Update below.
CNN correspondent Carol Costello compared Cindy McCain to a "Stepford Wife" due to her "low key" role in her husband’s campaign so far, in a segment on Wednesday’s "The Situation Room." Costello, detailing Mrs. McCain’s recent photo spread in Vogue magazine, stated the feature "projects an image quite unlike the Cindy McCain we see on the trail," and a talking head described this "Cindy McCain we see" as "low key... taking the traditional role of standing by her husband's side at events." Costello then quipped, "A role critics say makes Mrs. McCain look like -- well, Glenn Close in the movie ‘The Stepford Wives.’" [audio available here]
On the other hand, Costello described Michelle Obama’s Vogue spread more glowingly: "...Michelle Obama chose a traditional black dress with pearl earrings for her Vogue spread. As The Washington Post described it, it was if Michelle Obama was saying 'I am not some scary other.... I am Camelot with a tan.'"
Twice in her report, Costello emphasized that most people "don't really know much about Cindy McCain," except that she’s "really, really rich." After making this point the second time, Costello continued by bringing up the issue of Mrs. McCain’s tax returns. "What voters do know about her -- well, she's enormously wealthy, and she says she won't release her tax returns ever -- which says to voters, you're not one of us -- hence Vogue and the jeans."
Costello followed this portrayal of Cindy McCain by comparing it to Michelle Obama’s Vogue spread. "Interestingly, while Cindy McCain chose jeans for her Vogue spread, her likely competitor, Michelle Obama, chose a traditional black dress with pearl earrings for her Vogue spread. As The Washington Post described it, it was if Michelle Obama was saying 'I am not some scary other.... I am Camelot with a tan.'" The Washington Post quotation came from a May 18 piece by Robin Givhan which described the two Vogue features. In her article, Givhan also used the "Stepford wife" term.
Let’s get this straight: Mrs. McCain’s refusal to release her tax returns makes her some kind of elitist, but Michelle Obama, the millionaire, wearing a "traditional black dress with pearl earrings" is an attempt to connect with average voters? As if we needed another indication that CNN leans towards the Obamas.
The full transcript of Carol Costello’s segment, which first ran at the end of the 6 pm hour of Wednesday’s "The Situation Room:"
WOLF BLITZER: John McCain's wife Cindy is taking center stage in a whole new way. She's featured in a spread in Vogue magazine -- a move possibly aimed at a very specific goal. Let's go back to Carol. She's looking at this story for us. What are you seeing, Carol? What are you hearing?
CAROL COSTELLO, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Well, Wolf, you know, most of us don't really know much about Cindy McCain, except she's really, really rich. But if you take a peak at Vogue magazine, you may get a more well-rounded view.
COSTELLO (voice-over): Ooh la-la -- Cindy McCain in Vogue magazine looks spectacular, lounging at her seaside condo, sans John McCain -- feet bare, wearing size zero jeans. She projects an image quite unlike the Cindy McCain we see on the campaign trail.
SUSAN MACMANUS, UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA: So far, Cindy McCain has been low-key. She's been sort of taking the traditional role of standing by her side -- her husband's side at events and clapping and smiling and being supportive of her husband.
COSTELLO: A role critics say makes Mrs. McCain look like -- well, Glenn Close in the movie 'The Stepford Wives.'
GLENN CLOSE (from "THE STEPFORD WIVES"): Well, that's all marvelous.
GLORIA ROEMER, REPUBLICAN CONSULTANT: Well, you know, there's that saying that's been going on for years, you know, don't hate me because I'm beautiful. And that may apply here, because, you know, she is very attractive. You know, she can't help it.
COSTELLO: Roemer says Mrs. McCain's exterior belies who she really is. Mrs. McCain isn't perfect. She suffered a stroke four years ago and worked hard to overcome its affects. She donates tons of time and money to charitable causes. What voters do know about her -- well, she's enormously wealthy, and she says she won't release her tax returns ever -- which says to voters, you're not one of us -- hence Vogue and the jeans.
MACMANUS: Jeans are as all-American as apple pie, and in the fashion world, no matter what they look like, they're in fashion, and so it's no surprise that Cindy McCain would choose a spread with jeans and a nice shirt.
COSTELLO: Interestingly, while Cindy McCain chose jeans for her Vogue spread, her likely competitor, Michelle Obama, chose a traditional black dress with pearl earrings for her Vogue spread. As The Washington Post described it, it was if Michelle Obama was saying 'I am not some scary other.... I am Camelot with a tan.' Whether these images will sway voters one way or another remains to be seen. But we're still in the 'getting to know you' stage.
