Less than a week after they used an overwhelming amount of left-wing Internet clips from YouTube to forward the liberal agenda at the Democrat debate, CNN is promoting another left-wing Internet production. Sunday’s "Newsroom" program spent more than 5 minutes discussing the latest hack job from Max Blumenthal of "The Nation," in which the son of Clinton spin doctor Sidney Blumenthal attacks the "chicken hawks" at the College Republican National Convention.
Not only did segment reporter Josh Levs fail to identify many of Blumenthal’s left-wing associations (other than the fact that posted his video on the Huffington Post, which is not identified as a liberal website), he tried to cover for Blumenthal by stating that the left-wing writer "really rejects that radical left-wing label" after the co-chair of the College Republicans called Blumenthal part of "a bunch of radical left-wing people." "Newsroom" anchor Rick Sanchez closed the segment with a clip of an earlier interview where he posed Blumenthal’s question to three Republican college students earlier this month.
Video, with fixed links (4:34):Real (3.30 MB) or Windows (2.73 MB), plus MP3 audio (1.54 MB).
Levs, (pictured at right) a journalist who works for several mainstream media outlets, including CNN and NPR, did the report on Blumenthal’s "Generation Chickenhawk," the latest in a series of videos in which "The Nation" writer goes to conservative conventions to ask "hard questions." This is how Sanchez and Levs began the segment.
RICK SANCHEZ: A writer, opposed to the Iraq war, goes to a national meeting of College Republicans, and creates a video that's fueling a hot political debate over the Web. He says that he's exposing the quote, ‘hypocrisy of a group of young people who are behind the war, but won't put their own lives on the line when it comes to the war.’
CNN's Josh Levs here with ‘Josh's Corner’ now. This is interesting, because I know a football coach who used to say, you know, ‘ it doesn't work if it's all show and no go.’ And it does appear that this is moving in that direction.
JOSH LEVS: You know what, a lot of people have associations when they see this. That's one reason it's catching on so big. It's really interesting. You know, first of all, we're talking about the ultimate political question in America right now. It's all about Iraq. So what happens here, yeah, it boils down to one guy who went to this meeting, but he put together this video that right now is catching a lot of attention on the Internet. And you're going to see here that some of the people he talks to may have been asked a question that they did not expect.
Max Blumenthal is a writer who regularly takes on conservative politicians, positions, and groups. He has a new video on his Web site and on the ‘Huffington Post,’ tracing his visit to a meeting of the College Republican National Committee. Everyone Blumenthal interviews strongly supports the Iraq war.
Notice that Blumenthal is described as being "opposed to the Iraq war," and "a writer who regularly takes on conservative politicians, positions, and groups." There is no mention of the fact that he works for "The Nation" or that he is the son of Sidney Blumenthal.
As part of his report, Levs interviewed Max Blumenthal and the co-chair of the College Republican National Committee, Nick Miccarelli. The clip from the Blumenthal interview lasts uninterrupted for 35-seconds, while Miccarelli, whose clips are interrupted by a short biography of his background, last 20 seconds. A transcript of the interview clips.
LEVS: Blumenthal staunchly opposes the war. He calls his video ‘Generation Chickenhawk.'
BLUMENTHAL: An ideology that says you can support this war, which is not supported by most Americans, and which is wearing down the military, without serving it in any way, or participating in it, or making any kind of sacrifice.
LEVS: Isn't it possible to absolutely, thoroughly support a war, but not enlist, with no hypocrisy?
BLUMENTHAL: It's possible to absolutely support a war, but at this point, with the military worn thin, I think at this point it is hypocritical, since this country probably needs them to serve.
NICK MICCARELLI, COLLEGE REPUB NATL CMTE: I think we should take it for what it is, and that's a political hit piece. It's totally on- sided.
LEVS: The group's head, 25-year-old Nick Miccarelli is also in the National Guard, and served in Ramadi, Iraq.
MICCARELLI: People who support stricter laws on a lot of things in this country, and aren't necessarily willing to become police officers.
LEVS: He says some College Republicans do enlist.
MICCARELLI: We're more concerned with what the troops think about us than what a bunch of radical left-wing people think.
LEVS: Blumenthal, who's 29-years-old, summarizes his message in this final shot (shot of car bumper sticker that says ‘Draft College Republicans’), and says he's had some positive responses from some members of the military.
