CNN’s ‘The Situation Room’ Wheels Out Aging Rockers Against Bush

Photo of Matthew Balan.

Tuesday’s "The Situation Room" featured two segments with aging rockers who voiced their opposition to Bush administration policies - the first with Crosby and Nash (but not Stills), and the second with Paul Simon. In the first segment, CNN correspondent Carol Costello interviewed the two hippie icons, who compared the Bush administration to a "junta." In the second, host Wolf Blitzer asked Simon about his opposition to President Bush’s veto of the expanded SCHIP program.

Both the Crosby/Nash segment and the Simon segment aired in the 5 pm Eastern hour of "The Situation Room." While Crosby and Nash used fiery rhetoric against Bush, Simon used subdued language. All three wore coats and business shirts, compared to the "rocker garb" of their youth.

Costello interviewed Crosby and Nash at Washington National Cathedral, where the two were to perform at a "peace concert." In their rant against President Bush, Crosby and Nash completed each other’s thoughts, as if they were telepathically-linked.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

A partial transcript of the segment:

COSTELLO (voice-over): Graham Nash along with David Crosby at the National Cathedral. Veterans of the antiwar movement, they're singing for peace, again. They worry what the president calls the war on terror, especially Iraq, has taken the power out of protest, because of what they call Bush's ‘brainwashing.’ They say the administration has conned Americans into thinking it's unpatriotic to criticize the war.

GRAHAM NASH, MUSICIAN: It's the administration controlling the populace.

DAVID CROSBY, MUSICIAN: It's an old stuff...

NASH: It's old style. This is...

CROSBY: You can watch -- you can watch all of these same moves out of any other dictatorship or junta or, you know...

NASH: Emperor. Any...

CROSBY: This is...

COSTELLO: Are you comparing the Bush administration to that?

CROSBY: They use the same techniques. It's not any different. The same exact techniques. Look over there. Those people are different. Why, it must all be their fault. Nonsense.

NASH: Let's have a common enemy so we can unite against them.

CROSBY: Yeah.

NASH: Whoever they are.

CROSBY: Meanwhile, I'll rake off a few billion here. Nothing to it.

NASH: Take away your civil rights. You won't feel a thing.

At the conclusion of the segment, Blitzer thanked Costello, and added, "It brings back some memories, watching that piece of yours. Appreciate it."

In Blitzer’s segment with Simon, Irwin Redlener, who runs an organization called the Children's Health Fund with Simon, appeared with the musician. Simon tried to pull at viewers’ heartstrings, while Redlener got more specific about health care and SCHIP.

A full transcript of the Simon/Redlener segment:

WOLF BLITZER: Just two weeks ago President Bush vetoed a bill that would have dramatically expanded a popular children's health insurance program. The music legend Paul Simon is joining the effort to persuade Congress to override that veto. Another showdown vote is planned for Thursday. And joining us now, the artist Paul Simon and Irwin Redlener. He's the co-founder together with Paul of the Children's Health Fund, himself a pediatrician. Guys, thanks very much for coming in. It's not every day where Paul Simon says it's important enough to come to Washington, go up to Capitol Hill and get involved in an issue. Tell us why you're here.

PAUL SIMON, MUSICIAN: Well, Irwin and I founded the Children's Health Fund about 20 years ago. They're mobile pediatric units staffed with doctors and nurses that serve poor communities around the country. And over the years, I've been watching this issue of children's health care, and my observation is that people speak as if they care, but they don't really care.

BLITZER: But you're really upset that the president has vetoed the expansion of the so-called SCHIP program, the state children's health insurance program.

SIMON: I think -- I really think we need to have protection for all of these children.

BLITZER: I want you and Irwin to listen to what the president says in explaining why he thinks the Congress has simply gone too far in this expansion.

PRES. GEORGE W. BUSH, UNITED STATES: I happen to believe that what you're seeing when you expand eligibility for federal programs is the desire by some in Washington, D.C., to federalize health care. I don't think that's good for the country.

BLITZER: All right, Irwin, you've been involved in this issue in a long time. What do you say to the president?

