CNN Wonders If ‘Racial Undercurrents’ Will Stop Obama’s Success

Photo of Matthew Balan.

NewsBusters.org - Media Research CenterTaking a page out of Chris Cuomo’s play book on covering Barack Obama and race, CNN’s Carol Costello on Friday’s "The Situation Room" speculated whether Obama can continue to get whites to vote for him, or whether his second-place finish in the New Hampshire primary points to "the undercurrent about race that exists in this country."

Costello repeated a theory proposed by Andrew Kohut of the Pew Research Center, that Hillary Clinton’s victory could be partially attributed to "poor, uneducated whites who don't participate in polls and who often don't vote for blacks." She also pointed out the fact that there are nine female governors, but only one black governor in the United States; as well as the fact that there are 16 female senators, but Barack Obama is the only black in the Senate.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

For a bit of historical perspective, Costello brought up the so-called "Bradley Effect," named after Tom Bradley, a black Democratic candidate for governor in California in 1982, who lost to white Republican George Deukmejian. In one of the sound bites from the report, Charles Ogletree, a black professor at Harvard Law School, named Harvey Gantt (the first black admitted to Clemson University who lost twice to Jesse Helms in senatorial elections) and Harold Ford, Jr., the former representative from Tennessee, as possible victims of the "Bradley Effect."

The full transcript of Carol Costello’s report, which aired 28 minutes into the 5 pm Eastern hour of Friday’s "The Situation Room:"

WOLF BLITZER: Is the U.S. ready for an African-American president? Senator Barack Obama's strong showing so far in this campaign has many saying absolutely yes. Others, though, say it's too soon to tell. Carol Costello has been looking into the story for us. You've been talking to a lot of people, supposedly knowledgeable, on this very sensitive subject. What are they telling you?

CAROL COSTELLO: Oh, it is a sensitive subject, isn't it? Most I talked with today say it is too soon to tell. Obama seems to have transcended race, but can he in the long run? Already, critics say Obama's opponents are trying to create this subtle narrative of racial division. They deny it, but it illustrates show hard it is in this country to take race out of the equation.

COSTELLO (voice-over): The Iowa caucus created all kinds of excitement surrounding Barack Obama. His win in a predemoninantly-white state, and a strong showing in another, seemingly proves it -- Obama can transcend race. It's something Obama has always believed could happen.

SENATOR BARACK OBAMA, DEMOCRAT, ILLINOIS: If I have your support, if I have your energy and involvement, and commitment and ideas, then I am here to tell you, yes we can, in '08.

COSTELLO: Maybe, but they are those who feel while Iowa and New Hampshire prove Obama can certainly get white votes, it doesn't mean he can continue the trend, that Obama's second-place finish in New Hampshire, despite polls that had him coming in first, illustrate the undercurrent about race that exists in this country. Andrew Kohut, in charge of Pew Research, has a theory. He says many of those inclined to vote for Hillary Clinton in New Hampshire were poor, uneducated whites who don't participate in polls and who often don't vote for blacks.

ANDREW KOHUT, PRESIDENT, PEW RESEARCH CENTER: At least race should be considered, because we know that the kinds of people drawn to Mrs. Clinton are also the kinds of people who turn down surveys at pretty high rates. But we don't know much about whether the people who we don't get are like the people that we do get.

COSTELLO: Polls about race are notoriously difficult to analyze. Take this ABC/Washington POst poll conducted before the Iowa caucus. A whopping 88% of Americans said race would not matter in choosing a president. But pollsters say you have to take this result with a grain of salt. Few people are willing to tell a pollster they're racist. It reflects the 'Bradley Effect,' after Tom Bradley, a black man who ran for governor in California in 1982. Most polls showed him leading. But he lost to a white male candidate.

PROFESSOR CHARLES OGLETREE, HARVARD LAW SCHOOL: Ask Tom Bradley when he ran for governor in California. Black man. Thought he could win. He didn't. Ask Harvey Gantt in North Carolina. Ask Harold Ford, Jr.

COSTELLO: And look at the stats. There is one black governor in the United States. They are nine women governors. They are 16 senators who are women, and one black man -- Barack Obama. Still, Barack Obama got plenty of votes in New Hampshire and Iowa, which are both 95% white. And you could say that trumps the polls. But there are many more people yet to vote, and racial undercurrents that are so hard to predict.

