Over the course of at least nine months, CNN’s John Roberts has regularly labeled the troop surge in Iraq, the amassing of 28,000 additional troops in the country, the "so-called surge." Liberals, such as George Lakoff, have objected to the term "surge" in the past, since using the term would "subscribe to Bush’s misleading frame." Roberts' latest use of the phrase took place on Monday’s "American Morning." He posed the following question to White House Press Secretary Dana Perino. "The President is also going to be talking about Iraq tonight, Dana. He'll be talking, I guess, about the so-called surge, progress that's been made in terms of security and safety there. But there still has been little political progress. What's the President's message to Nouri Al-Maliki and the people who are in charge there in Iraq going to be tonight?"
This isn’t the first time Roberts has used the "so-called surge" phrase in an interview with Perino. In an April 20, 2007 interview with then-Deputy White House Press Secretary, Roberts asked, "You say that this so-called surge is working, that things are getting better. There are 182 people killed the other day in Baghdad, is that really getting better?"
Two weeks before Roberts’ first interview of Perino, during CNN’s "This Week at War" program on April 7, 2007, Roberts used the phrase "so-called surge" three times in the course of a segment. First,, Roberts inquired CNN Pentagon correspondent Barbara Starr about a recent statement made by Senator John McCain. "[T]he military likes good PR, likes to have people say, hey, what's happening on the ground with the so-called surge is a success. But do they think that McCain has gone off the reservation with this proclamations of how good things are?"
After Starr gave her answer, he then directed a question to CNN correspondent Kyra Phillips, who was then on-location in Baghdad. "Is there a concern there, Kyra, that the political debate here could hamper the chances for success of this so-called surge?" Following Phillips’ reply, Roberts, in his third question in a row that used the phrase, asked Flynt Leverett of the New American Foundation, "Does this so-called surge need to be given a chance without all this heated political rhetoric surrounding it?"
Over two months later, during a June 20, 2007 interview of Lt. General Raymond Odierno, the then-commanding general of the Multi-national Forces in Iraq, Roberts again used the "so-called surge" phrase. "Let me go to you there on the ground there and ask: the so-called surge, is it working or not?" The interview took place five days after the surge had reached full strength and its operations had begun.
During a November 30, 2007 interview of Rep. John Murtha, after the Pennsylvania Democrat came out and said that he thought the surge was working, Roberts introduced the segment by stating, "First, he was a hawk, then he was a dove. But now, Democratic congressman John Murtha has changed his mind again apparently. He's just back from Iraq and says the troop build-up there, the so-called surge, is working."
Less than a month later on December 26, 2007, Roberts interviewed another American general in Iraq, Major General Kevin Bergner, and bested his previous "record" by using his phrase twice in the same question. "You know, the big story of 2007 was this fairly significant reduction in violence, particularly in Baghdad. But Democrats here in Washington are still saying that the so-called surge is a failure because it has not paved the way for political progress, particularly on the issue of reconciliation. So, when you look at the troop increase, and the idea it was to set the stage for political reconciliation, has this so-called surge been a failure or a success?"
Roberts hasn’t always used the "so-called" label to describe the surge. The most notable example of this was his August 8, 2007 interview of Democratic Senators Dick Durbin and Bob Casey, after the two made a visit to Iraq. Roberts only directly referenced the surge once in his questions, and he didn’t use the "so-called" label. "But Senator Durbin, everybody in the Democratic Party is saying that the surge has failed. Senator Casey, do you agree with your colleague that there are some signs of military progress here?"
—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.





















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
A Canadian's opinion of our
January 28, 2008 - 18:18 ET by NortoA Canadian's opinion of our war efforts means nothing to me. I am so sick of belittling the troops efforts, IT'S THE MISSION, STUPID!
If Thompson had used this, as I suggested, he would have swept the field clear of opponents by now. He just did not want it badly enough and the job is bad enough as it is. Anyone wanting it in this atmosphere is a glutton for punishment.
Huh?
