CNN’s Mann: ‘For the First Time... We Can All Share the Nobel Prize’

Photo of Matthew Balan.
  • Bookmark and Share

NewsBusters.org - Media Research CenterCNN International’s Jonathan Mann, during an hour-long "love fest" in honor of Al Gore and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s reception of the Nobel Peace Prize, gushed over the former vice president. "You went from being 'Ozone Man' to 'The Goracle.' This became -- the Nobel Prize became 'The Goronation.' You must be conscious of the change in perceptions about you in particular because of that film [An Inconvenient Truth]."

Later, at the very end of the program, Mann speculated that Gore’s prize could actually be shared with all those who contribute to the planet-saving cause. "We may not all agree about the politics of global warming or about the big solutions, but we can all do our own little part, and it will add up. And for that reason, this year, for the first time that I can remember, we can all share the Nobel Prize."

Video clips (2:27): Real (1.79 MB) and Windows (1.11 MB), plus MP3 audio (1.44 MB).

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Mann interviewed Gore, along with IPCC chairman Rajendra Pachauri, live from the site of the annual Nobel Prize ceremony in Oslo, Norway during the 11 am Eastern hour. Besides a lengthy interview of the two Nobel Prize laureates about a number of topics, CNN aired a number of short segments about Gore and the subject of climate change.

Thomas Lovejoy, president of the H. John Heinz III Center for Science, Economics and the Environment*, appeared in two of the short segments. In the very first segment aired, Lovejoy showered Gore with praise. "Well, I think he's done just an extraordinary job of awakening public consciousness to essentially, you know, the largest environmental challenge of all time." In a later segment, Lovejoy went further than Gore and the IPCC on the threat of climate change. "I think, if anything, he underestimates the rate of change, and so has the IPCC. So the Arctic Ocean is now projected to be ice-free for the first time in 2020, instead of 2050 or 2100."

About a quarter of the way into the hour, Mann asked Gore and Pachuauri about "An Inconvenient Truth" and the controversy over its accuracy. A full transcript of the exchange:

JONATHAN MANN: Let me ask you about the criticism and the court battle in Britain about the facts. If you had that movie to make over again, how much of it would you change? How many of the facts would you just lighten up a little bit?

GORE: Virtually nothing. Virtually nothing. And one of the issues was they said the polar bears aren't in any trouble at all. Well, I think maybe they've taken another look.

MANN: Well, what they said -- to be fair, what they said is there's very little empirical evidence that polar bears are drowning. What some of your critics have said is that, in fact, more polar bears are being shot by hunters than are suffering because of global warming.

GORE: Well, you know, we have to do a reality check. The entire North Polar Ice Cap is in the process of melting in a very short period of time. That's their habitat. It's disappearing. The Greenland ice sheet and the Antarctic ice sheet were both excluded from the calculations of the IPCC in their previous report. The best scientists who have the expertise on ice science argue that it should be included. It was put into a footnote. And now they are going back, as they have said they would do, and they are including it. The rate of...

MANN: Well, let me jump in.

GORE: Yeah.

MANN: If our source here is the IPCC...

GORE: Yes.

MANN: ...they're actually well represented.

GORE: Not turning away, absolutely.

MANN: Have you seen the movie? Did you think it was accurate?

PACHAURI: I have. I think it's a very good movie. I was moved by the movie. I really enjoyed it very much. And I personally think when you're disseminating the message, you have got to do it in a manner that appeals to the audience. And I really didn't see anything that one could call a scientific inaccuracy. I never saw it from that perspective. But, you know, I went to see the movie because I wanted to see how he disseminated the message, and I think that was extremely well done. It was very, very effective.

MANN: Well, it was effective in another sense as well. And this was a personal one. Before the movie, you were best known, of course, as the former U.S. vice president, as the man who almost became president. Your critics ridiculed you as ‘Ozone Man,’ and then the movie came out...

GORE: Well, that was actually the first President Bush, who used that...

MANN: Exactly.

(LAUGHTER)

(APPLAUSE)

MANN: I think you have some fans here in the audience. You went from being 'Ozone Man' to 'The Goracle.' This became -- the Nobel Prize became 'The Goronation.' You must be conscious of the change in perceptions about you in particular because of that film.

GORE: Maybe we can stop somewhere in the middle of those two extremes. The movie had an impact, which I'm very grateful for, and I'd also like to acknowledge again my debt of gratitude to the scientific community that has really done the work in assembling this body of knowledge. I have tried for 30 years to translate the scientific insights into language that I personally can understand, on the theory that if I can understand it, I can communicate it to others. That's all I've tried to do really.

