CNN’s Toobin, Cafferty: Obama’s ‘Bitter’ Comments ‘Factually Accurate’

Photo of Matthew Balan.
  • Bookmark and Share

NewsBusters.org |screenshot from CNN broadcastCNN’s senior legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin, during a discussion on Friday’s "The Situation Room," defended Barack Obama’s comments, that small-town voters are often "bitter" and they "cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them," and blasted Hillary Clinton for her criticism of the comments. "I think that is so ridiculous.... I mean that is not at all what Barack Obama said.... I mean Hillary Clinton is clearly distorting what Obama said. And, by the way, what Obama said is factually accurate." Jack Cafferty, a regular contributor to "The Situation Room," agree with Toobin, and went further. "Look, Jeff's right. They call it the 'Rust Belt' for a reason.... The people are frustrated. The people have no economic opportunity. What happens to folks like that in the Middle East, you ask? Well, take a look. They go to places like al Qaeda training camps. I mean there's nothing new here."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Toobin and Cafferty appeared with host Wolf Blitzer and CNN senior political analyst Gloria Borger during the segment, which started 39 minutes into the 6 pm hour of Friday’s "The Situation Room. After Blitzer played a sound bite of Obama’s comments, he asked Borger for her take on the issue. She tried to explain away them away. "I think the people are angry. And maybe -- and maybe Obama's terminology was inartful, but I think he's expressing a sentiment of mad as hell voters not going to take it anymore that we've seen throughout this election. And that's why, perhaps, voters are saying over and over again that they want a change."

Blitzer then played some of Clinton’s reaction and criticism to Obama’s comments. It was after this that Toobin and Cafferty came to Obama’s defense. Borger then explained that "in this case, the Hillary Clinton campaign and the John McCain campaign have the same goal -- and that is to portray Obama as this sort of effete elitist who doesn't understand the real working class people or independent voters. And so they're both on the same side on this one and it's obvious why."

The full transcript of the segment from Friday’s "The Situation Room:"

WOLF BLITZER: There's new controversy right now involving something that Barack Obama said over the weekend on the campaign trail -- the audio of that only now emerging. Let's get back to the best political team on television. I'm going to play it for you guys. I'm going to play it for our viewers and then we'll discuss. Listen to this.

SEN. BARACK OBAMA (D-IL), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: '...they fell through the Clinton administration and the Bush administration. And each successive administration has said that somehow these communities are going to regenerate and they have not. And it's not surprising then they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren't like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.'

BLITZER: All right. Gloria, he's already being hammered by Hillary Clinton and John McCain, for that matter, for supposedly being an elitist and speaking ill of the people of Pennsylvania by suggesting that the economic problems there are causing them to become bitter and buying guns and becoming xenophobic and all of that. What do you think? Is this a real issue out there?

BORGER: Well, Hillary Clinton said today, you know, I don't see bitter people out there, I see struggling people or whatever it is. But she said that people aren't bitter. I think the people are angry. And maybe -- and maybe Obama's terminology was inartful, but I think he's expressing a sentiment of mad as hell voters not going to take it anymore that we've seen throughout this election. And that's why, perhaps, voters are saying over and over again that they want a change.

CAFFERTY: Yes.

BORGER: So I think Hillary Clinton is trying to make him into the elite candidate but he's talking about people being angry.

BLITZER: All right, and Hillary Clinton responded to the Obama comments this way, Jeff. Let me play her little sound bite.

HILLARY CLINTON: It's being reported that my opponent said that the people of Pennsylvania who faced hard times are bitter. Well, that's not my experience. As I travel around Pennsylvania, I meet people who are resilient, who are optimistic, who are positive, who are rolling up their sleeves.

(APPLAUSE)

H. CLINTON: They're working hard every day for a better future for themselves and their children. Pennsylvanians don't need a president who looks down on them.

BLITZER: All right. Jeff, what do you think?

TOOBIN: I think that is so ridiculous.

CAFFERTY: I agree.

TOOBIN: I mean that is not at all what Barack Obama said.

BORGER: Right.

TOOBIN: I mean I just think this is an example of how a campaign between the two of them can be purely destructive and not elevate either candidate. I mean Hillary Clinton is clearly distorting what Obama said. And, by the way, what Obama said is factually accurate.

CAFFERTY: Right.

