CNN Suggests ‘Prejudice’ and ‘Terror’ Motivates Opponents of Arabic School in NYC

Photo of Matthew Balan.
By Matthew Balan | September 4, 2007 - 18:40 ET

CNN, in their day-long reporting on Tuesday about the opening day for a controversial publicly-funded Arabic-language school in New York City, sympathized with the school and its supporters, and helped denigrate its opponents. On "American Morning" and throughout the day on Tuesday on their "Newsroom" program, CNN aired a report from correspondent Richard Roth on the Khalil Gibran International Academy, whose curriculum will focus on teaching "Arabic language and culture" (as detailed in a CNSNews.com report last week). The report focused on Carmen Colon, a mother and "community activist" in Brooklyn (a detail not mentioned in Roth’s report) who pulled her son from the school before its opening. The report closed with a clip from Colon, who said, "The people who are so against this school who, for me, seem more like the terrorists by terrorizing the community and making us feel that it's unsafe for our children to be there. They're the ones who are terrorizing us, not the school, not the principal, and not the administration."

Video (4:13): Real (3.10 MB) or Windows (2.56 MB), plus MP3 audio (1.92 kB).

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Roth’s report aired multiple times during CNN’s "Newsroom" program, as well as the "Your World Today" program on CNN International, which is simulcast on CNN during the 12 pm Eastern hour. The report was often prefaced and followed by Roth’s live reporting from the school in Brooklyn and from City Hall in Manhattan, where a rally against the school took place.

During the 2 pm Eastern hour of "Newsroom," anchor Kyra Phillips interviewed Pamela Hall of the organization "Stop the Madrassa" after the report reran. Hall, who was featured in Roth’s report, faced a hostile interview from Phillips, who took the statements from NYC education officials associated with the school at face value.

Excerpts from Phillips’ September 4 interview of Hall:

KYRA PHILLIPS: Pamela, tell me more about why you want this school closed down.

PAMELA HALL, "STOP THE MADRASSA": Well, the situation has never changed. We still do not know what the curricula is. It has not been released. We do not have the textbooks. We do not know what has been created. It is a false statement to say that they have to simply abide by some kind of public school regulations. And the latest document released by the Department of Education is that they cannot find the curricula. They opened that school today, 7:30 this morning. They've (sic) teaching the children something and they will not tell us what.

PHILLIPS: We will tell you what, because Garth Harries, who works for the school system, talked about the curriculum this morning on CNN. Here is what he had to say.

GARTH HARRIES, NYC DEPT. OF EDUCATION: It's the core sixth grade curriculum that these kids are starting with, which is the basics, math, English, history, science, and the kids are also going to be learning Arabic, which is an incredibly exciting and unique opportunity for these kids. Religion plays absolutely no part in this school. This is a public school. It wouldn't play a part in any of our schools. As a themed school focused on a language, it's like so many other. We have 70 dual-language programs around the city. Those are programs that frankly give our kids a leg up. It gives them a language, they're inclusive, and they let them learn about the world.

PHILLIPS: Well, there you have it. There's your answer. Do you feel better about the school now?

HALL: No. No, that is not an answer. Garth Harries is being quite dishonest with you. He himself, the Department of Education, they have known that they are not releasing the curricula, and they have not released it. That's why we have to go to court next week. They have told us they cannot find the curricula and it will take them at least a month to find it....

PHILLIPS: Well, I'm curious why you're calling it a Madrassa. It's an academy.

HALL: It is a public school that has associated with it people like Almontaser and her all-religious board of imams. These people are all ...

PHILLIPS: But they disassociated them from that woman who was wearing the T-shirt that was the principal. And they now have a new principal, a white Jewish woman...

HALL: She's not new. She’s not new.

PHILLIPS: She's the acting principal right now...

HALL: Yes. She's not new. She helped create the school.

PHILLIPS: But she's not Islamic. She's not Arabic.

HALL: Because you're trying to make this be that we are saying that they are teaching religion. This is an Islamist ideology propaganda textbooks that are out there that we have seen and we have done our research on...