Towards the end of the hour, Mann highlighted the supposed indifference of the American people concerning the issue of climate change.

MANN: Maybe the best way to describe American attitudes, and I hope this is fair to all concerned, is that Americans do know about global warming and they do care, but they don't care all that much. Al Gore, you travel across the United States, you know there are millions of ordinary Americans. There are senators, there are scientists who disagree with you. There are a few people running for president. Do you see their point of view, or is there some problem? Because around the world, people wonder why Americans feel so differently from everyone else.

Mann’s "we can all share the Nobel Prize" comment came during his last words to Gore and Pachauri. The full transcript of this closing monologue:

MANN: Gentlemen, I hope you're going to allow me a final word before we have to bring this program to a conclusion. The Nobel Prize has been given out many times before to diplomats and politicians, humanitarians and activists. It's even gone to scientists before, and at least once before to an environmentalist. So this year doesn't really set a precedent in that way. But it is different this year because of the other people involved, and that's the rest of us. You may not be able to solve the problems of the Middle East, you may not be able to stop the spread of nuclear weapons, but you can, we all can, do something about global warming. You can flip off the lights when you're leaving a room. You can take a longer walk and use your car less often. You can even shop differently to try to encourage business. We may not all agree about the politics of global warming or about the big solutions, but we can all do our own little part, and it will add up. And for that reason, this year, for the first time that I can remember, we can all share the Nobel Prize.

*Correction (Ken Shepherd | December 11, 11:17 EST): As Stacia VanDyne of the Heinz Center pointed out in an e-mail to NewsBusters, CNN erroneously credited Lovejoy as president of the Heinz Foundation, an error we consequently passed on in our initial coverage.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

So as a co-winner....

....does that mean I get a piece of the action?

Only if you give back double

Only if you give back double to whoever the Algores say you should give it to...and stop living your opulent western lifestyle (but don't expect the gurus of gaia to scale back their lifestyle)...

ya don't get a "piece"

but we all get "the shaft".

Wonder if Clinton will "feel our pain" then, too?

 That's o.k. Johnathan,

 That's o.k. Johnathan, you and Al Smore can keep it. Kind of lost it's allure for me when they gave it Arafat, Carter, and Annan.

 

"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "

                   - Ben Kenobi on  Liberals, and the MSM.

Wretch!!!... I think i just

Wretch!!!... I think i just puked in my mouth a little bit.

"....we can all share the Nobel Prize."  Gotta love that 60's era, free love, flower child, hippie mentality.  Blech!

Well, gag me!

Since we can all share, Al Gore and the IPCC can keep the medal, but send my share of the cash to my Paypal account. There's a big honkin twin engine bass boat I want to buy.

Any of you all who want to place the economy of this country in the hands of people led by a failed divinity student with no credible scientific background, and a bunch of political hacks, please move to Belgium or someplace and leave us alone.

Trying to force belief by constant repetition in the media isn't working.

 Politicians and their buddies in the MSM have less credibility than O.J. Simpson these days and scientists who pander to them in return for government grant money are no better.

 

 

Well, so long as we are

Well, so long as we are sharing... I just flushed by bit down the toilet bowl.

Check out my exclusive edit of BBC News America's interview with Mrs Clinton: It's news to me!

 Anyone who has ever

 Anyone who has ever enrolled their children in Little Leaugue sport's, know's that liberal's love to give out trophies for doing absolutely nothing.

 

"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "

                   - Ben Kenobi on  Liberals, and the MSM.

So true, Blazer..

I've got two boys, 22 and 19, both pitchers in Little League through Varsity baseball.  I can attest to many years of plastic trophies going out to each boy on the team for their "efforts".  Most boys were told, "it's the effort you gave, rather than the results of each game" every week.

One son was gifted, the other filled with desire.  Each one won trophies.  No matter which, each one to this day knows who was better.  No plastic trophies or parent speeches to fairness can sway opinions.  I love each son, but they both know who was better

No phony trophies can affirm truth.  Thankfully, each son has gone on to college w/o baseball.

In real life, effort is the one truth that counts.

But I never missed a game for either one.

Algore

What Do You Mean "We" Kemosabe?

I think I saw....

I think I saw this skit on Saturday Night Live recently. It wasn't all that funny, but the actor who played Gore made him look almost human, which is some pretty darned good acting in my book.

Awwwwwww, now I feel all

Awwwwwww, now I feel all warm 'n' fuzzy. All that warmth; is it all the luhvvvvvv or is it global warming? If it's global warming, and I turn my sarc off, am I doing my part to combat it?