TOOBIN: It's been true throughout history that people who have economic problems lash out against various others. I just think it is embarrassing for the Clinton campaign just to hang on to this as if it's some sort of gaffe by Obama.

BLITZER: It's not just the Clinton campaign, Jack. It's also the McCain campaign. They issued a statement saying, 'It's a remarkable statement and extremely revealing. It shows an elitism and condescension toward hardworking Americans that is nothing short of breathtaking. It is hard to imagine someone running for president who is more out of touch with average Americans.'

(LAUGHTER)

CAFFERTY: Oh, really? And this is from John McCain? Amazing.

BORGER: Yes.

BLITZER: No this is from Steve Schmidt, a senior adviser for John McCain.

CAFFERTY: Look, Jeff's right. They call it the 'Rust Belt' for a reason. The great jobs and the economic prosperity left that part of the country two or three decades ago. The people are frustrated. The people have no economic opportunity. What happens to folks like that in the Middle East, you ask? Well, take a look. They go to places like al Qaeda training camps. I mean there's nothing new here. And what Barack Obama was suggesting is not that the people of Pennsylvania are to blame for any of it. It's that the jerks in Washington, D.C., as represented by the 10 years of the Bushes and the Clintons and the McCains, who have lied to and misled these people for all of this time, while they shipped the jobs overseas and signed phony trade deals like NAFTA, are to blame for the deteriorating economic conditions among America's middle class. I mean I'm a college dropout and I can read the damn thing and figure it out.

BORGER: You know, in this case, the Hillary Clinton campaign and the John McCain campaign have the same goal -- and that is to portray Obama as this sort of effete elitist who doesn't understand the real working class people or independent voters. And so they're both on the same side on this one and it's obvious why.

BLITZER: You know --

TOOBIN: I think --

BLITZER: Go ahead, Jeff. Do you want to make a little point?

TOOBIN: Well, I just think it's remarkable that Barack Obama, this guy who grew up in a single family household with no money, who lived in Indonesia, who, you know, was -- came from very modest upbringings, somehow he's the elitist? That's really a pretty extraordinary sort of contortion of his background. I mean --

BORGER: It's that Harvard/Yale thing, yes.

CAFFERTY: (INAUDIBLE) One hundred and nine million dollars in the last eight years, did he?

BORGER: Right.

CAFFERTY: No.

BLITZER: Yes. He made a few million on that book, but that's another story.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Bitter

The only thing this small town resident is 'bitter' about is the fact that Obama and his ilk take my hard earned money and use it to give support to: politicians, deadbeats, illegal aliens, foreigners, prisoners, etc., etc., etc. Stop robbing me blind!!

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

Elitism

Exactly.

You know when Obama proved his elitism? It wasn't when he talked about guns. It wasn't when he talked about clinging to religion.

It was when (surrounded by his rich San Francisco donor-friends) he felt the need to explain what rural Pennsylvanians feel. He even felt that he could explain it. That was when he proved he was elitist. When he did that, he wasn't talking to us, about us - which is what a president is supposed to do. Instead, he was talking to San Francisco about --them-- those people.

Of course, the media proved their elitism immediately by treating rural Pennsylvanians equally as them.

Obama's a uniter ... my ass. And while we're on it, one last thing. The people in the Rust Belt were clinging to their guns, and clinging to their religion, long before free trade or NAFTA. But now Obama claims that when NAFTA came along, people got bitter.

So why not simply say that "NAFTA made them bitter"? Why drag guns or religion into it? There's only one answer. Obama wasn't accusing them of being bitter. He was accusing them of being racist. He was accusing them of being rednecks, with all that stereotype implies - guns, pickup trucks, religion, etc.

No one is fooled by the "bitter" thing. He was accusing rural Pennsylvanians of being racist, and trying to "explain" the racism to San Franciscans. And the coward doesn't even have the nerve to stand behind his accusations. Instead, because he needs their votes, he blames their racism on "Washington" or economic troubles. I once had a lot of hope for this guy. Forget that.

WOW

These posts prove the point of anger and frustration and bitterness in America. Across the board with no distinction of age, geographical area or education- the posters are roiling with it. Pointing at whatever their individual HOT BUTTON is to make the point. This is 20 +years of being neglected and ignored by Gov't. This shows that bitterness is apparent all across the nation- not just small towns and the RUSTBELT!!!
Great sadness and need for change...Choose your candidate with great care...WE NEED NOT KEEP THE OLD GUARD IN WHEN THEY HAVE PROVEN TO GO DUMB AFTER ELECTION DAY.

docb, Frustration, yes;

docb,

Frustration, yes; anger and bitterness, nope.

