CNN Sympathetically Portrays Obama’s Church As Being ‘Under Siege’

Photo of Matthew Balan.

NewsBusters.org - Media Research CenterCNN correspondent Susan Roesgen, reporting live from in front Chicago’s Trinity United Church of Christ on Thursday’s "The Situation Room," presented a sympathetic view of the Rev. Jeremiah Wright and his house of worship as being "under siege" -- from the national media. "Beyond what they say is the hurtful glare of the cameras, church leaders also say parishioners are hounded by reporters and they say the church received bomb threats. A church that feels under siege, now getting national support." Nearly the entire three minute segment, outside of Roesgen’s voice-overs and on-camera reporting, consisted of sound bites of the supporters of the church.

Besides featuring nobody but its supporters, Roesgen also painted the church and its congregations as victims of the controversy and of the news media. "I think they feel angry and they feel used. When they have talked about certain reporters, they were basically talking about reporters who were rude enough to go into the pews and hand out their business cards during the services, something of course CNN would never do."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The report, which aired 41 minutes into the 5 pm Eastern hour of the CNN program, featured the Rev. Michael Kinnamon of the liberal National Council of Churches; the Rev. Otis Moss, the current pastor of Trinity United Church of Christ; and the Rev. John Thomas, president of the national United Church of Christ. The three appeared at a press conference that was given from behind the pulpit at Trinity, the same pulpit where the Rev. Jeremiah Wright made his many controversial sermons. The three were among those who came to the defense of the "church that feels under siege," as Roesgen put it.

Roesgen herself only mentioned Wright in passing, and then in a relatively good light. "Standing behind the pulpit where former Pastor Jeremiah Wright inspired his congregation and enraged critics, national church leaders defended the church and blasted the news media." She also did not play any of the former pastor’s now-infamous remarks, thus failing to provide the context to why these religious leaders were coming to the church’s defense.

The full transcript of Roesgen’s report from Thursday’s "The Situation Room:"

SUZANNE MALVEAUX: Religious leaders are coming to the defense of Barack Obama's church which has been under a very hot spotlight over controversial remarks about race by the senior pastor. Our CNN's Susan Roesgen joining us live. Susan, obviously, there has been a lot of controversy over this. What is happening today?

SUSAN ROESGEN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Well today Suzanne, the church is trying very hard to defend its former pastor and its reputation.

REV. MICHAEL KINNAMON, NATL COUNCIL OF CHURCHES: In recent weeks, I have seen the United Church of Christ more than occasionally portrayed as some kind of radical sect. This, of course, is nonsense.

ROESGEN (voice-over): Standing behind the pulpit where former Pastor Jeremiah Wright inspired his congregation and enraged critics, national church leaders defended the church and blasted the news media.

REV. OTIS MOSS, TRINITY UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST: We have received unprecedented scrutiny that has taken its toll on our members, our staff, and our senior pastor.

REV. JOHN THOMAS, PRES., UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST: The intersection of politics, religion and race has heightened our awareness of how easy it is for our conversations about race to become anything but sacred.

MOSS: As a church, we say no more. Enough is enough. Today, we -- pastors, members, and supporters of Trinity United Church of Christ proclaim that we take back our sacred space.

ROESGEN: Beyond what they say is the hurtful glare of the cameras, church leaders also say parishioners are hounded by reporters and they say the church received bomb threats. A church that feels under siege, now getting national support.

KINNAMON: If there are threats against one church, as there have been here, all churches are threatened. If the privacy of church members in one place is violated, as it has been here, all places of worship are violated.

ROESGEN (on-camera): Now Suzanne, Reverend Wright himself was not here at the news conference today. He's been keeping a pretty low profile. And Senator Barack Obama was not here either. We know that he's in Chicago tonight. He's not campaigning, and his press spokesman told me that he has no idea when was the last time that Senator Obama actually attended a service here at Trinity United Church.

MALVEAUX: And Susan, you're there in Chicago at the church. You know, what is the tone of those -- the parishioners there? What sense do you get from them? Are they just fed up with this, or are they moving on, or resilient? What is the feeling there?

ROESGEN: No, they're not moving on Suzanne and that's why they had the news conference today. I think they feel angry and they feel used. When they have talked about certain reporters, they were basically talking about reporters who were rude enough to go into the pews and hand out their business cards during the services, something of course CNN would never do. And also, reporters who called up people who were sick, parishioners who were sick or in the hospital because they had gotten the names and phone numbers off of a prayer list from people who were praying for those particular parishioners. So these reporters actually went to the sickest members of the congregation to try to get their responses to the Wright controversy. And the church says that's horrible and this is a sacred place and we're not going to allow it anymore.

MALVEAUX: Okay, thank you very much Susan.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Great juxtaposition CNN

Doing a story about how the big bad media is hounding and laying seige to the church from where else? CNN's own hounding and seige position outside the church.