CNN clearly showed its knack for sympathizing with groups they see as "persecuted minorities" in the above excerpts. Since 9/11, they have focused in particular on the "plight" of Muslims and Arabs who live in the U.S. (as Christiane Amanpour did in "God’s Muslim Warriors"). They also showed their apparent disinterest in the school system’s lack of transparency with regards to the school’s curriculum.

After another clip from the earlier "American Morning" interview of Harries was played, Phillips put her "multiculturalism hat" on.

PHILLIPS: Now, Pamela, isn't that what we would want our children to do, is have a better understanding of the Arabic culture, so we don't create more prejudice, we don't create more division among Americans and the Arab culture?

HALL: Whose Arab culture? We keep asking them. That is why the friends of Khalil Gibran have said, please cease and desist using this name. How are they going to teach about Maronite, Melkite Christians that make up some of, most of the Arab-speaking world (sic)? How will they teach about their cultures? There is no Arab culture. Whose culture is he speaking about?

PHILLIPS: You're talking about those that speak Arabic, those that live in the Middle East, those of Middle East decent that live in the United States. They're talking about bridging a very divided world right now. You've got the war in Afghanistan, the war in Iraq, all the insurgency, the terrorism, what happened on 9/11. There's a lot of misconception about the Middle Eastern people, and this is one step toward teaching our children - this is what they say - to understand the language and the culture of the Middle East. Don't you think that's important?

CNN cannot genuinely portray itself as an "objective" news source is it continues to push this kind of multiculturalism in their reporting and in their questioning of guests.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Interesting.... I wonder

Interesting....

I wonder when the New York Public School district is going to sponsor an entire school dedicated to Koreans.  Or Norwegians, or if history is any help Dutch....

The thing that bothers me is that in past wars, new immigrants/citizens who come from a specific background of interest such as Italians, Germans, and Japanese used their ethnic pride and even more so their pride in their new nation to encourage their young to serve in the military.

I gotta ask:  Where is the Arabic equivalent of the 442nd Regimental Combat Team (Go For Broke) made up largely of Nisei from Hawaii and California  that was the most decorated US unit in WWII? 

When was the last time you saw a member of CAIR stand up and say that it was time for an AMERICAN JIHAD against their coreligionists who have attacked us and that all young men of arabic descent should report to recruiting stations??

"The report closed with a

"The report closed with a clip from Colon..." Subtle(and tried and true) technique of bias by the media: always let those with which you agree have the last "eloquent" word (that leaves the lasting impression).

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

The solution on Muslim Schools

Simple solution for these New York Muslims as there are lots of schools all the way from Turkey to Bangladesh for Muslims to teach them all sorts of third world culture as that is where Islam is big and not in the modern world.

Kids can be taught how Indian children are bought for sex, Muslim boys are molested by mullahs, how to drink sewer water, how to get shot by different factions, how to die in a dictator prison and how not to think, but do only what the Khomeini says........all in Arab as it is a fast lesson to learn "duck and run for your life".

Wonderful culture over there as it has not had 100 years where entire cities were not wiped out and people not beheaded. Great thing to be teaching kids.

So ship the kids over seas and their parents too for a refresher course in human traffic and murder. 

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

...judging from this post

...judging from this post it looks like CNN's right - we do need the school:)...

It's not going to kill us people...

Popular culture is what's destroying this country. This school will be a badly needed step up... 

Protest Craig's conservative abandonment - vote Democrat in 08'

Arabic School in NYC

1. Will the Arab immigrant students be isolated ?

2. Will they be forced to learn English, or will the American students simply be forced to learn Arabic ?

Deborah Howard curricula mistress CNN " There's no basis in fact for what they are saying" _

You deny it, what is actually ocurring ?

CNN " Deborah Howard and Riad Faraj (Arab man in business suit not heard speaking probably because of a very thick accent ), both parents of Brooklyn public school students, worked on the design team for the academy and say it is not a religious school."

Uh, no they don't, no they didn't. You merely say they did. I want to hear Mr. Arab man in business suit Riad Faraj speak.

( They snowed me the first couple of times through, till I noticed mr arab man and his non western name - since of course he was not allowed to speak -- the accent likely being so thick it would make one wonder...)