January 28, 2008 - 18:45 ET by Tom1969caNot even mine? :(
For the record, this Canadian thinks that if the media were barred from Iraq and the professional soldiers were allowed to do the unpleasant things a war requires them to do - without having to worry about opinion polls back home - this thing would be over by summer and the troops would be home before the election.
This Canadian would also like to apologize to America for John Roberts. He started out as a VeeJay on MuchMusic (Canada's version of MTV) in the early 80s. In fact, he was one of the most popular veejays on MM at the time.
I guess our loss is ... um ... your loss, too.
~~~
The difference between liberals and conservatives is that conservatives believe liberals are wrong, while liberals believe conservatives are evil.
While You're At It
January 28, 2008 - 19:13 ET by Del DolemonteCan we get an apology for this Canadian export?
http://www.mediarese...
The only Canadian newscaster I ever trusted was Earl Camembert
Sorry.
January 28, 2008 - 19:42 ET by Tom1969caI met him once at a Canadian journalism symposium. He was the most condescending, arrogant, self-important prick on the discussion panel. And that's saying something.
~~~
The difference between liberals and conservatives is that conservatives believe liberals are wrong, while liberals believe conservatives are evil.
I Will Admit
January 28, 2008 - 20:28 ET by Del DolemonteAnother Canadian broadcast journalist I did admire (now retired) was Radio Canada International's Ian McFarland. Class act all the way! Ever heard of him?
What a thing to say about this 'so called' reporter
January 28, 2008 - 21:34 ET by kgWhat a thing to say about this 'so called' reporter. :-)
Follow the link in the post above mine
January 28, 2008 - 23:06 ET by Tom1969caI was saying that about Peter Jennings, not John Roberts...
~~~
The difference between liberals and conservatives is that conservatives believe liberals are wrong, while liberals believe conservatives are evil.
How about John Roberts, a
January 28, 2008 - 20:37 ET by motherbeltHow about John Roberts, a so-called "journalist"?
And certainly
January 28, 2008 - 22:36 ET by DEVILDOCMOMCNN is a so-called news station.
So Call This
January 28, 2008 - 18:24 ET by NoMoreClintonsRoberts is a so-called news anchor. And everybody knows that an anchor is nothing but dead weight.
He's actually a so-called
January 28, 2008 - 18:46 ET by Gat New YorkHe's actually a so-called John Roberts as opposed to the real John Roberts. He probably goes through life calling everything s-called.
Sources say that must be
January 28, 2008 - 18:26 ET by FairlightSources say that must be similar to a "so-called reporter."
edit: lol, we just said the same thing.
Perino's Opportunity
January 28, 2008 - 18:25 ET by CaringwhiteguyWhat a perfect opportunity for Ms. Perino to call Roberts on his tactic! Did she, or did she just roll over to this hostle media person . . . thereby keeping up the fine tradition of the Bush Administration?
The So-Called unbiased media...
January 28, 2008 - 18:29 ET by NavyBuckeyeThe irony here is that the liberals all claim how the surge may be working but the Iraqi government is not making progress fast enough. I find this funny because our government and Congress has been around for over two hundreed years and they still can't get it right. But the Iraqis need to get it right in a few months. Hypocrites all around.
If everyone that claimed to be victim on a daily basis donated a dollar to the ending of the deficit, it would be irradicated rather quickly.
So called jounalist Roberts
January 28, 2008 - 18:30 ET by well99So as a so called journalist Roberts arent you suppose to report the news not try to shape it?As a so called journalist arent you suppose to control your bias Roberts instead of distorting it to your view.So as a so called journalist Roberts doesnt it suck that your buddies the terrorist are losing.
I too have noticed the use
January 28, 2008 - 18:31 ET by bigtimerI too have noticed the use of so-called not just here, but a lot of instances with the leftist press/msm, it is more than annoying it makes you want to go through the screen and wring some necks, it is done purposely of course to try to diminish any progress ect...to hurt the military, this administration and of course Pres. Bush.