It's not the 20+ years of being neglected and ignored by Gov't. It's the 20+ years of being controled and enslaved by Gov't

Great sadness and need for change...Choose your candidate with great
care...WE NEED NOT KEEP THE OLD GUARD IN WHEN THEY HAVE PROVEN TO GO
DUMB AFTER ELECTION DAY.

Unfortunatly, there is no viable candidate today who supports the dismantling of our bloated and domestically destructive federal government. McCain is the lesser of the three evils though.

 

Awww.... diddums, why so

Awww.... diddums, why so bitter?

Didn't get your government cheese today? Never mind. There's always tomorrow.

Vote 4 change. Vote 4 anything. See Jack & Mr Shy's first campaign ad for the ONLY viable 3rd party candidate.

docb, the frustration with

docb, the frustration with the Goverment is not because we are being ignored, it is because we are not being ignored by the Goverment. I want goverment out of my life, out of my house, out of my pocket and out of my way! In other words, goverment needs to take care of what they are supposed to take care of. And that is not me. That is the borders. Leave the people alone.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Sure they agree with Obama.

Sure they agree with Obama. It's a liberal and liberal media attitude down towards the middle and working classes. You can also read this self-superior attitude in the tone of the comments of many liberals who post here. Obama just spelled it out clearly and got recorded.

Remember when Peter Jennings said we all had that "national temper tantrum" after the '94 elections?

They should come to my part

They should come to my part of the rust belt.We'll take some frustrations out on their pin-like heads.Talk about antipathy for people who are not like us.These jack-asses fit the description.

 

 

Fetch my gun Mabel,there's varmints in the front yard.

Gloria Borger asserts: "I

Gloria Borger asserts: "I think [Obama is] expressing a sentiment of mad as hell voters not going to take it anymore that we've seen throughout this election."

Borger and Obama are correct.  There are plenty of angry, bitter people in the United States, but they are not the God fearing or owners of firearms.  The angry and bitter in the United States are called pagans, atheists, Marxists, socialists, tree huggers, earth worshippers, flag burners, draft dodgers, feminists, race baiters, race hustlers and fundamentalist homosexualists, to wit: the base of the Democrat party, which includes both Gloria Borger and Obama.

Media myth about terrorism

A little OT, but:

They call it the 'Rust Belt' for a reason.... The people are frustrated. The people have no economic opportunity. What happens to folks like that in the Middle East, you ask? Well, take a look. They go to places like al Qaeda training camps.

I call BS. Marc Sageman, an Ivy League expert and former CIA officer, created a massive database of terrorists and found that 75% were upper middle class and that 63% had gone to college. So really, it's folks like Cafferty who go to al Qaeda training camps. 

 

"I think government is a necessary evil, like, say, motion picture agents." -John Wayne

Okay..Let me get this straight...

"They call it the 'Rust Belt' for a reason...The people are frustrated. The people have no economic opportunity. What happens to folks like that in the Middle East, you ask? Well, take a look. They go to places like Al Qaeda training camps..."

That mental midget Jack Cafferty is comparing the pathetic excuses for human beings that join Al Qaeda to hard working small-town Americans who are frustrated about jobs and the economy?? I've always thought that Cafferty is a moron, but now I think he's completely lost his mind, such as it is.  

Uh, no, it's called the

Uh, no, it's called the "Rust Belt" because of all the iron ore and heavy industry. Not because there are no jobs.

But that's a liberal for you...tells you his opinion and then says "That's a fact."

BTW..it IS true that Barack Obama's middle name is "Hussein." So why shouldn't people be allowed to use it freely?

 

mb...

Cafferty's choosing of that phrase to make his point just illustrates how ignorant and ill-informed he really is. As I said, he's a moron.

I agree...Cafferty is

a putz! an old worn out blow hard....a sexist jerk who can't stand the thought of a woman being elected president. These folks at CNN, except for Lou Dobbs, are totally out of touch with middle America. I can't wait for the November election to bit them in the a@@.

Obama supporters

These people are just as thoroughly biased as a Ku Klux Klansman; not in the same way, but just as thoroughly biased.