COSTELLO (on-camera): And, in short, expect both would-be First Ladies to be much more visible in the near future, so you can get to know them -- Wolf.
BLITZER: All right, thanks very much. I'm looking forward to reading that article and seeing the pictures. Carol, see you tomorrow.
Update (Ken Shepherd | 21:44): Sgthulka noted in the comments section a speech Costello gave in March at Kent State University wherein she lamented, of all things, sexism in the media. No word if she considered calling other women "Stepford wives" sexist.
—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.





COSTELLO (voice-over): Ooh la-la -- Cindy McCain in Vogue magazine looks spectacular, lounging at her seaside condo, sans John McCain -- feet bare, wearing size zero jeans. She projects an image quite unlike the Cindy McCain we see on the campaign trail.















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
"As The Washington Post
May 22, 2008 - 15:48 ET by Darth Dutch"As The Washington Post described it, it was if Michelle Obama was saying 'I am not some scary other.... I am Camelot with a tan."
Ummm...isn't this a tad bit racist?
Darth Dutch
Givhan's background
May 22, 2008 - 15:51 ET by Matthew BalanNo, that insinuation isn't even going to be made, because Givhan is a black woman who works for the Washington Post -- enough said.
Hey, didn't you get the memo!
May 22, 2008 - 15:53 ET by Adam_MELay off Obama's wife! ;-)
»→ Lay off Obama's wife
May 22, 2008 - 15:57 ET by Cool ArrowWhich begs the question:
Has Obama witnessed anyone laying . . . never mind.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE!
"Wha'd he say? Lay Obama's
May 22, 2008 - 16:20 ET by mattm"Wha'd he say? Lay Obama's waife? Ohhh, lay OFF Obama's waife. That's a tad differnt, haw haw..." - Bill Clinton, over heard at a Hillary rally (not really, I just made it up)
can we tell these people to
May 22, 2008 - 15:54 ET by seaniepcan we tell these people to lay off mccain's wife
Of course not. She's got
May 22, 2008 - 20:34 ET by CortillaenOf course not. She's got the evil triple going: white, wealthy, and, worst of all, Republican. </sarc>
www.rhjunior.com Great comics with a hefty dose of Christian and anti-nutjob goodness.
"With your mind as high as Mt. Fuji you can see all things clearly. And you can see all the forces that shape events; not just the things near to you." -Miyamoto Musashi
When it comes to anything
May 22, 2008 - 15:55 ET by bigtimerWhen it comes to anything Costello reports...just consider the source.
As far as how either of them dress in the Vogue Rag I could care less one way or the other.
"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill
Elitism
May 22, 2008 - 15:59 ET by MeanderingI thought Obama wanted people to lay off the spouses of the candidates. Hmm, not very fair now is it? There is a difference between being rich and being an elitist. There are lots of down to Earth millionaries who care for people and can relate to the "everyman" lifestyle. Then there are those who might not be millionaires, but through their attitude say, "I'm better than you" That's an elitist. CNN is hogwash!
Given the fact that Cindy
May 22, 2008 - 15:59 ET by marpelGiven the fact that Cindy McCain can literally wear Michelle Obama in the back pocket of her designer gown...uh, oops...I think I better shut up for fear of being accused of being a rascist...
never mind...
Remember Cindy in 'Mars
May 22, 2008 - 16:01 ET by SickofLibsRemember Cindy in 'Mars Attacks'?
http://www.youtube.c...
Carol is a stepford
May 22, 2008 - 16:17 ET by charlietexasCarol is a stepford misstress to CNN.
You know something else
May 22, 2008 - 18:08 ET by BobAnthonyAnother Costello could do the news if he were still alive...LOU COSTELLO THAT IS!
HEYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY ABBOTT!!
Surprised no one, but a classic movie fan like meself has taken that route.
And for Obama's bitch to call herself Camelot with a tan--TALK ABOUT RACISM!
THE BROAD'S A DITZHEAD
May 22, 2008 - 16:25 ET by SgthulkaAs proof I offer her speech to the Akron Press Club back in February.
I'll give you the gist of the speech - America is a sexist wasteland.
Enjoy:
http://media.www.ken...
And any of this...
May 22, 2008 - 16:28 ET by okiehawk44And any of this matters how again?
We need to establish our own energy independence.
We need to ensure our right to exist as a country.
We need to ensure that those businesses who can't determine a citizen from a guy here for about 15 minutes go to jail.
Cindy and Michelle and the Clinton spouse -- what's his name -- are non-issues.
