he saw some pigs flying...
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Pigs Flying
August 14, 2008 - 17:24 ET by CpickeringMaybe he saw some pigs flying...
Did Hillary fly somewhere today??
Engage Adversaries
August 14, 2008 - 16:51 ET by allanfIt seems that Obama's idea of engaging adversaries is to lie down and show his belly.
That's not what we hire a President to do.
Right BT - TRACTION
August 14, 2008 - 17:06 ET by SickofLibsHey Kupchan - someone just jammed a potato in your exhaust pipe and it blew up: Thanks for pointing out that McCain has been voicing concerns over Russia for years, while... Obama has been elsewhere occupied trying to get himself elected and flushing stuff down the toilet.
When this guy takes a vacation, he really takes a vacation. I am enjoying the relative silence, tho. Hey, but no need to rush back since the Senate is in recess anyway, right? Not that he's been there even when it was session.
Thank god he's so savvy with the Blackberry. He can dispatch those dire warnings to despots worldwide in seconds while lounging on the beach.
Cold War
August 14, 2008 - 16:43 ET by BlondeWell, if we're going to have another Cold War, I want a certified Cold Warrier at the helm.
BHO is clueless...totally. And as this craziness in the Balkans plays out, Obama will be shown for the idiot and neophyte he is.
David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive
Not the Balkans
August 14, 2008 - 17:26 ET by CpickeringGeorgia is in the Caucusus or Eurasia region, not the Balkans (former Yugoslavia)
Myth
August 14, 2008 - 17:15 ET by HumblepieTo believe Russia departed from communism is naive. It only went into hibernation while it allows other to pay for their past follies. Guess thats the Russian version of a Chapter7, Bankruptcy. Hey! They would make good liberals.
During this time with political correctness at its zenith, I reserve the right to let you know you're an idiot.
Communism?
August 14, 2008 - 22:50 ET by needleI would certainly not call the government that Russia has now Communist. It is more like a kleptocracy driven by thuggery. The thugs from the earlier KGB have seized control of the government and have used their power to grab up the assets of the country, thus making billionaires of Putin’s friends.
Communism this isn’t. Instead it is huge mockery of communism from which it is derived. Authoritarianism is the one common thread connecting the present with the past.
Impunitas semper ad deteriora invitat.
True Needle's
August 15, 2008 - 01:08 ET by HumblepieIt's not the classic Communism/Socialism we are use to but a new hybrid consisting of one power hungry group suppressing individuals, groups, and businesses not associated with the inner sanctum. Just pay your fees (bribes) and we'll allow you to operate, and by the way we'll have some of our people on the inside to "help you." As former KGB, they're doing what they know best (lie, steal, cheat, extort). If that doesn't work they know people who will make the problem go away. Putin is still rewriting their history in an attempt to portray Stalin as their greatest leader since the 1912 revolution. A new generation will be introduced to the thoughts and wisdom of a deranged madman.
Still sound like a liberal.
During this time with political correctness at its zenith, I reserve the right to let you know you're an idiot.
Tom Foreman is one of the
August 14, 2008 - 17:25 ET by d1carterTom Foreman is one of the best examples of the Peter Principle there is....
sweep sweep sweep
August 14, 2008 - 18:13 ET by MidAmericaThe msm has all their brooms out desparately trying sweep all concerns about national security under the rug until after the elections National security is a big lose for the dems.
Agree
August 14, 2008 - 18:18 ET by 10ksnookerSince the lefts candidate is a naive dunce on world affairs, what else could they do. Singing Kumbaya to bears is not very effective.
Beatin' around the Bush.
August 14, 2008 - 18:23 ET by CrashThe second I learned that the bear had broken out of it's KGB I asked, "What Would Reagan Do?" McCain's response was what! I am happy that we made a missile deal with Poland. Have those thugs only been biding time. Star Wars here we come. We need to sell missile up & down the Russian boarder and show some compassion for the next victims of Russian treachery. Perhaps I'm a little more Reaganesque than Reagan, but, I would have daisy cut the tank division on the way to the party.
come on CNN
August 14, 2008 - 19:17 ET by candanceWake up and smell the proverbial coffee. Russia is actively starting the Cold War back up whether we want it or not. The next president will either recognize this or get embarrassed.
How I wish it were true
August 14, 2008 - 20:01 ET by CobraMan"And, in some ways, it almost appears either if he thinks the Cold War is still on or that he wants it to return."
Oh, how I wish that were true! After all, the Cold War is the biggest defeat the Democrats faced since the Civil War.