Again, Levs only mentions the fact that Blumenthal "staunchly opposes the war." After his report was aired, Levs was even more disingenuous about Blumenthal’s background.
LEVS: And Blumenthal, also, for the record, really rejects that radical left-wing label. He says, you know what, a lot of people in America agree with him. And Rick, it's also relevant to us to keep in mind there have been a lot of Internet videos on this whole argument over Iraq, and sometimes you've got people making fun of anti-war protesters as well.
How can Levs say that with a straight face, given Blumenthal’s background. He mentions the videos where "you’ve got people making fun of anti-war protesters," but when is CNN going to do a segment on that?
At the end of the segment, Sanchez played a clip of an interview he had conducted with visiting college students from both sides of the aisles about the Iraq war. He imitates Blumenthal by asking the 3 conservative/Republican students, "Raise your hand if you're ready to go? Raise your hand if you're ready to go to Iraq tomorrow." When the none of the 3 raise their hands, he pressed them for an explanation.
SANCHEZ: Is there anybody who is going to raise their hand and say they are ready to go to Iraq?
DAVID KIRBY, STUDENT, UNIV. OF GEORGIA: If my country needs me tomorrow, if they call me, if they draft me, then I will go.
SANCHEZ: You said it's the right war. So, are you ready to go?
KIRBY: If my country needs me to go, I will go.
So, you not only have two CNN journalists promoting a left-wing partisan journalist, one of them is trying to imitate him. It sure is an eye-opening 5 minute segment.
(h/t NewsBusters reader Damian G.)
—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
There is an easy retort to
July 30, 2007 - 13:24 ET by Mr. KafirThere is an easy retort to leftwing nutjobs that claim anyone in favor of the war should be serving in Iraq. It goes something like this:
Mr. Kafir
July 30, 2007 - 13:33 ET by Six String SpiffLMAO!! How very true!
I wished we had been tougher with Iraq, but we are there now, so we have to make the best of it.
What the MSSM doesn't report can kill you.
so then you are a "chicken
July 30, 2007 - 13:51 ET by TruthMongerso then you are a "chicken fire hawk" as well!
...harumph!
too bad leon ain't here for some leftard commentary
otherwise I used a similar analogy to yours on bal with sexual abstinence the other day
he used the typical lab talking point of "too unrealistic"
so then i says "just like anti-smoking campaigns?"
and he mutters something about no sudden urge to smoke at the age of 13 (as opposed to the completely and totally uncontrollable sexual urges we all face at the age of 13, i guess?)
the moral here is that these boneheads can easily ignore the salient points of our insightfully logical analogies - it's what they do for a living actually:)
too bad for the rest of humanity
Mr Kafir
July 30, 2007 - 13:56 ET by LionKingYour analogy would make more sense if the firemen were stealing the oil from the people they were helping...you know, so it will not contribute to the fire. </sarc
So now people are outraged
July 30, 2007 - 14:03 ET by balboaSo now people are outraged that the Bush Twins aren't firefighters?
Yeah, that's it.
July 30, 2007 - 14:51 ET by Mr. KafirYeah, that's it.
I'm outraged that college
July 30, 2007 - 17:46 ET by TruthMongerI'm outraged that college leftards haven't joined en masse:
1. Greenpeace anti-whaling ship crews - they can't give a sh*t about whales then...sorry - it's Blumendick's rule...
2. Assembly lines at the hybrid auto plants - - they can't give a sh*t about saving gas then...sorry - it's Blumendick's rule...
3. Darfur relief crews - they can't give a sh*t about Africans then...sorry - it's Blumendick's rule...
4. Soup kitchens to help the homeless- they can't give a sh*t about the homeless then...sorry - it's Blumendick's rule...
5. Universal health care lobbying firms- they can't give a sh*t about healthcare for all people then...sorry - it's Blumendick's rule...
6. Illegal Immigration assistance groups - they can't give a sh*t about Mexicans then...sorry - it's Blumendick's rule...
etc etc etc
LWNJ: Why haven't YOU
July 30, 2007 - 16:27 ET by drillanwrLWNJ: Why haven't YOU joined the military to go and fight in this war you support, chickenhawk?
Me: Because I am NOT as strong or brave as those who are serving. So, I'm here at home supporting them and their mission against idiot antiwar, antimilitary chickens#!+s like you!