IRWIN REDLENER, PRES., THE CHILDREN'S HEALTH FUND: Well, first of all, there are many health care programs that have been federalized for years very successfully; Medicare for example, Medicaid for the very poor. The one group that has been left out of the mix right now are the middle class and especially low-earning middle class families, where there's not enough money to buy insurance. Their employers don't provide it very often, and they're making a little bit too much money to afford Medicaid. All we're trying to do is help out a very important group of lower middle class working people.

BLITZER: The opponents of this expansion point out some families earn as much as $83,000 a year.

REDLENER: They might, although the states have a right to limit as much of that as they want to. But the point is that for example $80,000 in a rural part of the country may buy a whole lot more than it might, for example, in New York City or Chicago or Los Angeles. So, it's very hard it be that nit-picky about it. We're try to set some limits so that it is fair, that people who are not making a lot of money, even if you're making $80,000, by the way, insurance premiums might be $1,200 or $1,300 a month, which makes it essentially unaffordable even for them.

BLITZER: Paul, what's the major point? You're telling lawmakers, who may be on the fence right now, and urging them to go ahead and try to override the president's veto.

SIMON: I think it's a very pure issue. I think that there are children who are vulnerable because they're not covered. I don't think that this is a scam by people who are earning $83,000 to make money off the government. I think we have a large portion of our population, millions of children who are not covered and need to be covered, and I would hope that the people who supported the veto will reexamine their conscience and their hearts, and change their votes.

BLITZER: And do you think they will?

SIMON: I think some will, yes. I don't know if enough will to change the outcome of this next vote. But I think, eventually, we will find that the children will be covered.

BLITZER: Paul Simon and Irwin Redlener, thanks to both of you for coming in.

SIMON: Thank you for having us.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Aging Rocker Against Bush

A.R.A.B.?

This is your brain;

This is your brain on drugs......

Way to Go

I guess this is the new Crosby Stills and Nash  (sans Stills) tour.  For rockers, the way to revive a career is to Bash Bush.

Crosby, Stills & Bash?

Crosby, Stills & Bash? 

**My Daughter at the WWII Memorial

hehe

They may be able to revive their careers, but Crosby will never revive his hairline.

Good lord, man! You're bald! Get rid of the idiotic mullet and get on with your life!

Yeah, yeah, it was rebellious in the '60's - we get it. Blue jeans used to be counter-culture too. If you had real jobs, you'd now be as mainstream as your Volvo station wagon, you dumb hippies.

Was Michael J. Fox out of

Was Michael J. Fox out of the Country?  Paul Simon is 3rd team stuff.   Does anyone really care what he says?  Paul Simon is gay.  He doesn't have children.  He has no right to comment on what the Country should do for children.  He is a "chicken hawk" parent.

 

Crosby and Nash had their brains fried by hard illegal drugs.  Who cares what they say?  They are just another in a long line of has been entertainers, without a high school diploma, with an illegal drug lifestyle, that the media trots out to attack Bush. 

 

 

Not that I advocate paying

Not that I advocate paying attention to artists of any derivation for public policy recommendations, but Paul Simon is not gay, unless he's a closet gay. He's married to Edie Brikell (sp?) and has a son by his first marraige. He's a drive-by family guy. Married three times.

Reminds me of all the wonderful things that were said about Michael Landon being such a great family guy when he dies of cancer. Yeah, such a great family guy...he had three of them.

How would you like to have...

How would you like to have, in your bank account, the money these zoned-out geriatric "rockers" have spent putting drugs in their bodies for the past 40 years? If ever there was proof of what "this is your brain on drugs" looks like, this is it.

Dope Smokers

These two idiots know about as much about SCHIP as Algore knows about the enviroment. CNN again demonstrates it's partisanship by presenting a couple of dope-heads as though they're experts on the matter. What is their expertise? They hate Bush as much as CNN - what more do you need?

New Low for CNN

This is almost unbelieveable, but not quite since it's CNN we're talking about.   Did they happen to mention how many times that s-bag Crosby has been arrested for drugs and handgun violations?  He's spent quite a few years in prison so they should have asked him questions on topics he's qualified to speak about - like not dropping the soap in the shower.

Ain't a real debate unless

Ain't a real debate unless you invite on Gene Simmons (KISS) And Ted Nugent ...

Old dopers

Just reading their conversation sounds like a couple of old stoners. One will end the others sentences or make an astute comment like...."Yeah" The only thing missing is Cheech and Chong doing their running dialogs and a couple of "power to the people...man" Old dopers never die....they just lose their seeds.