3. Is it true the DOE cannot find the cirricula as your guest claimed ?

4. Have you seen the textbooks, or will you just "take the word of the defense team" all is well ?

5. Your mommie who pulled her child from the school, and said she felt terrorized by those questioning the cirricula APPARENTLY ACTUALLY BELIEVED THEY WERE CORRECT... did you ask why she pulled her child if none of it was true ?

_________________________________

So a mother who believed the accusations pulled her child because of the "terrorist" making the inquiry... (and of course you got that quote AFTER you CNN told her none of it was true- and assured she made the wrong choice in her panic - because CNN knows - it spoke to the school spokesperson...now she "feels" terrorized -)

I see...... except you guys didn't show that part...so we didn't see it.

No cirricula outline, no textbooks, no answers, just one mom who believes there are problems but calls the inquiry "terrorism", and the schools spokesperson unchallenged.

WOW.

What About This?

 

PHILLIPS: Now, Pamela, isn't that what we would want our
children to do, is have a better understanding of the Arabic culture,
so we don't create more prejudice, we don't create more division among
Americans and the Arab culture?

 

And, if you were to substitute Christian (or Catholic or Protestant) for Arabic, do you think Ms Phillips would have asked this question?

I don't think so either.

Just my $0.02

No Wildcatter, I'd put my

No Wildcatter, and I'd put my money (and more than .02 c :p) on it!

Oh, and also, Ms. Phillips, you've got it all WRONG on this one:

"They're talking about bridging a very divided world right now. You've got the war in Afghanistan, the war in Iraq, all the insurgency, the terrorism, what happened on 9/11."

... um, NO, you have the order all wrong, and some that shouldn't even be there. Here, let me fix it for you:

"They're talking about bridging a very divided world right now. You've got....

1) what "the terrorists did" on 9/11 (inserted a few words for you)

2) "THE terrorism" sounds, I dunno, funny..... what's the "the" for? .... how 'bout just "terrorism"

3) all the "terrorist insurgents" ... I added a vital word there, too

4) okay, Iraq may be flaming some fires... although, as I look around the world the last few years, there has not been a major (like people in the hundreds) terrorist attack anywhere (well, except in the theater of war, Iraq).... so not sure I'm buying this "we've created more terrorists and made the world less safe" theory.

5) what the heck is Afganistan doing in the list???

So, hmm, I think from this we can deduce exactly what/who has divided the world.... and, no, it has not been the "Uniter", as you're so clearly, in your not-so-subtle way, implying ;)

Yeah ... I have a hard time

Yeah ...

I have a hard time taking anything from Kyra Phillips seriously ... Unless it's on an open mic in the CNN bathroom.

PHILLIPS: Now, Pamela,

PHILLIPS: Now, Pamela, isn't that what we would want our children to do, is have a better understanding of the Arabic culture, so we don't create more prejudice, we don't create more division among Americans and the Arab culture?

Hey Kyra (on the crapper), why not ask that question of the mullahs in Iran, or Hamas & Fatah that like to train 6 year olds how to become suicide bombers?   <crickets chirping>   

oy:(  this is sad people

oy:( 

this is sad people - but I'm finding another nice thing about turning Democrat, I guess:)

Protest Craig's conservative abandonment - vote Democrat in 08'

Soooo... why is this being

Soooo... why is this being publicly funded?  If it was a private school, no big deal, more power to them, let them teach whatever they want if they think they'll be imparting to their kids what they need to succeed in America... but I somehow doubt that you can teach that withouth focusing on... (drumroll please) ... America.  Sure we should have cultural classes to broaden our kids' exposure, but it's no more sensible to focus on one foreign culture than it is to squander the kids' entire primary education on math with no English, or vice versa.  The taxpayer should not be footing the bill for this.

Privatize the ENTIRE public education system.

Empirical evidence is piling up...

Once you've seen and particularly heard the video of David Pearl...hell, any video of any person having their head sawed of with a dull knife at the hands of one of Allahs most dedicated worshipers...it changes your whole perception of Islam and Jihad in general.

That and the murders of innocent people that happens every single day without fail at the hands of some very religious young man who never hurt anyone in his life until the day he kills scores. In all parts of the world, Monks are murdered, Nuns are killed or kidnaped, young school girls are attacked on their way home from school. No act is beneath them.