COSTELLO (on-camera): And let's face it: Obama has been genius at transcending not race, but racial issues. He's very careful to deliver a message that is not exclusionary. In other words, he's a member of the black community, but he doesn't vocalize racial grievances. So, so far, so good.

BLITZER: All right, let's see what's going on. Carol, thanks very much. A sensitive subject indeed.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Democrats have a race probl;em

Maybe Sen Byrd can help them to understand the Democrats institutional history of racism. I predict this is not going to be pretty, but it will be fun.

stunning

It's absolutely stunning how that is NEVER brought up (Dem institutionalized racism).

To take the IARHSI (if a repub had said it) a step further, IF this was the republican ticket - it would be the "inherent racism" in the repub party.

They've decided to try and shame votes for Obama

They are trying to shame as many people as possible into voting for the black guy. That in itself is racist.

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

I am sick and tired of libs

I am sick and tired of libs claiming that if Obama isn`t elected President it proves how racist whites are. And with Clinton, it`s if she isn`t elected, it proves how sexist men are.

Don't worry, those are just

Don't worry, those are just election season tactics, like "If you vote Democrat the terrorists will get you". We don't really believe it, we're just hoping it will snag the most highly suggestive swing voters.

"He was, and is yet, most likely, the wearisomest, self-righteous
pharisee that ever ransacked a Bible to rake the promises to himself
and fling the curses on his neighbors."
-Emily Bronte

And it all works, so their's

And it all works, so their's a method to what we percieve as madness.

 

If only 1-3% of the voters are influenced by these sleazy comments, then they have done their job.   And sometimes, it only takes a couple percent to win an election. 

Jason, there is a big

Jason, there is a big difference between hollering racism, and warning people of the consequences of their vote.

There is demonstrable evidence that, when in the White House, dims are very likely to let terrorism go unchecked. See Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter.

On the other hand, the race baiters cry wolf at every opportunity! It gets old really fast.

If Carol, Wolfie and CNN

If Carol, Wolfie and CNN are so worried about this subject they had better start reporting in detail all the tag-team politics the Clintoon pair are propagating with Billary doing most of oh so not subtle racist commenting against Obama...after-all he was the real first black President now wasn't he?

These two are going to end up digging their own graves politically the more they open their mouths and show their true colors...like Hillary said, just calling a spade a spade here.

Wonder what James Clyburn is going to do now with his support in SC...wanna' bet it is going to go to Obama..that is unless she has something on him. 

This is disgusting. What if

This is disgusting. What if you just do not agree with him politically? Or is it mandatory to vote for the black guy because he is black, reguardless of how liberal/socialist/communist and empty his ideas are?

They Contrive ... They decide ... They report

These people really are throwing sh!t against the wall and calling it news ...

I don't think that racism

I don't think that racism will play a part unless Obama gets the nomination.  If he does he will have to answer for his own church and denounce their racist beliefs, or else people will see him for who he is....a racist, anti-American black man.

as a white male

I'm offended by all these racist/sexist comments that assume I'm racist/sexist...

I'm not,,, so they can all kiss my tasty white butt...

I'm sick of this crap from the racist MSM and libs...

makes me want to puke..

bp... ...Awwww but I love

bp...

...Awwww but I love it all these PC critters who have been cramming all this PC down our throats from woman's rights/leftist women's lib's gals...to all the words and phrases we have to watch and say all the time only if you are someone with an 'R' behind your name and especially white for decades now is coming right back to bite them all in the end....watch and see.

What has gone around is coming around...to their side of the aisle with their own rules...it is about time, this couldn't get any better for me.

Let them insinuate and spin with all of this and other PC subjects...they are spinning themselves into a real big mess. 

I am loving this.

yeah

I'm loving the democrap hissy fit melt down too,,

but dang I'm tired of being found guilty without a trial...or evidence..:)

BT - you've got to be careful

talking about the msm(Lsm), and saying cramming and throat, and isn't it interesting, as you point out, that all these "statements", both sides, are being made by demolibs?? Interesting spin of events.

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

Hair

I hadn't noticed Carol's new hairstyle until I saw today's programming. I think it's an improvement. That's the best I can say about the Situation Room.

but Barack Obama is the

but Barack Obama is the only black in the Senate.

maybe, but that's a thin slice of pie. What's the ratio in the House?