So a couple of washed-up

So a couple of washed-up junkies don't like the President's policies.  Isn't that more reason to vote Republican?  I think one of the biggest threats to humanity is the possibility that David Crosby might spread his seed even further. 

Junkies?

You mean Libertarians don't you?

I find it hilarious that

I find it hilarious that these has-beens use the term "brainwashing".  The cocaine did that to them decades ago.

And CNN thinks..

.. that these two idiots will be taken seriously?? I have to wonder if the guy in charge at CNN is also smokin' dope.

  There is quite a lot of

  There is quite a lot of contrast between the interviews of Paul Simon and messrs. Crosby and Nash.  Simon states his case from the point of view of someone who is involved with childcare and the other two just rant illogically against the evil Bush.

What the hell does that nut

What the hell does that nut mean by this:

 The one group that has been left out of the mix right now are the middle class and especially low-earning middle class families, where there's not enough money to buy insurance. Their employers don't provide it very often, and they're making a little bit too much money to afford Medicaid.

I've never heard of employers, of generally middle class employees, that DO NOT provide health insurance. Every time I hear one of these sob stories, I find the internet to be a great friend. They say insurance costs "thousands a month" and I look up a rate quote and get below $200 a month for a 45 year-old male. Idiot journalists.

 Typical socialist B/S.

Redneck tax

"But the point is that for example $80,000 in a rural part of the country may buy a whole lot more than it might, for example, in New York City or Chicago or Los Angeles."

C'mon Col, show a little compassion. Them Iced White Chocolate Mochas in the city can really put a dent in the urban working stiffs wallet.  Let the redneck taxpayers at NASCAR (that don't buy Paul Simon CD's) foot the insurance bill. They carry more diseases anyway.

In the ozone

Convicted felon David Crosby may be off the dope now, but he and his two buddies still seem to have trouble grasping reality.

Developing Store?

How are the opinions of two burnt out hippies considered a developing story?  Only if their rant is anti-Bush. It is sad what passes for news on CNN.

 

A.R.A.B.

Love the one your with! OH, except Bush.

Idiots

"The administration is controlling the populace"

Really? Is that a fact? Is that why we don't see any public opposition to the administration? Yes! Of course! Protestors are being locked up for years without charge and dissidents are "disappeared".

"You can watch -- you can watch all of these same moves out of any other dictatorship or junta or, you know..."

This brilliant gem is offered up with no examples given. A sure sign that the person making the argument is intellectually vacant. The accusation itself is the proof. (funny the left has never objected to dictators like Castro, or Chavez...... I'm just sayin'.)

"Take away your civil rights." 

See both responses above.

Further proof that the baby boomer generation ushered in an era of moral idiocy.

Well stated.

Well stated.

"For some reason the press

"For some reason the press and people seem to think performers have the answers to the problems of society.  I mean, what can you say to something like that? It's absurd, really." - Bob Dylan

Day the music died

"We even had some leftist politicos from Berkeley ranting, the only bring-down of the day.'  Phil Lesh, Grateful Dead - Searching for the Sound

On a brighter note, most of

On a brighter note, most of these aging hippies will be dead within ten to twenty years. All the granola in the world can't undo thirty years of self-induced chemical torture.

Now if we can only reprogram their offspring, we won't have to hear what the KGB thinks about any given subject anymore.

The octopus is dead, but the tentacles still do its bidding.

is graham nash even a US citizen?

 

why does the media pay so much attention to rock and roll artists' opinions?  david crosby?  you've got to be kidding ... this guy, of all people, should be nothing but greatful that he's even a free man ... check out his numerous repeat crimes spanning the 80s and early 90s ... some involving guns.