"...I am Camelot with a
May 22, 2008 - 16:58 ET by celator"...I am Camelot with a tan."
Camelot-- the metaphor invented to create the image of a saintly President Kennedy determined to slay the political dragons created by the same political interests who invented the Camelot fairy tale which was created by the same political interests who created the political dragons. . . . . etc.
In other words a phony image created to, once again, fool the MSM and the public. You can get very rich if you are successful at it. Ask the two political alligators, Carville and Begala.
Reminds me of the Obama image machine's efforts to heft up a candidate who is such a lightweight he needs to keep rolls of quarters in his pockets so he doesn't float off the political landscape.
And don't tell me Michelle
May 22, 2008 - 19:23 ET by motherbeltAnd don't tell me Michelle Obama wasn't going for the "Jackie" look with the black dress and pearls!
Very subtle, Michelle.
Of course she was
May 22, 2008 - 19:54 ET by bigtimerOf course she was mb....miracle she didn't have a pill box hat on to-boot...lol.
"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill
Wolfie's 'The Constipation Room'
May 22, 2008 - 17:26 ET by SickofLibsAh yes Carol, we can all dream about the new Obamalot Camelot...
"Mr. President, Presidents Ahmadinejad, Chavez and Kim Il-sung have arrived for the dinner gala and bridge tournament."
What, no Jackie-O pillbox hat for Mrs. Obama's spread?
Funeral Attire
May 22, 2008 - 17:26 ET by EvilCon555The last time I wore a black dress and pearls I was at a funeral. Does Michelle know something about BO's chances for President that we don't?
As for Mrs McCain....she is a bit plastic, though beautiful. What impresses me is that IS keeping her tax records away from the biased media. That takes guts. To date we haven't really seen anything truthful from the Clinton's, underwear aside...
"All great change in America begins at the dinner table" Ronald Reagan, Jan 21, 1981
It's interesting to hear
May 22, 2008 - 18:06 ET by fitzfongIt's interesting to hear Carol Costello comment on anyone's appearance. After all, the work she's had done to her face could provide enough script material for a whole season of Nip/Tuck.
"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan
Michele Obama - on the board of a pickle corporation
May 22, 2008 - 18:04 ET by Gary HallWell, Carol Costello, you know, most of us don't really know much about Michelle Obama, except that she's really bitter, angry, doesn't like America much, and until recently sit on the board of a pickle corporation.
Guess, taking compensation from a big bad corporation didn't look to good, so she dropped that position, and kept her highly paid job as an executive on the board of a hospital, for which her husband does his best to bring home the bacon from Washington.
You know Wolfie, maybe we should support an excise tax on excessive profits on pickle corporations; you know, cars can run on vinegar as well as fish fry oil.
I'm sure she is just being
May 22, 2008 - 19:34 ET by JerryI'm sure she is just being consistent with last election, when she informed us that Teresa Kerry was filthy rich....... NOT.
When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).
I never knew..........
May 22, 2008 - 18:34 ET by zoro7957...........that there was a black lady in Sir Arthur's court............
Fug ugly
May 22, 2008 - 18:45 ET by ScrapironBig mouth Michele Osama Hussein Obama is Fug Ugly and the expensive clothes and jewelry can't hide that fact. I've alway wondered, if Hussein O is so hot, as the democrat creeps describe him, why did he marry such an ugly plow horse shaped broad? Maybe so he can sleep around with men and snort/smoke coke and she won't say anything for fear of losing the only thing she has accomplished in her liberal life, marrying a criminal politician. That' s my view of the two criminals and i'm sticking to it.
Old, Retired and glad of it.
Well now that you're
May 22, 2008 - 19:52 ET by mandrakeWell now that you're prepared to be perfectly rational about it, how about a game of cards tomorrow at my place...say around 8 pm?
If you inject yourself into
May 22, 2008 - 20:12 ET by mostlymoderateIf you inject yourself into the public political arena, expect to be questioned and interrogated. If you DO NOT inject yourself into politics, it should be common courtesy to leave you alone. For example, Chelsea Clinton injected herself into the arena when she touted off about how great her mother was. She should be questioned. Michele Obama did the same thing. She is an uppity wife that feels she needs to spout off occasionally in favor of her inexperienced husband. When she does this, she should be questioned.
Since McCain's wife never spouts off about how great her husband is, she should not be subject to public ridicule. Gosh, it is so simple!!
I'd vote for Cindy McCain
May 23, 2008 - 11:19 ET by mattmI'd vote for Cindy McCain over her Hubby.