If there is the possibility that this facility could become a hub or meeting place for those with like minds that is all well and good. However the subjects discussed at these meetings kind of concerns me. Over and over we hear of someone being "radicalized" by some revered Muslim leader while they were attending services at their Mosque. Where else would one expect the Jihadist to come from?

This is not a matter of Islamophobia or racism. (Islam is not a race.) When members of a particular religion are the primary practitioners of the use of the suicide vest, are we wrong to wonder what their local Imams are telling them?

Islam and freedom are not, as far as my limited abilitiy to see, compatible. There are nearly 70 rules in Islam for urinating and defecating. Can you imagine having to cleanse yourself in a very specific fashion according to any religious text? Imagine how micro-managed the rest of your life would be. Women as cattle may seem OK to some but not to me. The only "Arabic culture" that I can think of that they might be alluding to that is nearly universal to the region, is Islam.

High ranking Islamic leaders in Iran putting their OK on sex with animals, as long as you kill them afterward. (Can't sell the meat to your neighbors, but to someone in a different village.)Sex with children "as young as a baby" is okay, as long as you only sodomize them. Only? This from a revered leader of the faithful?

Prostitiution a problem as in Iran? Legalize 2 hour marriages or whatever time suits you, so long as you pay the dowry. Yeah...that will stop prostitution.

I'm afraid I don't see what this "culture" has to offer us in the
free world, except a total loss of every freedom we presently enjoy of any and all kinds.

Happy Trails...

Army Brat

I sincerely hope you're being facetious....but somehow, I know that you're not.

Thankfully I don't live in New York, where taxpayers $$ are being spent to fund a school where such ideology is taught....but if it's in NY today....it will be in Florida in five years.

This kind of craziness must stop.  RIGHT HERE, and RIGHT NOW. 

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

Clarity.....for Blonde...did I mislead you somehow?

I think this is a bad thing. I wasn't even going to address the whole public funding thing. Obviously that is wrong. But having any kind of "Arabic studies" going on where the teachers don't want you to know what the curriculum is, is unacceptable and to me, the greater concern/threat.

Happy Trails...

Just lovely -- Growing our own Terrorists now Hmmm?

Will this "bite" us? Yes? How soon? How long to rainwash little kids into thinking they will be "superheros" if they put on this speical vest with "special powers" and walk over there to greet the nice people just standing there?

Our culture has a strict adversion to using children as weapons, and killing of children (just not the unborn - those you can kill and flush all you want).

It is one of our weaknesses. It will be used against us and I bet within the duration of the NEXT Presidential Administration (no matter whom is elected),

 

We're missing the point

Why not have all Black schools.  Oh, that was ended in the 60's.  My bad.

If only that were

If only that were true.

No, they weren't ended... there still exists plenty of schools that are exclusively for blacks, from kindergarten up through college.  They even use that as their selling point: "exclusive."  Kind of sad how the Sharptons of the world have brainwashed young blacks into thinking voluntary segregation is a GOOD thing.

If it's a private institution, I don't care... If that's the way parents think their kids will thrive, with an artificial superiority complex propped up on racial heritage rather than meritorious worth, that's the parents' choice to make.  But it bothers me when racist programs are covered even in part by public subsidies.

 

Let's See Now...

....99.99 percent of all terrorism is perpetrated by Arabic people.  The Arabis Islamist have vowed to Islamicize the world.  They are establishing a "school" in New York City.  And the MSM portrays opposition to this as prejudice???

Prejudice means PRE - judge, not POST - judge.  It's merely logical to be suspicious of any Arab/Islamic activity in America, it's not prejudice, it's postjudice...

Ever notice how

Ever notice how leftists/Dems, in collusion with Muslims, always use the term "Arabs" or "Arabic" to soften the description of Muslims.  (For instance, I have only EVER heard this school referred to as an Arabic school)  Funny, since the vast majority of Arabs are Christians and most Muslims are NOT Arabs.

Gee, disingenuousness on the part of the MSM...who'da thunk? 

 

"Yesterday's Communists are Today's Democrats....

Yesterday's Democrats are Today's Republicans..." - An analogy made by *ME*