"All generalizations are false, including this one.” Mark Twain

OTIS MOSS

<<REV. OTIS MOSS, TRINITY UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST: We have received unprecedented scrutiny that has taken its toll on our members, our staff, and our senior pastor. >>

I thought Otis Moss was the replacement for Wright.

Otis Moss has the exact same views on America that Wright did/does and is of a much younger generation so NONE of Obama's BS about Wright's ideas being from an older generation and he didn't know Wright held those ideas can give him any cover now about his own deeply held beliefs. Obama hates this country. Obama's wife hates this country. Obama's closest advisors and friends hate this country. Otis Moss is now Obama's pastor and hates America too. So a vote for Obama is a vote for someone who hates the country of his birth and the country he says he wants to lead. BALDERDASH!

The GD church ought to be under Seige

Preaching Garbage from the Pulpit under the disguise of being a Church, they ought to be under Seige, under an Education edict, under a "Truth in America" review, and under all sorts of investigations from the IRS review of their "religious Exemption" to someone calling out the Rev. Wright on where does he get his Information on AIDS from ?

The Congregation ought to be taking cover, because they're selling those DVD's of the Wright's view of America, and some Americans don't like it, one might even be so bold as saying a Majority disagree with what's being preached from the Pulpit.

I guess Obama's vote getting power will tell the tale of exactly how popular that particular church has become, and it's appeal the citizens who decide to vote for a particular 20 yr. attendee.

A Church getting positive coverage from the Press?

Well, this is a sure sign the Church isn't following Jesus.

The Bible is clear that the majority of people are only going to oppose and have bad things to say about Churches and People who teach, preach and live their lives by The Bible and Jesus' Teachings.

The message

I guess the message from the church leaders isn't God bless the media?

 

NOT EXACTLY...

It's really not so much of a case of Trinity United being "under siege" as much as it is a case of Trinity United being exposed.

"Some of us are wise, some of us are otherwise"  Mark Levin

Simulating Bill having sex at the pulpit was pretty funny

Maybe the media will not want to miss whats next

I caught this pathetic

I caught this pathetic drivel yesterday...it was infuriating nonetheless...this attempt to make the racist hatepreach coming from Wright and the others that are following and defending this POS is absolute leftist arrogance they are trying to cram down normal peoples throat...

Not going to work...we see it for what it is, I for one hope more that anything that Obama is the one to beat..these filthy critters , these pathetic people are going to see just how much people do care in Nov.

Keep it up though, as you will...same as Obama avoiding the real point that he sat in a pew for twenty years, he donated to this man and this Church, he was married by him, his kids were baptized by him, he threw his own grandmother under the bus for this man and his political agenda...no Mr. and Mrs. Obama, CNN, and msnbc, you can keep spouting your rose-colored BS out here, we still aren't looking through those glasses, nor are we going to.

You will be trounced....have boxes of kleenex at the ready. 

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Wooowww Bigtimer!!

Are you auditioning for a pastor position??

I read your post out loud using my best Jeremiah Wright imitation, and . . .wow! What passion! But you made sense.

You have a follower.

Do you want a $1.7 million dollar home? Just ask!

Mica.... Hell

Mica....

Hell yes!

Pretty please...with sugar on top...lol.

....did that work?

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Too much to say/too mad to say it

I've stayed out of this way too long.  It's utter BS to say these hateful racists are "under siege."  When is Bob Jones U. or the Southern Baptist Church, two groups who really ARE under siege, given this kind of sympathy?

Furthermore, it was the Clinton camp that took this stuff to Steffy and the ABC gang, so why aren't they getting the blame for it like they should be??

All this is is a way to goad whites into a revival of using the n-word (which would be justified) so that ALL of the Dems can say "SEE, SEE?? I TOLD YOU THEY WERE STILL RACIST!"  I'm not taking the bait, but I'm getting madder by the day.

And Mr. Hussein Obama, don't frigging tell me that a baby is "punishment" when my wife and I (both of whom have reproductive issues) are 0-for-3 at in-vitro and would consider a baby the ultimate blessing.

Anger subsided, albeit only for a while... 

Those conservatives who stay home on 11-4-08, by impact of probable election results, apparently like Marxism.

Gee, Rev Wright was right.

The chickens are coming home. I see where this where Obama was in town but failed to attend this all-important meeting.. Though he still supported his church?

As for me I don't get mad anymore, I just ask Obama supporters how it feels to support a racist. Let them try to explain it to me, much more fun.

Under Siege?

Wouldn't it be more appropriate to call it Under Siege II, Dark Territory?

Ok, flame away!

Flame away...

Hardly.  That was seriously funny! 

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

  They won't know what it's

  They won't know what it's like to have their church under siege until they look out and see Janet Reno and a formation of tanks.

Chickens coming home to roost

Rev Wright preached "GD America".  If Trinity United doesn't like being 'under siege', they should denounce Rev Wright.

Trinity United's chickens are coming home to roost!