How about this?
July 30, 2007 - 17:38 ET by JungusI would like to see less crime where I live...
How about I become a gun-toting vigilante?
The Traitor Corps
July 30, 2007 - 14:10 ET by allanfThis kind of name calling is just plain nasty. Blumenthal, Sanchez, Levs and CNN are disgraceful.
But this behavior seems to typify the today's left wing. If you can't win an argument by reason, just call names. Blumenthal and his ilk would be the first to be outraged if they were called the "traitor corps". Name calling is easy guys. Finding well reasoned arguments is a bit harder.
Young men and women who choose to serve in the military should be praised. These people should be lionized and admired. Blumenthal seems to believe that only the military men and women can praise the military or support their goals. If you think about that dim witted logic, such militaries exist only in police states.
Apparently by his reasoning one can only support an organization by joining that organization. Otherwise you are a hypocrite. He is lamely trying to turn patriotism on its head.
I guess I really can't support the local police any longer, since I'm not a policeman. Heaven help me if I want to support my volunteer fire department. I'm not a volunteer fireman. Excuse me for praising emergency medical technicians. I'm not a paramedic. One can go on and on to prove the absurdity of his logic.
If a left winger ever pulls out chicken hawk just say: "You can support the fight against Aids without being HIV positive and you don't need to be a military man to admire and support our nation".
I guess the next time Blumenthal wants to lecture us about stem cell research, we just say. "How can you talk about that when you haven't shown you have the intellect to become a doctor"
Th
Chickenhawks... Don't they
July 30, 2007 - 14:18 ET by Hero SquadChickenhawks... Don't they eat chickens?
*****
"Some people have a way with words. Other people, er, I don't know. Not have way, I guess." - Steve Martin
Actually, the name
July 30, 2007 - 18:37 ET by Del DolemonteActually, the name "chickenhawk" has been applied to several different varieties of hawks, specifically the red-tailed hawk and the Cooper's hawk, both of which prey on birds of all types.
Both hawk species are in fact vicious, fearless predators. Which makes the curious leftist selection of the word "chickenhawk" as an insult so hilarious.
And I thought the term
July 30, 2007 - 18:55 ET by drillanwrAnd I thought the term "chickenhawk" is also used to describe a male pedophile who preys on young boys:
http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=27228
Chris Matthews wantabes.He
July 30, 2007 - 15:41 ET by well99Chris Matthews wantabes.He did it on his show.I may be wrong but in this country everyone is allowed to voice their opinion.I served 23 years in the military but that was my choice.It isnt a requirement for people to join to have free speech here.These left wing scuts think they are the only ones allowed this.That is bull.
Mr.Kafir good job.Left wingers are always trying stop any voice but theirs.This a free country despite them.
Perhaps Mr. Blumenidiot has
July 30, 2007 - 19:00 ET by drillanwrPerhaps Mr. Blumenidiot has NO concept of who/what it takes to join the military. As they say, "It's NOT just a job".
A Reenlistment Seen Round The World
July 30th, 2007 Posted By Pat Dollard
http://patdollard.com/2007/07/30/a-reenlistment-seen-round-the-world/#comments
Wounded Marine Reenlists For Fourth Tour - From Stretcher
As I said, "because they are stronger and braver than me" ... and allow me to add better.
drill... Thanks so much
July 30, 2007 - 19:08 ET by bigtimerdrill...
Thanks so much for that info about that magnificent man Hawkins.
Pat Dollards site is one of the best....
This story brought tears to my eyes and gratitude to heart.
I feel so insignificant with men/women like them.
bt - And to top it all
July 30, 2007 - 19:17 ET by drillanwrbt -
And to top it all off, in reality, they serve us ... You know, We The People ... It's really saying something when those who serve are held up high by the people they are serving.
He's taken a page from the
July 30, 2007 - 20:13 ET by BigBHe's taken a page from the head Guru, or shall we say Budda, of the ambush interview master that is Michael Moore...Now if this toilet bug had any sack at all, he would go to Iraq and interview some of the Marines or Soldiers there...but go ahead and show them some of his previous work first....
I wonder how many of em' would line up on his side??? I wonder if he'd make it out with something like 'Oops, it musta went of by mistake'....
I also wonder why people like this can be walking around with all their teeth still in their heads....
Now, this might sting just a little bit.....