... meanwhile, while these "artists" are busy complaining about how ruthless and wealthy the US is ... let's remind ourselves of what these people seem to forget:

* all the illegal drugs they've abused in the past (and may still be abusing now)

* they have no problem criticizing corporate american but conveniently forget that corporate america made them who they are (sony, atlantic records, BMI, columbia, etc)

* they don't mind becoming wealthy at the consumers expense (with the exception of 1 or 2 cds, most of these artists efforts are mediocre and overpriced)

* criticize US wealth, but still maintain their personal wealth

* the price of a concert ticket these days ... bitch about the upper class controlling everything, but not having a problem with pricing tickets so high that only the upper class can afford to see their aging asses in concert

* they were riding high in their heyday ... they are irrelevant now

* besides a few good tunes, they have not proven themselves worthy of anything more than collecting royalties from their past efforts ... most don't have any formal education ... and playing a guitar and writing a few songs protesting war does not give them the credentials to manage foreign policy

* david crosby penned and sang the song "almost cut my hair" ... listen to it and ask yourself why on earth would you ever lend an ear to this moron ever again.

 

 

* criticize US wealth, but

* criticize US wealth, but still maintain their personal wealth

* the price of a concert ticket these days ... bitch about the upper class controlling everything, but not having a problem with pricing tickets so high that only the upper class can afford to see their aging asses in concert

These morons dont seem to realize THEY are the upper class.

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

Anti-Bush Media

Anti-Bush media will run to put a microfone in front of anybody who has something bad to say about President Bush.  Whether it is a dictator, an actor, a politician, or a washed up rock star.  It looks like CNN looks up to rockers for deep policy opinions.  This doesn't reflect well on CNN by those who care about credible information.  CNN will have to change "The most trusted name in news" slogan to "the most anti-Bush name in news."

A new definition of "hell"

If I wasn't a Christian, I think I'd have found a new definition for hell in the current political climate:  Hell is having to live the late 60's and early 70's all over again.  Lefty politicians trying to make Iraq another Vietnam by effectively surrendering.  Mindless anti-war protesters.  Rockers of the era popping up out of obscurity to protest the war.  And Democrat candidates vying to be the 21st Century McGovern.  Do you suppose there'll be riots at next year's Democrat convention?

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

The fact is, that anyone

The fact is, that anyone who

1) knows who these two are and

2) care who they are and what they think

3) already agree with them ...

Matthews and CNN ...Duuuuuhhhhhh!!!

Free publicity

PAUL SIMON, MUSICIAN: ............ And over the years, I've been watching this issue of children's health care, and my observation is that people speak as if they care, but they don't really care.

Is it just me, or did this seem like a jab at all of the Dems and media rhetoric on the coverage of this issue?

And as far as the old rockers, to me it is just more of the old has-beens trying to get in the spotlight for free. Anybody know how many new "Best of" CD's these guys have coming out?  Free publicity, you know. Bruce did it, released a new CD and went on the MSM circuit bashing Bush to promote his new CD. It happens all the time. Those celebs' publicists are smart that way, and the idiots in the media fall for it hook-line-and-sinker every time.

I kinda felt like it was a

I kinda felt like it was a little poke at the dems too. It will never get played that way though. One redeeming thing about Simon is that it sounds like he is actually trying to help too, instead of just bitching about why republicans dont help people while he sits on his fat mounds of cash.

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.us)

Drug use

Remember the old commercial about "this is your brain on drugs"......?????

I rest my case. 

Is President Bush supposed

Is President Bush supposed to have an LBJ "If I've lost Walter Cronkite, I've lost Middle America." moment of awakening here??

Pres. Bush:  If I've lost the aging, has been, hippie, drug-infested rock and rollers, I've lost Middle America ... May as well give into whatever they want.

Don't forget

the new liver Crosby received in 1994 after years of alcohol and drug use... http://www.rotten.com/library/bio/entertainers/music/david-crosby/. So is he now destroying this one?

Just because....

they are celiberity rockers in the rock and roll hall of fame it does not give them moral or political rectitude to be making anti-anything statements. They should have to earn it like anybody else. Just because they are celiberities, and this includes Hollywood, it does not raise them to a higher moral or political status over the "average joe"! The MSM's paying attention to their opinion like this is an indication of not only thier liberal bias but how shallow they are. Examine their lives, have these Rockers displayed the moral rectitude and political rectitude that would give them the right to make the statments that they are making? In my eyes they have not.

I actually believe that CNN

I actually believe that CNN and MSNBC are doing us a favor, albeit unintentionally, by trotting out these incoherent fossils to speak on all matters political.  They serve as a timely reminder of why '60s era activists are such stupid jokes and how we cannot tolerate their return to power.