 

 

Well in the past blacks have

Well in the past blacks have made a run for the senate but libs and msm do everything they can to get blacks not to vote for them and for some reason alot of blacks won't vote for a black guy because they think they can't win. Well isn't that the time to rally up and get out the vote? Makes no sence. And thats all I have to say about that.

Well in the past blacks have

Well in the past blacks have made a run for the senate but libs and msm do everything they can to get blacks not to vote for them and for some reason alot of blacks won't vote for a black guy because they think they can't win. Well isn't that the time to rally up and get out the vote? Makes no sence. And thats all I have to say about that.

Gee,

There's more women in political offices than black people? Gee, wonder why that is.

Could it possibly that, despite what liberals like to think, women are not a minority and there are far more women than blacks in the United States.

Nah, no way. Must be racism.

Speaking of bigots.

"Costello repeated a theory proposed by Andrew Kohut of the Pew Research Center, that Hillary Clinton’s victory could be partially attributed to "poor, uneducated whites who don't participate in polls and who often don't vote for blacks."

That is a bigoted statement.I guess it is ok for her to stereotype people.Two standards typical of msm and some libs.

Barak will get blown out...

Barak will lose because of the racial undercurrents, and it will come from his very own party. I have noticed that Dems seem to be the most racist group, so it iwll be his own that will eat him alive. 

Rush Limbaugh stated that of the top 5 Republicans running for the presidency, only one was a true conservative. http://www.fred08.com/ 

Clear Thinker

You nailed it! I have been waiting for years for them to get exposed.

Jerry...

I was recently in a local store when the Democats County Chair said "if the ni**er get's elected, I hope he get's shot before he takes the oath". He was talking to some of his fellow Dems and did not care one iota who heard him say it. The locals know I'm a Republican, but after 25 years I guess they finally decided to put up with me because they don't pay a whole lot of attention to me. 

After he said this to his buddies there was a chorus of 'N' word suggestions. This may come as a shock to some, but not me, I have heard this type of talk out of Dems ever since I moved here.  

Rush Limbaugh stated that of the top 5 Republicans running for the presidency, only one was a true conservative. http://www.fred08.com/ 

Hi Ct... It doesn't shock

Hi Ct...

It doesn't shock me one bit...

I agree with you if you haven't seen any of my posts regarding this all....the dems are hanging themselves with the ropes they brought to the party.

It's been years in the making. 

bt...

I rather enjoy watching Dems eat their own. 

Rush Limbaugh stated that of the top 5 Republicans running for the presidency, only one was a true conservative. http://www.fred08.com/ 

Ct... I'll pass the salt

Ct...

I'll pass the salt and pepper to them...heheheee...

It is interesting, too

that with all the comments being made, and with references to Johnson and the laws, that people "forget" it was the (R)'s who got the legislation passed - simply forgettable, huh, msm(Lsm)??

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

"She also pointed out the

"She also pointed out the fact that there are nine female governors, but
only one black governor in the United States; as well as the fact that
there are 16 female senators, but Barack Obama is the only black in the
Senate."

Thinking in terms of racial quotas is ingrained in the leftie mind.

That picture of Carol

That picture of Carol Costello says it all. Just take a good look at it.

obx... Excellent

obx...

Excellent observation there...her expression does say it all...

Like they say a picture is worth a thousand words.

YES.  Racial undercurrents

YES.  Racial undercurrents WILL keep Obama from being elected.  However, it is not the American people injecting race into this election; it is the American media.  The media is to blame, not the people.  The MSM is to blame for ALL racial incidents of the last few years.  

Give it a rest, CNN

CNN:  I'm repeating myself here, but...

The score so far:  Two very white states.  One blowout victory.  One close second.  Obama does not have a race problem with the electorate.

As for Hillary, she has a second place finish and a victory.  So apparently sexism doesn't matter either.

Give it a rest. 

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

If the "second coming"

If the "second coming" Barack Obama doesn't get the democrat nomination, there will be no one to blame but democrats. White, black, whatever. It will be racist democrats that didn't nominate Barack Obama, not republicans.

I watch with amazement at

I watch with amazement at the various ways the race card is used in so many subtle ways by the various democrat candidates and democrat news networks. It pathetic that anyone could insinuate that I would hesitate to vote for a person of any inferior race in todays society.