I make a point of not going to whorehouses, and not watching or listening to such odiously biased elitists. The language coming out of these people’s mouths is just as biased as the Reverend Wright. And they are obviously Obama supporters… It figures!

Impunitas semper ad deteriora invitat.

And when liberal "elites"

And when liberal "elites" get frustrated and bitter they cling to Bush Derangement Syndrome...

CN...

Exactly...We have had to listen to nonstop "frustrated and bitter" garbage from the liberal elites since the 2000 election.

Oh Really?

#1. If the truth were expressed by McCain about blacks in the ghetto, Cafferty and his "liberal" friends would be all over him for his "insensitivity" and "racism".

#2. To have Barry criticize middle American whites for going to church and legally owning a gun while the blacks in the ghetto "cling" to welfare, illegal guns, drugs, murder, alcohol, disrepect for education, single motherhood , anti-American preachers in their so-called "churches", etc. is infuriating. Talk about people in glass houses!!

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

isia, Liberals, when they

isia,

Liberals, when they can't understand why some people don't come to their siren song of government, but instead, support conservative positions on, among other things, religion, gun control, and illegal immigration, have to pin the problem on "bitterness", unsophistication, and ignorance. They can't bring themselves to grasp the fact that intelligent people might not vote liberal and don't want the liberal control of government handouts. Talk about self-deluded, pompous, and condescending...

Right, Chris

"Liberals" are also often quite ignorant and uneducated. Cafferty sqawks, "No wonder they call it the rust belt". The term "rust belt" has a number origins which go back more than a century. It has nothing to do with middle America's current economic problems. "No wonder they call Cafferty a fool and an ignoramus."

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

Well, their attitude is that

Well, their attitude is that if these people would just put their faith in government, they wouldn't need guns. And they especially wouldn't need God. That's the basis of Communism: deny the existence of God and thus the state becomes supreme.

lets have fun "...the

lets have fun

"...the blacks in the ghetto "cling" to welfare, illegal guns, drugs, murder, alcohol, disrepect for education, single motherhood , anti-American preachers in their so-called "churches", etc"   Soon after GOP candidate ___________ made these remarks at a fundrasier this week while factuly acurate  he was forced to drop out of the race, due to the things he said were just plaine stupid.

 

 

I was a professional twice over - an analyst and a therapist. The world's first analrapist

history has proven them WRONG

because you will find that the folks that join AlQueda come not from the "Rust Belt" but the west coast, California. Stockton, and other parts of the Breakfast Cereal State. The "American Taliban", the "shoe bomber", are all hailing from CA, the land of all sorts of government bleeding heart spending that doesn't do anything but encourage sloth and racial hatred. I know personally of one other non mentioned case of a "university kid" whose entire "family" was behind bomb making plots in the Bay Area (kid got caught testing devices and found with lots of material in storage at the school and his "home"). Makes you wonder how many *more* cases are quietly cleaned up and plots stopped that no one will ever hear about. because "terrorists are all made up by government to strip away your rights!" 

If you want another example, that chaplain that was smuggling info in and out of Getmo, was based out of Washington State. Same as the "DC Sniper".

All Left Coast, from the biggest liberal states. Which means the article mentioning the Rust Belt is either complete discrimination and borderline racism, or an outright lie.

It's amusing that the facts and statistics are all there for anyone to see: all places where Democrats and liberals now rule, the worst coming from
places where liberal ideology has held sway for decades-the worst gang
violence, the worst crime, the worst economy, the most racial unrest-CA
and New York. Any place that has gained a relatively recent Democratic
tumor, Washington State, has been heading downhill fast.

 

"to call an illegal immigrant an "undocumented alien" is the same as calling a streetcorner drug dealer an "unlicensed pharmacist".

I guess you never heard of

I guess you never heard of Timothy McVeighy or Ted Kaeznski..they never came from  California..Just adding my two cents worth of facts.

And your point is?

And your point is?

motherbelt

I never said I had 'point'! I was just pointing out a factual error..people here do that all the time.

I see. You were responding

I see. You were responding to the "all came from...."

Whites:

Why do you criticize "white" Americans so much, Barry? Learn it from Rev. Wrong?----in "church"?

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

I like how Hillary

I like how Hillary criticizes Obama for "feeding into the Republicans attack" on the liberal Democrats as looking down on the middle and blue collar classes. Uh, he's not only "feeding" it, Hillary. He's confirmed it's accuracy.