The same as many say...as if they are speaking for the majority...when it is usually the opposite.
Just how dim do they think we all are...
...as far as I am concerned it's proof positive of so-called journalism with an leftist agenda...
ahhh...the good ol' enemy within...always busy little bees.
Big TimerUnfortunately
January 28, 2008 - 18:47 ET by NavyBuckeyeBig Timer
Unfortunately the sheeple of this country flock to their shepherd the MSM. They don't really care that what they are saying is false.....it's less work for them to just accept everything as fact. Then when one of the sheeple tries to free themself the shepherd raises his cane and exclaims "Biggot, racist, sexist, hate mongor, or war-mongor" and the sheeple falls right back in line. It's a rather pathetic life. I wish we had to go to a zoo to see this but no, we just have to walk out our front doors. In my case I look to my left everynight and see my wife. I love her to death but she falls right in line with the rest of the sheeple in this country. The worst part..she has a Masters Degree and claims to be an educated self thinker.
If everyone that claimed to be victim on a daily baisis donated a dollar to the ending of the deficit, it would be irradicated rather quickly.
NB... You said a lot...but
January 28, 2008 - 18:52 ET by bigtimerNB... You said a lot...but the phrase that hit me the best in your post was...They don't really care that what they are saying is false.....it's less work for them to just accept everything as fact.
You said it all!
...which for me is past pathetic...but some things will never change...I'm old enough to realize that as a fact.
Yeah, I guess the sheeple
January 28, 2008 - 19:33 ET by NavyBuckeyeYeah, I guess the sheeple do not want to work for anything they own, but they also lack the work ethic to seek the truth. Thomas Jefferson said it best when he said "The most truth one can find in a newspaper is in it's advertisments". Change newspaper to MSM and it holds true today. Heck most of the advertisments contain very little truth anymore. But the sheeple still flock.
If everyone that claimed to be victim on a daily baisis donated a dollar to the ending of the deficit, it would be irradicated rather quickly.
To Big Timer
January 28, 2008 - 19:12 ET by FranksamDon't give up on her yet. My beloved wife, a law student at the time, was a lib and a feminist when we met 40 years ago, but she had several redeeming 'qualities' that led me to overlook those detrimental attributes. Many years, a couple of children and a few arguments later, she is as conservative and traditional as one might hope.
Truth will out. BTW, she has retained the beauty that made me lust for her long ago.
Liberals don't care what you do, as long as it's mandatory. -Franksam
Hi Frank...I am so glad
January 28, 2008 - 19:27 ET by bigtimerHi Frank...
I am so glad things worked out so wonderfully for you and your wife...I mean that sincerely...but I think you meant the post you sent to me to be sent to NavyBuckeye...read above mine...lol.
Catch ya later...gotta' get some work caught up with.
Hey Roberts,you're so-called
January 28, 2008 - 18:49 ET by the strugglerHey Roberts,your so-called Village called.They want their Idiot back.
John Roberts is a so-called
January 28, 2008 - 20:02 ET by jezebelleJohn Roberts is a so-called stupid face.
Thanks Balboa, I think I found my new favorite insult.
Another one of my favorite
January 28, 2008 - 20:33 ET by AJAnother one of my favorite past times: listening for coercive, conotative verbiage in the way anchors speak on TV. But wait-- if a democrat were in office there'd be no such overt use of language at all.
Soon CBS, NBC, ABC, and all the other alphabet-soup networks will need to use visual quotes to "really" "emphasize" their "point".
CNN's Wennie John Roberts
January 28, 2008 - 20:57 ET by SR71 555John Roberts is a traitor to this country....plain and simple !!!
He is a REAL Fairy P_ick !!!!!
Roberts is just sore that
January 28, 2008 - 23:11 ET by R D HelmRoberts is just sore that his native land, most likely destined to become known as Canadistan in another generation or so, is really nothing more than a nation of boring white people.
Who cares what this twerp thinks about anything?
None are so hopelessly enslaved as those who falsely believe they are free. -J.W. von Goethe