Oh, Captain Repus

I hope you didn't mean to say what you just said.  It's pretty bad. 

I ♣ My Seal

Not to worry my friend -

Not to worry my friend - just a little humor

 

Democrats are Predominately Racist

I spent much of my childhood in South Carolina and had many black friends growing up. The only time there arose problems between whites and blacks is when (liberal) whites tried to impose their guilt on us and started "blaming the children for the sins of the father." When I suggested that it is ultimately unhelpful to continue the inane categorization of human beings by skin pigmentation to liberal colleagues, they acted as if they had been hit by a stun grenade. And perhaps I was wrong. In retrospect it is definitely helpful to drag on racial tensions for Democrats who profit from the "politics of exclusion" and by "divide and conquer" election strategies. And as if the Democrats' perpetuation of white guilt wasn't dubious enough, people forget that the Democrats are still led by such renowned racists such as Robert Byrd, former Kleagle of the Klu Klux Klan, proving their utter hypocrisy. As far as Iowa goes, I used to live in Iowa and there are virtually NO blacks there. Wolf Blitzer and his cohort had to go into full spin control to protect the flank of the Democrats in the upcoming election, particularly the soft underbelly of Hillary, when Obama proved the irrelevance of race in this election. The so-called "halo effect" doesn't account for the large margin Obama won by in Iowa, and the spinocrats know it. In addition, it should be pointed out in this supposedly "historic" election for Hillary, that the liberals did not hooray and hurrah for the unprecedented elevations of Colin Powell and Condaleezza Rice to Secretary of State, which goes to show that it is not race at all that liberals are concerned with, but the expansion of party power and their ultimate control over the U.S. government and the citizenry.

 

The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority, but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane. - Marcus Aurelius

Obsession

The left is obsessed with race and sex (which they call "gender"). The left doesn't see an extreme liberal who belongs to a racist anti-White church and a radical ruthless marxist who has successfully hidden her true intentions from the general public.

If the racist loses, the left will blame it on White racism. If the marxist loses, the left will say that the country isn't ready for a woman president.

 

My white Hillary loving

My white Hillary loving neighbors told me they can't believe the black guy won in Iowa.

Did she forget about Black Racism?

Did she forget to mention the reality of Black Racism and the fact that 80% of black Democrat voters vote for a black when given a choice between a black and a white candidate? Oopsie daisy, she forget that ELEPHANT in the corner.

Shut up and blog! If you claim to be a conservative, please don't disgrace yourself and conservatism by thinking and arguing like a liberal. Go Rudy!

 

Condescending Dems

Of course Dems have a race problem.  Bill and Hill think like Dog the Bounty Hunter.

Yeah, we can talk trash, we're cool.

But Hillary raising LBJ above Martin Luther King as the true champ of civil rights was the last dozens they're gonna play.

It was a serious effort led by Dr. King whose greatest ally was Sen. Everett Dircksen (R), not LBJ.

Now that the realization of a very real dream is on the line, it's understandable that the title of "First Black President" is no longer a cute little jest from the older set.

The youngsters are taking it seriously.

I ♣ My Seal

CA

"But Hillary raising LBJ above Martin Luther King as the true champ of civil rights was the last dozens they're gonna play."

Gee next thing you will say it was Dems that wiretapped MLK.

Ask Obama the monster on

Ask Obama the monster on the "Born Alive Infant " bill.  That we would even need a bill for this is just unbelievable.  This monster has consistently voted against making sure that babies bore premature with some difficulties do not live to see the light of day.

I am talking Downs Syndrome babies and such.  If the mother had induced labor to have the baby and it survived outside the womb then Doctors would have had no obligation to try and keep this baby alive. The "Born Alive Infant" bill made sure the doctors tried their damnedest to keep these babies alive.  Obama consistently voted no or "present" (which is a no) on passing this bill every time it came up in the Illinois legislature and tried to kill it on the federal level.  He is a monster, there is no other word for him! 

Disheveled

Hussein Obama will win easily in SC! The black turnout will be very big and almost entirely his. Likewise in any other primary with a large black vote.

IMHO, if Hillary does manage to win the nomination, blacks will feel betrayed and stay home in droves in November!!! Any significant loss of the black vote spells doom for Dems in the national election!

BTW, Ms Costello is the cutest, disheveled, non-blonde news bunny on cable!