Peace Prize for Propaganda

Gore Deserves Nobel Prize for Propaganda (CNSNews)
The Science of Gore's Nobel (The Wall Street Journal)

Al Gore's climate change film 'is propaganda' (The Daily Telegraph, UK)
UK Court finds 9 Inaccuracies in Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth (The New Party, UK)
- Gore’s Nine Lies (FrontPage Magazine)
- Al Gore told there are nine inconvenient truths in his film (The Times, UK)
- British Schools Ordered to Offer 'Balance' When Showing Al Gore's Global Warming Film (FOXNews)
35 Inconvenient Truths (Science and Public Policy Institute)
25 Inconvenient Truths for Al Gore (The National Review Online)
23 Scientific Errors (Science and Public Policy Institute)
16 Errors in Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth (Science and Public Policy Institute)
6 Inconvenient Truths Indeed (Robert C. Balling, Ph.D. Geography)

Al Gore 'Debates' Global Warming (Video) (9min)
Scare Tactics in Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth (Video) (8min)
Marlo Lewis Critiques Al Gore's "An Inconvenient Truth" (Video) (1hr 2min)

Al Gore’s Science Fiction: A Skeptic’s Guide to An Inconvenient Truth (PDF) (Mario Lewis Jr. Ph.D. Government)
A Skeptic’s Primer on Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth (PDF) (Mario Lewis Jr. Ph.D. Government)
Some Convenient Distortions (PDF) (Mario Lewis Jr. Ph.D. Government)

Al Gore Is a Greenhouse Gasbag (Robert Giegengack, Ph.D. Geology)
An Inconvient Truth Review (Black & White, Birmingham's City Paper)
Arctic Climate Expert: Gore's Film Is 'Science Fiction' (Dr. Syun-Ichi Akasofu, Ph.D. Founding Director International Arctic Research Center)
Climate Change Hysteria and Al Gore’s “Chicken Little” Scare Tactics (Frontiers of Freedom Institute)
From a Rapt Audience, a Call to Cool the Hype (The New York Times)
Gore's Film Violates Oscar Academy Standards (CNSNews)
Inconvenient Truths (Patrick J. Michaels, Ph.D. Ecological Climatology)
Inconvenient truths (David Deming, B.S. Geology, Ph.D. Geophysics)
Questions for Al Gore (Roy Spencer, Ph.D. Meteorology, University of Wisconsin)
So how did An Inconvenient Truth become required classroom viewing? (National Post, Canada)


The Anti "Man-Made" Global Warming Resource

Printed these out

I've printed these citations out.....still reading them...amazing stuff. Thanks!!

Please don't include me

I don't want to touch anything Al Gore has had his dirty little hands on. Give my share to some moonbat who would appreciate.

Never let it be said I thanked Al Gore for anything...except losing the 2000 election. 

 

Wanna see censorship in America? Talk about politics with a southern accent.

thank you little people

First Times person of the year and now this....,sniff.

 Times Man-Bear-Pig Of The

 Times Man-Bear-Pig Of The Year ?

Due to Time magazine's extremely high standard's, he will be joining esteemed company.

 Mahmoud Achmedinijad will be green with envy.

 1938: Adolf Hitler

 1939: Joseph Stalin

 1942: Joseph Stalin

 1951: Mohammed Mossadegh

1957: Nikita Khrushchev

1979: Ayatullah Khomeini

And our poor little earth, who even 20 yrs. ago was doomed for destruction within ten yrs.

 1988: The Endangered Earth

 

"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "

                   - Ben Kenobi on  Liberals, and the MSM.

ya know i thought they banned

open sickening sex on tv.. huh guess not.. i wonder if mr manns kids later will say to him. gosh dad why didnt you just kiss him geezz..  i like how he tries to play it off.. whos buying that>? oh gross ya know? and if he is being honest well then they gotta realize how sickening it is.. how bout having a cop or firefighter on your show who saved someones life and say those just wonderfull things about them> this dude made a movie.. ya know in church they talk of false gods.. al is one hollywood in general is more.. scary i think.

 

 

 

 

honesty is the best policy... unless your running for office.

If Gore can get the Nobel Prize for that...

I'm going to make a movie about how we can all pitch in to save us from the imminent attacks of sasquatch hoards! Folks, we HAVE GOT TO ACT TOGETHER, and NOW if we are to survive the impending attacks.

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

MANN ISN'T AMERICAN

He's a Canadian. Just another one of Ted Turners "internationalists" brought in to "report" on evil American transgressions.

The only thing I'll be flipping off

when I leave a room, is these three douchebags - and all their sheeple.