Right on

Chris:

The truth is always termed "The Republican Attack Machine" by the Dims. Sad

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

isia, From what I've seen,

isia,

From what I've seen, this infamous "Republican Attack Machine" is powered by toy poodles and fires Nerf balls and powder puffs. I think this is yet another case of Democratic transference...

→ Cafferty's condescension

Cafferty is fine with Inner city youths embracing their culture of gun violence.  At least they aren't religious.

Cafferty's opinion, same as Obama's, is destructive at a level beyond bitterness.

♣ a seal

badexcuse

Cafferty thinks he is smarter than his look. Liberals in general think alike and say the palestinians, muslim youths are bitter because they are depraved of education, job opportunities and are neglected they turned to violence as cafferty claimed joined al kayda. Many Tibetans, Mongolians, Indians, Laotians, Latinos and many more are depraved of jobs the world over and they do not join al kayda, we do not see them blowing up children and women. Cafferty's speech is subversive.

Toobin & Grumbles

What's also "factually accurate" is that most liberals like Toobin & Grumbles are bitterly disappointed that Communism has failed.

Has anyone else noticed how Jeffrey Toobin is always consistently wrong? Not just politically, but factually. He almost always makes inaccurate statements about basic facts.

If you can stomach it, watch him on CNN's election night coverage. When it's live and he has to shoot from the hip, he is a bungler.

Jack Count Dracula Cafferty is dispicable!

Comparing the enemy Al Qaeda to hard working Americans is ALL you have to know about that tool.

CAFFERTY: Look, Jeff's right. They call it the 'Rust Belt' for a
reason. The great jobs and the economic prosperity left that part of
the country two or three decades ago.

Well gee there Jack, if that were the case why would they be bitter 30 years later? What a Jackass!

 

 

 

 

For me, it boils down to the environmentalists,blame wise..

I still live in a small town, born, raised, and no way

would consider leaving home. Sure, that decision has caused financial hardships, We just do it. Go to work, Shut up...

Thirty or forty years ago, though, things were better, here, by a long shot.

We had a thriving lumber industry. ya know, lumber mills, logging companies, trucking companies, railroad crews, and all the trickle down

economies you could think of.  The ranchers, farmers of course provided many jobs.

Along comes THE SPOTTED OWL...enviros champion the cause,, And wa-la..No more logging,No more turning your livestock out to graze which by the way, helped keep wildfires down.US forrest service..does not, serve...blm..joke! But in case we have wildfires they will spend millions protecting the very bug infected, dying trees we can not harrvest.

This type of Kill the small town thought/meme has been going on for as long as I remember..

We are still here, I could ( and a bunch of others too) put more examples up like this to show just how it is with the enviros, the globull warmers, the I want everone to think like me, The bho speeches designed to sound  like he speaks for me.

He does not.

Gee, Jogger

Are you bitter?

You don't sound very bitter to me.

Except for the fact that there were numerous enviro whacks....telling you all how to pursue your livlihood.

Like that.

We see it all of the time.  The envirowhacks....shut down whatever they hate.

It's time to wake these idiots up, yes?  

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

Sometimes, bitter gets the best of me.

And I have to hope that there are more folks like minded enough to Say, This continual affront on just plain common sense has to stop.

Bitter..

If it helps.

Wont help, I think

Time to make a stand.

I am very bitter today.

I am very bitter today. Excuse me while I go and cling to my guns.

What in hell does clinging to guns mean? Is this liberal speak for something? Alienate the electorate surefire way to get elected.

Obama's "inartful" facts...

Adolf Hitler is purported to have said, "By the skillful and sustained use of propaganda, one can make a people see even heaven as hell or an extremely wretched life as paradise."

The American media asserts things such as, "What happens to folks like that in the Middle East, you ask? Well, take a look. They go to places like al Qaeda training camps.", when referring to law-abiding American citizen who "cling to" their (constitutionally garanteed right to) religion and guns and don't like illegal aliens by the millions flooding into thier nation.

Do you see a correlation?  The MSM is using Hitler's principles of propaganda to demonize Americans whom it deems to be unfit. 

Scary!

Dependence begets subservience and venality, suffocates the germ of virtue, and prepares fit tools for the designs of ambition.”  Thomas Jefferson